this is what I miss about 2nd gen groups. the emotion flows naturally and unforced. the live vocals are intense and the choreography whilst it is not too complex, it is not that simple as well. It is just a perfect balance of both vocals and dance. I feel like I am just watching a dance performance in most group these days sadly.
No disrespect to existing girls groups, I still like the dance back in the old days..now days, the girls tend to be "cutie" instead of showing "confidence" and "sexy"....that's just me..
@@thebluerook6972 lets be honest. After School, Rainbow (except A) and 9muses are the few girl groups that can be sexy without even trying. They project elegance and sexiness w/o being trampy.
yeah they're still look sexy even without wearing very short pants and uncomfortable clothes. but honestly i don't care about the concept, the old group sing 100% live with low background music that you barely found it nowadays, i think it's the most important thing that you should have to become a singer.
Here in 2020! This is honestly one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard in life, not even just in Kpop. When they performed it, you can tell they really felt the lyrics. So pretty! After School were really THAT group.
2ne1 on hiatus + lost one member4minute gone disbandSecret still on hiatusT-ara busy overseas activityAfterschool on its long hiatus 2009 bad girls need to slay again. Wake up agencies and make them slay comebacks
Nope. There are some gossips but just gossips still. I mean is they we're on long hiatus and keep promoting Hyosung solo. Though Zinger reportedly preping for his solo debut, what I want is secret as whole.
No matter how many year passes by, this song remains as one of the most beautiful song ever. If people doesn't know this song, they're really missing out a lot
2010년 이때가 18살 고2때 나온 노래인데 이 노래도 정말 많이 좋아했었는데 11년만에 들으니까 옛날 생각나게 하는 추억의 노래 명곡이다 슈가맨4에 소환했으면 좋겠다 지금 가요보다 옛날 가요가 더 좋은것 같아 지금 들어도 신나고 2021년에 들어도 정말 명곡이야 이것도 수능 금지곡으로 유명한데 SS501-U R MAN 유키스-만만하니도 수능 금지곡이야
I still can feel the pain, the resentment, the sadness through this song after years not listening to it. How can a song be powerful enough to break my heart?
I regret not getting into kpop a long time ago so I could appreciate this song when it was released, as well as the old AS. It's like my favourite rn...
Apology ...among korean kpop group girls ...no one can beat the AFTER SCHOOL GROUP...THEY ARE THE MOST TALENTED AND AWESOME PERFORMANCE ....THAN EVER....REQUESTING FOR THEIR COMEBACK AND REUNION PERFORMANCES PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE .. THEY HAVE DONE POLE DANCING PLAYING DRUM AND OTHER TALENTS...WHILE NOW GIRL GROUP ONLY SWEET DANCE AND SINGING ....PLEASE KPOP BRING BACK " AFTER SCHOOL " PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE
i know the dance because key (at that time i don't know the lyrics,only understand their music) then i know this song because Seventeen. And now i'm fallin in love with "because of u" whatever the version.
Nana was one of the first girls in kpop to have a full blond hair. I remember comments saying how After School had a foreign member lol. Old kpop is gold.
not even global petition can change pledis decision... i hope kaeun effect may be able to make pledis change their mind... or atleast final comeback so fans can bid farewell properly..
Please bring back the old kpop that I love. I keep on watching old kpop videos and performances and it hurts so much. The vibe that brought me to KPOP. I miss it so much. Uri 2nd generation of kpop groups and bands, we miss you so much. Let's cry my fellow 2nd gen kpop fans. TT
![[HD] 110619 After School - Shampoo & Because of You](/img/n.gif)
이맘때 특유의 이런 분위기 노래들 너무 좋음 ㅠ 뉴이스트 - 여보세요/유키스-0330 같은거
비슷한 시긴지 그 뒤인지 기억나지 않지만 틴탑 쉽지않아......도
용형 돈바싹 벌때가 좋았죠 시스타 aoa 유키스 애프터스쿨 브레이브 걸스 다 그때 노래가 좋았어요 노래 시작할때 브레이브 사운드 나올때 간지도 났고
와 너무 공감이다 저때만 해도 피아노 건반이 밑사운드라서 솔직히 빅뱅 하루하루도 ㅠ
저도ㅋㅋ여보세요 0330 2000년대노래가더좋아
너때문에랑 저런 듣도보도 못한곡들이랑 엮지좀마ㅠ
너때문에는 1위곡임
근데 가희 진짜 얼굴선이랑 이목구비 깔-끔하다. 입도 커서 웃을때 시원시원하고. 인간 박하인가 춤선도 시원하고 ㅌㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
레이나 진짜 잘한다 오캬도 그렇고 레이나 들어온거 신의 한수인듯..
ㄹㅇ 정아 하나로 부족하던 보컬라인을 잘 보충해줌
@@paradox4006 ㅇㅈ👍 레이나 신의한 수 보컬라인 중심 잘 잡아줬지
레이나 고음이 시원해요!
예전엔 몰랐는데 베카는 꼭 있어야 되는구나 랩 찰떡이네
무슨 그걸 10년만에 아냐? 그정도면 심각한거아님?
@@준영이-o4s어렸을 때 보고 오랜 시간이 지나서 다시 봤을 수도 있죠 무슨 말을 그렇게까지 해요?
심각한건 니 인성인듯 @@준영이-o4s
베카랑 가희가 앺스 초기의 정체성이었음
솔짇히 이멤이 애프터스쿨 레전드야 ㅜㅜ
its still beautiful no matter how many years have past.
An absolute masterpiece, this song is.
After school + SNSD + 2NE1 + T-Ara + Sistar = LEGENDS! i really miss this girl groups!
You miss one.. KARA
Why people always forget KARA 😔
4 minute ??
KARA
Don't forget Apink, still exist until now 💖
this is what I miss about 2nd gen groups. the emotion flows naturally and unforced. the live vocals are intense and the choreography whilst it is not too complex, it is not that simple as well. It is just a perfect balance of both vocals and dance. I feel like I am just watching a dance performance in most group these days sadly.
Yea there’s a lot of dance performances in this generation
I agree... Today the groups only care about "strong dancing, beating, sealing"... there isn't much distinction, as it was before!
I miss the old afterschool....
me too ♥♥♥♥
Me too
TerraDoLL i miss the old kpop
Me too :(
Me too
정말 명곡임...10년이 지났은데도 정말 좋은 노래임...
No disrespect to existing girls groups, I still like the dance back in the old days..now days, the girls tend to be "cutie" instead of showing "confidence" and "sexy"....that's just me..
Now there’s not enough cute groups either. No sexy, no cute, no sentimental, no weird...mostly only girl crush
@@thebluerook6972 lets be honest. After School, Rainbow (except A) and 9muses are the few girl groups that can be sexy without even trying. They project elegance and sexiness w/o being trampy.
@up Up but for me this AS still in my trend, cant replaceable
yeah they're still look sexy even without wearing very short pants and uncomfortable clothes. but honestly i don't care about the concept, the old group sing 100% live with low background music that you barely found it nowadays, i think it's the most important thing that you should have to become a singer.
AS didn't promote for sexiness. They just perform as Grown Women. 6 of 7 are 80 lines at that time (except Nana, she's 1991).
컴눈명 보다가 여기까지 왔다,,
이때 애프터스쿨은 레전드 그 자체...
Here in 2020! This is honestly one of the most beautiful songs I've ever heard in life, not even just in Kpop. When they performed it, you can tell they really felt the lyrics. So pretty! After School were really THAT group.
Britbi PREACH! One of my fave songs of all time. I know the lyrics by heart 🥰
2022
레이나 진짜 잘한다..
다 이쁘기도 힘든데 진짜 다들 여신이다
리지 이영 가은도 아이돌 멤버로 괜찮은데 애프터스쿨은 이 멤버 구성이 훨씬 내가 아는 애프터스쿨의 이미지임 ㅜㅜ
리지 어딨음?
@@dct_va_ 리지는 이 다음 뱅 활동에 합류했어요 너때문에는 없음
해울 ㄱㅅㄱㅅㄱㅅ
오캬생각해서 리지까진 좋앗는데ㅜ 리지는 예능맴으로 필요하긴햇었음.. 이영부터 진짜 푸시도 제대로 안해주고 굳이 넣어서 장점도없었는데
This has always been one of my favourite girl group songs. It's one to keep coming back to and I still love it after replaying tons
Agreed. It's a classic and a masterpiece
After all these years, I still can't get over how stunning Kahi looks. Such a glow emanating off of her.
2ne1 on hiatus + lost one member4minute gone disbandSecret still on hiatusT-ara busy overseas activityAfterschool on its long hiatus
2009 bad girls need to slay again. Wake up agencies and make them slay comebacks
Secret disbanded?! OH MY GOD
Nope. There are some gossips but just gossips still. I mean is they we're on long hiatus and keep promoting Hyosung solo. Though Zinger reportedly preping for his solo debut, what I want is secret as whole.
*were
im just glad SISTAR is still here
Fynboen sistar just disbanded too... :'(
애프터스쿨 데뷔 첫 1위 한 노래
01:20 이안무는진짜 ㅈㄴ잘짠듯 너무찰떡!
After School, KARA and T-ara are the best group in this kind of concept. Miss 2nd gen group so much.
2.5세대 감성 그 자체임 이당시 저런 갬성노래가 너무 그리움😢
다른 영상에서 본 댓글대로 애프터스쿨의 심장은 가희, 베카, 정아가 맞는듯.
레이나 누님 오랜지캬라멜하고는 분위기가 정반대네 ㄷㄷ
가수한테 누님 이카노
@@준영이-o4s느기미한테.하리?
The rap parts in kpop before is really a Rap, compared today.
FACT!
No matter how many year passes by, this song remains as one of the most beautiful song ever. If people doesn't know this song, they're really missing out a lot
This was totally UEE's era for me. She sings and dances so emotionally
2010년 이때가 18살 고2때 나온 노래인데 이 노래도 정말 많이 좋아했었는데 11년만에 들으니까 옛날 생각나게 하는 추억의 노래 명곡이다 슈가맨4에 소환했으면 좋겠다 지금 가요보다 옛날 가요가 더 좋은것 같아 지금 들어도 신나고 2021년에 들어도 정말 명곡이야 이것도 수능 금지곡으로 유명한데 SS501-U R MAN 유키스-만만하니도 수능 금지곡이야
저때 유이 진짜 비율 각선미 오진다 현존 아이돌중에 누가 이길까 싶음
레이나 너무 귀엽다 ㅎㅎ 노래도 잘하고~ 중간에 레이나 들어온게 신의한수였지~
I still can feel the pain, the resentment, the sadness through this song after years not listening to it. How can a song be powerful enough to break my heart?
One of their best performances of this era
who is still listening in 2018?
omg. I still have this on my phone.
Bernadette Azcarraga beautiful song
And will still listen to beyond
Me
One of all time fav
The way they sang it live was incredible
The passion in their faces when they sing the part at 2:21 is beguiling.. WE NEED MORE OF THIS IN K-POP!!!!
This group was one of the best and I loved their variation, sound, and style. In this song particular, I loved how Raina and Jung ah finished strong.
모든 멤버가 각자의 매력어필 한사람도 모두 소중한 존재감 뿜뿜뿜 응원해요~~
유이 왜케 이뻐 ㅋㅋㅋ
Bekah always was the star of the group for me. Incredible rap and presence 👏❤
THIS is what missing in new gen KPOP. The FEELS of this song my god. 2nd gen is the best!!
who are still listening in 2019??
Who are still listening in 2017 ?
hk0030 me
hk0030 me ofc
hk0030 mee
me..the most perfect broken-hearted song
meee
uee was so pretty
섹시와 카리스마가 섞인 레전드 애프터스쿨 because of you 무대
I regret not getting into kpop a long time ago so I could appreciate this song when it was released, as well as the old AS. It's like my favourite rn...
솔직히 용형이 만든 곡중에 최고의 곡
Apology ...among korean kpop group girls ...no one can beat the AFTER SCHOOL GROUP...THEY ARE THE MOST TALENTED AND AWESOME PERFORMANCE ....THAN EVER....REQUESTING FOR THEIR COMEBACK AND REUNION PERFORMANCES PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE ..
THEY HAVE DONE POLE DANCING PLAYING DRUM AND OTHER TALENTS...WHILE NOW GIRL GROUP ONLY SWEET DANCE AND SINGING ....PLEASE KPOP BRING BACK " AFTER SCHOOL " PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE
Wow..I miss these days for girl groups, 4minute, 2ne1, Miss A and them...and also Kahi a mom now, saw her on TROS, time sure flies😭💜
이 노래나올때부터 몇년간 계속 들었는데
이노래가 거리에서 들릴당시에 아픈기억들이 있어 잊고 있다 알고리즘에 의해 큰릭을 하게 되어 멍하니 듣고 있네요 ㅜㅜ
ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ ...
I really like Bekah rap :)
And Kahee can both rap and sing 👍
I miss After School.
I first here from Nu'est cover in Produce101, they are doing very well. Support Nu'est!!!
애프터스쿨은 5인조가 최고지만 나나,레이나 까지만 영입을 했어야....(메보가 정아만으로 부족했기때문에)
리지가없어서 오캬가탄생못했을지도
리지까진 괜찮았었음 예능에서도 많이 활약하고
Pledis please makes them to have a comeback
I just want to see how After Schhool will become a proud mom to Seventeen :(
Bekkah is so beautiful
애프터스쿨 너 때문에 노래 여전히 좋아요 🤗
진짜...너무 멋지다...좋은그룹 좋은노래는 역시 세월이 지나도 좋구나....
i know the dance because key (at that time i don't know the lyrics,only understand their music) then i know this song because Seventeen. And now i'm fallin in love with "because of u" whatever the version.
God. Listening to this brings back memories of K-Pop back in the day. I like the songs now but it doesn't bring the same feelings as back then.
이 때 레이나는 미모 가창력 레전드네
Uee is so pretty🖤
와 근데 확실히 레이나 들어오고나서 고음파트 음청나게 탄탄해졌네
몰랐다 이 때는 이렇게 라이브 하면서
안무 소화 하는 게 엄청난 실력이라는 걸
정말 잘만든곡
애프터스쿨이 불러줘서 고마워
This feels like watching Uie’s focus fancam🤣
베카 진짜 너무 멋있어..컴눈명보다가 여기까지왔네
my first kpop song ..I miss them so much
유이씨 아기아기하고
너무 청순하네요
2019? No matter how Seventeen made this beautiful, This version made me miss them so much
Nana was one of the first girls in kpop to have a full blond hair. I remember comments saying how After School had a foreign member lol. Old kpop is gold.
Very good music. Miss the era of k-pop; very good music in this period. Not so much, today.
always in my memories .. they dont make this kind of music anymore ..
OMG UEE's legs!!!
I miss Afterschool so much 😭
2017 is almost over and I’m still coming back for this. The best era ever. 😭❤️
Best era. Best song. Best group ever 😢
추억이다 이때로 돌아가고싶다 😢
레이나가 이렇게 매력적 였다니 ㅡㅡ
i first heard this song in the seventeen cover..until i decided to watch the original...i didnt know it has rap lines
me too
+happy loh seventeen really do a good job
+AIRA_shiii kpopper argee😉😉
th-cam.com/video/GWp7tmoawt0/w-d-xo.html
애프터스쿨 너때문에 커버해봣습니다!ㅎㅎ
좋아요 싫어요 구독 악플 다 받습니다! ㅎㅎ귀엽게 봐주시고 새해복 많이 받으세용!!
레이나짱
I actually thought this was performed a year ago........until i saw Kahi and Bekah..........*ugly sobs in dark corner*
i liked afterschool best at this time. loved all the members and their songs. dont really know the new members now
ah.. i miss after school.
2:35 유이 마이크 잡는거 조금 신기
몇살이냐.
난 유이 연기하는게 왜케 어색한지 모르것다.
원래 가순디 ;;;;;
파크 나 몇살이냐고?
일반적으로 가수가 저렇게 잡지는 않는데... 급하게 바로잡아서 저런걸수도?
어차피 라이브 안하니
Still here 2019 😍 just love this line up.
Same here
MmTG brought me back here
이 노래 개좋아했는데 개띵곡
you know what i love from 2nd gen? they dance on high heels without any worry
AFTER SCHOOL BEST ERA
I miss Afterschool so much
I hope that one day they will come back
Who are still listening this song in 2018?
2-10-2018
Still listen this in 2021
not even global petition can change pledis decision... i hope kaeun effect may be able to make pledis change their mind... or atleast final comeback so fans can bid farewell properly..
This is still their best song and one of my fav kpop songs ever!
2023 I’m still crying over this 😢❤ after school ❤forever
this is one of the kpop songs i first knew when i became a kpop fan. And it is still good everytime I listen to it👍
Me too! And it's still my absolute favorite up to this day
Please bring back the old kpop that I love. I keep on watching old kpop videos and performances and it hurts so much. The vibe that brought me to KPOP. I miss it so much. Uri 2nd generation of kpop groups and bands, we miss you so much. Let's cry my fellow 2nd gen kpop fans. TT
I miss After Schooooooool 😔
The emotions in this song....
Beautiful.
이때 레이나 그립다
지금 여리여리한거보다
이스타일이 정말 이쁘고멋진데ㅜㅜ
머리며 중성적이면서도
신입인데 혼자노래로 압도하는포스