ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 17 ต.ค. 2019
- a tribute to the two amazing groups who love each other as best friends and also as brothers and sisters. i haven't been here without them and no regrets for me to discover them 8 years ago.
thank you and let's wak on the flower road, my shinee & fx - ตลก
Sorry for deleting some comments. Hopefully later there will be less triggering comments in the comment section. Please be careful of your words and think hard before you write if it'll be affect to others or not. Thank you ❤️
Thank God i dont hv to see those nasty comments.. you are the best for doing this.. thank you..
thank you so much for doing this !
thank you for your hard work ❤️❤️❤️
not even just the nasty comments but the ones people make thinking they're being "supportive" and "empathetic" but are actually just really inappropriate and gross.
Sorry for asking but what were the comments about?
Thank you so much
The amber and minho llama thing always cracks me up, even after the 1000th time I've seen it 🤣🤣🤣
Same! I still remember singing it randomly in my head all the time. I guess ima start again after being reminded. 😂
Your profile name made me wheeze sksksjsksjsjejs
LMAO YOUR PROFILE NAME
Best profile name ever 😂❤️
LMAOOO YOUR PROFILE NAME JAJAJAJAJAJJAJAJAJAJA
these were the times when idols can dance to each other's songs, take pics of each other for fun, and play rock, paper, scissors at an idol olympics event without people going crazy and accusing them of dating. Nowadays, idols can't even look and smile at each other, or publicly enjoy the opposite gender idol's music without fans accusing them of dating...tsk tsk, smh
I miss golden era 😭 when other fandoms enjoy and cheer what group is performing instead of staying silent or bashing what group is performing
I wasn't even a fan of kpop until 2017 and I still feel like I miss those days since I mostly like the groups of gen 2... current kpop I feel like no one can be funny anymore or feel relaxed.
i really miss the old kpop
@@ryu3884 jfc what's happened i need a time machine lmao
sad i miss this era
Jonghyun getting mad because they don't think they're pretty is just about the most Jonghyun thing EVER
what point was that i couldnt find it?
@@3rachafascination5 1:53 (JH: very pretty!!)
@@3rachafascination5 because jonghyun is a very loving and caring person. He's a happy pill and always lifts others up.
Istg Jjong must be protected at all costs. He's literally the most loving, caring, thoughtful man on earth. He always compliments others and puts his friends before himself. He's a gem.
wowwwww he really did say that? i dont even know korean but their gestures made me think they are saying that only. i imagined victoria saying (m pretty sure its vic, the eyeliner makes it confusing tho) "i dont look good in this photo" and jonghyun replying, "you look so good"
Jonghyun and Krystal brother and sister relationship tho😭
As well with minho and amber
I'm so sad for this 2 groups, they lost 2 members, that must have been so hard for them. 😭😭😭
Hope they are happy now.
I always thought SHINee and F(x) were the most real. And the way SM planned them to be was awesome, if only they stuck with it. Fx was suppose to mirror SHINee, having similar music styles and releasing similar songs around the same time. They were also suppose to do promos together. Like how snsd and Fx did “chocolate love” for Android, SHINee and Fx did “lollipop” for lg. But YG (bigbang n 2ne1) did the korean version and Fx and a Chinese boy group promoted in Chinese. But SHINee n Fx still recorded their korean version. There are also a handful of stages they promoted on together like shinees “hello”. I just wish they did covers of each other’s song, performed together more, and had more official collabs.
It’s crazy how differently they were treated by SM and how both groups’ history has come to compliment one another
:'(
Yes. Til the end. "View" was supposed to be f(x)'s song but it didn't fit them so the producers took "4 Walls" from SHINee.
It's just so sad that Sulli got bullied so bad that she had to take a long hiatus.
@@ohnana95 Indeed, "View" was supposed to be for f(x), but I actually "heard" that Krystal liked "4 walls" so much that they decided exchange the songs 🤔 But then I don't really know how accurate this is 😅
@@ohnana95 jonghyun made view for shinee actually
i want a f(shinee) collab so bad
Awww These moments are so precious. I bet there is no other female and male idol groups can be as close as siblings like them in nowadays generation...
bts and snsd are pretty close...yet fans cant seem to keep their asses away from the btsnsd ships.
@@hoseokisdisappointed1397 bts and snsd? No lmao stfu
bts and snsd?..when Did that happen??.I dont think that's true
But SHINee and SNSD are also very close.
@@3-aasvipatel838 yeah... bts is closer to red velvet and i think closest to mamamoo but not snsd. they do admire snsd a lot but never seen them being close
@@aarushikishore1417 I dont know about mamamoo but bts and red velvet??..I have never seen their proper interaction
And actually red velvet and shinee are also close..coz yeri use to consider as her brother they even said that on TV.na di have also seen their interaction. This is what ik
When SM was a family 💔😭😭😭 my teenage years
Yes tht was the day that cant happen again.
9:03,I love how Minho went from a serious conversation with Sulli to talking about llamas with Amber...they really are the crackhead duo
deepa mahesh the fact that...
Fiel Cuevz 😳..
yaaaaa xD xD
remembering the days when krystal and taemin were sm's lil babies :'((((
yaaa
The way they are so comfortable with each other warms my heart. It's not very often that girl groups and boy groups show so much affection for each other, yet here we have f(x) and SHINee proving they are friendship goals 💙💜 love you all, stay happy and keep making amazing content x
I'm surprised at how comfortable krystal is!
She seemed clod i thought she was also shy.....but she goes so well with shinee and she actually never looked cold whenever she talked to them
She's only shy to strangers but she's jolly around friends
dont like how most people in the comments simplified this cute and happy video to be tragedy porn
respect jjong and sulli. is all shawols and meus/peaches ask.
yep. i mean some people are obviously coping but others are just saying shit like “now theyre smiling down from heaven” like stfu u probably hated them (or at least ssul) when they were alive dont pretend u care now
I feel like SM is the only company where these interactions are still possible between opposite gendered groups. Thank you for making this video! Shinee and f(x) members deserve all of our love and support!
True
SM plus YG and JYP to an extent.
8:13 IF A MALE AND FEMALE IDOL DID THIS TODAY THEY'D GET CANCELLED OR RIDICULED FOR BEING TOGETHER.
True
Ikr..
....or rumored to be dating
@@velvet8859 pretty much..
@@shrutis yup, sadly...
SuperGeneration & f(SHINee) are some of the moments that I miss the most among 2nd Gen of kpop! I love SM FAMILY! SHINee & f(x) are really like brothers & sisters! 💎💜
I started to cry when I saw Jonghyun taking photos. Imagine the memories they have when looking back at those photos. I hope f(x) and Shinee are okay
ugh. i had the exact same thought at that moment. those were little pieces of memory you look back to. at least we and the others and look back to them. it felt weird. it felt like the poem "The photograph" by Shirley Toulson but worse. it was a casual day which you dont care about at that time but in future even those casual/normal days seem precious.
i miss this time so bad they were the first two groups i stanned their relationship always cheered me up :( kinda feels weird to see soojung so happy with sm artists too 😭
8:04 if idols did that now we wouldn't hear the end of it
Who are they?
@@cindyyelios5037 minho and krystal
"why are you here"
minho is too funny haha
I love their friendship so much. It still hurts because I imagined both of them with a significant other and kids when they got older, but I will try to remember all of the happy times like this video.
When you were watching this with a big smile on your face. I've never seen girl group and a boy group relationship this much. Just them
At this point I think Amber is related to half the industry....Johnny is the little brother, Ten is the son. Minho is the big brother.
Sulli's laugh is iconic tbh 😂😂
I thought I was the only one who is obsessed with her laugh.
It's so contagious when she laughs I can't stop laughing. 😂
Many comments say that they were so happy before. Aren't we all? As we age, we learn about life and sadness slowly creeps in and drains us
whatcha doin ☹️
yeah sadly most people who grow up face more sadness than usual, but not for everyone. i hoped them to be the part of "not everyone".
11:23 their conversation feels so warm and soft aaa
08:06 WHO CAN DO THIS NOWADAYS???!!! so cute, they just being themselves. Not only shinee f(x), absolutely they're soooo cute. But with the another group idol, they being themselves too!!💕
I miss those era
f(shinee) forever. ot10 forever.
Thank you for such a beautiful and heartwarming video...SHINee and f(x) are forever my favorite boy and girl groups and that never gonna change...SHINee and f(x) = Forever 10 :))
Krystal and Jonghyun exhibit some serious sibling energy.
Fx & shinee are literally have a deep bonding :') sad to know we are not going to see this kind of sibling feels anymore in smtown, but i guess nct and the new gg would alr friends-siblings relationship too like shinee & fx
New GG???
Kaga Min sm new girl group, if u following smtown u will be familiar with lami and hina i guess bcs sm quite often promoting them since they were a child
@@kagamin6984 NCT as a whole seems like having this kind of relationship too with RV.
i think no groups can replace them
Black And white but the interaction are not as close as a siblings like (as much as i seen), mayb because the age gap was quit far. Meanwhile nct jeno-jaemin are going to school by subway and walking together with hina (soon to be sm gg) since predebut
My favorite sibling groups F(SHINee)
please give us more, still got a lot of minstal, lunew, smtown moments and fancam of them supporting each other on stage
2:14 this is the cutest thing ever! I love how Minho and Amber have this kind of relationship. The kind of relationship where a girl and a guy can hang out and wrestle or sleep next to each other without it being weird and or worrying about how media will see them. They are just really good friends, siblings even and I'm living for it
it's not Amber, it's Sulli and Minho 🥰
mate that’s sulli
I've never seen two kpop groups so comfortable with each other.. this is a match made in heaven
musically too.. imho they're SMtown finest.. still.. no one can come close to these two discographies
They've got such chaotic energy, makes me nostalgic because these were groups I grew up with as well as many of my friends. We grew up obsessing over them, it's a nice throwback.
when they were messing around with the sleeping bag it was such a sibling goals moment but you know everybody would be trying to say they're dating these days ugh
My god damn MinSul heart 😞💘
I just really love how when they're in a large group f(shinee) is always gonna be there doing SOMETHING. They are so goofy and sweet together. I also really love how much they support one another especially Jonghyun and Krystal. Their relationship is so sweet!
The interactions between Shinee, Fx, Super Junior ,TVXQ and Snsd is what I live for. Now we don't really see such interactions between idols. Second generation was really the best.
This is a boy group and girl group interaction that I need
THE CUTEST BROTHERS AND SISTERS RELATIONSHIP IN KPOP :(
I hope all the members can keep these warm memories of friendship inside their hearts. Even after all the years to come, i hope they can all come back to those times and feel a certain lightness in spirit.
My f(shinee) is the best siblings group.. I really miss those days. Thank u so much for this. This made me smile
Does anyone here noticed the moment when Taemin carries Krystal, both Luna and Victoria are happily shocked. I don't if any filipino here would read this but I feel "kilig" with that hehehehe
hello! my fellow filipino Meu!!🤗🤗
6:54 is so CUTE. onlun remains superior
SHINee and f(x) are SM's most convincing, showy, and real sibling among its groups
One of the strongest groups in kpop
I love both so much ❤️😭 legends!
Finally the video plays 💘
f(SHINee) are my ults ✨😭
Minho and Sulli laughing their butts of always cracks me up 😂❤️
13:23 if they were doing that in 2020 the fans would go crazy and say"whaaaaat we should do some thing about this amber girl"
Not like those fans that were saying "wooa or hehe"
They so close to each other and lot laughing together,,,
That why when they alone and do solo, they feel so lonely....they miss n need each other so much.
I miss kpop when everyone was friends and yt views does not matter.
No two groups will ever be as close as f(shinee)
they are the only k-pop groups that i love so much. i like other very few groups as well. but SHINee and f(x) are the best! they give me comfort and happiness. i can never get enough of them and still always listen to their songs and watch videos of them. to this day i love them so much that i want to get to know more and more even as individuals. i will always keep on supporting them.
This brings me back when I use to ship f(shinee) 7 years ago😵😭😭 The first 2 kpop group that I got into💓
I used to watching video clips of them. It’s been such a long time and I am here again 2020. I miss them so much with everyone and when they used to play around and when sulli being such a innocent baby and jonghyun being short and hot.. lol and teamin being the most pretty maknea.. amber and Victoria have hard time understand korea. Onew voice keep cracking. Minho being over competition. They come along way. They all succeed now. Make me happy. I’m not a fan but I enjoy every single of their video clips and songs. Their fan clubs is super nice too.
I'm betting of my life that SM's artists are soo damn close to each other..female or male ..they are like true siblings..soo cute SHINee,f(x), SNSD,exo, IU and many more ..they have such a close relationships .. today's idols can never be and enjoy like how they did ..even tho BTS , black pink or whoever are famous now ..the ones whom I love will be SHINee,FX ,snsd,exo .....I swear I will watch these videos at my ending days and die
Yes my second family sm town family popularity doesn't mattee
yall i wish it was more like this, instead of idols that have to keep a straight face and not interact becuse of delulus
두 그룹이 친한데 왜 내가 엄마미소를 짓고있지..
I love how sulli used to smile and laugh. It's precious (｡♡‿♡｡)
Lunew still matters ✨💘
F(x) were like SHINee’s and SNSD baby siblings ❤
2:14 they are really looks like brother and sister, they are so close and comfortable together ❤️❤️
Who are they?
@@cindyyelios5037 sulli and minho
F(Shinee) era was the best😭
So TVXQ and Suju decides to prank Shinee and Shinee decides to prank f(x) and they continue the cycle by pranking... Who? NCT or Red Velvet 😂😂 I wish they could have!!
Exo and NCT prank yeri during their trainee day on yeri 's birthday.
I'm so glad somebody's made a happy video. This is so adorable and it put the biggest smile on my face. ☺😊
f(x) is indeed different from other ggs
whoever you are, thank you so much for making this video. it made my day! ♡
yeoksi, this time of kpop was the best of them all... and I'm not saying only with f(x) and shinee but to every collab that happened back then were the best
I love them so much.
The cutest siblings ever.❤️
I miss sulli's and jonghyun's laugh the most
I miss the family bonding of 2nd and 3rd gen idols. It’s like when the group would debut they would hold the torch of being the older brothers or sister for the next group. Suju < tvxq < snsd > shinee > fx & exo
f(shinee) is the sort of friendship we all want but dont deserve
Minho is that elder brother who is playful, extremely caring and helpful to younger siblings, and a little brother to cool sisters.
The good times
It was so nice to see them all so happy and together. I miss them so much. I wish the best for SHINee and the rest of f(x). These are tears of love filled memories 💜💜
I swear, Sulli and Minho have the greatest laughs. Always makes me smile 💜💎
I honestly miss these times and miss these adorable interactions, nowadays idols can't even be friends with other groups of opposite gender without people assuming things. This video honestly brought a smile to my face seeing these clips again
Hopefully both groups can lean on each other through these rough times and help each other cope ❤
lol i was so jealous of the sm family when i was growing up. like wow i want a big group of friends like that 😂😂💖 obviously they probably had some drama but if you know all these people for so long, it's nice to see most of them are friends with and support each other too
Sulli’s laugh is so precious
Sulli and Minho really melt my heart...
Literally the two groups that make me a kpop fan. They have been introducing me to this new world that have been a part of half of my life. But now I kinda stop care about it because it was never the same anymore. I feel bad sometime cuz I never felt like I was a 'fan' enough. I never been to any of their concerts, never bought their album (since I still a teen that grew up in a strict family and usually the concert venue are far from my home and the album cos a fortune) sometime I feel like I never care enough for them. I really wish there was a time machine where i can go back and talk to myself to enjoy the moment. Maybe i wouldn't regret it today.
my two favorite groups always and forever .. f(shinee) is so precious
I miss them being this close. I wish they still interacted this much and made content together😭
Minho has the cutest laugh. I’m dead....
It's so cute when Jjong amd Soojung is fighting there is IU in the background doing her blank face...
한때에 제일 행복하고 발랄한 아이들이었는데... 그동안 쌓이고 쌓인게 뭐길래..
I miss sulli i miss jonghyun, i miss them all together, what a good day back then, thankyou for your video. This bring all sweet memories
This is the kind of interactions i wish groups could have :( the fans' god culture needs to stop
agree
LMAO you just had to start with that onew crashing on luna from isac 🤣🤣🤣🤣
I'm glad that they got to experience somewhat of a normal life,than the idols that are there now.I'm glad that they got to enjoy life at least a little bit more,I'm glad that you came when the fans are crazy and delusional.I'm glad that you guys were close and made good music.
Will forever be missed❤️❤️
Amber: Oppa..
Minho: Ne?
Amber: Oppa..
Minho: Weh?
They were sooo cuuute ❤️❤️😂
2 grup yg interaksinya paling aku kangenin huhuhu kangeeennn
Jonghyun and Sulli, you both will always be remembered ❤❤❤
Gosh I miss these good old days so much. They are my only 2 stan and now..
I know I have to grow up but this, this is too cruel
I wish more idols were like this, they were just normal platonic relationships
I really want a part 2 💘
I suddenly miss F(x) and Shinee as OT5 :-(
i really miss the gen 2 groups these days,,, no group can replace them,,,
watching old videos makes me regret not stanning them from the beginning😢
This video feels like a warm hug :)