@Julien Ostiguy The problem I have with these teams is the fact they're current players over actual all-time great players. Harry Howell for the Rangers is a better choice than D'Angelo and Skjei
This was fun, But you gotta work on your name pronunciations lol. For instance, Rod Gilbert (Jyill Bear) You also made Serge Savard a Russian lol Sergei Savard I enjoyed the video, great job! John Van Bees Brook
Where on earth did you come up with some of these ratings? Like, Hasek and Vasi either equal to or higher than brodeur? And Elias, Lemiex, Iginla on the second line? Also, what's this with Niedermayer on Anaheim? He spent the bulk of his career alongside Stevens in NJ, but greats like Gretzky and Messier on Edmonton. Are you going for players early in their careers, at the end of careers, or if they apply to the all-time teams. Because Selanne scored 70 goals and 130 points on the Jets before they folded in the 90s, and Oates put up 140 points with Boston. But Selanne is in the 90s (understandable) on Anaheim, but Oates is in the 80s (disgraceful) on the Capitals?
@@notthatfriendly596 Yeah the team selection in this roster seems all over the place. It’s almost like the creator just picked whichever team they remembered/liked them being on the most. I’d honestly prefer duplicate players over a messily subjective roster like this one. Too many uncertainties.
That's not even close to the best Sabres team 😂 try like the French Connection, I'll take Lafontaine over Eichel, I'll take even Peca over Eichel, Miller is backing up Hasek. All wrong
Petry over Markov or Subban for the Canadiens is pretty sad... I gotta agree with some people here, the team making is missing out on great players, especially in the bottom 6. Also, just casually taking out the Golden Knights and Kraken for the Nordiques and Whalers ? Video is interesting, but a lot of choices are questionable
The breakdown of how they determined who went on the legend teams for each team doesn't make a lot of sense. I mean, I get that in the case of a player like Patrick Roy he had 2 cups for both Montreal and Colorado, and with Montreal's franchise history, handcuffing them by leaving a 96 Roy off for a 94 Price and 93 Plante doesn't look as bad as it would to leave him off Colorado and have their backup be a.... 42 rated Stephane Fiset (I'm joking of course, Colorado's had some good goalies over time). But, the fact remains, Roy played 551 regular season games in Montreal, and only 478 in Colorado, so, he should be on the Habs roster (and I say this as very much NOT a Habs fan). His years in Montreal were more impressive too. Sure, his stats were lower overall but it's pretty much inarguable that Roy had to do more to get the Habs over the line than he did with the Avs talent: 14.0 GSAA (goals saved above average) in 85-86, 14.2 GSAA IN 88-89 when they lost to Calgary, and 21.4 GSAA in 92-93. As compared to 13.5 GSAA in 2000-01, and 9.2 GSAA in 95-96 in Colorado.
I questioned to myself why he didn’t know how to say Vanbiesbrouck, but then I was confused on why i immediately knew, from just a glance, it was Vanbiesbrouck
20:19 as a massive fan of the bruins I was gonna go wild on you in the comments before you said that EA is stupid for not including Tuukka and Tim Thomas
Scott Niedermayer, Tim Thomas, Pronger..... yea this vid is chalked. Appreciate the effort to making the vid but theres some GLARING holes in this roster. It definitely needs a overhaul if it's a true all-time teams.
A lot of those teams are just not what they should be if you are going for all time great players. Hell most of them shouldn't even be on the teams they are on. What is the criteria you used for this?
Who ever made this Winnipeg team hates Winnipeg because we were missing so many legends, and yet they still made it to the final? Someone explain EA logic
Whoever made these teams, man these are missing out on key and instrumental, franchise altering players
You can thank EA for that
@@tysonkehler7582 No its a custom roster
EA cant really do shit correct the past 20yrs
@Julien Ostiguy The problem I have with these teams is the fact they're current players over actual all-time great players. Harry Howell for the Rangers is a better choice than D'Angelo and Skjei
Ik as soon as i saw Sabres without Lafontaine I was like “wtf is this💀”
Ahh Ray Burke my favorite defenseman.
Kinda goofy that some of the players aren’t given upgrades for the all time rosters, especially OEL
No Patrick Roy, no Koivu, no damphousse, no Turgeon, no Subban, no Denis Savard what happened to the Habs team
8:20 Holy crap that first line is not fair.
Leetch wearing 4 made me cry.. also they have hayes on the team and not Hadfield?
Prime Nicklas Kronwall 84 overall?????
This was fun, But you gotta work on your name pronunciations lol. For instance, Rod Gilbert (Jyill Bear) You also made Serge Savard a Russian lol Sergei Savard I enjoyed the video, great job! John Van Bees Brook
Burakovsky is more elite than mcdavo 🤷
I see no lies
John Vanbiesbrouck(Van-Bees-Brook):)
3 things in life are certain:
1. Death
2. Taxes
3. The Blues losing to the avs
I have an idea for you next upload. You should do the best NHL players ever verses the best in the league.
Where is ZDENO CHARA in boston
Who’s Patrick Roy?
Sup
Legendary Goalie Igor Sorokin.
Also there are no duplicate players. So Gretzky is only on the Oilers.
Dude would literally shutout every team
I feel like Patrick Roy should’ve been with the habs cause he was drafted and played more seasons there
IKR LOL🤣🤣🤣🤣
Where on earth did you come up with some of these ratings? Like, Hasek and Vasi either equal to or higher than brodeur? And Elias, Lemiex, Iginla on the second line? Also, what's this with Niedermayer on Anaheim? He spent the bulk of his career alongside Stevens in NJ, but greats like Gretzky and Messier on Edmonton. Are you going for players early in their careers, at the end of careers, or if they apply to the all-time teams. Because Selanne scored 70 goals and 130 points on the Jets before they folded in the 90s, and Oates put up 140 points with Boston. But Selanne is in the 90s (understandable) on Anaheim, but Oates is in the 80s (disgraceful) on the Capitals?
@@notthatfriendly596 Yeah the team selection in this roster seems all over the place. It’s almost like the creator just picked whichever team they remembered/liked them being on the most. I’d honestly prefer duplicate players over a messily subjective roster like this one. Too many uncertainties.
Petry instead of Subban and Markov? Paccioretty over so many other legendary forwards? No Patrick Roy? Habs got done dirty here.
If Toronto lost in the first round I would’ve started busting out laughing
as a Boston fan, I can confirm we are one of the main reasons we keep the loss streak and gave them ptsd since 2017.
Why the hell is Tony Esposito not on the Hawks
Also Gustafsson but not Hjalmarsson, like... what?
And where's Stan Mikita and Pierre Pilote?
How about you put everyone in their prime
Ya
Do all time prime
You can’t then it’s close to a 99 every where
@@emilysmith1100 u could make only a few of players 99, like gretz, mario, and howe, then the rest can be a little lower
No I meant like current
Seeing Demitra and Gaborik in Wild brings me joy again 🤍
Rip demitra
How the hell is Scott Niedermayer not on the Devils roster?
Right? I thought it was all time rosters! Where are all the superstars!
I don't think he's in NHL 23
@@jumboshrimp7419 he is
these rosters were custom made by a different guy to be used by anyone online
Scott is on the ducks roster.
The most entertaining part of this video were the rosters. I love seeing who the greatest of the greats are!
Igor Sorokin 😂
You should do the same video but with all of the CHL leagues
Patrick Roy out deked Wayne Gretzky.
Bro really can’t pronounce player names🤣. Regardless keep up the good videos 👍
Igor Sorokin is legit the most buzzing goaltender ever
That's not even close to the best Sabres team 😂 try like the French Connection, I'll take Lafontaine over Eichel, I'll take even Peca over Eichel, Miller is backing up Hasek. All wrong
Literally the worst possible sabres team he could have built. And LaFontaine on the isles instead of buffalo should have him in prison
Missed Konstantinov, Fetisov, Larionov, Hasek, Probert and McCarty at the very least. LGRW
Hasek is Buffalo's. Cope
offense was stacked enough so larionov and mccarty wouldve been 3rd or 4th liners, sawchuk is fine, but vlad and slava shouldve been there
Lol whoever made this roster was on the zaza 😂 dahlin was reverted back to 2018 cause why is he only 80 ovr
For real what is wrong with that Jets team wth 😂😂
They always do so good in sims idk how man
I feel like 2018-19 Norris winner should have been on the Flames defensive roster.
For a hockey channel this guy constantly butchers old time legends names.
Bro as a Devils fan, how'd they miss Claude Lemieux, Scott Neidermayer and Taylor Hall?
Claude is probably on the Canadians, Scott on the ducks. Idk about Taylor Hall.
First game of Buffalo : Tage Thompson score an OTW and was shown on the bench also hahaha
Nhl 23 goalie have terrible rebound control
Al Macinnis retired with the Blues why didn't they get him?
who the heck is igor sorokin?
do you mean ilya sorokin?
Ray Burque?
So we now know what it Takes for TO to get the Matthews era Core past the first round. ITs the Legends who know how to get past the first round :p
I so thought my Canucks would lose in round one I was pleasantly surprised
How is Tony Deandelo on the Rangers all time team?
Petry over Markov or Subban for the Canadiens is pretty sad... I gotta agree with some people here, the team making is missing out on great players, especially in the bottom 6. Also, just casually taking out the Golden Knights and Kraken for the Nordiques and Whalers ? Video is interesting, but a lot of choices are questionable
The breakdown of how they determined who went on the legend teams for each team doesn't make a lot of sense. I mean, I get that in the case of a player like Patrick Roy he had 2 cups for both Montreal and Colorado, and with Montreal's franchise history, handcuffing them by leaving a 96 Roy off for a 94 Price and 93 Plante doesn't look as bad as it would to leave him off Colorado and have their backup be a.... 42 rated Stephane Fiset (I'm joking of course, Colorado's had some good goalies over time). But, the fact remains, Roy played 551 regular season games in Montreal, and only 478 in Colorado, so, he should be on the Habs roster (and I say this as very much NOT a Habs fan). His years in Montreal were more impressive too. Sure, his stats were lower overall but it's pretty much inarguable that Roy had to do more to get the Habs over the line than he did with the Avs talent: 14.0 GSAA (goals saved above average) in 85-86, 14.2 GSAA IN 88-89 when they lost to Calgary, and 21.4 GSAA in 92-93. As compared to 13.5 GSAA in 2000-01, and 9.2 GSAA in 95-96 in Colorado.
no O'Relly on the sabres?
You should do a team of 36 overalls but all have high franchise potential
Mark Reeki? Do you watch hockey 😅
I questioned to myself why he didn’t know how to say Vanbiesbrouck, but then I was confused on why i immediately knew, from just a glance, it was Vanbiesbrouck
Where’s teemu selanne
Where is Gretzky and messier on the rangers
15:20 “Igor Sorokin” 💀
20:19 as a massive fan of the bruins I was gonna go wild on you in the comments before you said that EA is stupid for not including Tuukka and Tim Thomas
Who noticed at 2:45 when Tage Thompson scored he was somehow on the bench
Scott Niedermayer, Tim Thomas, Pronger..... yea this vid is chalked. Appreciate the effort to making the vid but theres some GLARING holes in this roster. It definitely needs a overhaul if it's a true all-time teams.
Patrick what now on the devils?
Right off the bat, Scott Niedermayer has been snubbed from the Devils all-time roster for... Bruce Driver, Damon Severson, or Tommy Albelin. Okay.
I don’t know why he didn’t just keep Ullmark and Swayman…. They’re some of the best goalies we’ve ever had and their still in the game!
Omg this guy butchers every player from the 90s names and some of the roster choices make no sense Ryan Miller isn’t the back up for Buffalo like wtf
patrick la leeeeeemmm lol not lime
with the logic of new jersey and not having mogilny nor should demitra be on the wild where is Brunette and Zhotek on minny
dont care bout tim thomas and rask, why isnt ilya kovalchuk on the devils team??? tampa never wouldve made it with him in the devils team
So Detroit lost all its 02 cup winners Hull Robitaille Hasek argue Modano also he played here my old rink named after him
Tj Compher? It's Jt Compher
I'm 30 seconds in and there's no Scott Niedermayer on the Devils? What is this malarkey...
YOOO!!! @Stick On The Ice I GAVE YOU THIS IDEA ON A LIVE TYSM ❤
A lot of those teams are just not what they should be if you are going for all time great players. Hell most of them shouldn't even be on the teams they are on. What is the criteria you used for this?
Caugh ** Winnipeg shouldn’t have Hawerchuk, he should be on the Yotes since that is the franchise that has his records **
Vegas Golden Knights is the greatest franchise
True 🛐👍
There a a TON of greats not on teams.
The pronunciations are killing me
The fact that Ronnie Francis isn't on the Penguins is all I needed to see to not watch any further.....
No chara on bruins🤣🤣
Original 6 team and have Connor Murphy making the all time top 6 that's embarrassing
Pat lalalalalafontaine
The bruins d was fire. 3rd line with Krug and Carlo over Chara, makes sense
prime bobrovsky? cause he was 90 ovr in nhl 19 while him being 87 ovr 💀
Anyone want to point out that the leafs actually made it out of the 1st round
If Belfour isn't the Stars goalie, I'm out.
No Jeff Carter with Philly? He had a better career than Mike Richard’s
These rosters are a joke
Of course Sabres don't advance, we're not allowed to win anything
No Chara for all time Ottawa Senators? He was part of the Yashin Deal with NYI
Who ever made this Winnipeg team hates Winnipeg because we were missing so many legends, and yet they still made it to the final? Someone explain EA logic
Winnipeg doesn’t have the history of the first Jets franchise, genius….
no mike richter lol this roster was made by a late 90s kid and it shows
why is rob blake on the avs 😭 bro should fs be on the kings
Why are Barclay Plager, Gary Unger, & Brian Sutter not on the Blues roster?
The rating of brad marchand was better than Guy Lafleur. WTF
No pronger on the ducks is a crime. No cup without him
He’s on the oilers, that’s why
Blackhawks were screwed, we didn’t have prime Hjalmersson.
Edmonton fans
These rosters are absolute trash but the Lightning won so great job! No notes.
Bro Winnipeg is obviously the greatest franchise of all time
Nerfed the Hawks team to cater to the inferior Blues. What a shocker
I think it proves that EA’s sim engine is the worst of all time.
These rosters 🤦♂️
We’re is teemu on jets
the current jets were the Atlanta Thrashers franchise?
How the oilers didn’t have Dwayne the main man Roloson
This was cool, I’m sure it took more work than we’d know
You should do a Ducks rebuild