Hi, great video as always. But I have doubts about the rules for the creation of Breakfast. I'm using a "DDD approach", so Breakfast is an Entity that has a static method "Create()" that works as Factory Method. In your example, you put the "sunrise" rules inside the DateTimeValidators and not inside the "Create()" method of Breakfast class. Is this a good approach? I have to put all the creation rules inside my “BuberBreakfast.Contracts” project and Validators or should I put the creation rules inside the Entity Breakfast? In short, the creation logic of an entity must be put inside our contracts or inside the Entities? Thanks!
Hey Gaetano, that's an awesome question. I spent a lot of time thinking about it myself, questioning some of the recommendations, reading several blogs, and checking how some solutions behave at scale within Microsoft projects. For large projects with several teams/team members - I would recommend having the application layer validate the command/query, and the domain layer validate the object in the Create method, as you said. Will you have multiple duplicate validations? Yes. But allowing the domain models to be in an invalid state because it was already validated in the application/presentation layer assumes only the client provides invalid values when in actuality, we should also be defending our domain models from developers. Of course, the behavior on failure is different in each layer. Invalid request details? No problem - 400. Invalid values when trying to create a domain model? That's probably an internal error
Hey Amichai :) I have been subscribed to your channel since your first video came out and I though it was about time to leave a comment. I really enjoy watching your videos. They are informative and at the same time fun to watch (at least for someone interested in coding and software archtiecture). At work we already use a lot of the technologies and patterns you introduced in your last videos. Nevertheless, I still learned one or two new things or got a different perspective on things. Thank you for that.
Great video! Nice structured and explained. What extension or customization are you using for your terminal? The color state of the branch and path looks gorgeous.
i have to say i love your videos, i always check to see if you have uploaded new content, are you going to build the front-end as well or it's just going to be a service ? Greate Video by the way!
Haha thanks, Musa! I'm not planning any from-end work as part of this series. This can be a fun .NET MAUI series for when I feel I know the topics well
Thanks, I'll probably do something like that in the future. For now, if you're interested, I have a video all about vscode for .NET: th-cam.com/video/m9HvsB1-hAo/w-d-xo.html For recording the screen, I use OBS Studio.
Fantastic playlist/work! Thank you! How would you approach fluent validation in a project with application services (without mediatr). Automatic or manual validation -> which means no pipeline behavior, but instead doing the work manually for each action?
Thanks, Jim! I'd use automatic validation. If async validations are needed, I'd see if it's possible to implement some middleware/filter to do the work. Never looked into it though
How can we use fluent validation to validate the DTO like the behavior of Datanotations? Because when the validation happen later on, some of the null fields might have taken their default values by the framework. ex: int --> 0 Which would miss my validations. So how can we validate beforehand?
if I did have the same rule for multiple proprieties (with only different parameters like max Length), Is there a way I could make a delegate or any think like this that could point at the same rule. And use it with different proprieties and there corresponding parameters. As it will be easier to make everything consistent, in case I wanted to change anything in the rule itself. Specially, that I have many Models and Dto that use the same rule. Thanks.
Great library and greate demo. I am a bit dissapointed however that you put the validation in the controller layer and did not keep your structure, with domain and application layers, from previous chapters. If anything, validation is the core of domain functionality.
26:51 😉. This video was an introduction to FluentValidation. In the next video we'll integrate it with our Buber Dinner application as part of the application layer. We'll also discuss and the difference between application layer validations and domain layer validations.
Wow, pretty detailed explanation about this library. Do we use it? Of course 🙂 but more for a simple validations like 'greaterThaZero', 'notEmpty', etc. and several custom validators like '...doesExist'
Thank for the video but AddFluentValidation is deprecated and is not working with Minimal API. Please can make a newer video with Minimal API and show us how to validate a request without using [FromServices] IValidator
I have become a big fan of urs now. If you noticed I recently joined and start learning from ur videos. Is there any new video coming about Clean Architecture series where you already have I guess 7 videos.
Love your videos! Every time you say "Yes" whenever the copilot autofill's syntax is really satisfying. Co-pilot is really great
Yes! :D
Such a great introduction to the FluentValidation library. I loved that you showed that DI is supported inside of validators. Great job!
Thank you dear for your detailed, quick, and straightforward demonstration.
you are the best .net technology teacher I have ever seen.
Thanks Daniel! 🫶🏼
I've been using FluentValidation for some time now and was stunned by what I saw you doing with this custom validator. Great video, thanks !
Great video. Been diving into a dotnet project at work and needed some refreshers over this.
Bro your channel is small but you are making some of the best .NET 6 content already. Keep up the good work.
Thanks 🫶🏼
Great overview of FluentValidation package, I realy like last parts about custom validators.
Thanks!
Thanks for this great introduction into the FluentValidation library.
Great pacing and information, keep up the great work. My only complaint is I cant get videos fast enough! :D
Hi, great video as always. But I have doubts about the rules for the creation of Breakfast. I'm using a "DDD approach", so Breakfast is an Entity that has a static method "Create()" that works as Factory Method. In your example, you put the "sunrise" rules inside the DateTimeValidators and not inside the "Create()" method of Breakfast class. Is this a good approach? I have to put all the creation rules inside my “BuberBreakfast.Contracts” project and Validators or should I put the creation rules inside the Entity Breakfast?
In short, the creation logic of an entity must be put inside our contracts or inside the Entities?
Thanks!
Hey Gaetano, that's an awesome question. I spent a lot of time thinking about it myself, questioning some of the recommendations, reading several blogs, and checking how some solutions behave at scale within Microsoft projects.
For large projects with several teams/team members - I would recommend having the application layer validate the command/query, and the domain layer validate the object in the Create method, as you said.
Will you have multiple duplicate validations? Yes. But allowing the domain models to be in an invalid state because it was already validated in the application/presentation layer assumes only the client provides invalid values when in actuality, we should also be defending our domain models from developers.
Of course, the behavior on failure is different in each layer. Invalid request details? No problem - 400. Invalid values when trying to create a domain model? That's probably an internal error
Hey Amichai :) I have been subscribed to your channel since your first video came out and I though it was about time to leave a comment. I really enjoy watching your videos. They are informative and at the same time fun to watch (at least for someone interested in coding and software archtiecture). At work we already use a lot of the technologies and patterns you introduced in your last videos. Nevertheless, I still learned one or two new things or got a different perspective on things. Thank you for that.
Wow, that's awesome to hear. It's rare to have an opportunity to impact on such a scale, one of the reasons I created this channel. Thanks, Daniel!
This video has everything I was looking for, incredible, thank you!
I liked this "Yes" to the copilot autofill :D. I didn't get the idea behind the IAssemblyMarker, can you please elaborate more?
Great video! Nice structured and explained.
What extension or customization are you using for your terminal? The color state of the branch and path looks gorgeous.
Thanks, Humberto! I followed Scott Hanselman's tutorial. You can find it via "Scott Hanselman windows terminal" on YT or on his blog.
Nice video! Could you make more detailed video about Attributes and how to use them for validation? Also making Custome Attribute validators?
what is the name of the screen recorder you're using to do marks during recording ?
Fantastic playlist. Can this use for domain entity validation ?
i have to say i love your videos, i always check to see if you have uploaded new content, are you going to build the front-end as well or it's just going to be a service ?
Greate Video by the way!
Haha thanks, Musa! I'm not planning any from-end work as part of this series. This can be a fun .NET MAUI series for when I feel I know the topics well
What is the tool that suggests the code to you ?
I love your videos, it's very straightforward. Can you share your setup when recording (VScode, screen recorder, etc) in the future?
Thanks, I'll probably do something like that in the future. For now, if you're interested, I have a video all about vscode for .NET: th-cam.com/video/m9HvsB1-hAo/w-d-xo.html
For recording the screen, I use OBS Studio.
Great video! Thanks!
Amichai you are the best! ❤️
Did you know how we convert fluent validation responses to custom class responses while using auto validation feature?
Fantastic playlist/work! Thank you! How would you approach fluent validation in a project with application services (without mediatr). Automatic or manual validation -> which means no pipeline behavior, but instead doing the work manually for each action?
Thanks, Jim! I'd use automatic validation. If async validations are needed, I'd see if it's possible to implement some middleware/filter to do the work. Never looked into it though
Thanks for the great content, it really inspires me to improve myself to become a better developer. Your are doing great, keep going 👍
Best comment I could get. Thanks, Denis!
How can we use fluent validation to validate the DTO like the behavior of Datanotations?
Because when the validation happen later on, some of the null fields might have taken their default values by the framework.
ex: int --> 0
Which would miss my validations.
So how can we validate beforehand?
if I did have the same rule for multiple proprieties (with only different parameters like max Length), Is there a way I could make a delegate or any think like this that could point at the same rule. And use it with different proprieties and there corresponding parameters.
As it will be easier to make everything consistent, in case I wanted to change anything in the rule itself. Specially, that I have many Models and Dto that use the same rule.
Thanks.
looking forward to your new videos.
Great library and greate demo.
I am a bit dissapointed however that you put the validation in the controller layer and did not keep your structure, with domain and application layers, from previous chapters. If anything, validation is the core of domain functionality.
26:51 😉. This video was an introduction to FluentValidation. In the next video we'll integrate it with our Buber Dinner application as part of the application layer. We'll also discuss and the difference between application layer validations and domain layer validations.
@@amantinband Cool, looking forward to it!
Which extentions do you use in vs code? I realy need this info.
Oh, you switched to dark mode. Thank you, from all of us night owls. hoot🦉🌠
Haha yeah it bothered me for a while 😂
Hey!
What's the shell and theme you're using in your integrated terminal?
great vid, which software do you use to draw those arrows on screen?
Thanks, Linden. I use ZoomIt
excellent tutorial as always, you are awesome
Loving your videos
Will you proceed with the CQRS version of this application? Just want to see FluentValidation + MediatR Behaviors work together.
th-cam.com/video/FXP3PQ03fa0/w-d-xo.html 😉
Excellent!
As always, great !
Thank you!
Such a great content. Keep it up. Yes! :)
I misheard. Is it recommended to use manual or automatic validation?
It is recommended to use Manual validation
Wow, pretty detailed explanation about this library. Do we use it? Of course 🙂 but more for a simple validations like 'greaterThaZero', 'notEmpty', etc. and several custom validators like '...doesExist'
Thank for the video but AddFluentValidation is deprecated and is not working with Minimal API.
Please can make a newer video with Minimal API and show us how to validate a request without using [FromServices] IValidator
Excellent one
I have become a big fan of urs now. If you noticed I recently joined and start learning from ur videos. Is there any new video coming about Clean Architecture series where you already have I guess 7 videos.
17:13 Does it make much difference that you define NotBeEmpty() as static?
Nope 🙂
Should not this be a continuation of BubberDinner?
Where do you get your Idatetimeprovider from? thanks
It's a simple wrapper around the built in DateTime
how to return custom response ?