This was a nice comparison test. Pointed out the pros and cons of both vehicles. A lot of people hate on the CVT, but I have had 2 Nissan vehicles with the CVT and I really like the smoothness and gas mileage of the CVT. On the highway in my 2018 Murano with a 3.5L V-6 I get in excess of 33 mpg. My wife wants a Rogue, and I'll probably buying one.
Great Video @Robert !! keep it up. My parents just bought the Rouge and I was pushing them to get the Rav. They love the Rouge and that's all that matters
RAV4 has a lot of road noise. Doors sound cheap when you close them. But it is popular. And some safety items are better than Nissan. But I’d buy the Rogue. Handles better, drives better.
Branz Factor if you live anywhere in the Maritimes in Canada, I invite you to come into O’Regan’s Nissan in Dartmouth and I can help you pick the one that’s right for you
Roommate has the 2011 Rogue with the CVT. No issues, he has only done oil changes only, not full service. Was great on move from Calif to Missouri. Has only replaced tires.
You did a very good and fair job. I enjoy watching your videos especially the ones where you show how to work all the displays and the infotainment. My wife and I have been wanting the Rogue for a while but we keep putting it off. We're hoping when the new Rogues come out, the 2020s will be offered with some big discounts. I wish you worked at a dealership in California.
Robert Shaw thank you very much for your kind remarks. I would have enjoyed working with you and your family if we were closer. I’m sure when the time is right you’ll get a great deal on a great Rogue.
Very nice review & comparison. I really appreciated the leg room, getting in & out of the passenger side & knowing you are 6'3. I am only 5'1 but have taller friends & dont need to hesitate on driving them & their comfort. 👍 I have access to a 2011 Rogue, love it & was curious how it compared. Thank You!
Good video over all. But you missed the part that Rav 4 rear view mirror can turn to a digital LCD display, by flicking the middle control, which rogue don't have. You also missed that on the back seat passengers have access to 2 extra USB charging port, which rogue don't have.
@@RobertTigheCars I just got me a Nissan Rogue 2020 and lots of people are telling me why in bought a Nissan and not a Toyota or Honda since nissan have a CVT and it’s a headache with the transmission . Ugh
The RAV4 has lane keep assist when the dynamic cruise control is on, which helps keep the vehicle centered. I can take my hands off the wheel and my RAV4 can stay centered on curves as well as straightaways. It also gives a warning to put hands back onto the wheel.
Nice review...very objective and informative. I have an almost identical Rogue SL AWD except it's a 2019. It's even the same pearl white color except with black leather interior. I would add a few comments about the Nissan Rogue for clarity and additional insight. 1. The back seats also slide forward and back. I didn't see you point this out, and it could be an important feature for some potential buyers/owners, especially those who need more legroom in the 2nd row. 2. The panoramic sunroof also has a fully automatic shade (like all others I presume), unlike the Rav4's manual shade. 3. The small storage cubby under the center stack is too small for pretty much any modern cell phone, which is too bad considering it's in the perfect spot for your phone to lay while it charges and/or streams Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. Not a big deal for some but wanted to point it out. I'm a big guy (6'2", 280#) and I'm pretty comfortable in the front seat. One of the main things for me was having room for my right knee/leg not to be forced too far to the left...I need room for it to be able to hang to the right or at least not be pushed in to the left. The Rogue was good for me in this area. Overall my wife and I are very happy with the Rogue. It's her daily driver and she loves it...and I also enjoy driving it on the rare occasion I need to. It's still very tight, solid, quiet, no loose pieces, squeaks or rattles, and feels refined and technologically advanced for a small SUV. We love the ride and the large interior for the class. We didn't need one for performance so the CVT was not a concern for us. Just passed 8k miles and 9 months of ownership. Just my $.02. Keep up the good work!
I am going from a 2017 Rogue SL black into a 2020 Rogue SL white starting tomorrow, same as yours, but my interior will be almond color. Love the Rogue even if it doesn't have all the latest convenience features like USB ports in the back and ventilated seats in the front. Rogue has less performance power, but like you, that doesn't matter too much to me. Its existing power train is good enough for me. Rogue styling is really nice too, a beautiful looking SUV with lots of comfort inside and a great Bose sound system.
Isn't the front row seats in the Rogue a lot more comfortable? That was what I noticed - I heard that an amazingly comfy seat was something that Nissan sought out.
As a Rogue dude for the last 3 years and going into another one tomorrow, I can tell you indeed the seats are some of the most comfortable I have ever experienced. I used to drive Ravs before.
My wife has one. Very comfortable ride and accelerates fast when need be. The only thing I don't like is the smaller windshield. It feels weird at first but you get used to it (just like everything else in life).
ADNAN AKRAM I work for O’Regan’s out of our Nissan Store. We also have a Toyota store so I am able to sell a brand new RAV4 as well...and have. The brand doesn’t mean anything to me when to comes to doing a review. I can sell a new Nissan, Toyota, Hyundai, Kia, VW, Subaru or GM/Chev. I did this review because they are direct competition and I was tired of all of the biased reviews.
I work out of a Nissan store, under O’Regan’s Automotive Group who also have a Toyota store. I am able to, and have, sold Toyota’s over the last 4 years with the company. As well as Hyundai, VW, Kia, Subaru and GMC/Chevrolet. I do truly appreciate the feedback. I have not, to this point, ventured into comparing other models, but I will be soon. Thanks for following!
i rent a 2018 rouge awd drove it 1750 miles on vacation...now i am a gm guy worked 32 years at delco in dayton,,,oh...we are now looking to buy one,,,it was so nice to drive an 36 mpg in some places as i was going to sunset beach nc,,, ran like a top,,an was not as doggy as they make out,,,,,,waiting on a 2018 lease turn in now....an sv ,,,
Official Jonathan personally, and I am a little biased as I work for Nissan, but I think the Rogue is a better buy. I would invite you to check them both out for yourself. It’s the best way to find the one that’s right for you. I should mention that the company I work for, O’Regan’s, gives me the ability to sell either as they have both the Nissan and Toyota brands. So when I deal with a customer, I go to the one they want, not the one I want.
We traded our 2014 Rav4 for a 2017 Murano. The Rav was very noisy and uncomfortable, especially the seats. After driving 2 hours I would have to stop and walk around. ON the Nissan I can drive until I have to stop without any issues. Both vehicles have been bullet proof. I would never own another Rav4 but that is just me, they are very popular. I know I am not comparing to the Rogue just giving you my opinion on the Rav4. Cheers
the Rav4 is ridiculously ugly by its looks! while the the rogue looks beautiful on the outside, design wise, it's got nothing in comparison of the Rav4 .... Rav4 is a solid all around vehicle durability wise. a nissan is a nissan, period ! that's about it.
It is an unfair comparison ... because this model from Nissan appeared in 2017, while Rav 4 appeared in 2020 !!!! Rather, it was a comparison of Nissan with Rav4 2018
@@ApplesSullivan Honda dealerships are usually arrogant. They are not enthusiastic about showing cars and could care less if you buy one. They think people will buy one just because it's a Honda.
Very fair review. You met your goal and then some to be unbiased! I'm impressed!
This was a nice comparison test. Pointed out the pros and cons of both vehicles.
A lot of people hate on the CVT, but I have had 2 Nissan vehicles with the CVT and I really like the smoothness and gas mileage of the CVT. On the highway in my 2018 Murano with a 3.5L V-6 I get in excess of 33 mpg. My wife wants a Rogue, and I'll probably buying one.
Great video, You truly covered everything. My 16 year old daughter had a 2017 Rogue. She loved it.
Comprehensive and definitely unbiased. Well done
Great Video @Robert !! keep it up. My parents just bought the Rouge and I was pushing them to get the Rav. They love the Rouge and that's all that matters
RAV4 has a lot of road noise. Doors sound cheap when you close them. But it is popular. And some safety items are better than Nissan. But I’d buy the Rogue. Handles better, drives better.
Damn, this was an awesome comparison. It’s confirmed, I need a Rogue in my life!
Branz Factor if you live anywhere in the Maritimes in Canada, I invite you to come into O’Regan’s Nissan in Dartmouth and I can help you pick the one that’s right for you
Branz Factor. As long as Nissan has the cvt I would strongly suggest you rethink that opinion.
Roommate has the 2011 Rogue with the CVT. No issues, he has only done oil changes only, not full service. Was great on move from Calif to Missouri. Has only replaced tires.
Ophelia Payne I actually bought one. 2020 SV. Very happy with my decision. We’ve had Nissan in my family for years. Never any major problems. 👍🏽
You did a very good and fair job. I enjoy watching your videos especially the ones where you show how to work all the displays and the infotainment. My wife and I have been wanting the Rogue for a while but we keep putting it off. We're hoping when the new Rogues come out, the 2020s will be offered with some big discounts. I wish you worked at a dealership in California.
Robert Shaw thank you very much for your kind remarks. I would have enjoyed working with you and your family if we were closer. I’m sure when the time is right you’ll get a great deal on a great Rogue.
L😊@@RobertTigheCars
Robert, another great, honest, informative-unbiased video.
Very nice review & comparison. I really appreciated the leg room, getting in & out of the passenger side & knowing you are 6'3. I am only 5'1 but have taller friends & dont need to hesitate on driving them & their comfort. 👍
I have access to a 2011 Rogue, love it & was curious how it compared.
Thank You!
Good video over all. But you missed the part that Rav 4 rear view mirror can turn to a digital LCD display, by flicking the middle control, which rogue don't have.
You also missed that on the back seat passengers have access to 2 extra USB charging port, which rogue don't have.
You should acknowledge those so you can be unbiased. Thanks
It was unbiased comparison. Both cars are good and have its own pros/cons .
Great job! I recently bought a 2018 Rogue SV. Still learning! Thanks for your tutoring.
Hi, any issues with your car yet ?
Not at all, why do you ask?
@@RobertTigheCars I just got me a Nissan Rogue 2020 and lots of people are telling me why in bought a Nissan and not a Toyota or Honda since nissan have a CVT and it’s a headache with the transmission . Ugh
Honda also has a CVT and Toyota does in many of their vehicles as well. If you’re having issues, please take it to your nearest service department
The RAV4 has lane keep assist when the dynamic cruise control is on, which helps keep the vehicle centered. I can take my hands off the wheel and my RAV4 can stay centered on curves as well as straightaways. It also gives a warning to put hands back onto the wheel.
The RAV redesign makes it near impossible for a normal sized man to get into it! The Rogue is much more comfortable.
NAILED IT!
You did an amazing review. Well done bro.
Nice review...very objective and informative. I have an almost identical Rogue SL AWD except it's a 2019. It's even the same pearl white color except with black leather interior.
I would add a few comments about the Nissan Rogue for clarity and additional insight.
1. The back seats also slide forward and back. I didn't see you point this out, and it could be an important feature for some potential buyers/owners, especially those who need more legroom in the 2nd row.
2. The panoramic sunroof also has a fully automatic shade (like all others I presume), unlike the Rav4's manual shade.
3. The small storage cubby under the center stack is too small for pretty much any modern cell phone, which is too bad considering it's in the perfect spot for your phone to lay while it charges and/or streams Apple CarPlay or Android Auto. Not a big deal for some but wanted to point it out.
I'm a big guy (6'2", 280#) and I'm pretty comfortable in the front seat. One of the main things for me was having room for my right knee/leg not to be forced too far to the left...I need room for it to be able to hang to the right or at least not be pushed in to the left. The Rogue was good for me in this area.
Overall my wife and I are very happy with the Rogue. It's her daily driver and she loves it...and I also enjoy driving it on the rare occasion I need to. It's still very tight, solid, quiet, no loose pieces, squeaks or rattles, and feels refined and technologically advanced for a small SUV. We love the ride and the large interior for the class. We didn't need one for performance so the CVT was not a concern for us. Just passed 8k miles and 9 months of ownership.
Just my $.02. Keep up the good work!
I am going from a 2017 Rogue SL black into a 2020 Rogue SL white starting tomorrow, same as yours, but my interior will be almond color. Love the Rogue even if it doesn't have all the latest convenience features like USB ports in the back and ventilated seats in the front. Rogue has less performance power, but like you, that doesn't matter too much to me. Its existing power train is good enough for me. Rogue styling is really nice too, a beautiful looking SUV with lots of comfort inside and a great Bose sound system.
You going to lose a lot of money to jump up 3 model years with the same trim level.
Isn't the front row seats in the Rogue a lot more comfortable? That was what I noticed - I heard that an amazingly comfy seat was something that Nissan sought out.
As a Rogue dude for the last 3 years and going into another one tomorrow, I can tell you indeed the seats are some of the most comfortable I have ever experienced. I used to drive Ravs before.
Thanks, excellent video, nice pace to absorb information.
How about a comparison of Mazda CX5 and Rav4 please?
I’ll see what I can do. O’Regan’s Automotive Group doesn’t have a Mazda but I may be able to borrow one
Nissan Rogue hands down. Don’t even need to watch the video.
Ew, RAV4 is the better vehicle
A TH-cam Channel with no name you obviously don’t know what a good car is. Nissan will out work, out drive and out last a Toyota
Hi Rob, nice review for the two popular suvs. Would you like to shoot a delivery for Murano 2020 SV? Thanks
My wife has one. Very comfortable ride and accelerates fast when need be. The only thing I don't like is the smaller windshield. It feels weird at first but you get used to it (just like everything else in life).
Very nice review so far. At the drive test 🙂👌🏾
Guy working in Nissan doing comparison between Nissan and Toyota!!!
ADNAN AKRAM I work for O’Regan’s out of our Nissan Store. We also have a Toyota store so I am able to sell a brand new RAV4 as well...and have. The brand doesn’t mean anything to me when to comes to doing a review. I can sell a new Nissan, Toyota, Hyundai, Kia, VW, Subaru or GM/Chev. I did this review because they are direct competition and I was tired of all of the biased reviews.
The 8” display on the Toyota looks like crap. Totally looks like a crappy aftermarket installation
And he works for nissan! I agree with most of his review though.
I work out of a Nissan store, under O’Regan’s Automotive Group who also have a Toyota store. I am able to, and have, sold Toyota’s over the last 4 years with the company. As well as Hyundai, VW, Kia, Subaru and GMC/Chevrolet. I do truly appreciate the feedback. I have not, to this point, ventured into comparing other models, but I will be soon. Thanks for following!
Nissan is betrer. Never been caught up in Toyota. Nissan is way better to most people. Luv my Rogue, tho I looking to get the Murano in a few months🤗
This video was offer by Nissan Corp. Thanks guy. Oh, I just read than Robert works for O'Regan's Nissan in Dartmouth... Ok, I just understand ;-D
A cvt is great for the first low mileage owner,the next owner gets screwed
As long as Nissan as the cvt in their vehicles,RUN!
Yup Rogue is 5 inches longer too!
I didn't understand with apps names
That RAV4 is one ugly looking vehicle that Rouge looks sweet.
Rogue is indeed better looking
i rent a 2018 rouge awd drove it 1750 miles on vacation...now i am a gm guy worked 32 years at delco in dayton,,,oh...we are now looking to buy one,,,it was so nice to drive an 36 mpg in some places as i was going to sunset beach nc,,, ran like a top,,an was not as doggy as they make out,,,,,,waiting on a 2018 lease turn in now....an sv ,,,
plus the screen blocks your view over the dash,,,i hate that
Lmao
great job
I'm in the market for a compact SUV. Can anyone suggest one over the other?
Official Jonathan personally, and I am a little biased as I work for Nissan, but I think the Rogue is a better buy. I would invite you to check them both out for yourself. It’s the best way to find the one that’s right for you. I should mention that the company I work for, O’Regan’s, gives me the ability to sell either as they have both the Nissan and Toyota brands. So when I deal with a customer, I go to the one they want, not the one I want.
We traded our 2014 Rav4 for a 2017 Murano. The Rav was very noisy and uncomfortable, especially the seats. After driving 2 hours I would have to stop and walk around. ON the Nissan I can drive until I have to stop without any issues. Both vehicles have been bullet proof. I would never own another Rav4 but that is just me, they are very popular. I know I am not comparing to the Rogue just giving you my opinion on the Rav4. Cheers
Nissan Rogue or Murano
Toyot have a longer life than Nidsan especially transmissions
@@terriewright2149 yeah..buy Toyota reliability isn't what it used to be....i have one and it's nickle and diming me to death
the Rav4 is ridiculously ugly by its looks! while the the rogue looks beautiful on the outside, design wise, it's got nothing in comparison of the Rav4 ....
Rav4 is a solid all around vehicle durability wise.
a nissan is a nissan, period !
that's about it.
this is x-trail only in USA say rogue
Can you really compare these two?
Toyota over Nissan. My husband has a Nissan AWD. Paint is peeling off the entire vehicle.
It is an unfair comparison ... because this model from Nissan appeared in 2017, while Rav 4 appeared in 2020 !!!! Rather, it was a comparison of Nissan with Rav4 2018
Honda over all
Paul Michael I was hoping to do a comparison of all 3, but the local Honda company wouldn’t loan me one.
Hi!! Why Paul?!
@@ApplesSullivan Honda dealerships are usually arrogant. They are not enthusiastic about showing cars and could care less if you buy one. They think people will buy one just because it's a Honda.
Nissan would be the choice for me if it wasnt for their shitty cvt
My rouge car went out at 65k miles. Avoid like the coronavirus.
What year?
It’s called maintenance. If you don’t do it a car will not last.
@@braggland8451 but he did change oil every 30,000 miles
@@diggingmystyle Wait, how do you. He didn't say that.
@@joykennedy3478 is a joke bro....or maybe he never did oil change in 65,000 miles...it's theoretically possible to drive a car like that