На самом деле, это довольно часто встречающийся "аргумент". Думаю, он появился благодаря социальным опросам, в которых очень "образованные" японцы обвиняли русских в бомбардировке Хиросимы и Нагасаки, потому что они на самом деле не знают, кто это сделал (а если ты не знаешь, кто виноват - значит виноваты русские)
I KNOW And she got a carry out boyfriend from china so that’s where her loyalty lies, but how stupid not the poor girl but the system that Indoctrinated her such. And she needs to take a breath and really think before she talks
What is the woman at 1:20 blabbing on about? She says the US blames USSR/Russia for the atomic bombs dropped in Japan? As an American, I've never heard this. And said US-Russian relations have never been positive except WW2 but the 1990's things were relatively positive. There was hope that Russia would turn into a normal country but the brutal way Russia fought in Chechnya gave the west and US less hope in Russia. It was under Putin the relations soured.
@@kastus77 Yeltsin, right? Is it Eltsin in Russian? The mid 90's fight in Chechyna was already seen as troubling in the west but they hoped things would change. The 1999 fighting lead by Putin was brutal and that really concerned the US and west. Putin did basically what he had done in Ukraine and Syria which is target civilians and punish them.
I heard several times that Japan was about to surrender anyway, and the bombs had 2 goals : end the war before USSR turn against Japan and take control of the island, and the bomb will show how powerful the US are so the USSR will not turn against them. I guess that's what she refers to
how's that? you can't compare education in Europe, including russia and older soviet countries, with any other in the world apart from countries like Singapore, Hong-Kong, etc. In the Americas, besides Canada, the rest is really bad, and unfortunately, Africa is still the wealthier continent with the poorer educated (as we wish, of course).
@@peristicas3119Because they seem to understand that China is no one's real friend. China only cares about China, and how other countries can help China achieve world dominance.
@@peristicas3119Here in Spain I think the education is pretty bad. However I've met classmates that went to a US highschool and said it was much easier.
According to Valentina 2:46, when the US comes to the aid of a people under attack by tyrants, it's "starting a war." Ok then: In that case, when the US began aiding the USSR in the 1940s, it "started" World War II. 🙄🙄🙄🙄 And she's supposed to be an educated person! (Retired economist.)
@Max შემიწყალე even if that had anything to do with it (which I disagree with because Japan remained independent) it is sure as heck not ‘blaming’ the Soviet Union.
She never said that US blamed Russia about Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombing. She said "В японии выстроили такие отошения что виновата pоссия". Translation is "In Japan, they built such attitudes that Russia is to blame". I saw a video where Japanese people were asked about who bombed them and majority said Russia. The question remains - why people think that.
I would imagine the Japanese still remembered defeating Russia in the Russo-Japanese War and other hostilities with Russia, which is a close geographic neighbor, and so in many ways it was an almost natural, albeit incorrect, conclusion that it was the Russians as they had ample historical reason to be vindictive towards the Japanese people.
Stalin invaded Manchuria the same day the 2nd a-bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. So the Japanese people probably felt they were stabbed in the back and blame USSR for them losing WWII, not dropping the a-bomb.
@@iMost067 Japan never invaded USSR in WWII. Stalin didn't want to fight a 2-front war and Japan didn't have enough resources to fight USSR and US at the same time, so they signed a neutrality agreement. Of course Stalin also signed a neutrality agreement with Hitler.
"how can they attack us?" Some people are detached from reality to assume that they can wage war, and not be hit back by those same people. They don't have their own feet attached to the ground.
It's just that she's only heard propaganda and is convinced that Russia was never the one attacking anyone in the first place, but has to "defend" it's souvernity. Can't blame her, she's old and probably only watches TV.
as a Chinese, the history with Russia is super complicated. China has lost most of her territory to Russia/USSR directly or indirectly. However China had also received a lot of assistance from USSR in the 50s. Today, it was the US led Western world that pushed Russia and China closer. Maybe it's not an alliance but it's definitely a partnership that benefits both sides
@@Thinkaton10 Yes, imo only indigenous people such as the First Nations of Canada, USA, Australia, and New Zealand have the right to complain. The settlers have exploited, genocided, and pushed the native people into tiny pockets of Indian Reserves. Of these countries, New Zealand is probably the one doing the most for reparation. All that's left to do is to change the name back to Aotearoa and elect a new flag, national anthem, and education system as Canada did. Australia and the US should follow suit.
Maybe he's thinking "Next time I will try an actual Chinese girl instead of a Russky who is just trying to kiss up to me by pretending to like the tyrants running China right now."
1:11 Вообще-то, Россия и США были в хороших отношениях с момента обретения последними независимости вплоть до падения Российской Империи. Так что, за исключением периода Холодной Войны, Россия и США - это, как ни странно, исторические друзья.
@@УважаемыйИван-с9чнет чувак, не будет никакой России в будущем. Ваша судьба это развал на маленькие кусочки, империя зла будет уничтожена. Слава Украине 🇺🇦💪🏻
And oddly enough America also totally won WWII on behalf of russia, who would have completely collapsed without never-ending American supplies. Russians forget that a lot.
I would rather the question being asked is of “good partners” rather than “allies”. Ally typically means you are all in on most if not all geopol-topics and must come to aid without regards for self interests, or the interests are mostly aligned. You can enjoy very close relationships and help each other economically, militarily internationally, but you should not lose your own national identities. China is a explicitly stated Non-Ally country. So I don’t think they are the ally that you are looking for. Nor should you expect allies in that strict “Ally”definition nowadays. US could be partners but they would prefer to keep larger countries subjugated unless you are small and could never pose any threats or challenges to their hegemony, or they will fuck you over like they are doing with Russia and China today. After all, “自力更生 (work hard yourselves)but with lots of good friends”should every countries motto.
Russia is now a vassal state to China, the junior partner in their new relationship, a source of raw materials for their industries. 14 months ago Russia was the leader of Central Asia, now the undisputed leader of that region is China. Russia is starting to resemble N. Korea more and more every day.
true. China has absolutely NO interest in building up the russian industry, all it wants is cheap oil and gas and they will just flood the russian market with their own products, as it is way cheaper for them to produce in China. So not having western investors in the russian economy will lead to russia being the new Iran. Only ressources, nothing else. Oh, of course some nukes.
Where do these people get their crazy information from? The young lady talking about the bombs for example! It's mind boggling, honestly.🤔 Is there really any hope for these people? Glory and Victory to Ukraine! 😊😎🎸🇬🇧🇺🇦
In Japan, it is not customary to say that America bombed their country with nuclear bombs. Young Japanese, I have seen interviews, often do not know who did it and some believe that Russia did it.
As a Chinese I think Russia and China are not allies but we need each other’s support in many situations. China and Russia have maintained very positive relationship, economically and politically, for a long time with mutual respect. Sometimes I think this relationship is even better and more stable and sustainable than allies. No allies can last forever but a good neighbor is possible. Btw, I have seen so many colleagues from Russia and I work as a software engineer. I have met so many talented Russian engineers with superb math and coding skills. I ❤ them
Though China and Russia have a long border, the border is not near to the population center of either country. So, do Chinese and Russians think of the other as "nearby"?
@@controlLyapunov It's a simple question about psychological distance. If you don't know the answer, just say so. Here in the US, residents of Boston are more attuned to Europe than to Mexico or China. Miami thinks of Columbia and Brasil as nearby. Honolulu thinks about Japan.
@@jonlenihan4798 I get it. Similarly in northeast China people feel close to Russia and Korea. In Inner Mongolia province of China there live many citizens from Mongolia. In Tibet and Yunan people feel even closer to Vietnam and other southeast countries than some part of mainland China. However that doesn’t mean Russia and China are NOT nearby because there are ppl living in the far east side of Russia and the borderline is so long. I encourage you google a city in China called Harbin and check out how heavy it is impacted by Russian culture. If you don’t know the answer just say no
It is possible that China will not absorb Russia in the sense of annexation, because the risk is too great for China (social, economic, Russia is too depraved and rotten to the very roots). These are two very different autocratic systems based on different values. But China will certainly colonize and fully pacify Russia, so that it will no longer play any role, at most in the style of North Korea. In addition, China also started to care about good relations with Ukraine (due to its resources and location), which (surprise!) will not turn into a Russian colony and a large Russian concentration camp, as both China and Russia imagined a year ago.
@@tnickknight All it takes is a little referendum. Ask some of the Chinese living/working in Russia if they would like their current locations to become part of China. Then declare that they all said yes, sign a few papers and voila.
I'm yet to hear what legitimate harm did the West do to Russia? What and when exactly was done to Russia by the West? All I hear is bitterness that Russia is not treated as an equal partner by USA and EU combined, which is farcical when Russia has an economy the size of Spain. But no specific explanation is ever given, what did the West do to Russia to deserve hate?
He's Asian looking, but that doesn't mean he must be Chinese. He could be Russian (there are many Russians with Asian features) or he could be from a different East Asian country.
No, seriously, you're allowed to support the government as much as you want. It's like the old saying about Ford "you can choose any color you want as long as it's black", here it's "you can express any opinion you want as long as it matches the government view"
Never mind, here, in Russia, it is normal been in parallel reality and do not see naked facts. It is country of absurd, but be careful- that is why we get victory against Napoleon(he did not expect such unprecedented stupidity from the enemy; our tactics then do not lend themselves to any logical explanation at all).
7:47 Valentina, 70: "What right do they have!?" Great question! :) They don't have right shelling, but do russians HAVE right shelling Ukrainian cities? Russian logic - we DO have right to do bad things to the whole world, but the whole world DON'T have right to do bad things to us!
Character in a French play: "Cet animal est très méchant. Quand on l'attaque, il se defend!" ["This animal is very vicious. When you attack it, it defends itself!"]
I visited Russia about 10 years ago on a tour. It was eye opening as Russia was painted as the evil for so many years by the Western media. Anyway my tour guide was a lady in her thirty. She was sad to see Russia stopped the space industry which was world leading due to economy, and had to share the knowledge with US for the money. People were looking for quick money instead of building up their competitive edge. China has probably done better in this regard.
@@freefree1219 Ideology talks aside, I think that's why some Russians like Putin say that the downfall of the USSR was a huge geopolitical catastrophe. Russia basically sold their entire country for cheap and that cost them decades of their future. During the same period, China was just about to jump on the globalization bandwagon and boom in economics, and the policymakers most likely have taken notes from the story very carefully.
My dad had a saying that when people are hell bent on destroying their lives it’s best to let them “live their paycheck”. If you try to rescue these people from their personal choices or try change their world views before they experience the natural consequences of those choices and beliefs, it’s not going to work. They will resent you for trying to help, make you responsible for for their lot in life and then embrace those who are trying to exploit them. If people in a culture value the mirage of strength and stability of authoritarianism, you can’t rescue them from the natural consequences of that belief. You can only wish them well and leave them to decide when they’ve finally had enough of the corruption and oppression that authoritarianism brings. Whether we help them or not, Ukraine has spent the last 13 months demonstrating that they will lay down their lives to fight for their sovereignty, freedom and self governance. It couldn’t be more clear that helping Ukraine, by giving them a leg up in this fight, is resources well spent because Ukraine is ready to change. Sadly Russia is probably best left to it’s own devices. Prematurely rescuing them again, like we did in the 90’s, will only perpetuate the problem for both them and for the rest of the world. If they believe that they can go it alone in the world or that they want to trust and partner with China, we should just let them.
I couldn't agree more. I've thought about this every time that I've heard an American say that the Russian people just don't understand what's happening. I'm certainly not saying that all Russians are bad, but most of them support what is happening. This is what they want.
Yeah I don't have much hope for Russia taking a democratic turn... They are in love with strong men who do nothing but exploit them.... They have proven time and time again they do not value or understand politics. At least many of the intelligent Russians were able to leave and I wish the best for that group...
I listened to a Timothy Snyder lecture the other day, where he says that the best thing that could happen to the russian people is the rf completely, decisively losing this war
It's insane how throughout history russia has had countless oppurtunities to make itself one of the most prosperous and powerful nations on earth, at times even coming so close, but has squandered it every single time through authoritarianism, war and corruption.. to what end. The cycle simply repeats and probably will for as long as russia exists as a country.
@DMZDMX1 True. I have to admit, they're awesome in their own way, but I wouldn't wanna live in a society dependent on them. Not the most reliable car in the world.
@@mobeltass It was a joke. These foolish people don't realise that their nation is historically one of the least creative in the world and how much they should be grateful to the west for what they have. Strip away that and you have a nation of mediocrity.
If we’re talking about hiroshima and nagasaki can we please also talk about the massacre of katyn and the invasion of poland by russia? Or how the soviets were friends with the nazis and helped them defeating france in 1940? Remember the hitler-stalin pact!
@@willthecat3861 Stalin attempted to justify the occupation of poland, etc, by saying he knew Hitler was going to attack the east so by pretending to be his ally he occupied some of the east and protected it from Hitler. That might almost sound logical and sensical, if it was not for the massacres you mention, the fact Stalin in fact used the occasion to exterminate all the people with military experience, teachers, intelligentsia, politicians, anyone able to organise any kind of resistance against the nazis or against himself, in the countries he occupied and 'saved' from the nazis. This too I suppose although never mentioned in USSR was probably attempted to be portrayed or justified as self defense against capitalists anti communist or fascist partisan traitors - although they were too many for that to make sense.
On 6 and 9 August 1945, the United States detonated two atomic bombs over the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, respectively. The two aerial bombings together killed between 129,000 and 226,000 people, most of whom were civilians, and remain the only use of nuclear weapons in an armed conflict. The Katyn massacre was a series of mass executions of nearly 22,000 Polish military officers and intelligentsia prisoners of war carried out by the Soviet Union. Almost the same numbers. Did you mean The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact? (which gave soviets some time to prepare for a war with a country with an ABSOLUTLY OPPOSITE IDEOLOGY) Should study history a little more. Ussr reconqured polish lands, annexed by Poland during Polish-Soviet War. But it's useless to enlight you, cause your mind is a dark side of the Moon.
@@danilabychkov7398 Your answer does not make a reasonable and fair comparison. Katyn massacre was only one among very many the soviet union conducted. In every country they occupied, they deported and killed very large number of civilians. They deported millions to Siberia; of those a large proportion died, already a much greater number than civilian deaths in japan. 22 000 is nothing, you have to add the civilians deaths in general the soviet union caused - in the second world war alone these are millions. The excuse it gave them time to prepare for war does not explain why they killed all military officers and any people able to organise a resistance in all the countries they occupied, countries they knew nazis wanted to attack. The truth is at the time, soviets thought genocide of populations was justified if it could help them enforce what they pretended to be a utopy, and was in fact a totalitarian state. There is no reason to excuse the disregard for human life of the totalitarian soviet union.
I am really sad for some youth in Russia, there are too ignorant , the elders are more concious , cooperation is about give and take, but they always selfishly expect others only to give .In addition, Russia and China are neighbors that can never move away, so peace and cooperation are of greatest benefits for both sides. China obtains the market, Russia obtains the commodities that are sanctioned by the West and obtains foreign exchange, which is beneficial to both sides. and China has been stable in its policy towards Russia without back-and-forth. as for what is the common interest of China and Russia, is to deal with the pressure of the United States. China didn't agree sanction Russia like other countries , that has become a stain for many countries to criticize, what did russia do for China? why should China be asked to confront the mainstream world for Russia ? China relies heavily on the EU and the US for its scientific and technological sources and economic trade. Don't forget that it was Russia that hurt China more, when the Tsarist Russia stole more than 1.5 million square kilometers of land from China. something you might don't know, The price of oil and gas that China buys from Russia is also more expensive than that of the Middle East. Don't they know the collapse of the Soviet Union is because of the oppression of the United States in the Cold War, and the predicament after is also made by the United States, If you can not distinguish between the enemy and friends , there will be no wonder Russia has no friends, even the Central Asian Soviet Union countries to betray, because that hurts the heart of the friends.
Coming from one of the more neutral countires, there has never been a mention of Russia being blamed for that in the textbooks or any internet articles I've read in my language or in English.
>> I don't ever remember being taught Russia was to blame for bombing Japan. Was you taught about mass imprisonment of innocent men of japan origin in the USA??
Конечно помним. Однако мы также помним как вы сделали все чтобы все стало еще хуже. Начиная с поддержки Ельцина, заканчивая помощью чеченскими террористам.
@@rutgerb Of course I don't do that. What should I thank you for? Will you thank me if I join in your beating and then throw a pack of Band-Aids in your face?
Throughout 3000 years of history, China fought foreign invaders alone, never had allies. We did get help from the U.S. against Japan during WWII. But we won't forget after 1937 when Japan invaded China, U.S. merchants continued to sell oil and steel to Japan to help them kill Chinese. We also won't forget those "allies" who helped build Japan into an empire the first place.
What are you talking about? America is a friend of China for a long time, even when Russia has plans to divide for China, America does not have those plans. America's enemy is not China but the communist ideology. If it weren't for the help of Britain and the United States, I don't even see the possibility that the Chinese Nationalist Army has a chance in the armed struggle against Imperial Japan. America was still in business when the Chinese Nationalist Army still had a chance of victory, but when Japan attacked Indochina and South China, America stopped selling oil to Japan because the supply lines used to send weapons and materials to the Nationalist troops were cut. what is your nationality? Are you a citizen of the People's Republic of China?
@@Arcticos0 Minimizing the role of the United States in helping the Chinese nationalist troops is the official position of the Communist Party, the Communist Party is just bandits trying to establish a failed communist system
Understandable by older generations but the hate that is carrying to younger people is a huge problem. The whole "I won't forget what your country and your people did even though I didn't experience it myself" is so dangerous to our society.
Those who enslaved the Africans are now waging trade war and doing smear campaign against China. Imperialism lives on, within the minds of westerners and Japanese alike. It is part of their DNA.
Thank you very much for your videos, the questions are always respectful, interesting, smartly focused on one subject and the answers offer a large variety of what the Russian people could think. I really appreciate getting to know the closest-to-real point of vue of your people!
I like it when the interviewees come out with some bizarre fiction that they have been taught, like the USA blaming Russia for Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Here is the West's version of events. 26th July, USA, UK and China issued Potsdam Declaration (surrender or be destroyed). Japan didn't surrender. Aug 6th, USA bombed Hiroshima. Aug 9th, Soviet Union invaded Manchuria and USA bombed Nagasaki. Aug 15th, Hirohito announced surrender. What is Russia's version, I wonder?
The questions are provocative as always. It is especially unpleasant to listen to ignorant zoomers. People who choose USA, as if they did not understand that the current level of relations is the level of the Cold War. As Emperor Alexander 3 said, Russia has only two allies: its army and navy.
@@videowa4er It is a real bias, now, isn't it ? In most videos like this one, people always interview very young students, as if they know anything about politics or life. 🙄
@@oldbloke135 What the girl in the video said was that someone interviewed young Japanese, and many young Japanese blamed Russia for Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This is the result of Japan's long-term vassalage to the United States and the propaganda and education it has received.
Very good. This is among the best of your videos, Daniil. Congratulations to you and Artyom!! Sheer luck, really, as you bumped into a large number of articulate and well-informed people to interview. Thanks!
@@romanz9342 If true, I am all right with that, Roman. But viewing from my little New York City bubble, I am very glad that Daniil and his crew are giving me the opportunity to listen to views from urban and semi-rural Russia. It gives me a small (though imperfect) window into Russia that I would not have had otherwise.
What the hell is with all of your “the next question should be” statements? One OK, 2 perhaps, but come on - find another ‘clever’ way to start your point. 🥱
Couldn't believe the guy in one video a while back using the apparent Russian equivalent of the "N" word while wearing a hat with the Michael Jordan jumpman logo. Clueless zombies.
Good to see a diverse spectrum of answers, but I am indeed surprised by the percentage of people expressing favorable views toward EU & US even at this historical moment, with ongoing war happening. Not sure how many Americans will express their favorable views toward USSR back in Vietnam. Many Chinese do not really have much clue on historical events on Russia-China relationship, and sadly it seems the Russian side wasn't much better on that neither. Both side were only educated on events where they got screwed by the other side, but clueless on events where they screwed the other side. Victims of propaganda barking at each other all the time. Both playing victims but in reality both deserve each other, I guess
Nah, its pro-liberal channel, here are compilation of opinions of a small part of the population in the center of Moscow, of course here is alot of pro-western zoomers. In other places situation is completely different
Watching this made me think of how the sentence "When one run out of arguments one resort to violence" also holds true to countries & geopolitics. Interesting topics & opinions as always Daniil.
You are correct: "One of the most senior US officials in the Pacific has refused to rule out military action against Solomon Islands if it were to allow China to establish a military base there, saying that the security deal between the countries presented “potential regional security implications” for the US and other allies. 26 abr 2022"
The US never wait until it has ran out of arguments before resorting to violence. Violence is the only thing they think of all day! They killed more Americans than all the world combined.
There were no arguments anyway. From very beginning, as in past, so now, the West only wants colonies, with cheap labor and resources. They don't need allies because they are possible competitors. Looking at arrogance of west, I don't mind if this world burns to ground.
100%, she's one of those who thinks is smart but is stupid as f... 😂 I like the part with Moskvich car. That car comes 100% made in China and they just install the badge in russia 😂 And I love when soviets talk their anti-west cr@p wearing Marshall headphones 😂
У государства как системы, да, а вот у отдельных представителей государства, чиновники или там президенты и премьер министры,то вполне могут быть и союзники и друзья,межличносные которые в конечном итоге могут влиять на политику всего гос-ва.
"We've always had a fairly positive relationship with China, except for the conflict on Damansky Island" I guess she didn't learn that island is part of Outer Manchuria, which the Russians forcefully took from China in the 19th century. That's over one million square km worth of land, now giving Russia access to the Sea of Japan. I'm sure China would love to take that back. Russia is the only European country that still holds historically Chinese territories.
Imperial china ceded those lands without a fight because their control was nominal. There were no chinese subjects to bring under Russian rule. Few chinese habour irredentist thoughts wrt to russia and nobody claims those lands as you fantasize.
Well, Russia in one way or another will lose the Amur region including vladivostok. It will remain a russian city by name only. Maybe - prior to 2022 I never thought of that - it will be for the best. Amur and Siberia under chinese influence and indirect rulle could thrive. If Russians can t develop the eastern regions possibly the Chinese can?
@@formikulo nor did any Russians ever live there until they stole it from china , china had official territorial claims in the UN for most of Siberia until the mid 2000's If you think that the Chinese will provide one pence of assistance without reclaiming that lost territory , likely you haven't spent much time in china , their stolen Siberian land is more of a hot button issue to average Chinese than Taiwan
They forgot the American Civil War. The Russian Pacific fleet wintered in San Francisco and the Russians provided the Union with updates on European artillery updates.
A young woman is speaking in Chinese but cannot be heard over the noise. But it was interesting. 1420 is my favourite. Keep up the good work, Daniil, and all the staff.
There was a proverb in Russia and I didn't understand it until last year: "Optimists study English, pessimists study Chinese, realists study Kalashnikov".
Wow, I think choosing between Shenzhen or Detroit must be a very difficult choice. "Which of these cities would I like to visit? Hummm... I really need quite a bit to decide."🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Потому что страна наша страна это наше личное это как огромная семья и большой общий дом , это наши традиции , если вы не уважаете это то не стоит лезть сюда
@@EcoZen24I dont care what the traditions are in your country, but I do if you think it gives you the right to invade a neighbouring country! I see it as a problem when to the crimes committed by the Russian government you simply say 'these are our traditions, we are like a big family and a common house '. So is that enough to stop you from having a conscience and listen to your inner voice? If your father goes to the neighbour, kicks his door in, kills the wife and children, destroys the flat all you say is 'these are our traditions ' ? Well in that case people do mind and certainly would not want to come to your country. You killed 40.000 in Grosny, devastated the city, just like Aleppo, Mariupol and Kharkiv, invaded Georgia and Ukraine, have Journalists and Politicians in huge numbers killed, kidnapped children, imprisoned civilians with different opinions and keep telling yourself everyone else is evil and against you? You are bullies! Let me tell you, as a German, you will deal for generations with the consequences of you, the people, supporting crime and war by your country and making wrong excuses for it. And you deserve it.
It would be good if Russia would use Mexico for its own selfish purposes against the United States. How would the Americans react, would they be fools if they defended their borders? You Englishmen don't have to meddle where they shouldn't, I assure you we live very well in Russia. We are not afraid that we will not be able to go to Europe or the USA, we can go to many other countries. We do not need your technologies, and why should we service your external debt to our own detriment? In the war in Ukraine, the US aggressor against Russia is 100%.
we raised you, but somehow forgot about ourselves. )) In fact, we have serfdom (just a hidden character). And on the throne is another digenerate king, as in the old days. The only plus of this system (can you imagine, there are such) is the absence of LGBT propaganda. Sorry, but this is definitely immoral and unnatural, not to mention transgender people.
I wonder if that girl thought (was told) that Russia opening a new front against Japan forced America's hand and therefore were somewhere held responsible for the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs? Or was it some Z propaganda thing where the West claims Russia really dropped those bombs? I wish there had been a follow up question on that one...
Given that US used this as display of power. Why would US accuse USSR for developing nuclear bomb, cutting edge at that time and most impressive scientific and military achievement. Ridiculous.
USSR did not declare war and invade until two days AFTER the first bomb was dropped. The US was pushing USSR to get in the war. They probably think that it was because the US had to drop the nukes because USSR was getting into the war.
I don’t know the channel and I don’t know how much cherry picking went on in the process of making this video. What I find impressive is how much these young people seems to care and to be informed about what’s going on. You can’t find that level of interest in Italy, where I live, even in older generations (of course they are much more involved in geopolitical events than we are, but still…) Also, quite brave for them to discuss politics so openly, I truly hope they will not incur in any problem because of it!
I can only guess they are deliberately targeting young people close to universities OR make a huge amount of interviews as I kinda doubt every Russian is that interested in politics.
It’s not hard to be interested in geopolitics while your country is in the middle of the war which has no benefits to anyone besides the current government.
@@CoIdHeatI, as a Russian, will tell you that I am as actively interested in politics as all my classmates and friends, I think 80% of Russians are interested in politics, and I was shocked when I found out that my friend from Austria knows practically nothing about politics, I thought Europe is also interested in this
7:49 What right do they have? A similar question: what right does Russia have to send its troops into the territory of another country and shell their cities there? Even if this grandmother supports the so-called Special Military Operation, she cannot but understand that Russian soldiers are not just sitting there and drinking tea.
@@ПавелЗольников-п7э 1 раз?)))) Напомнить в каком году войска в Грузию вводили? Напомнить в каком году войска в Крым направили, когда он еще Украинским был? Напомнить, войска какой частной военной компании тусуют в Африке?
In California, I have met Americans of Russian decent. Personally, I enjoy interacting with People from other countries. Being an immigrant to the US myself I enjoy the ‘melting pot’ concept. Although we are far from perfect, everyone brings positive and yes sometimes negatives to the table.
@@shiinondogewalker2809 What's the goal of that comment? Like he said, you can meet Americans of Russian decent. Other cultures influence by ours in our country. No crap you can find diversity in other countries. America is not the most diverse country in the world. I specifically meant other cultures mixed with American culture in America. Ur tryna be offended when there's nothing to be offended about.
@@Johnny-wf1df my goal was to make sure there's one less false statement on youtube, all while using few characters to type and being slightly annoying in the process. Thank you for retracting your statement sir that's most appreciated
I love watching your channel because it is such an incredibly strong illustration of the power of propaganda. Over the last year, I've heard a continuous change in the comments and tenor of the Russian people. The older people especially (whom I assume are not really reading any external news via VPN), have said increasingly crazy things and forget the logic of the early invasion (Ukrainian Nazis). It reminds me to consider news from multiple sources, and those outside of those of my own preferences. If you don't hear multiple viewpoints, you only reinforce your own beliefs, which may be false. I know we are all susceptible to these manipulations. I hope they, and we, can see the truth behind the propaganda.
"If you don't hear multiple viewpoints, you only reinforce your own beliefs, which may be false" Good point, something happened in the UK a couple of years ago which surprised part of the population - because they only read/watched/heard views like theirs.
Preach. Watching these videos are so eye opening to how powerful media is. I've started watching EU news stations live here on YT because American political reporting is so polarizing, superficial and not very deep from both sides of the political spectrum. And as a Moderate/Centrist/Independent voter I just can't stand US Journalism anymore. It's interesting to hear about other news and stories going on around the world that just doesn't get any airtime in the US.
The question is what is the natural course of events for the future. This very difficult to discern. Howevre, look into the heart of the people of Russia for their ambitions and dreams. This video is insightful.
Yeah Sinno-Soviet relations have always been great, unless you count that time the Soviets were preparing to wipe China off the face of the earth with a nuclear strike. Then the US president got on the phone and threatened a nuclear response if the Soviets acted. Other than that, stellar relations.
It seems that distrust in China is same for everyone in the world. Also funny that no matter how bad things go, Russian old people still seem to think that every good option for future is to be Soviet Union again. Babushkas are truly soviet to the bone. Golden memories for those who lived in privileged urban areas with no holodomors etc. Even though they were not privileged at all compared to West.
@@РусланЗаурбеков-з6е Communism is rubbish, suffering and poverty, death and despair. Any other fantasies and false memories are false. Old people always love old times and whatever it is today is wrong and terrible. It's always been this way, especially after societies started to develop and grew and technology skyrocketed. There is no answers in ancient false views, religions and other fantasies, and there's no deity controlling anything, and if there was, it's still a moot point, they are the ones controlling everything, puppets ignore their strings and do nothing else what the puppeteer moves them. "I can do no wrong. For I don't know what it is".
Nostalgia for past eras is the inevitable part of humans growing old. In the US, we're seeing a huge surge in the belief that things were better in the 80s, for example. Trump's MAGA slogan is an example of someone weaponising nostalgia, even though Americans were actually worse off in the 80s. Boris Johnson and Farage did the same in the UK, causing us voting for brexit. The phrase "we're no so different, you and I" springs to mind.
@@peterclarke7240 Both MAGA and Boris Johnson and anti-EU and exit movements were something that Russia has backed up and spread with trolls for over a decade now. It's funny how Putin then instantly repaired all the cracks between EU countries and USA by starting a war. Stronger than ever, and instantly also two new NATO members and NATO firmly united from pieces. Democracy won. Easily. Despite Putin's grandiose fantasies that have become a some sort of a religion, or cult. Now the Russian regime and it's corrupt network is destroyed in Ukraine, and it will never rise again.
Well it's like you want to have a friend but they just won't take their meds and now they're attacking one of your other friends. It's seriously mind-blowing how some Russians can believe that the West was after them... It's all our fault for thinking Russia would drop the anti-western sentiment. There is still obviously a lot of resentment. Haters gonna hate.
Leon is 17 years old and already he has a greater understanding of geopolitics than most Russians. Gives me hope for a different Russia in the future that can work with other countries. It's interesting to see how many people are aware of how China cannot be trusted as an ally. Another student also pointed out China has never really had Russia's back when the US helped them in the 90s. Even I didn't know that!
@@kastus77 In the beginning of 90s russians were starving - again - and US provided food (not the first time in russia's history) - nozhki busha - chicken legs. Also Ukraine provided grain.
Really?? He didn't express any deep thoughts, he just said he can't trust China completely as well as anyone else. Where has you seen such "great understanding of geopolitics"? For me, it was Sofia who is more educated, she talked a lot. P.S. Yes, but USA supported Russia driving into the 90s in the first place, that doesn't sound as a gratuitous ally...
Countries do not have friends or enemies. They have interests. Russia is entitled to pursue its interests, but what they cannot do is go around invading countries unless there is a reason like an attack or something (which is not the case)
huh, USSR helped China with tech a lot. just look to military equipment of China. very similar to soviet. of cource USA was better partner and China switch to USA later on. but seems China never thankful for help. not for soviet, not for americans small invasion to USSR in 1969. and now dancing with Taiwan. proofing this.
@@soen2368 Ussr invade china not the other way around . You think Canada will invade America?😂 And china treat ussr so well. Mao Zedong think the successor of ussr run counter to the will of Stalin and came into some kind of revisionist government.
В истории России была установлена власть Коммунистической партии, даже в современной политической системе существует много сходства между Китаем и Россией. На самом деле, решения и мышление людей из этих двух стран довольно похожи. Когда я работал в одном из вузов, канцлер моей нанятой факультета был членом Российской академии наук и бывшим первым секретарем партии Коммунистической партии СССР.
I, against my will 😂, have to agree. However, I believe it's like what my son said once, many years ago, as a teenager that just came up with a humorous comment on something, that actually was spot on the "true truth" on the subject. "So, I'm wiser than my understanding?" "Så jag är klokare än mitt förstånd?" Meaning, they aren't aware of what they say is really clever. The words just happened to come out that way.😅
Treaty of Aigun 1858 and Convention of Peking 1860 Russia took Tanu Tuva, territories in central Asia and entirety of Outer Manchuria. Wouldn't bet that chinese forgot those unequal treaties. Russia is not in a good geopolitical situation, not anymore.
Undoubtedly the Chinese all remember. I was in China for some time in the early 1990s and was amazed at the widespread knowledge and resentment towards the British regarding Hong Kong. And the Chinese I met in the mining industry were all very resentful of the Russian technical assistants (engineers and geologists) who "helped" them modernise. These Russians insisted the Chinese learn Russian, and made no attempt to learn Mandarin while they were in China. The Chinese of today carry a very big chip on their shoulder regarding their past treatment by the West, Japan, Russia. They teach these past injustices in their schools.
I am Chinese, I will never forget how western powers such as Japan Russia, Britain, France, Germany, America, Italy, Austria-Hungary, Germany, Italy bullied China when China was weak, never forget
Guys, she didn't say here that the US blames Russia for the bombing of Hiroshima. This is not a correct translation. She said that after a long time, Japan began to believe that the USSR was the cause of this bombing. You were brazenly deceived in the translation, it is completely incorrect in some moments.
That girl with the guy under umbrella... Alternate reality.. what is she smoking? It's Russia who is constantly attacking neighbors so US doesn't support that andshe thinks US blames Russia for atom bomb on Hiroshima? Nothing she says makes sense
A really interesting set of opinions. Easy to focus on the more outlandish ones but by and large well reasoned and thoughtful. The older lady at the end stating that Russia had helped the west get richer by selling its resources to the west and then buying its goods has more than a degree of truth. But it ignores the role of Oligarchs and the widespread corruption within Russia that has held it back.
The oligarchs are the result of the destructive nature of man, we could not do anything with them, and you pandered to them. It is difficult to say how strong control over the economy is necessary in our case, and how far we can go. You will hang new stamps and labels, calling us a totalitarian society more and more loudly. At the same time, you will introduce new prohibitions and restrictions in your societies in the same way. I hope you have lived well for the last 30 years?
And the fun part (or tragic more likely) is that they think they are some sort of superpower. 😂😂😂 With an economy and development like a mid 3:rd world country.......
0:30 and at 50 seconds are both right. China is not true ally of Russia. No loyalty between the two unlike the collective west. it's a relationship of pure convenience where one side will drop the other at the moment the other side isn't beneficial to their short term goals.
@clemathieu JT There are 26 photos of the SS-750 Russian navy ship, which carries a small submarine that is designed to carry out underwater operations. A Danish patrol boat detected a Russian vessel near the Nord Stream gas pipelines four days before they were sabotaged in multiple blasts, according to media reports. The defense command confirmed it had 26 images of the SS-750 Russian navy ship, which carries a small submarine that is designed to carry out underwater operations, photographed from a Danish patrol boat in the vicinity of the pipelines on September 22, 2022, local newspaper Dagbladet Information reported Thursday.
I really love this channel. Comments here are better than any humorous show. I love to read how "educated", "enlightened", "free" and "democratic" Anglo-Saxons pity us, the dense, unhappy Russians and want to re-educate us and teach us to read their "correct" history textbooks. You guys are so cool, it's so fun to read your snobbery and complete misunderstanding of my country. Keep going, don't stop😄
Hey, if the shoe fits. It’s “your” countrymen sharing the words of your countrymen… and Russians like yourself sure like to complain about everyone else.
The US is really operating things amazingly smooth... I've watched many street interviews in Japan. Even though the US had dropped 2 nuclear booms in Japan, most of the japanese favourite country is the U.S. Here are the same. amazing.amazing.amazing
Based on some Russian comments here, she never said US blame USSR, but said "In Japan, they built such attitudes that Russia is to blame." Stalin invaded Manchuria the same day the 2nd a-bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. So the Japanese people probably felt they were stabbed in the back and blame USSR for them losing WWII, not for actually dropping the a-bomb.
Fascinating how russkies don't seem to remember they were in Afghanistan FIRST, or that they were in Syria as well, using chemical weapons, no less. And...uhh...darn them for Hiroshima?
Somehow most people on both sides have missed the fact that for the past 200 years , china and Russia were mortal enemies supporting opposing armies during the cold war Beyond that china had territorial claims against Russia for most of Siberia until 2017 including Vladivostok If you actually spend time in china , average Chinese are furious about this. They vent more about losing Siberia and Mongolia than about Taiwan which plays big in the west. It is because in china everyone knows and believes that Taiwan is a part of china , because Taiwan never declared independence and no major countries recognize or claim it , this is not a big concern for normal people debated about , where as you will hear them moan and groan and claim that everything from the Pacific to lake Baikal is Chinese
@@knyghtryder3599 I knew China and USSR had an on again-off again relationship, but I didn't know Chinese claims from the Pacific to Lake Baikal. Right now I see it both as an alliance of convenience and perhaps an attempt by China to add the biggest spoke yet to its Belt and Road program. It would be ironic if Putin set out to rebuild the Soviet Empire and ended up turning Russia into a Chinese client state.
@@knyghtryder3599 The pair of Russia and China right now resemble the Soviet Union and Germany before the WW2. I wouldn't be surprised to see WW3 in the near future, where the USA would be ironically helping Russia to fend off the Chinese invasion.
After watching this interview. Sadly to say most younger Russian seems to be very ignorant not knowing how much badness and exploitation done on Russia and treating their exploiter as ally. The power of distorted internet media which was carefully manipulated had rooted in younger Russian. More should be done, reading from history books is essential. Polarised opinions and not able to differentiate facts and fictional story will destroy younger Russian's patriotism to their Government.
Russian govt has been trying to integrate to Europe, since the fall of USSR & that is on record. After the fall of USSR, Russia asked for help from US & western Europe to create Russian Constitution & help with the economy, but Russia was flat out rejected, accdg. to Jeffrey Sachs who were there. US & western Europe helped others tho like Poland.With the declassification of US records, we now know that US has viewed Russia as their enemy even when Russia was weak. The plan has been always to expand NATO to ex-soviet states, create chaos within & surrounding Russia, & divide Russia into many smaller countries, which for me are all existential threat to their country, Russia. China is not Russia's natural ally, but they do not have a choice but to have good relationship with them, as they share similar problems. West is Russia's natural ally, but they never want Russia anyway. It is a mistake in US foreign policy, esp with the emergence of upcoming Superpower, China. This video baffles me that they seem to think that US is better than China, when declassified docs & history of actions of US has been to dismantle Russia. lol
When has the US ever blamed the USSR for the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki? And what would be the purpose?
propaganda
Crazy propaganda in Russia 🙄🙄😀
They are deranged.
Exacly, it's first time when i hear such a kind of statement. Seems like propaganda for their internal audience.
It happened AFTER the Germans bombed Pearl Harbor. What do they teach you in school? Yes, I am kidding. 🙂
What school did she go to?...The Americans blamed Russia for Hiroshma/Nagasaki....i suppose the brainwashing has to start somewhere.🤣🤣
That's the one where I was like.... wait what?
На самом деле, это довольно часто встречающийся "аргумент". Думаю, он появился благодаря социальным опросам, в которых очень "образованные" японцы обвиняли русских в бомбардировке Хиросимы и Нагасаки, потому что они на самом деле не знают, кто это сделал (а если ты не знаешь, кто виноват - значит виноваты русские)
I KNOW And she got a carry out boyfriend from china so that’s where her loyalty lies, but how stupid not the poor girl but the system that Indoctrinated her such. And she needs to take a breath and really think before she talks
@Max შემიწყალე cite your source please
@Max შემიწყალე even if that is true, that doesn't mean the US blamed anyone. Do you know what blame means?
What is the woman at 1:20 blabbing on about? She says the US blames USSR/Russia for the atomic bombs dropped in Japan? As an American, I've never heard this. And said US-Russian relations have never been positive except WW2 but the 1990's things were relatively positive. There was hope that Russia would turn into a normal country but the brutal way Russia fought in Chechnya gave the west and US less hope in Russia. It was under Putin the relations soured.
Do not lie. USA were quite in good relationships with Eltsin who started war in Chechnya. But with much worse with Putin who finished that war
That poor guy she was with looked like he had to hear her talk a lot...
@@kastus77 Yeltsin, right? Is it Eltsin in Russian? The mid 90's fight in Chechyna was already seen as troubling in the west but they hoped things would change. The 1999 fighting lead by Putin was brutal and that really concerned the US and west. Putin did basically what he had done in Ukraine and Syria which is target civilians and punish them.
@@Stephen85 she doesn't stop yapping ffs!
I heard several times that Japan was about to surrender anyway, and the bombs had 2 goals : end the war before USSR turn against Japan and take control of the island, and the bomb will show how powerful the US are so the USSR will not turn against them.
I guess that's what she refers to
These Russian people understand the relationship with China better than I would have expected.
We can no longer return to cooperation with Europe and the United States without losing sovereignty, so China remains the only option.
how's that? you can't compare education in Europe, including russia and older soviet countries, with any other in the world apart from countries like Singapore, Hong-Kong, etc. In the Americas, besides Canada, the rest is really bad, and unfortunately, Africa is still the wealthier continent with the poorer educated (as we wish, of course).
It does for now, or in the short term, but for long-term strategy, it is not too peaceful for two great powers to border each other.
@@peristicas3119Because they seem to understand that China is no one's real friend. China only cares about China, and how other countries can help China achieve world dominance.
@@peristicas3119Here in Spain I think the education is pretty bad. However I've met classmates that went to a US highschool and said it was much easier.
According to Valentina 2:46, when the US comes to the aid of a people under attack by tyrants, it's "starting a war." Ok then: In that case, when the US began aiding the USSR in the 1940s, it "started" World War II. 🙄🙄🙄🙄
And she's supposed to be an educated person! (Retired economist.)
maybe early retired (fired)
What tyrants? If there's any country that loves tyrants is the United States
You say when in 1933 the usa
FINANCED THE NSDAP OR IN 2014 BIDEN ORDERED THE SHELLING OF THE DONBASS?
"Well, by judging what the astrologers predict, we will be prosperous by 2032"
😅😅😅
Now you know where she got all her informations from
I'm speechless wtf 🤪🤪🙄🙄
With a demographic collapse on the front door😂😂
Hahaha last time i heard an astrologist said the next yr will be prosperous then china virus came 😂
Astrologers perdicted the "operation" would end in less than a week 😅
I’m sorry wait, the US said the Soviet Union was to blame for Hiroshima and Nagasaki? Wait what?
Yeah, maybe Russians were told that by the Soviets, but the US never said it.
The most funniest thing America country based on plenty of genocides now blaming other countries for human rights
The US tells a lot of fantasy like Russia bombed its own pipelines 😂
Propaganda in school since 1917, you are welcome :)
@Max შემიწყალე even if that had anything to do with it (which I disagree with because Japan remained independent) it is sure as heck not ‘blaming’ the Soviet Union.
She never said that US blamed Russia about Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombing. She said "В японии выстроили такие отошения что виновата pоссия". Translation is "In Japan, they built such attitudes that Russia is to blame". I saw a video where Japanese people were asked about who bombed them and majority said Russia. The question remains - why people think that.
I would imagine the Japanese still remembered defeating Russia in the Russo-Japanese War and other hostilities with Russia, which is a close geographic neighbor, and so in many ways it was an almost natural, albeit incorrect, conclusion that it was the Russians as they had ample historical reason to be vindictive towards the Japanese people.
Because they were not taught properly in school and ignorant about it, and that’s by design.
Stalin invaded Manchuria the same day the 2nd a-bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. So the Japanese people probably felt they were stabbed in the back and blame USSR for them losing WWII, not dropping the a-bomb.
@@mintheman7 Ah yes, stabing in the back someone from Axis, who already invaded USSR
@@iMost067 Japan never invaded USSR in WWII. Stalin didn't want to fight a 2-front war and Japan didn't have enough resources to fight USSR and US at the same time, so they signed a neutrality agreement. Of course Stalin also signed a neutrality agreement with Hitler.
9:17 did he just say there are no severe censorship in Russia ?!
Allllrighty then.
Yeah, I wish he asked the person to recite the anti war phrase (niet voyna=no war) openly on video after they say such stupid stuff.
If cosider decapitation as severe, there is no severe censorship.
"can't complain"
Censorship exists only on paper
@@namesurname-1488 Bullshit
"how can they attack us?" Some people are detached from reality to assume that they can wage war, and not be hit back by those same people. They don't have their own feet attached to the ground.
Unbelievable. I get upset just hearing them talk like they are a victim when whole cities have been totally destroyed by Russia
How does Ukraine or any other country want independence? Only Russia can be independent! Mentally ill poeple.
She is convinced russia and ukraine is fighting as allies against nato.
It gets like that. I know every time I'm randomly going to punch somebody. I always freak out when they punch me back.
It's just that she's only heard propaganda and is convinced that Russia was never the one attacking anyone in the first place, but has to "defend" it's souvernity. Can't blame her, she's old and probably only watches TV.
''You can expect anything from even your closest ones these days!''
Yeah, Georgians, Ukrainians and Chechens know a thing or two about that.
Хорошо, что Уркаина исчезает, иначе история узнала бы еще много случаев массовых убийств.
Well said. I wasn't able to reply to the troll who replied to your comment so I had to attach my reply to yours - I hope that's clear!
Something...somthing kuril and north manchuria.
Русские тоже знают, что можно ожидать от "братьев".
@@Katerina.r таких "братьев" как русские врагу не пожелаешь...
as a Chinese, the history with Russia is super complicated. China has lost most of her territory to Russia/USSR directly or indirectly. However China had also received a lot of assistance from USSR in the 50s. Today, it was the US led Western world that pushed Russia and China closer. Maybe it's not an alliance but it's definitely a partnership that benefits both sides
China should be last one to complain about lost territory.
@@Thinkaton10 Yes, imo only indigenous people such as the First Nations of Canada, USA, Australia, and New Zealand have the right to complain. The settlers have exploited, genocided, and pushed the native people into tiny pockets of Indian Reserves. Of these countries, New Zealand is probably the one doing the most for reparation. All that's left to do is to change the name back to Aotearoa and elect a new flag, national anthem, and education system as Canada did. Australia and the US should follow suit.
@@Thinkaton10 the usa, unlike latin america, exterminated all its natives and imposed other cultures and customs
@@talyssonkrigor That's a caricature of history betraying a total lack of knowledge and understanding of both Americas.
@@Thinkaton10 一码归一码！
Umbrella holding boyfriend appears to be rethinking his relationship. Maybe get a dog next time. 😂
LOL I agree
Yeah he had that "what have I done" look on his face...
What instead of a bitch!
Maybe he's thinking "Next time I will try an actual Chinese girl instead of a Russky who is just trying to kiss up to me by pretending to like the tyrants running China right now."
hey people are entitled to their opinion. Don't be hateful
1:11 Вообще-то, Россия и США были в хороших отношениях с момента обретения последними независимости вплоть до падения Российской Империи. Так что, за исключением периода Холодной Войны, Россия и США - это, как ни странно, исторические друзья.
Да я надеюсь мы помиримся когда нибудь снова, если политики опять не будут мутить воду
@@УважаемыйИван-с9чнет чувак, не будет никакой России в будущем. Ваша судьба это развал на маленькие кусочки, империя зла будет уничтожена. Слава Украине 🇺🇦💪🏻
@@УважаемыйИван-с9ч I hope so to and I’m from the U.K.
раньше были и другие сверхдержавы. теперь только Россия и США.
And oddly enough America also totally won WWII on behalf of russia, who would have completely collapsed without never-ending American supplies. Russians forget that a lot.
"Judging by what astrologers predict..." Say no more.
And she said that seriously! 🤣🤣
Conspiracies are extremely popular in RF
there's the atheistic and progressive soviet education for you
It seemed like she was joking
I would rather the question being asked is of “good partners” rather than “allies”. Ally typically means you are all in on most if not all geopol-topics and must come to aid without regards for self interests, or the interests are mostly aligned. You can enjoy very close relationships and help each other economically, militarily internationally, but you should not lose your own national identities. China is a explicitly stated Non-Ally country. So I don’t think they are the ally that you are looking for. Nor should you expect allies in that strict “Ally”definition nowadays. US could be partners but they would prefer to keep larger countries subjugated unless you are small and could never pose any threats or challenges to their hegemony, or they will fuck you over like they are doing with Russia and China today. After all, “自力更生 (work hard yourselves)but with lots of good friends”should every countries motto.
所以，印度要想发展，阻碍他们的不是中国，一定是美国。
At least China don't attack u from eastern part and helped Russia in economy so u can stand still, unlike 1989
who cares
asad
老铁说得可以，6666
Russia is now a vassal state to China, the junior partner in their new relationship, a source of raw materials for their industries.
14 months ago Russia was the leader of Central Asia, now the undisputed leader of that region is China.
Russia is starting to resemble N. Korea more and more every day.
W comment
true. China has absolutely NO interest in building up the russian industry, all it wants is cheap oil and gas and they will just flood the russian market with their own products, as it is way cheaper for them to produce in China. So not having western investors in the russian economy will lead to russia being the new Iran. Only ressources, nothing else. Oh, of course some nukes.
Even now you are trying to humiliate the Russians and trying to do it with the whole world, but the world has changed.since the 90s
Russia has always been a poor country. Not a leader of anything
@@gm-123-0 at least they could still show their muscles to apear greater than they are. it's not even an option now.
Rumor has it that Sofa is still talking.
🤣 🤣 🤣 🤣
The boyfriend seems used to it.
@@liamros3562 he is still holding the umbrella 😂
felt so sorry for that SIMP
Where do these people get their crazy information from?
The young lady talking about the bombs for example! It's mind boggling, honestly.🤔
Is there really any hope for these people?
Glory and Victory to Ukraine!
😊😎🎸🇬🇧🇺🇦
They get it from astrologists as the lady was speaking about
In Japan, it is not customary to say that America bombed their country with nuclear bombs. Young Japanese, I have seen interviews, often do not know who did it and some believe that Russia did it.
@@imperium_vox Young Japanese only need to read a book or look on the internet. Surely they are not that stupid are they?
Victory to Ukraine.
😊😎🎸🇬🇧🇺🇦
@@steveu235 That's the funniest response so far.
From putins tv
As a Chinese I think Russia and China are not allies but we need each other’s support in many situations. China and Russia have maintained very positive relationship, economically and politically, for a long time with mutual respect. Sometimes I think this relationship is even better and more stable and sustainable than allies. No allies can last forever but a good neighbor is possible.
Btw, I have seen so many colleagues from Russia and I work as a software engineer. I have met so many talented Russian engineers with superb math and coding skills. I ❤ them
Cool. But Russia is a terrorist state. Loving their good people does not mean you should be allies.
Though China and Russia have a long border, the border is not near to the population center of either country. So, do Chinese and Russians think of the other as "nearby"?
@@jonlenihan4798 if countries with shared borders are not considered nearby then what are neighbors? Capitals close to each other within 10 miles?
@@controlLyapunov It's a simple question about psychological distance. If you don't know the answer, just say so.
Here in the US, residents of Boston are more attuned to Europe than to Mexico or China. Miami thinks of Columbia and Brasil as nearby. Honolulu thinks about Japan.
@@jonlenihan4798 I get it. Similarly in northeast China people feel close to Russia and Korea. In Inner Mongolia province of China there live many citizens from Mongolia. In Tibet and Yunan people feel even closer to Vietnam and other southeast countries than some part of mainland China. However that doesn’t mean Russia and China are NOT nearby because there are ppl living in the far east side of Russia and the borderline is so long. I encourage you google a city in China called Harbin and check out how heavy it is impacted by Russian culture. If you don’t know the answer just say no
I'm sure Russia will have a much better relationship with China once they annex them 😅
Yup. They are already building the first steps to that goal,
Together with China we will smash the West real good 💪
It is possible that China will not absorb Russia in the sense of annexation, because the risk is too great for China (social, economic, Russia is too depraved and rotten to the very roots). These are two very different autocratic systems based on different values. But China will certainly colonize and fully pacify Russia, so that it will no longer play any role, at most in the style of North Korea. In addition, China also started to care about good relations with Ukraine (due to its resources and location), which (surprise!) will not turn into a Russian colony and a large Russian concentration camp, as both China and Russia imagined a year ago.
@@tnickknight All it takes is a little referendum. Ask some of the Chinese living/working in Russia if they would like their current locations to become part of China. Then declare that they all said yes, sign a few papers and voila.
Lol
I'm yet to hear what legitimate harm did the West do to Russia? What and when exactly was done to Russia by the West? All I hear is bitterness that Russia is not treated as an equal partner by USA and EU combined, which is farcical when Russia has an economy the size of Spain. But no specific explanation is ever given, what did the West do to Russia to deserve hate?
USA support jihadists and Kiev regime for killing russian people. Isn't it enough?
I even do not tell about long game against Russia
Its a part of propaganda from USSR still living 😉
Impossible to answer. Russians had inferiority complex for centuries and destructive behavior since at least 1917.
Apparently we want to destroy Russians and Russia and steal all their oil.
Russia has not conquered the west and therefore evil. Yeah, I don't get it, either.
Lol asking the girl with a Chinese boyfriend to choose.
What is that chinese guy doing there?
@@AlskinsX1-9 holding her umbrella
@@AlskinsX1-9 what do you think? china have too much men and russia don't have enough men left.
He's Asian looking, but that doesn't mean he must be Chinese. He could be Russian (there are many Russians with Asian features) or he could be from a different East Asian country.
@@xaverlustig3581 in the last scene it sounds like she was speaking Mandarin. So probably why people said Chinese.
Interesting topic! You give us ideas to use for our own channel! We will keep watching your videos! Much love from America! ❤
"No severe censorship" Are you joking? You can go to prison for 8 years or more. That isn't censorship?
No, seriously, you're allowed to support the government as much as you want. It's like the old saying about Ford "you can choose any color you want as long as it's black", here it's "you can express any opinion you want as long as it matches the government view"
@Wonder Nine... yes, I had to replay that bit about censorship, as I felt I must have misheard or that they were talking about somewhere else.
Never mind, here, in Russia, it is normal been in parallel reality and do not see naked facts. It is country of absurd, but be careful- that is why we get victory against Napoleon(he did not expect such unprecedented stupidity from the enemy; our tactics then do not lend themselves to any logical explanation at all).
I think he was trying to be ironic.
He just meant Russian censorship is not as severe as Chinese one. It is like saying Russia is more democratic than China.
The Good The Bad and The Ugly….
My mind is blown! 🤯
Slava Ukraini! 🇺🇦
Слава России 🇷🇺🇷🇺Z
@@Илья-у1ю rashists will lose, good always wins. Glory to Ukraine!
@@Илья-у1ю Come to Bakhmut, homeland needs your protection 🧟
@@Илья-у1ю how to say that you are zombie with a couple words:
@@krigsljud Z. O. V. Англичанка закрой свой рот !
7:47 Valentina, 70: "What right do they have!?" Great question! :) They don't have right shelling, but do russians HAVE right shelling Ukrainian cities? Russian logic - we DO have right to do bad things to the whole world, but the whole world DON'T have right to do bad things to us!
Ruski Mir.😅
Это называется "российское лицемерие".
Character in a French play: "Cet animal est très méchant. Quand on l'attaque, il se defend!" ["This animal is very vicious. When you attack it, it defends itself!"]
Если кто-то один намеренно нарушает правила системы, то это могут делать и остальные. Так что не западу судить о действиях России
I loved the sentence from the wise lady at the end, that must be the policy of any sovereign country
I visited Russia about 10 years ago on a tour. It was eye opening as Russia was painted as the evil for so many years by the Western media.
Anyway my tour guide was a lady in her thirty. She was sad to see Russia stopped the space industry which was world leading due to economy, and had to share the knowledge with US for the money. People were looking for quick money instead of building up their competitive edge. China has probably done better in this regard.
@@freefree1219 Ideology talks aside, I think that's why some Russians like Putin say that the downfall of the USSR was a huge geopolitical catastrophe. Russia basically sold their entire country for cheap and that cost them decades of their future.
During the same period, China was just about to jump on the globalization bandwagon and boom in economics, and the policymakers most likely have taken notes from the story very carefully.
@@freefree1219Russia never lead the global space industry, Perhaps in the 60s, briefly.
totally agree bro!
The lady with the umbrella? What are you talking about. She is almost as unhinged as the woman babbering about astrology
My dad had a saying that when people are hell bent on destroying their lives it’s best to let them “live their paycheck”. If you try to rescue these people from their personal choices or try change their world views before they experience the natural consequences of those choices and beliefs, it’s not going to work. They will resent you for trying to help, make you responsible for for their lot in life and then embrace those who are trying to exploit them.
If people in a culture value the mirage of strength and stability of authoritarianism, you can’t rescue them from the natural consequences of that belief. You can only wish them well and leave them to decide when they’ve finally had enough of the corruption and oppression that authoritarianism brings.
Whether we help them or not, Ukraine has spent the last 13 months demonstrating that they will lay down their lives to fight for their sovereignty, freedom and self governance. It couldn’t be more clear that helping Ukraine, by giving them a leg up in this fight, is resources well spent because Ukraine is ready to change. Sadly Russia is probably best left to it’s own devices. Prematurely rescuing them again, like we did in the 90’s, will only perpetuate the problem for both them and for the rest of the world.
If they believe that they can go it alone in the world or that they want to trust and partner with China, we should just let them.
I couldn't agree more. I've thought about this every time that I've heard an American say that the Russian people just don't understand what's happening. I'm certainly not saying that all Russians are bad, but most of them support what is happening. This is what they want.
Yeah I don't have much hope for Russia taking a democratic turn... They are in love with strong men who do nothing but exploit them.... They have proven time and time again they do not value or understand politics. At least many of the intelligent Russians were able to leave and I wish the best for that group...
I listened to a Timothy Snyder lecture the other day, where he says that the best thing that could happen to the russian people is the rf completely, decisively losing this war
Tell me how you saved Russia in the nineties? Directly breathtaking from interest?
Great idea, get away from us please=) and take your nuclear missiles away=)
It's insane how throughout history russia has had countless oppurtunities to make itself one of the most prosperous and powerful nations on earth, at times even coming so close, but has squandered it every single time through authoritarianism, war and corruption.. to what end. The cycle simply repeats and probably will for as long as russia exists as a country.
maybe same other etnic should rule russia
And blame it on the west, the cynical cycle of delusions never end with Russia.
Russia's rural territories, which are most of the state, are deplorable, poor, and undeserved. Most of the wealth is concentrated in Western Russia.
Maybe becouse russia always had western puppets as leasers except for Ivan the grozny and Putin
Lets end this cycle...
To the last person: I don't think you can produce everything yourselves in Russia. I know what I'm talking about, I've owned a Lada.
They could not even make a ballpoint pen.
To be fair...Only ruzzia could produce a Lada in this day and age.😂😂😂😂😂
Trabis weren't much better.
@DMZDMX1 True. I have to admit, they're awesome in their own way, but I wouldn't wanna live in a society dependent on them. Not the most reliable car in the world.
@@mobeltass It was a joke. These foolish people don't realise that their nation is historically one of the least creative in the world and how much they should be grateful to the west for what they have. Strip away that and you have a nation of mediocrity.
If we’re talking about hiroshima and nagasaki can we please also talk about the massacre of katyn and the invasion of poland by russia? Or how the soviets were friends with the nazis and helped them defeating france in 1940? Remember the hitler-stalin pact!
Ya. They've got no clue about that. They never heard about it.... and, wouldn't believe it if they did.
Western Belorussia not Poland
@@willthecat3861 Stalin attempted to justify the occupation of poland, etc, by saying he knew Hitler was going to attack the east so by pretending to be his ally he occupied some of the east and protected it from Hitler. That might almost sound logical and sensical, if it was not for the massacres you mention, the fact Stalin in fact used the occasion to exterminate all the people with military experience, teachers, intelligentsia, politicians, anyone able to organise any kind of resistance against the nazis or against himself, in the countries he occupied and 'saved' from the nazis. This too I suppose although never mentioned in USSR was probably attempted to be portrayed or justified as self defense against capitalists anti communist or fascist partisan traitors - although they were too many for that to make sense.
On 6 and 9 August 1945, the United States detonated two atomic bombs over the Japanese cities of Hiroshima and Nagasaki, respectively. The two aerial bombings together killed between 129,000 and 226,000 people, most of whom were civilians, and remain the only use of nuclear weapons in an armed conflict.
The Katyn massacre was a series of mass executions of nearly 22,000 Polish military officers and intelligentsia prisoners of war carried out by the Soviet Union.
Almost the same numbers.
Did you mean The Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact? (which gave soviets some time to prepare for a war with a country with an ABSOLUTLY OPPOSITE IDEOLOGY) Should study history a little more.
Ussr reconqured polish lands, annexed by Poland during Polish-Soviet War.
But it's useless to enlight you, cause your mind is a dark side of the Moon.
@@danilabychkov7398 Your answer does not make a reasonable and fair comparison. Katyn massacre was only one among very many the soviet union conducted. In every country they occupied, they deported and killed very large number of civilians. They deported millions to Siberia; of those a large proportion died, already a much greater number than civilian deaths in japan. 22 000 is nothing, you have to add the civilians deaths in general the soviet union caused - in the second world war alone these are millions.
The excuse it gave them time to prepare for war does not explain why they killed all military officers and any people able to organise a resistance in all the countries they occupied, countries they knew nazis wanted to attack. The truth is at the time, soviets thought genocide of populations was justified if it could help them enforce what they pretended to be a utopy, and was in fact a totalitarian state. There is no reason to excuse the disregard for human life of the totalitarian soviet union.
If I was the Asian guy with the umbrella I’d find someone else to share it with.
I am really sad for some youth in Russia, there are too ignorant , the elders are more concious , cooperation is about give and take, but they always selfishly expect others only to give .In addition, Russia and China are neighbors that can never move away, so peace and cooperation are of greatest benefits for both sides. China obtains the market, Russia obtains the commodities that are sanctioned by the West and obtains foreign exchange, which is beneficial to both sides. and China has been stable in its policy towards Russia without back-and-forth. as for what is the common interest of China and Russia, is to deal with the pressure of the United States.
China didn't agree sanction Russia like other countries , that has become a stain for many countries to criticize, what did russia do for China? why should China be asked to confront the mainstream world for Russia ? China relies heavily on the EU and the US for its scientific and technological sources and economic trade. Don't forget that it was Russia that hurt China more, when the Tsarist Russia stole more than 1.5 million square kilometers of land from China. something you might don't know, The price of oil and gas that China buys from Russia is also more expensive than that of the Middle East.
Don't they know the collapse of the Soviet Union is because of the oppression of the United States in the Cold War, and the predicament after is also made by the United States,
If you can not distinguish between the enemy and friends , there will be no wonder Russia has no friends, even the Central Asian Soviet Union countries to betray, because that hurts the heart of the friends.
You said what I wanted to say. Young Russians don't understand the situation of their country at all.
Brainwashing and peaceful evolution by western media has worked. This is the impact that Russia allows Western media to spread on young people.
@@answer007-b2n I mean yeah. they're teenagers ?? lol
7:04 The retired Russian economist relies on astrologers. I am going to have to let that sink in.
I'm going to have to start looking at the stars before I invest.
it's Soviet economics, meaning ridiculous esoteric Marxist bs, so there's no wonder really
I don't ever remember being taught Russia was to blame for bombing Japan. This is the first I've heard of it.
USA NEWS, YOUR SSHITTY GOVT N MEDIA SAID THAT.
Well there is a simple explanation , it never happened, that doesn't rule it out being taught all over Russia though
She's a dumb girl who wanted to seem smart by making up some nonsense on the fly
Coming from one of the more neutral countires, there has never been a mention of Russia being blamed for that in the textbooks or any internet articles I've read in my language or in English.
>> I don't ever remember being taught Russia was to blame for bombing Japan.
Was you taught about mass imprisonment of innocent men of japan origin in the USA??
4:19
I didn't think anybody in Russia remembered this.
Конечно помним. Однако мы также помним как вы сделали все чтобы все стало еще хуже. Начиная с поддержки Ельцина, заканчивая помощью чеченскими террористам.
@@Русскийорк-у1м you only remember what Putin wants you to remember.
@@Русскийорк-у1м you dont seem to be grateful.
@@rutgerb Of course I don't do that. What should I thank you for? Will you thank me if I join in your beating and then throw a pack of Band-Aids in your face?
My family remembers. We mostly got help from French people, but we knew that there were packages from US aswell.
Throughout 3000 years of history, China fought foreign invaders alone, never had allies. We did get help from the U.S. against Japan during WWII. But we won't forget after 1937 when Japan invaded China, U.S. merchants continued to sell oil and steel to Japan to help them kill Chinese. We also won't forget those "allies" who helped build Japan into an empire the first place.
What are you talking about? America is a friend of China for a long time, even when Russia has plans to divide for China, America does not have those plans. America's enemy is not China but the communist ideology. If it weren't for the help of Britain and the United States, I don't even see the possibility that the Chinese Nationalist Army has a chance in the armed struggle against Imperial Japan. America was still in business when the Chinese Nationalist Army still had a chance of victory, but when Japan attacked Indochina and South China, America stopped selling oil to Japan because the supply lines used to send weapons and materials to the Nationalist troops were cut. what is your nationality? Are you a citizen of the People's Republic of China?
You don’t need to minimize the help US and Australia provided in WW2, it was a large reason China was liberated.
@@Arcticos0 Minimizing the role of the United States in helping the Chinese nationalist troops is the official position of the Communist Party, the Communist Party is just bandits trying to establish a failed communist system
Understandable by older generations but the hate that is carrying to younger people is a huge problem.
The whole "I won't forget what your country and your people did even though I didn't experience it myself" is so dangerous to our society.
Those who enslaved the Africans are now waging trade war and doing smear campaign against China. Imperialism lives on, within the minds of westerners and Japanese alike. It is part of their DNA.
Thank you very much for your videos, the questions are always respectful, interesting, smartly focused on one subject and the answers offer a large variety of what the Russian people could think. I really appreciate getting to know the closest-to-real point of vue of your people!
I like it when the interviewees come out with some bizarre fiction that they have been taught, like the USA blaming Russia for Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Here is the West's version of events. 26th July, USA, UK and China issued Potsdam Declaration (surrender or be destroyed). Japan didn't surrender. Aug 6th, USA bombed Hiroshima. Aug 9th, Soviet Union invaded Manchuria and USA bombed Nagasaki. Aug 15th, Hirohito announced surrender. What is Russia's version, I wonder?
The questions are provocative as always. It is especially unpleasant to listen to ignorant zoomers. People who choose USA, as if they did not understand that the current level of relations is the level of the Cold War. As Emperor Alexander 3 said, Russia has only two allies: its army and navy.
@@videowa4er It is a real bias, now, isn't it ?
In most videos like this one, people always interview very young students, as if they know anything about politics or life. 🙄
Obviously far from the truth . Cherry picked and arrange.
So many still love US ? Only ignorants believe such
@@oldbloke135 What the girl in the video said was that someone interviewed young Japanese, and many young Japanese blamed Russia for Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This is the result of Japan's long-term vassalage to the United States and the propaganda and education it has received.
9:15 "Here [In Russia] there is no severe censorship."
They are completely detached from reality.
Ага, у нас настолько жесткая цензура что персонажи подобные Данилу спокойно ходят по улице.
Z-zombie people
@@Русскийорк-у1ма такие персонажи как девочка которая нарисовали рисунок за мир теперь в интернате 🤡
He said that Russian censorship is not as severe as Chinese. And that is true
@@Русскийорк-у1м Сталин в аду кстати, удачи ему вместе с Гитлером гореть в котле
Very good. This is among the best of your videos, Daniil. Congratulations to you and Artyom!! Sheer luck, really, as you bumped into a large number of articulate and well-informed people to interview. Thanks!
He edits out articulate and well informed people in other videos for views and "shock content".
@@romanz9342 If true, I am all right with that, Roman. But viewing from my little New York City bubble, I am very glad that Daniil and his crew are giving me the opportunity to listen to views from urban and semi-rural Russia. It gives me a small (though imperfect) window into Russia that I would not have had otherwise.
😂😂😂
Next question should be Should we stop buying western products? Apple,Nike, Gucci etc
What the hell is with all of your “the next question should be” statements? One OK, 2 perhaps, but come on - find another ‘clever’ way to start your point. 🥱
How can I stop buying these brands, if I never started???
You should not have these items to sell due to sanctions ... So please help the sanctions and don't purchase any of them, thanks.
This is not realistic, Western goods will still be bought.
@@LucioSimone nobody asked
I love how they talk about the west wearing their western branded clothes
Couldn't believe the guy in one video a while back using the apparent Russian equivalent of the "N" word while wearing a hat with the Michael Jordan jumpman logo. Clueless zombies.
Western clothes made in China.....
sheeple knobs!
You can’t love anything, while you dirty barking like a homeless dog 🐕
@@bjrgjohannessen5184 do you think all clothes come from china? Actually most of my clothes are not from china...
The Asian man and Russian girl perfect symbol for SINO-RUSSO alliance
You are so wrong, most Asian hate the Chinese, especially the CCP.
Why would you post a picture when you look like that?
That Asian man is obnoxiously loud...just can't stop talking!
would not be surpriced if ukranian women were sold as slaves to chinese men.
You talk nonsense. Like there are no Asian men with American girls
Good to see a diverse spectrum of answers, but I am indeed surprised by the percentage of people expressing favorable views toward EU & US even at this historical moment, with ongoing war happening. Not sure how many Americans will express their favorable views toward USSR back in Vietnam. Many Chinese do not really have much clue on historical events on Russia-China relationship, and sadly it seems the Russian side wasn't much better on that neither. Both side were only educated on events where they got screwed by the other side, but clueless on events where they screwed the other side. Victims of propaganda barking at each other all the time. Both playing victims but in reality both deserve each other, I guess
Nah, its pro-liberal channel, here are compilation of opinions of a small part of the population in the center of Moscow, of course here is alot of pro-western zoomers. In other places situation is completely different
People talk about propaganda in Russia, as if they're not affected by propaganda in their countries. Grow up kids.
Watching this made me think of how the sentence "When one run out of arguments one resort to violence" also holds true to countries & geopolitics. Interesting topics & opinions as always Daniil.
You are correct:
"One of the most senior US officials in the Pacific has refused to rule out military action against Solomon Islands if it were to allow China to establish a military base there, saying that the security deal between the countries presented “potential regional security implications” for the US and other allies. 26 abr 2022"
And the US is the most violent, militaristic country on earth
The US never wait until it has ran out of arguments before resorting to violence. Violence is the only thing they think of all day! They killed more Americans than all the world combined.
There were no arguments anyway. From very beginning, as in past, so now, the West only wants colonies, with cheap labor and resources. They don't need allies because they are possible competitors. Looking at arrogance of west, I don't mind if this world burns to ground.
you are right, all the countries that fought germany in ww2 did so only because they ran out of arguments
1:04 she blathered a lot, yet managed to say nothing! That is some real talent right there
She didn't even let the guy share his opinion. Obviously, she's the boyfriend. Poor guy. He needs rescuing lol
100%, she's one of those who thinks is smart but is stupid as f... 😂
I like the part with Moskvich car. That car comes 100% made in China and they just install the badge in russia 😂
And I love when soviets talk their anti-west cr@p wearing Marshall headphones 😂
@@ymvtech Maybe he's the boss when the lights go out :)
@@ymvtech i doubt he knows Russian
У государства не может быть союзников, могут быть общие интересы (временно) и это всегда нужно держать в уме.
Fact: as an chinese my president have a plan to attack russian when they switch side (fact)
@@whathuy9302любой кто на нас нападёт ждут муки от лучевой болезни мы готовимся к этому дню
У государства как системы, да, а вот у отдельных представителей государства, чиновники или там президенты и премьер министры,то вполне могут быть и союзники и друзья,межличносные которые в конечном итоге могут влиять на политику всего гос-ва.
В этом и проблема Путина он пытается найти союзников или друзей,но никак не партнеров...
@@epzipson6142Плохо вы его знаете, раз так пишите
"We've always had a fairly positive relationship with China, except for the conflict on Damansky Island"
I guess she didn't learn that island is part of Outer Manchuria, which the Russians forcefully took from China in the 19th century. That's over one million square km worth of land, now giving Russia access to the Sea of Japan. I'm sure China would love to take that back.
Russia is the only European country that still holds historically Chinese territories.
Chinese people never lived in Manchuria. Manchurian nomads invaded and conquered China.
Imperial china ceded those lands without a fight because their control was nominal. There were no chinese subjects to bring under Russian rule. Few chinese habour irredentist thoughts wrt to russia and nobody claims those lands as you fantasize.
Well, Russia in one way or another will lose the Amur region including vladivostok. It will remain a russian city by name only. Maybe - prior to 2022 I never thought of that - it will be for the best. Amur and Siberia under chinese influence and indirect rulle could thrive. If Russians can t develop the eastern regions possibly the Chinese can?
@@formikulo nor did any Russians ever live there until they stole it from china , china had official territorial claims in the UN for most of Siberia until the mid 2000's
If you think that the Chinese will provide one pence of assistance without reclaiming that lost territory , likely you haven't spent much time in china , their stolen Siberian land is more of a hot button issue to average Chinese than Taiwan
There were barely any Chinese in that area, its not historically important at all unless you are an extreme revanchist.
Does that young girl ever come up for air ? Otherwise a very informative video as usual from 1420
Hard to breathe when her mouth is full of Chinese spring roll.
She would drive me nuts
What's wrong with all those babushka's they are all war crazy
Nasty lot
They forgot the American Civil War. The Russian Pacific fleet wintered in San Francisco and the Russians provided the Union with updates on European artillery updates.
A young woman is speaking in Chinese but cannot be heard over the noise.
But it was interesting.
1420 is my favourite.
Keep up the good work, Daniil, and all the staff.
good girl, she have learned the language of the future masters of russia
There was a proverb in Russia and I didn't understand it until last year: "Optimists study English, pessimists study Chinese, realists study Kalashnikov".
@@husbanana Hell no.
@@husbanana That is really hilarious, but it’s true. Putin screwed up everything, he has no choice to allying with China, Iran even N.Korea.
@@mrvorp4622 This Russian proverbs in China should be “Optimists study Russian, pessimists study Russian, realists study Xi Jinping.”
Wow, I think choosing between Shenzhen or Detroit must be a very difficult choice. "Which of these cities would I like to visit? Hummm... I really need quite a bit to decide."🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
People seem so terribly naive. They asses everything like a personal relationship. Or like on a monopoly board.
Потому что страна наша страна это наше личное это как огромная семья и большой общий дом , это наши традиции , если вы не уважаете это то не стоит лезть сюда
@@EcoZen24I dont care what the traditions are in your country, but I do if you think it gives you the right to invade a neighbouring country! I see it as a problem when to the crimes committed by the Russian government you simply say 'these are our traditions, we are like a big family and a common house '. So is that enough to stop you from having a conscience and listen to your inner voice? If your father goes to the neighbour, kicks his door in, kills the wife and children, destroys the flat all you say is 'these are our traditions ' ? Well in that case people do mind and certainly would not want to come to your country. You killed 40.000 in Grosny, devastated the city, just like Aleppo, Mariupol and Kharkiv, invaded Georgia and Ukraine, have Journalists and Politicians in huge numbers killed, kidnapped children, imprisoned civilians with different opinions and keep telling yourself everyone else is evil and against you? You are bullies! Let me tell you, as a German, you will deal for generations with the consequences of you, the people, supporting crime and war by your country and making wrong excuses for it. And you deserve it.
главное оружие в России это не ядерное а невероятное количество дураков которых можно посылать в атаку почти все население
😂 Is there a special fools breeding program in place?
Thank you for making me laugh, take care 🤍💙🤍
Thats absolutely true.. cant say better..
It would be good if Russia would use Mexico for its own selfish purposes against the United States. How would the Americans react, would they be fools if they defended their borders? You Englishmen don't have to meddle where they shouldn't, I assure you we live very well in Russia. We are not afraid that we will not be able to go to Europe or the USA, we can go to many other countries. We do not need your technologies, and why should we service your external debt to our own detriment? In the war in Ukraine, the US aggressor against Russia is 100%.
I sincerely tell you that people in Russia are far from stupid, you just have such stereotypes. In Russia, people are much smarter than in the US.
ля, как же ты прав
That woman who says relations have never been good, when soviet union collapsed US gave 1.8 billion in humanitarian aid to help its citizens
Thank you for raising us! 😅
we raised you, but somehow forgot about ourselves. )) In fact, we have serfdom (just a hidden character). And on the throne is another digenerate king, as in the old days. The only plus of this system (can you imagine, there are such) is the absence of LGBT propaganda. Sorry, but this is definitely immoral and unnatural, not to mention transgender people.
You are welcome !
I wonder if that girl thought (was told) that Russia opening a new front against Japan forced America's hand and therefore were somewhere held responsible for the Hiroshima and Nagasaki bombs? Or was it some Z propaganda thing where the West claims Russia really dropped those bombs? I wish there had been a follow up question on that one...
I'm f*cking wondering that too!😂
Very strange, everyone knows it were whale and dolphin.
Given that US used this as display of power. Why would US accuse USSR for developing nuclear bomb, cutting edge at that time and most impressive scientific and military achievement. Ridiculous.
USSR did not declare war and invade until two days AFTER the first bomb was dropped. The US was pushing USSR to get in the war. They probably think that it was because the US had to drop the nukes because USSR was getting into the war.
I don’t know the channel and I don’t know how much cherry picking went on in the process of making this video. What I find impressive is how much these young people seems to care and to be informed about what’s going on. You can’t find that level of interest in Italy, where I live, even in older generations (of course they are much more involved in geopolitical events than we are, but still…)
Also, quite brave for them to discuss politics so openly, I truly hope they will not incur in any problem because of it!
I can only guess they are deliberately targeting young people close to universities OR make a huge amount of interviews as I kinda doubt every Russian is that interested in politics.
Well if Italy was rolling its tanks across the border into Switzerland, the probably everyone of all ages in Italy would be informed of the situation.
It’s not hard to be interested in geopolitics while your country is in the middle of the war which has no benefits to anyone besides the current government.
@@CoIdHeatI, as a Russian, will tell you that I am as actively interested in politics as all my classmates and friends, I think 80% of Russians are interested in politics, and I was shocked when I found out that my friend from Austria knows practically nothing about politics, I thought Europe is also interested in this
@@CrabCommand3rв России вроде нету войны, ты о чем? Да и тут говорится ВПРИНЦИПЕ о интересе в политике, и да в России этого много еще до войны, лол.
Парень и девушка олицетворяют Китай и Россию 😂
Yup, she is already learning Mandarin.
I mean, if China taking over Russia means Russians no longer invade its neighbours, I wouldn't mind.
Может парень вообще бурят.
Especially since the girl never shuts up 😅
Молча наблюдает, но в нужный момент отымеет🤣
So true!
7:49 What right do they have? A similar question: what right does Russia have to send its troops into the territory of another country and shell their cities there? Even if this grandmother supports the so-called Special Military Operation, she cannot but understand that Russian soldiers are not just sitting there and drinking tea.
Correct
Что делают американские солдаты в Сирии?
@@ПавелЗольников-п7э Так же совершают военное преступление. Никто не имеет права вторгаться на чужую территорию. Что теперь скажешь?
@@youngblood7191 Только мы это делаем 1 раз за 30 лет против очень враждебного государства. 1 рад за 30 лет можно
@@ПавелЗольников-п7э 1 раз?)))) Напомнить в каком году войска в Грузию вводили? Напомнить в каком году войска в Крым направили, когда он еще Украинским был? Напомнить, войска какой частной военной компании тусуют в Африке?
Valentina is basing her International Relations critical-thinking analysis on astrological predictions. That one was definitely not expected!
In California, I have met Americans of Russian decent. Personally, I enjoy interacting with People from other countries. Being an immigrant to the US myself I enjoy the ‘melting pot’ concept. Although we are far from perfect, everyone brings positive and yes sometimes negatives to the table.
The diversity of people and cultures is something you cant find anywhere else
@@Johnny-wf1df what you mean can't find anywhere else...
@@shiinondogewalker2809 What's the goal of that comment? Like he said, you can meet Americans of Russian decent. Other cultures influence by ours in our country. No crap you can find diversity in other countries. America is not the most diverse country in the world. I specifically meant other cultures mixed with American culture in America. Ur tryna be offended when there's nothing to be offended about.
@@Johnny-wf1df my goal was to make sure there's one less false statement on youtube, all while using few characters to type and being slightly annoying in the process. Thank you for retracting your statement sir that's most appreciated
Didn’t retract. You won’t find it anywhere else. You’re too dense ig… have a good day bro!
Man some of these outros that i've seen lately on these videos have been pure art in context. Excellent work
Amazingly brilliant and insightful people.
Whoa... did the US somehow try to pin Hiroshima/Nagasaki on Russia? If so... it didn't work... as that's the first I've heard that said!
I love watching your channel because it is such an incredibly strong illustration of the power of propaganda. Over the last year, I've heard a continuous change in the comments and tenor of the Russian people. The older people especially (whom I assume are not really reading any external news via VPN), have said increasingly crazy things and forget the logic of the early invasion (Ukrainian Nazis). It reminds me to consider news from multiple sources, and those outside of those of my own preferences. If you don't hear multiple viewpoints, you only reinforce your own beliefs, which may be false. I know we are all susceptible to these manipulations.
I hope they, and we, can see the truth behind the propaganda.
"If you don't hear multiple viewpoints, you only reinforce your own beliefs, which may be false" Good point, something happened in the UK a couple of years ago which surprised part of the population - because they only read/watched/heard views like theirs.
Preach. Watching these videos are so eye opening to how powerful media is. I've started watching EU news stations live here on YT because American political reporting is so polarizing, superficial and not very deep from both sides of the political spectrum. And as a Moderate/Centrist/Independent voter I just can't stand US Journalism anymore. It's interesting to hear about other news and stories going on around the world that just doesn't get any airtime in the US.
It's an echo chamber of idiocy.
Great comment John Wiser, 👌👌
How many Russian sources have you read lately, smart guy?
wtf with the guys that think US is their closest ally? Which kind of info make them choose such a wrong answer? 🤣🤦♂
In geopolitics there is no friends. Only temporary acquaintances.
I see you everywhere
@@anthonyfeatherstone4710 gold commentator
@@anthonyfeatherstone4710 because he's just a turtle
Wrong. What's with Entente or NATO?
That’s typical interest based international orders, values and principles are all ignored….
I love these videos. Thank you.
Save Nikita for all costs. He is pure boy.
The question is what is the natural course of events for the future. This very difficult to discern. Howevre, look into the heart of the people of Russia for their ambitions and dreams. This video is insightful.
Yeah Sinno-Soviet relations have always been great, unless you count that time the Soviets were preparing to wipe China off the face of the earth with a nuclear strike. Then the US president got on the phone and threatened a nuclear response if the Soviets acted. Other than that, stellar relations.
You talk nonsense
And a little earlier, the USSR took part of the territory of China, taking advantage of the weakness of China at that time. Real friends 🤡
@@letslearn3513 might wanna look up 1969 lmao
@@letslearn3513 Americans literally make up random things.
And the Amur annexation 😮
This was one of your best survey questions in recent weeks. Thank you for the insights I gained from these people.
It seems that distrust in China is same for everyone in the world. Also funny that no matter how bad things go, Russian old people still seem to think that every good option for future is to be Soviet Union again. Babushkas are truly soviet to the bone. Golden memories for those who lived in privileged urban areas with no holodomors etc. Even though they were not privileged at all compared to West.
Distrust in China is only between white people and wannabe-white people.
>>> Babushkas are truly soviet to the bone.
They can make comparison. (Younger people can't.)
@@РусланЗаурбеков-з6е Communism is rubbish, suffering and poverty, death and despair. Any other fantasies and false memories are false. Old people always love old times and whatever it is today is wrong and terrible. It's always been this way, especially after societies started to develop and grew and technology skyrocketed. There is no answers in ancient false views, religions and other fantasies, and there's no deity controlling anything, and if there was, it's still a moot point, they are the ones controlling everything, puppets ignore their strings and do nothing else what the puppeteer moves them. "I can do no wrong. For I don't know what it is".
Nostalgia for past eras is the inevitable part of humans growing old. In the US, we're seeing a huge surge in the belief that things were better in the 80s, for example. Trump's MAGA slogan is an example of someone weaponising nostalgia, even though Americans were actually worse off in the 80s. Boris Johnson and Farage did the same in the UK, causing us voting for brexit.
The phrase "we're no so different, you and I" springs to mind.
@@peterclarke7240 Both MAGA and Boris Johnson and anti-EU and exit movements were something that Russia has backed up and spread with trolls for over a decade now. It's funny how Putin then instantly repaired all the cracks between EU countries and USA by starting a war. Stronger than ever, and instantly also two new NATO members and NATO firmly united from pieces. Democracy won. Easily. Despite Putin's grandiose fantasies that have become a some sort of a religion, or cult. Now the Russian regime and it's corrupt network is destroyed in Ukraine, and it will never rise again.
Older people do seem more knowledgable on history of the relationships.
It's very interesting, most consider EU and US the closer ally while half of those states send weapons to fight Russian soldiers on Ukrainian soil.
If Russia lost, they are free young leaving people.
@@sacotafiruta2348 *living?
Fighting Putin's soldiers.
they don't provide advanced high-range weapons to strike inside Russia, that's big difference
Well it's like you want to have a friend but they just won't take their meds and now they're attacking one of your other friends. It's seriously mind-blowing how some Russians can believe that the West was after them...
It's all our fault for thinking Russia would drop the anti-western sentiment. There is still obviously a lot of resentment. Haters gonna hate.
Leon is 17 years old and already he has a greater understanding of geopolitics than most Russians. Gives me hope for a different Russia in the future that can work with other countries. It's interesting to see how many people are aware of how China cannot be trusted as an ally. Another student also pointed out China has never really had Russia's back when the US helped them in the 90s. Even I didn't know that!
don't hope
He is too young. Too many russians know how America "helped" in 90s
@@kastus77 In the beginning of 90s russians were starving - again - and US provided food (not the first time in russia's history) - nozhki busha - chicken legs. Also Ukraine provided grain.
Whoa…even YOU didn’t know something about historic Russo-Sino-American relations??
Really?? He didn't express any deep thoughts, he just said he can't trust China completely as well as anyone else. Where has you seen such "great understanding of geopolitics"? For me, it was Sofia who is more educated, she talked a lot.
P.S. Yes, but USA supported Russia driving into the 90s in the first place, that doesn't sound as a gratuitous ally...
Countries do not have friends or enemies. They have interests. Russia is entitled to pursue its interests, but what they cannot do is go around invading countries unless there is a reason like an attack or something (which is not the case)
Why USA can and Russia can't?
Being the most superior country in the world and in history, Russia can do whatever it thinks is right 🇷🇺🇷🇺Z
@@RussianShortsEmpire There is a rule you can't just invade another sovereign nation to forcibly take land.
@@Илья-у1ю Your superior contry is getting bitch slapped by Ukraine, imagine going up against someone with real power.
@@Илья-у1ю the US is superior to modern Russia in every way possible
Russia never treated China as an equal partner, I don't know why would China do the same...
huh, USSR helped China with tech a lot. just look to military equipment of China. very similar to soviet.
of cource USA was better partner and China switch to USA later on.
but seems China never thankful for help. not for soviet, not for americans
small invasion to USSR in 1969.
and now dancing with Taiwan. proofing this.
@@soen2368 Ussr invade china not the other way around . You think Canada will invade America?😂 And china treat ussr so well. Mao Zedong think the successor of ussr run counter to the will of Stalin and came into some kind of revisionist government.
@@linfenghuang2152 "china treat ussr so well" I can see this well in Afganistan war =)
money is best friend
@@soen2368 USSR invade afghan . And don’t tell me you like Gorbachev that much.
@@soen2368 Chinese people may be the only nation who think the fall of ussr is a bad thing. Even young Russian don’t think the same
В истории России была установлена власть Коммунистической партии, даже в современной политической системе существует много сходства между Китаем и Россией. На самом деле, решения и мышление людей из этих двух стран довольно похожи. Когда я работал в одном из вузов, канцлер моей нанятой факультета был членом Российской академии наук и бывшим первым секретарем партии Коммунистической партии СССР.
every once in a while these citizens walking on the streets of Russa have something incredibly insightful to say that I agree with 100%
I, against my will 😂, have to agree.
However, I believe it's like what my son said once, many years ago, as a teenager that just came up with a humorous comment on something, that actually was spot on the "true truth" on the subject.
"So, I'm wiser than my understanding?"
"Så jag är klokare än mitt förstånd?"
Meaning, they aren't aware of what they say is really clever. The words just happened to come out that way.😅
Maybe because that's how the author or editor of this video chose to show.
which part? Love US more than China?
@@hkfoo3333 - China alwaaays numba one!!!!
There girl at 1:04 seems really well informed. I wonder what she thinks of Putin.
2:00 this girl tries to look smart, but she doesn't even know that 'Moskvich' car is a chinese JAC JS4 car, but just re-named.
To be fair, I think they put on wheels filled with Russian air.
А вы говорите Китай не помогает
@@ПавелЗольников-п7э China is not helping, it does this in exchange for your resources, such as timber in huge amounts
Treaty of Aigun 1858 and Convention of Peking 1860 Russia took Tanu Tuva, territories in central Asia and entirety of Outer Manchuria. Wouldn't bet that chinese forgot those unequal treaties. Russia is not in a good geopolitical situation, not anymore.
Undoubtedly the Chinese all remember. I was in China for some time in the early 1990s and was amazed at the widespread knowledge and resentment towards the British regarding Hong Kong. And the Chinese I met in the mining industry were all very resentful of the Russian technical assistants (engineers and geologists) who "helped" them modernise. These Russians insisted the Chinese learn Russian, and made no attempt to learn Mandarin while they were in China. The Chinese of today carry a very big chip on their shoulder regarding their past treatment by the West, Japan, Russia. They teach these past injustices in their schools.
I am Chinese, I will never forget how western powers such as Japan Russia, Britain, France, Germany, America, Italy, Austria-Hungary, Germany, Italy bullied China when China was weak, never forget
Guys, she didn't say here that the US blames Russia for the bombing of Hiroshima. This is not a correct translation. She said that after a long time, Japan began to believe that the USSR was the cause of this bombing. You were brazenly deceived in the translation, it is completely incorrect in some moments.
That girl with the guy under umbrella... Alternate reality.. what is she smoking? It's Russia who is constantly attacking neighbors so US doesn't support that andshe thinks US blames Russia for atom bomb on Hiroshima? Nothing she says makes sense
A really interesting set of opinions. Easy to focus on the more outlandish ones but by and large well reasoned and thoughtful. The older lady at the end stating that Russia had helped the west get richer by selling its resources to the west and then buying its goods has more than a degree of truth. But it ignores the role of Oligarchs and the widespread corruption within Russia that has held it back.
The oligarchs are the result of the destructive nature of man, we could not do anything with them, and you pandered to them. It is difficult to say how strong control over the economy is necessary in our case, and how far we can go. You will hang new stamps and labels, calling us a totalitarian society more and more loudly. At the same time, you will introduce new prohibitions and restrictions in your societies in the same way. I hope you have lived well for the last 30 years?
it also ignores all the purges, wars and man-made famines that destroyed the country and its people.
And the fun part (or tragic more likely) is that they think they are some sort of superpower. 😂😂😂
With an economy and development like a mid 3:rd world country.......
oh dude, your camera quality upgraded significantly since I last watched. NICE
0:30 and at 50 seconds are both right. China is not true ally of Russia. No loyalty between the two unlike the collective west. it's a relationship of pure convenience where one side will drop the other at the moment the other side isn't beneficial to their short term goals.
@clemathieu JT Yeah, new reports are that 6 Russian ships were at that location just a couple days before it happened!
@clemathieu JT There are 26 photos of the SS-750 Russian navy ship, which carries a small submarine that is designed to carry out underwater operations.
A Danish patrol boat detected a Russian vessel near the Nord Stream gas pipelines four days before they were sabotaged in multiple blasts, according to media reports.
The defense command confirmed it had 26 images of the SS-750 Russian navy ship, which carries a small submarine that is designed to carry out underwater operations, photographed from a Danish patrol boat in the vicinity of the pipelines on September 22, 2022, local newspaper Dagbladet Information reported Thursday.
@clemathieu JT That's funny. 😂
I really love this channel. Comments here are better than any humorous show. I love to read how "educated", "enlightened", "free" and "democratic" Anglo-Saxons pity us, the dense, unhappy Russians and want to re-educate us and teach us to read their "correct" history textbooks. You guys are so cool, it's so fun to read your snobbery and complete misunderstanding of my country. Keep going, don't stop😄
Hey, if the shoe fits. It’s “your” countrymen sharing the words of your countrymen… and Russians like yourself sure like to complain about everyone else.
As an American we don't think of Russia at all we could care less...
Do you have indoor plumbing?
Тем же самым занимаюсь , но половина из этих достопочтенных западных граждан в действительности уркаинские фейки:)
@@Rob-metoo527 I personally find it insightful to learn how Russians think and why this war is continuing, due their distorted mindset.
7:12 The calmness in his voice is amazing. How doesn't he burst into laughter is beyond me.
The US is really operating things amazingly smooth... I've watched many street interviews in Japan. Even though the US had dropped 2 nuclear booms in Japan, most of the japanese favourite country is the U.S. Here are the same. amazing.amazing.amazing
Based on some Russian comments here, she never said US blame USSR, but said "In Japan, they built such attitudes that Russia is to blame." Stalin invaded Manchuria the same day the 2nd a-bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. So the Japanese people probably felt they were stabbed in the back and blame USSR for them losing WWII, not for actually dropping the a-bomb.
Fascinating how russkies don't seem to remember they were in Afghanistan FIRST, or that they were in Syria as well, using chemical weapons, no less. And...uhh...darn them for Hiroshima?
In both countries, Afghanistan and Syria, we were invited by the governments of these states. Can you say the same about your beloved US or NATO?
@@imperium_vox Rusia was also invited in by Slobodan Milosevic. History remembers you well for that.
That woman who thinks the island conflict was the only between China and Russia in history clearly doesn’t know how Russia came to have Vladivostok.
Россия получила город основав его, до этого там ничего не было (хоть это и была территория Китая) 😄
Frankly I'm surprised that so many Russians interviewed seemed circumspect or distrustful of China as an ally. Putin has made a great deal of this.
i think its defensive reaction to not agree that dependence on China is too high
If China wanted something bad it would be do it already
Somehow most people on both sides have missed the fact that for the past 200 years , china and Russia were mortal enemies supporting opposing armies during the cold war
Beyond that china had territorial claims against Russia for most of Siberia until 2017 including Vladivostok
If you actually spend time in china , average Chinese are furious about this. They vent more about losing Siberia and Mongolia than about Taiwan which plays big in the west.
It is because in china everyone knows and believes that Taiwan is a part of china , because Taiwan never declared independence and no major countries recognize or claim it , this is not a big concern for normal people debated about , where as you will hear them moan and groan and claim that everything from the Pacific to lake Baikal is Chinese
@@knyghtryder3599
I knew China and USSR had an on again-off again relationship, but I didn't know Chinese claims from the Pacific to Lake Baikal. Right now I see it both as an alliance of convenience and perhaps an attempt by China to add the biggest spoke yet to its Belt and Road program. It would be ironic if Putin set out to rebuild the Soviet Empire and ended up turning Russia into a Chinese client state.
Russians are a little racist, just like all white people.
@@knyghtryder3599 The pair of Russia and China right now resemble the Soviet Union and Germany before the WW2. I wouldn't be surprised to see WW3 in the near future, where the USA would be ironically helping Russia to fend off the Chinese invasion.
After watching this interview. Sadly to say most younger Russian seems to be very ignorant not knowing how much badness and exploitation done on Russia and treating their exploiter as ally.
The power of distorted internet media which was carefully manipulated had rooted in younger Russian. More should be done, reading from history books is essential. Polarised opinions and not able to differentiate facts and fictional story will destroy younger Russian's patriotism to their Government.
I was not expecting to hear anyone speak favorably about the US. It hit me pretty hard actually.
Russian govt has been trying to integrate to Europe, since the fall of USSR & that is on record. After the fall of USSR, Russia asked for help from US & western Europe to create Russian Constitution & help with the economy, but Russia was flat out rejected, accdg. to Jeffrey Sachs who were there. US & western Europe helped others tho like Poland.With the declassification of US records, we now know that US has viewed Russia as their enemy even when Russia was weak. The plan has been always to expand NATO to ex-soviet states, create chaos within & surrounding Russia, & divide Russia into many smaller countries, which for me are all existential threat to their country, Russia.
China is not Russia's natural ally, but they do not have a choice but to have good relationship with them, as they share similar problems. West is Russia's natural ally, but they never want Russia anyway. It is a mistake in US foreign policy, esp with the emergence of upcoming Superpower, China.
This video baffles me that they seem to think that US is better than China, when declassified docs & history of actions of US has been to dismantle Russia. lol
@Sasen91 yes😀
@Sasen91 really ??
@@qunituabastard1754 typical story - if you said truth, you are american propaganda. Так и живём...
Well because the US is still way better than China