Damn it, i honestly love the Alternate main theme and Toby main theme. After all, i don't just love them, i can call them an absolute banger if you ask my opinion
Toby's theme actually sounds like old ragtime music here. I wonder if that's what they were going for, that old fashioned feel doesn't show as much in the final version. Great stuff!
@@strasburgrailfan90 "That's James, why didn't you know?" "Its James' shape all right, but James is a splendid red engine, and you never see his paint blue...!"
The alternate main theme reminds me of the time I tried to recreate the final theme by having a bunch of random household items and beating them to the theme
I have plans on getting some stuff done so I can recreate the version of the theme I made, it will probably be a bop but I will need some more stuff before I can do it
These all sound very lovely! The Anonymous person who made these did a fantastic job, I think the songs all fit the themes they’re supposed to represent quite well. The Alternate Main theme, the Early Toby theme and the Harbor themes are my favorites, but all of them are great.
all of these could work for their backstories, like thomas’ clunky theme could be used for when he was first built with all of his E2 class. Edwards theme could be a bit faster, for when he was owned by the furness railway. Sir Topham Hat’s theme could be the theme for Sir Charles Topham Hat, the FIRST fat controller. And so on and so forth.
I can get some idea from this in how Toby's theme was originally conceived as the main titles theme apparently when demonstrated to Britt Allcroft. Like the Edward variant and the alternate Fat Controller theme too. Regards, Samuel Farris.
I don't know why, but I get 'Super Mario World' vibes from the early Edward theme. Nice work, and especially on the alternate Fat Controller theme. (Inb4 it's stated, yeah I'm aware this is all an ARG)
Who else feels that Toby’s early theme should’ve been used instead? It just sounds so much better and more upbeat, still love the final version but still
![[Live สด] การออกรางวัลสลากกินแบ่งรัฐบาล งวดวันที่ 16 ธันวาคม 2567](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dNTiBBthKgQ/mqdefault.jpg)
"Make a song for a children's show about steam trains using the most popular instruments of the 1980s" is exactly the prompt I'd expect from this
I feel like any picture of Edward with James' face and vice versa should be considered a cursed image.
Now now... that is already a cursed image
@@thomasinslippysodor tbh, it didn’t look too different
@@thomasinslippysodor Not as hard to look at.
"Blursed" Image
Donald or douglas having edwards face
2:21 meanwhile, in an alternate timeline where Toby was the main character
toby the tram engine and pals
@@AlejandroMartinez-fn2zw
Y e s
Then Toby would go on the crappy going all over the world thing and have a sheet reboot
Toby and the magic railroad
Well, it's a fun act: Toby's theme should be the TV show's theme
Sir Topham Hatt's unused theme sounds like something you'd hear in a boss fight in a 1980s video game.
Maybe like a Cuphead boss or something
It’s the pink elephant sene from dumdo
The alternative main theme is very clankey I like that
Good beat too
Damn it, i honestly love the Alternate main theme and Toby main theme. After all, i don't just love them, i can call them an absolute banger if you ask my opinion
That Fat Controller theme is a fucking _vibe_
So is the unused harbour theme my guy
Yes
Even the clankey Thomas theme is great my guy
Sounds like Heffelumps and Woozles
Even the alternative main theme my man
Toby's theme actually sounds like old ragtime music here. I wonder if that's what they were going for, that old fashioned feel doesn't show as much in the final version. Great stuff!
They even got MOTL confused, this arg is great
That's what was going to be the TV theme
The alternative version of the Main Theme has John Henry's hammer clanging.
Its jedward
@@elchinostopmotion8609 i dont think you get the joke
Nostalgia hit me hard there
@@vphil09 Since I’m a idiot neither do I :D
Are we just not gonna talk about how Edward has James's face?
They did that in the edward and gordon episode too
So it looks like James got Painted Blue after all
Nope its James remember how the fat controller said he would paint James blue if he kept being bad so he made him look like Edward
It looks very jarring
@@strasburgrailfan90 "That's James, why didn't you know?"
"Its James' shape all right, but James is a splendid red engine, and you never see his paint blue...!"
I love the rendition of Toby’s theme. It is the perfect mashup of Toby with the actually used theme.
Well.. one early contender for the main theme became Toby's theme, so this is likely it.
The unused harbour/seaside theme just hits different
I know
Sounds Like a western theme.
most of these are complete bangers ngl
I agree mate
u are right bro
Like the alt main theme, I wouldve taken that any day of the week.
@@AverageCytrius Im glad they went with a more faster-pace version of the main theme but i still like the alt main theme
it’s a arg
"unused Fat Controller theme"
well, i can see why they didn't use it, Disney would have been up their asses for riffing "Pink Elephants on Parade"
Or maybe The Fat Controller is secretly working for the USSR...
@@jayswithjam8754 lol
What if it riffed the imperal march from star wars
@@knuckles1206 as a Star Wars fan and someone who owns a stormtrooper helmet I say. *YES*
shame, it sounds so good but I’m happy with the results.
The Toby one' my favourite.
Same. Especially at the end of it. 2:50
I know I’m actually boppin
I did that old 19 somthing carton boping up and down
Edward’s theme and Toby’s theme in this were accurate to the original ones I think
Can't disagree on that!
0% comments = wow this is the early theme!
1005 comments = _EDWARD WITH JAMES' FACE_
Wow look a early the- jk look at Edward with James face
These were very interesting takes on the themes and I am surprised at how different the early versions were.
0:00 Tom The Steam Loco
2:21 Toby The Brown Tram Engine & Friends
1:41 Edward The Proud Locomotive
3:05 The Thin Controller
3:26 The Perfect Sunny Day
lol the thin controller
Aka mr percival if he was in season 1
The fat controller before he was fat pretty much
@@samjahna they arent the same person the thin controller works on the narrowgauge line and the small controller works on the arlesdale line
seeing edward's face replaced with James's is cursed change my mind
In Edward and Gordon Edward is shown wearing James's sad face
@@allabonproductions8193 that is still cursed
@@jiggyjohn6949 Sir Handle and Rhenas often wear each other's faces.
@@allabonproductions8193 WHAT!?!?
There are lots of instances were one character wears another character's face.
The alternate main theme reminds me of the time I tried to recreate the final theme by having a bunch of random household items and beating them to the theme
Sounds more like Thomas’s Theme from the Thomas Pinball game.
Sounded like the SNES game
I have plans on getting some stuff done so I can recreate the version of the theme I made, it will probably be a bop but I will need some more stuff before I can do it
3:05 So the Fat Controller is essentially one of the Pink Elephants from Dumbo? How curious.
I was thinking the exact same thing! :o
Holy crap you’re right.
I get it now
@@stumpyfunnelalt9920 Are we sure these aren't "high quality rips"?
@@TheVicarstownSentinel these are pretty high quality
Hopefully My airpods won't disconnect so people won't know i listen to the banger that is Beta Thomas The Tank Engine Music
@joshua nation channel 132
You are in the bright side of TTTE.
@joshua nation channel 132 Where Thomas is shipped with MLP ponies
@joshua nation channel 132
Mattel
@joshua nation channel 132
Ok then Nia and Rebecca
I started mine in low volume, and checked before turning it up lol
This is inspiring me to do custom “demo” themes!
Good job 👍
I’m staying up till 2AM just to watch this
Same
Lol
If I stay up till 5 am I up early or late?
Trick question I'm boned
Lol I'm up at 4 AM.
The unused Fatt Controller theme sounds like Fatt Controller is the villain of the show.
These all sound very lovely! The Anonymous person who made these did a fantastic job, I think the songs all fit the themes they’re supposed to represent quite well. The Alternate Main theme, the Early Toby theme and the Harbor themes are my favorites, but all of them are great.
Sir Topham Hatt's theme sounds like a hybrid of the Pink Elephants song from Dumbo, and Dr. Robotnik's theme from AoStH
The unused Sir Topham Hatt Theme sounds like video game boss fight music
WhY Do i hEaR BoSs mUsIc?!
The Alternate main theme sounds so good ❤️❤️
The start of the Unused TFC theme is literally from Pink Elephants on Parade.
I knew it sounded familiar
I know right-
Counting down the days before someone uses it in a remake of Henry and the Elephant.
Yes i know
Maybe he too, is drunk
Whoever made that alternate theme must’ve OD’d on his cowbell prescription.
I could listen to that -Pink Elephants- Fat Controller theme for hours
i will wait all night for this to start
The Fat Controller's sounds like "Pink Elephants on Parade" from Dumbo lol, "Fat Controllers on Parade"! lol.
He’s so fat he brakes the stage
all of these could work for their backstories, like thomas’ clunky theme could be used for when he was first built with all of his E2 class.
Edwards theme could be a bit faster, for when he was owned by the furness railway.
Sir Topham Hat’s theme could be the theme for Sir Charles Topham Hat, the FIRST fat controller.
And so on and so forth.
Is nobody talking about how much the harbor theme is a bop???
Seriously i could listen to it for hours it deserves its own video
The alternate main theme is a fricking bop
Oh hello! Didn’t see you there. I’m one of ur subscribers. U encouraged me to collect all the talk n action trains
@@owendinostudios1200 Oh, nice! Thanks for the support!
These sound pretty real. I like them.
What do you mean pretty real? Are these not real? Were these fanmade? I want to know if I'm not being tricked into believing the wrong thing...
The Fat controller theme sounds like a boss fight
Maybe eggmans theme from adventures of sonic the hedgehog kinda they are both fat tho
Wow! The Fat Controller's theme sounds like Sega game boss music or a villain's theme!
To me, it sounds a bit like a cross between the games Monster Bash and Nitemare 3D.
the main theme banged so hard that one side of my headphones broke
BRO THIS OPENING BE BANGING!!!!
Early Toby theme is basically unused Thomas intro theme
True
sounds like something that would be in a retro game 3:05
Clean early Toby's Theme sounds something along the lines of an another alt. intro. Very cool, gives me a lot of nostalgia !
3:04 LOOK OUT, LOOK OUT, SIR TOPHAM HATT'S ON PARADE! HERE HE COMES! HIPPITY HOPPITY -
The edward theme at 1.50x speed is actually good sounding.
Well, whoever this 'Guy' is, his contributions to this stuff is surely very much appreciated! :)
The unused fat controller song hit different for real😎🫡🫡
I love the unused Edward theme so much !!
Okay am I the only one who hears the Thomas SNES game's sound font at 0:44 to 0:50
i hear it to
i hear it too
Now that you point it out...
Same
0:00 thomas theme 1982-1983
1:41 edward furness theme
2:21 toby old line theme
3:04 sir charles theme
That wrong facemask was kind of disturbing. Makes me wonder: Who got into the scrapyard and got their body parts taken by the other
1:41 speed this up to 1.5x it’s a slowed version of Edward theme music
More like 1. 25x it sounds like the actual theme
What fascinating discoveries!
Arg
@@birdyforbrains Arg? Are we talkin' like Salty now?
@@thomasoates3003 Alternate reality game
@@birdyforbrains (I know this is an ARG. It's more fun to play along. Besides, doesn't part of you wish this were true?)
Of these early music, the Alternative Main Theme and the Early Toby Theme are my personal favorites.
Fell asleep waching live got wock up to some sick beats
I love how the alternate main theme sounds like the Chorlton and the Wheelies theme.
Great I cant believe I am still a Thomas Fan for 20 years
It fell out of favor until I decide I was going to kit bash a accucraft ruby into a live steam percy
@@wesbrackmanthercenthusiast4695 ok
@@JackTheThomasFan2000 I'm just messing with ya lol it's nice to see I'm not the only one who has liked it for 20 years
@@wesbrackmanthercenthusiast4695 ok
So, is nobody gonna talk about how the alternate main theme sounds SO AGGRESSIVE?? It’s so hard-hitting it’s almost violent-
Cuetly punches you with the power of music*
@@thomastomystorys3209exactly
To all the people who are like "wow this was the old theme" it's a arg
I really like the harbor / Seaside theme
Timestamps
0:01 Early Thomas Theme
1:42 Early Edward Theme
2:21 Early Toby Theme (Old Intro)
3:05 Early Fat Controller Theme
3:26 Early Seaside Theme
The fat controllers unused theme is an actual vide ngl
I wish I had permission to use these because Edwards's theme fits my Edward ideas well
I can get some idea from this in how Toby's theme was originally conceived as the main titles theme apparently when demonstrated to Britt Allcroft. Like the Edward variant and the alternate Fat Controller theme too. Regards, Samuel Farris.
They all sound like they’re form a Nintendo 64 or sega mega drive game
I like how they all sound
tfw people are unironically falling for this still
The unused fat controler theme makes me think of them bricking up henry
That alternate main theme kinda bangin fr
So this is what Marcus was talking about.
I haven't heard these in years, being 22 when working on the show
Just a fun little roleplay I'm doing :)
2:19 They just need to change the 2 to 5 and it really will be James' dream from James and the coaches.
if you speed up any of these to 2, they're really epic gamer tunes to listen to while speedrunning
I don't know why, but I get 'Super Mario World' vibes from the early Edward theme. Nice work, and especially on the alternate Fat Controller theme.
(Inb4 it's stated, yeah I'm aware this is all an ARG)
10/10 For This Unreleased Archive Soundtrack!
The unused fat controller theme is good for a video game, or conversation, or things like that
The Unused Seaside Theme was beautiful.
Who else feels that Toby’s early theme should’ve been used instead? It just sounds so much better and more upbeat, still love the final version but still
0:48-1:00 Sounds Beautiful
0:01 this sounds like a note block song irl of the theme
if you put on 1.25 speed on Edwards early theme its the speed of his later theme
Seriously - these actually sound like they could've been in the actual show!
Are these real or is this all fanmade?
@@blenderbachcgi I believe real?
That early Toby theme is a bop
teh unused fat controller theme sounds like a boss theme from an 80's 8-bit game
Sir topham theme sounds like something they would use for scratch and grounder from sonic
1:41 The early edward theme in start sounds like the same melody in Super Mario Bros Snow Map from Super Mario Maker 2.
2:21 First Early Thomas theme, Then Early Toby theme. Does this mean that music could've used for Toby's theme or Thomas opening/closing theme?
3:05
"are you approaching me?" said the driver.
i relly love the unused harbour/saeside theme
Nice arg
The thumbnail made me for a second
If you just look at Sir Topham Hat tell me you can't imagine but see the Penguin in your eyes
These themes sound like they would be from a long lost Thomas and Mario crossover game for the NES
I actually wold not mind the alternate main theme as the og 1 there almost the same but also so different I like it
3:25 If All At Sea were a Season 2 episode
I agree. I can't understand why they didn't use this theme, but it sounds good to have been used in the series.
@@ethanstrainz5376 Because it's fanmade.
Actually it was meant to be a season 2 episode at some point but they didn’t have enough budget for the dock set
The alternate main theme is so aggressive
These actually sound like they would be in the Series! Btw what do you use to make these?
ARG
You think a ARG will tell how it does it’s stuff?
@@obbyandAWE sorry, ARG is augmented reality gaming
@@owendinostudios1200 Thank You Very Much
@@themarklinengine5408 ur welcome
all of them are fantastic