The Law That Made INDIAN Cities BAD & Can We Replan it ? || क्या भारत अपने शहर फिर बना सकता है
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 มี.ค. 2022
- Download link - kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/4ugo/zzk4
Coupon code - PT50
( Coupon valid for first 50 users )
#ad #IndianCities #India
India is so bad at planning cities because we have no ‘one’ effective, central urbanisation plan at all. We do not have state-level urbanisation plans either. And till recently, we did not even have effective, functional district level comprehensive urbanisation plans. Though there have been ministries and departments, but their power to make deep dents in the system was negligible.
It has now become a torism that Indian cities are poorly planned and governed. Plans do not have complete sway over our cities since they are constantly violated and a significant section of the urban population lives outside “planned” neighbourhoods. Nevertheless, the state religiously performs the ritual of master planning every 10 or 20 years
The Urban Land Ceiling Act was a law in India, that was passed in 1976. The stated purpose of the law is "bringing about an equitable distribution of land in urban agglomerations to subserve the common good."Consequences[edit] In a real world scenario, monopoly of land can take place when people, entities and corporate companies, with access to huge capital can occupy vast tracts of land, hoard it, make it scarce and use this scarcity to control demand - supply of land However this is problem is compounded due to the fact that governments from 1992 till today refused to develop lands quickly based on growth and demand, much like Germany where timely development of land and releasing it to public allowed land to be affordable.[citation needed] The Act was repealed by Urban Land (Ceiling & Regulation) Repeal Act, 1999. The repeal Act had in-built commencement date on 11 January 1999, vide section , for Haryana, Punjab and the union territories. For other states, it was left to the state legislatures to decide the date of commencement. Accordingly, it has been implemented on 28 November 2007 in Maharashtra[2] and 30 March 1999 in Gujarat.The repeal Act has been adopted in all states except Andhra Pradesh, Assam, Bihar and West Bengal.This act was repealed in November 2007 in the state of Maharashtra. The repeal was a pre-condition to the state government with a grant under the Jawaharlal Nehru National Urban Renewal Mission (JNNURM), to be used for major infrastructure development projects (like the Mumbai Trans Harbour Link, the Mumbai Metro Project, the Bandra-Worli, the Worli-Nariman Point sealink and the Mumbai Urban Transport Project-II). However, there is still considerable confusion in the process required for the clearance of land for buildings; the repeal has not had much impact on the ground. The Maharashtra Government has purchased large tracts of land under provisions of this act, to be used to provide low-cost housing to the common people. However, this land continues to lie vacant.
भारत शहरों की योजना बनाने में इतना बुरा है क्योंकि हमारे पास कोई 'प्रभावी', केंद्रीय शहरीकरण योजना नहीं है। हमारे पास राज्य-स्तरीय शहरीकरण योजनाएं भी नहीं हैं। और हाल तक, हमारे पास प्रभावी, कार्यात्मक जिला स्तर की व्यापक शहरीकरण योजना भी नहीं थी। हालांकि मंत्रालय और विभाग रहे हैं, लेकिन सिस्टम में गहरी गति बनाने की उनकी शक्ति नगण्य थी।
यह अब एक मशाल बन गया है कि भारतीय शहर खराब तरीके से योजनाबद्ध और शासित हैं। हमारे शहरों पर योजनाओं का पूरी तरह से बोलबाला नहीं है क्योंकि उनका लगातार उल्लंघन हो रहा है और शहरी आबादी का एक महत्वपूर्ण वर्ग "नियोजित" पड़ोस से बाहर रहता है। फिर भी, राज्य धार्मिक रूप से प्रत्येक 10 या 20 वर्षों में मास्टर प्लानिंग का अनुष्ठान करता है
🔶INSTAGRAM- / aakash_rb
🔶Twitter- / powertrain_yt
Copyright Related Issue Please Contact
aakashbhavsar88059@gmail.com
OR
DM on Twitter - / powertrain_yt
DISCLAIMER
CLIPS / IMAGES USED IN THE VIDEO ARE
-ROYALTY FREE
-IN PUBLIC DOMAIN
-CREATIVE COMMONS
-COMMON OWNERSHIP GIVEN BY GOVERMENT OF INDIA
Video is for educational purpose only. Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purpose such as critcism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarships, and research. - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Download link - kukufm.sng.link/Apksi/4ugo/zzk4
Coupon code - PT50
( Coupon valid for first 50 users )
Hello
Bycott British low in India 🤷
Basically due to socialism and communism ideology after 1947 India's cities planning got destroyed.
This celling factor which implemented In 1976 was a communist ideology.
Communists loves money, but hates earning it.
sky view se toh dono hi ache lag rahe hain 11:00 and 9:50
@@thebholevlogs this was not british law, this was done by congress govt after 1947
When Singapore was planning and making houses accessible for all where majority of the population were homeless while India had implemented poor laws like this
Congress do many blunders i can write 100 books of congress Blunders
@@sunilpaliwal4782 congress ka dusra naam scam Aur blunder hai
@@sunilpaliwal4782 to likh de gadhe 🤣🤣Animated videos dekh kar jai modi papa jai modi papa mat chilla
@@anshkalra3910 muze modi - modi chilane ki jarurat hi nahi hai duniya chila rahi hai. Ha liberanduo ki Suzi padi hai bechare Dhruv rathee ke video dekh kar brainwashed ho rahe kya kar sakte hai.
Either gov needed to take all land and distruibute properly or give to private people. India neither adappted communism nor capitalism .
Seriously, I also think the same. Replan hone se aur khoobsurat diktha humara India 🇮🇳 ❤️😍
Chaitanya is Telugu surname na?
I think this daily when at evening i go to roof top of my house i think many ways to make our country cities smart
@@sudhirghosh_ Chaitanya isn't my surname bro. It's my name 😊.
Surname kuch aur h
@@LiberalNehru me too 😊
@@krishnachaitanya8590 Chaitanya name he to fir Krishna kya he Bhai Ji
in KOLKATA we can see the RJARHAT NEWTOWN AREA is so much planned and developed. It was Made by HIDCO. if private players and govertment works together we can make indian cities great again. One big problem i have seen personally that no one follows the road marks or guidlines while driving, lanes are not followed at all.
In every major city in India, some places look ultra modern and the rest look like overgrown villages.
In Mumbai as well, there is a section called Navi Mumbai which was developed by CIDCO. It has high rise buildings, wide highways and well planned nodes. It also managed to be in top 10 cleanest cities in India for 3 consecutive years at 3rd position.
@@RohanSingh-bl2sq I have lived in Navi Mumbai and loved it so much more than main Mumbai. Clean, wide streets, ample greenery, parks, reserved marshlands, no garbage lying on the streets, and one more thing - does not smell of fish everywhere as in Mumbai.
Government workers, staffs and engineers can also make indian cities more planned than any other foreign cities but the main problem in India is corruption where the person who takes tendor to the low level workers are all corrupt •Whereas, the workers of the private companies are not so corrupt because of the hard regulations implemented on the workers and other persons•
You might have heard that majority of the people wants to do government jobs because of easy rules given to workers and officers॰And due to this careless rules workers are being corrupt and careless whereas the workers of the private companies are not•
Letting the private players enter this arena is a good option but there is no surety that there will no corruption and scams. Afterall it all the people's taxes
भारत में मुख्य समस्या ये है कि हम सुधार तो चाहते हैं , लेकिन कठिन कानून को अपनाना नही चाहते। धनयवाद 🙏🏼😊
Brastachar aur alasi government worker bhi reason hai.
@@bharatlaljayswal2653 ye chiz to hamesa rahegi india me, bas dekh na ye hai ki ham apno problem la solution nikaalte h in sab k bich
कानून सही होना चाहीए जो भी । कठिन का क्या मतलब कानून गणित का सवाल थोड़े हैं ।
Elites dont follow anything, all politicians, businessmen, rich, celebrities, mafias, dons, goons, officers suffer from ultra hyper egos & godly feeling, they consider common people as slaves or insects...this nation will die painfully & spread stecnch in whole world, so whole world will raise a high wall around india to contain the dirt, stench, shit, pus, inflected blood & diseased stinking people to spread out
Arre Bhai Jo karna chahta he unko yelog gareebo ka dushman bolke chunav ladte he
Jese ki agar koi purani bastiya ko hatane shahar banane ki sochta he toh kahte he dushman
India has always been unfriendly to private entrepreneurs. Take for example, the recent bashing of Adani and Ambani during the farmer protest. Some people and organizations were bashing industrialists. It feels like making money is a sin, even if these people bring jobs, money, and technology to us.
But the same people would worship Pichai (because of Google tag), Zukerberg (Facebook tag) and Bezos (Amazon tag) even though they pay nothing in taxes in the US. This is called colonial mindset where Western brands look cool and Indian brands are all in cahoots with the govt and looting people!
In front of my house, their is serious rearrangement of infrastructure happening now....
The roads from being one lane is being upgraded to a three lane one....
I'm really looking forward to driving on it....
Which place
@@BatMan-dy6uk most probably South
Why are you not looking forward to using buses? This is what happens, roads are widened, which makes them attractive to private vehicle drivers, who drive more vehicles, and thus traffic increases again. This is called induced demand phenomenon. Road widening cannot solve traffic issue for long time. The solution is to have good public transport.
Indian Air Force Campuses are better then the Planned ciities in India
That's bad. We don't need car dependent cities. Why do we not learn from the mistakes made by the western countries such as US or candada. They have shit urban planning for mist places. We just copy idiotically and not from the places like Melbourne, European cities which are actually livable. 2 lanes are more than enough We don't need urban sprawl. We need better connectivity and public transport to reduce the dependency on Cars and provide more public spaces.
9:59 That was a very good suggestion. We have so many narrow roads in ancient cities , we should have similar one way road or no vehicle zones which would be just used by pedestrians
Time stamp waley babu 👍👍
Indeed,public friendly spaces and streets connected with public transportation is the future of cities,
A perfect mix of the Old and New urban design to accommodate far greater residential and commercial efficiency all the while ensuring the beauty,ease of transportation,health and social health & lifestyle of the city.
Ofcourse roads are still essential within cities for public transportation and goods,but the reliance of the common person on personal vehicles to go anywhere within the city should be reduced.
It's how they should be promoted from now onwards.
@@krapto3467 Indeed, recently a lot of urbanism channels critiquing North America's model have sprung up, like Not Just Bikes, Armchair Urbanist, Oh the Urbanity, Alan Fisher, Eco Gecko, and Adam Something.
Europe and East Asia (Korea, Japan) is what we should seek to emulate instead.
😆
Exactly. Just like in company office campuses. Only public transport buses should be allowed in such areas which will drop passengers to nearby public transport (metros, locals, RRTS) or parking where people who want to visit such areas can park their private cars. Such places with pedestrian friendly roads and shops and workplaces would be an awesome place to live.
I have seen that a lot of Indian cities have wide enough roads but 50% of that is covered with two wheelers , cars and stalls. Parking space is almost non existence
And u forgot about mud and harbage
@@Anmolnegi-yw7hg mud is usually there no bad roads in monsoon but yeah
And the hawkers too
We don't need wide roads fgs. We need public transportation and reduce rldependence on Cars. The more you increase the width of the roads the more Cars you are allowing to flood it - it's never gonna end. We need livable city, with multiple purpose zones and pedestrian friendly roads. We need to make spaces for public activities, for people NOT for Cars. US suburbs are shit. I have live in Australia and US and have been tp Hongkong. The best and most happening places in theae countries are where you can move around cities without Cars and all necessities are accessible within 15 minutes like a hospital, supermarket or a school and parts that are very well connected with efficient public transport.
Each day I learn a new blunder done by Congress government. The amount of things they don't teach is ridiculous 😑
Sector wise planning in Gurugram and Noida seem quite better.
Yes sectors are good, but need correct site allocation, if it gose wrong, it will pathetic like my city
@@vksays4253 gurugram is not planned good
check polymatter
Basically due to socialism and communism ideology after 1947 India's cities planning got destroyed.
This celling factor which implemented In 1976 was a communist ideology.
Communists loves money, but hates earning it.
The Only PlannedCity AndGoodLooking City Is Chandigarh
Planned cities ka halat thik hai but not of international quality
we should take inspiration from Japanese and korean cities. Highly developed nations but with streets like ours.
Problem is that they have the economic resources and actual responsibility, which we lack
@Jango We have a very big economy - we may be poor in average income, but by GDP, we are one of the largest, which can fund our infrastructure with through taxes. If only we lacked corruption and had capitalism...
And how big of a country is Japan and Skorea compared to India
@@jango8442 Bro here is another case, they have a Large Economy, but they havenot have any Complicated Spending.
Meanwhile India is a Very very Big Country which makes Spending very very Complicated.
also India Spends its Huge Chunk to its Military as India have a Hostile Neighbour like Pakistan and China, Meanwhile JAPAN and SOUTH KOREA spends its huge chunk of Money in Planning the Cities, Education, Research and Development etc etc. about Protecting their Sovereignity US Military take care of them.
JAPAN and SOUTH KOREA are not INDEPENDENT Country but a VASSAL COUNTRY of USA.
O please forget Korea
Even indus valley civilisation had a planned city but new india lacks after congress rule.We should revive our indian beauty again.
This was just about Urban Land ceiling act.
Land ceiling act was also applied to agricultural areas. And it not only stopped people from buying big plots of agricultural land, it also redistributed the big plots from landowners to the farmers working on them. This resulted into farms being converted in small patches in the hands of poor farmers who lacked enough capital and land to properly cultivate it. After a generation, even these already small patches would be divided among farmer's children.
This had a big part in creating today's sorry picture of agricultural sector of India that we see today.
So what is wrong in stopping people from buying big plots of agricultural land?
@@yashagrawal88 land ceiling act.
@@ziasmailbox Land ceiling act main phir bhi ceiling is like 50-150 acre per person. Its a lot for anyone. With mordern technique you can produce a lot in 10 acres. Urban Land ceiling main sizes bahut chotte the. Plus farms par agar corporate kabza kar le toh pura desh barbad ho jayega.
@@Richdadful Yes.
Instead of only aiming to make cities look good we should aim to make them efficient, reduce traffic and improve public transit.
Saade 30 hazar log reh rhe h hr meter square me kuch change nhi hoega
Yes congestion tax like tokyo, london will force people to use public transportation. But before that we hve have to drastically improve public transportation
@@JMian yes , public transport needs to be improved very badly. I travel in bus , to go to my college for study. And the bus is so conjusted wuth people , that one can not even breath properly. And bus conductor packs people in bus like cattles , until the bus stops working from the weight of passengers
@@MG2-_- tokyo isse zyada dense hai... Vaha ka infra dekh aur apne major cities ka
Our cities are a lost cause
Great video as always
we need to learn from our ancestors. see how they have planned Indus valley civilization
@@jashpatel161 indus valley civilization existed 3000 years ago its irrelevant today. This person is right, Indian cities are a lost cause... Just look at south America, even tried very hard to reform their countries but nothing has changed in decades. Same will happen with India. Politicians will introduce plans for City planning and eat all the budget
@@MG2-_- then you don't know anything about indus valley civilisation and their proper town building. I suggest that you catch up on some history.
@@MG2-_- bhai tuje kuch pata bhi hai city planning kai baarai mai ??? 3000 ho ya 4000 purani ho city planning city planning hoti hai
Navi Mumbai, Chandigarh and Gandhinagar are the only decent cities we have rn
Really I feel Urban Development is probably the most ignored issue so far in the country . One major advantage of Urban Dev is we can slowdown the brain drain from the country as most ppl leave due to lack of infra & opportunities in cities which can be cured by improving Urban infra as by that more & more it will propel Economic activity
Nehru ka socialism wala Pyaar poore india ko le duba 😶
Jaago Hindu Jaago
Tum khatre main ho jaago 🚩🚩🤡
@@rajvardhankadam4685 😂😂😂tum log hmesha katre me ku hote ho ?? Aree baki log vi ha is desh me muslim sikh Christian Buddhism wo katre me ni ha or tum majority hokar katre me ho tum log shivagi jese kabi ban hi ni paye
@@osowiecwalking9434 😊😊katre me whi ha jinone Shiva g maharana Partap Dr br Ambedkar bhagat singh g ke bare me kabi pda ni agar pda hota to pta chl jata katra kya hota ha
@@kirandeepkaur7858 didi end me clown wala emoji bhi dekhlo pehle 🤡
@@kirandeepkaur7858 he's being sarcastic dear 🤡 dimag ki batti jalao 💡
It's actually true, if you see clips from Mumbai, Kolkata, Delhi from around the time of Independence, you will immediately notice how nice and clean the streets look almost European in that sense, and with streecars/tram lines they even look more modern somehow. Even I was shocked to see this cause I only expected to see chronic poverty. But that was not really the case but then most of these clips I saw were from a youtube channel named British Pathe, so yeah... however it might be that back then only the more privileged came to these cities and the rest of the population resided in the villages.
Just the other day while I was watching a clip of Mumbai (Bombay) in 1964 out of my curiosity for “what the heck happened to the trams of this country?”, I came to the realisation that we had everything to be a first world/developed nation by the end of the 20th century, but sadly, “we f*cked up”, both figuratively and literally.
Bombay was destroyed by the Ghatis , they are incompetent to be in government and have never really contributed to the economy of bombay , their racist approach have destroyed bombay
The British should have stayed. Despite all, they never physically fucked our country up. They cared about maintaining beauty and standards. We ruined our own country
@silentcougarxx6972 agree
Political parties destroyed our country more
If there is big enemy in your own house, then it's better get it owned by less animous outsider
Bhai tab tak plastic itna use me nahi tha sayad.🤡
India mein foreign jaisi strict rule honi chahiye taki indian people stricly rules follow kar sake.
true
Itna information to government ke pass bhi nahi hoga perfect content 👏👏👏
West Bengal is the only Indian state that hasn't repealed the Urban Ceiling Act
I don't expect much from Bengal anymore. Their Socialist and Communist mind cannot be changed.
AAP WAS COMING 👍👍👍
@@143varunsherke2 same with socialist bihar
Indian Air Force Campuses are better then the Planned ciities in India
*Hum democracy mein rehte hain.. hum secular hain.. these things sucks me more than anything else..*
The growth and development of present India.. is way way way less than.. what even china at 3 trillion dollor economy in 2008... Aur uper se congress wapas aa jayegi to jo chal rha hain vo bhi khatam ho jayega..
Democracy Is Right But Secular? Secular Countries Grow Very Well Eg Us,France,China, Japan Etc.Non secular like Pak,Iraq,Afghan Etc Failed
@@devadutts3592 China secular??? How???
can a commi country be secular?
@@Cool_Boygamr Chinese are actually atheist. They don't follow any religion but as per country's preamble they are ought to respect other religions!
@@devadutts3592 Absolutely bro....religion radicalism being done by BJP and the brain washing by media is a serious threat!!
1960s-1990s was the darkest era for india in terms of infrastructural development. Poor governance and unreasonable laws made indian cities and towns so badly planned
Roads laid in cities are also of bad quality. I stay in Hyderabad. In prime areas like Financial District and Hitech city, roads are not of good quality expected in such areas. We can understand the quality of the road just by seeing it. Seriously, the road leading to my grandma's village is of better quality. And, roads are laid layer upon layer every 5 years that the road level keeps rising and rising. They should dig some depth atleast in such prime economic centers before laying new layer of road! If roads get destroyed before their expected lifetime- the contractors who built it should be named and shamed openly. And, speed brakes after speed breakers after speed breakers....🤦
Hyderabad roads r much better than Banglore, Mumbai, Pune, recently GHMC has Smoothened roads in the city what r u on about, even lane markings have been drawn, once travel on the Outer Ring Road you will understand what world class roads mean...
@@Checkitytu I know that and Just wish Their children perish lol
For 3 Reason
1 the contractors did this for Money lol to keep Their family
c'mon
2 Their parents will probably teach them that india is like that and take Advantage of this and that
3 Welp you have to pay for the sin of your family , isn't that like that?
Seriously only way they deserve to get better life if these children just Shame their parents
realise whats wrong and improve the next generation
:c
Basically due to socialism and communism ideology after 1947 India's cities planning got destroyed.
This celling factor which implemented In 1976 was a communist ideology.
Communists loves money, but hates earning it.
@@umbrellacorporation5723 I see your choice for the name is Despicable :)
Speed breaker for Safety
car system was popularised by america, which takes a lot of space
and only fits americas large roads
we must start using public transport, cycles and electric tricycles, skateboards etc instead of roaming in a huge metal box
I'd prefer car all the time. it's much more convenient, safer, comfortable, than other modes of transportation.
@@abirnigam8816 you have the american instinct of preferring cars
yes, cars should only be meant for long distances, not inside city...European cities do the same, they too don't have this level of car culture...but here too everyone wants to do showoff
Exactly. New cities and newer parts of cities should be build by this concept. Enough cycle lanes, better public transport, less parking space for car. Encourage more green transport options
@@bobbytrap283 believe me, when given choice 90% of Indians will choice car.
Plus instead of labeling me stuff, try to beat the argument. Tell me any other mode of transportation more comfortable, convenient, ready on the hand, safer, comfortable, weather proof (scorching heat and sun of India, heavy monsoons and freezing cold)
Electric cars are making it even better.
And also if you think car is and America way, 80% of Europen individuals own car besides having one of the best public transportation systems in the world.
ASEAN countries have 15% of CAGR of car ownership. Majority of them are first time buyers from 2 wheelers, which mean people of ASEAN nation like me also have American instinct of preferring cars.
India's car market is fastest growing in the world.
Main Cities Skylines game khelta hoon, uske kai content creators hain TH-cam mein, mainly European based, aur Japanese bhi hain kuch, kya gazab ka cities banate hain game mein. Unki videos dekhkar pata lagta hai ki kitna meticulously unke country ke cities ko design kiya gaya hai. Kahan landscaping karna, kaha zoning karna, kaha par road intersection mark karna, etc. Hum Indians jo cities mein rehte hain, usme sab haphazardly design kiya gaya hai isliye zoning, intersection marking samajh mein nahi Ata kyunki yeh sab cheez se hum familiar nahi hain. Main filhal Mumbai aur Sikkim based map mein unko Cities Skylines mein recreate karne ka koshish Kar raha hoon, dekhte hain kaise jata hai. Cities Skylines ka Indian community pretty much non-existent hain, bahut Kam hi Indian asset creators aur modders mile Steam Workshop par 😟
India me bhi re plan karke japan jesi cities banana asan hai, magr jo paisa lagega woh worth it nhi hoga. abhi hume cities kei beech ki connectivity ko better karna hai, industries Lani hai taki village se log sheher shift ho, fir banane hai
Bruhh mujhe bhi city planning games pasand h, but i only can play simcity mobile because i dont have any high-end pc to play cities skyline or pese bhi nhi h legally kharidne ke game ko but haan mujhe city planning games psnd h
Same bro mera favourite game hai
@@kantasingh7160 Main cracked wala hi khelta hoon, aur Steam wale mods use karne ka ek trick bhi hai cracked wale games mein use karne ke liye. Mera bhi specs utna accha nahi, Core i5, 8 GB RAM, aur Intel HD Graphics 520 😂 Lag to Hota Hai zyada mods use karne par, phir bhi usme chala leta hoon. Bina mods ka aaram se game chalega accha performance ke saath.
@@ArghyadeepPal epic games mai free ane wala hai cities skyline claim kar lena
Your videos are exceptionally well researched and structured. Lots of success would be coming your way ahead!
I don't usually come out political on platforms like these, but I must say our communist approaches like these have made the country pay a hard toll.
It's not communist approach it's democracy-dictatorship approach
India was more socialist than communist. Communist countries actually planned cities well for their purpose
Blame liberal democracy not communism
@@vipanrana2919 exactly
@@vipanrana2919lol even indian communists are inferior, Russian and Chinese communists are miles ahead
Pune has already adopted one way system and really it is a good option for ctities in India. So you can have larger footpaths,tress planted and still ample of space for vehiches to travel. Also we have an odd even parking system so on even days like 2,4,6,8 you will park on left side of roads and on odd days like 1,3,5,7,9 you will park on right side. This has made Pune city look more beautiful as well as even traffice problem is reduced.
Having horrible streets has broken self respect of Indians. Our cities looks worse than those in Afghanistan or Poor African regions.
That's what congress has achieved.
Japan is the perfect example of how fine streets can be planned, They have small streets yet clean and well planned that too on hilly planes. If we indians keep our ego aside, We can learn a lot of things from japan and japanese culture
Indian Air Force Campuses are better then the Planned ciities in India
@@JokerJoker-xc7xb though everyone pays the taxes, only govt owned society, airforce bases, military, politician areas are green and clean with europe style roads
@@rklokesh1 bro dont you think its Sounds like a Neo Colonialism???
First White Skin Colonisers and Now these Bastards Brown Skin Coloniser.
😢😢😢😢😢 Hey Bhagwan when will India will again restore its Past Indic Civilisational Glory
@@JokerJoker-xc7xb India is a very emotional country, people are emotional, and that's why corruption, and electing wrong people in power makes india poor and behind UK and other 1st world country, If you notice 1st world country are not emotional, they think practically.
@@rklokesh1 Ahh Bro so here is the fact.
Today whatever the Whole Western Country is, its is on the Expense of the Stolen Wealth from AFRICA, INDIA and CHINA.
meanwhile the Starting of India was very very Struggling and Poor.
Means India was Poorest of Poor Country in this Planet (All thanks to Britishers).
and Everything India have to Rebuild its Civilisation from the Scratch which was Difficult Equivalent to Impossible.
Because Despite the Development, Advance Technology and Science, Government Must also had to cater the Welfare and Addressing the Poor and Oppressed People with taking Corruption in their Mind.
also despite being Poorest of Poor after Britishers Left, India was at War Zone for Last 50 Years...
Despite Struggling from this Shit and Mess and Being a War Torn Country Created by Britishers, India today have 3 Trillion Dollar of Economy, with Economic Growth of 10 percent which is no 1 in this Planet.
also India is a Sovering Country, Means India is Resolving its own Security Issue without the Help of USA and Other Western Countries and Now Investing in Research and Development and other Indegenously made Technologies and also the 4th Powerful Country in this World.
Which is just just just a Phenomenal Work by India
Exactly. Just like in company office campuses. Only public transport buses should be allowed in such areas which will drop passengers to nearby public transport (metros, locals, RRTS) or parking where people who want to visit such areas can park their private cars. Such places with pedestrian friendly roads and shops and workplaces would be an awesome place to live.
Many expanding areas of Pune city are now built with good city planning only the city centre/old city now have road congestion. Atleast local administration here has rectified the issue and are making sustainable changes for growth and efficiency.
Most of the American cities are bad in public infrastructure, they are not that good in city planning as compare to Tokyo, Soul, Singapore, Taipei and Hongkong.
Traffic is a very huge issue in American cities. The major flaw in American cities is interstate expressway and highways pass through cities instead of alternate Ring Road system. This makes traffic congestion extremely bad. Same problem is present in many Indian cities.
@@ArghyadeepPal Not just highways, their main problem is car/truck centric transportation less use of public vehicles.
@@ArghyadeepPal hamare yaha public transportation ban raha hai jaha usa me nahi
Hats off to you man..... How u do this.... U have such a diverse knowledge.... Just amazing
Your videos are superb bro 💯❤️
thanks
Rural development is also important. Many parts of india have little opportunities. This resulted into mass migration into cities and cities are overwhelmed.
We have disgusting architecture too ,it looks ugh 🤮🤢 and current central government is not even thinking about to solve this issue nor they will take any good decision to build good infrastructure even upcoming new smart cities materials are also poor quality, you can check them after one rainy season and affording is not a problem bcz we can go for eco friendly houses with beautiful architecture like Britain does
What architecture do we truly have though? Most people live in those boring shitboxes in cities which are so plain and boring that it's an insult to architecture.
@@jango8442 mostly government people take excuses that they build poor and low qualities cities becoz public can't afford those expensive infrastructure but let me tell you search eco friendly houses in youtube , you will get so many beautiful affordable houses (water proof + those houses automatically maintain temperature in hot climate) even with 4 bed rooms houses up to 15 lakh to 25 lakh, but those residential buildings or houses which are recently created by modi government in smart cities are ugh , poor quality plus expensive up to 35 lakh to 70 lakhs .
Asia's largest slum area Dharavi in Mumbai. Replan hona chahiye
hmm..MMRDA karti hi kya hai, pata nhi
That's why dholera & gift city like city needed and that should be develop successfully. And till now Small town or city are not planned and after 30 year it will be worst and politician and common citizen are also not aware of this. can we expect that we will make our country good as Europe practically in future????? We not china but we can spread awareness among people from now so that we can see result
We have rebuild a lot of things,
Agar Mai municipality ki hi baat karu to mujhe to aaj tak samjh nahi aya unlog karte kya hai... Kuch saal pehle iron ke kachre ke dabbe aaye the pure town mai rakhne ke liye... Humlog usko ground mai pade rehta dekhte rahe or wo jang pakad ke khatam.... Har 5 saal mai road banti hi banti hai mai 22 saal ka hu or 3 baar ka Road banna to mere ko yaad hai...
Or pehle road banti hai Phir uspe gaddha khoad ke baaki kaam hote hai... Or gaddha khodne ke baad Matti bhi wahi chor dete hai Phir wo dust ban ke udte rehte hai.... Illegal encroachment hai humare Town ke entry pe hi but kisi ko kuch nahi pada... Ulta jitne bhi parshad or maha sacheev aare hai wo ye bolte hai ki Hume vote do hum tumhe yaaha se nahi hatayenge... Koi bhi ho bjp ya congress.
This is what happens when you start as a socialist country and then try to become a capitalist one.
Unplanned development and allowing people to encroach land is a big hindrance... even us individuals also do this when we increase the balcony or veranda of our houses by protruding out...illegally. and admin should take strict prompt action so that others are not encouraged to do the same as then it becomes an entire extended illegal construction which cant be demolished in human rights or gareeb aadmi ka ghar name...
Democracy is the biggest Hurdle we have.
For this, some such inhabited cities in the country can be redeveloped again, which can become a role model for the rest of the existing cities in the country. Like Indore city is known for its cleanliness, which has inspired many cities of the country to keep themselves clean.
Repeal of Urban Land Ceiling Act has been advised to govt from many decades but govt has been reluctant tp give up control.
The land cost and cost of housing has been sky rocketed in India due to Urban Land Ceiling Act, FSI rules and development charges by govt.
this channel is really underrated.. i love your videos bro keep it up❤️🔥..
Hats off to your hardwork in research in such topics.
More power to you and people like you, individual and independent creators 👍🏻👍🏻
It's all about education
Kisi bhi country ka education system hi usski roots hoti hai
And rhi baat infrastructure ki to
Uska fully improve hona impossible hai
@meghanath japan and Germany jesi countries bhi exist keti hai un se inspire hona zaroori hai
7:03 as an urban planner, we already have 100+ of planners passing out every year from IIT itself. But for Planning we have colleges called "School of Planning and Architecture" which are much better than IITs for urban planning. 30+ colleges teach planning all over India and it's a growing field.
The problem is, companies hire civil engineers and architects to plan our cities - something they're both clueless about.
lol, believe me they don't even hire architects.
May be Central Government should bring a constitutional amendment where urban planning can be brought to the control of a central government agency instead of giving that to state governments. City and town planning is an urgent priority for nation building and it cannot be left in the fate of incompetent state governments. It needs dedicated experts who are interested in nation building
India must be colonized by the Chinese or Americans for rapid development
For future projects...
Must include parking area and facilities (washrooms).
Homes needs parking, commercial area needs way for big and long vehicles, parking and washrooms for both owner and customer.....
Indian Air Force Campuses are better then the Planned ciities in India
I dont think anyone can replan Mumbai. Its the most unplanned city. Like so bad! Thry see an empty piece of land they start constructing a building there. It looks so bad and congested. I have been to NYC and there they have lot of buildings too but it looks so well planned and dosent look congested at all. I know Mumbais population is way more than of NYC but still it looks like no efforts are made to plan construction in Mumbai. Even the bmc buildings they are building for the people of slum. OMG! they look so bad! and also what is up with people drying clothes on the window! why arent ruled made for that, it looks so bad!
Sometimes I see underwears hanging on the window kept for drying 💀
@@Criselle307 😭
There are new bridges being built in and around Ahmedabad speeding vehicles out side and highways but the internal roads are narrower and brts takes a lot of resource which is not available for other vehicles .. many places,
Very Detailed Analysis👌
Thx to indian congress for loss
#askpt brother you should start city planning game on your channel. Please play 'cities skyline' game. And make cities from your POV and explain it to us..
In india no one youtuber playing this game.. Aur jo youtuber khelte bhi hai unko kuchh bhi samaj nahi hai City planning ki aur utna interest bhi nhi hai jitna aapko hai aur aapke viewers ko hai..
And I assume ki meri tarah aapke Baaki viewers ko bhi iss game me interest hoga ya phir interest aa jayega..
Watch 'biffa playing indie game' channel..
Wahi main bhi soch raha tha.
Ukraine ka GDP per capita hamare GDP per capita ke aas paas hi hai fir bhi unke sheher dekho aur hamare dekho.
Zameen asmaan ka fark hai.
Paisa he sab kuch nahi hota 😬
@@Lemonn1016 Wahi to.
Paisa hi sab kuch nahi hota.
Agar hamari government aur hamare log chahe to waise sheher bana sakte hai par Socialism ki wajah se sabko sirf baith ke khaane ki aadat lag gayi hai.
Overplanning and over-zoning is also a problem. Most US towns are over zoned and one cannot find a corner store for MILES. But, yes, we need to really buck up.
The video I was expecting alot for a really long time in India TH-cam space - Replanning Indian cities, thanks for the video. ❤️
But could've have been in English or atleast comes with subtitles.
the neighbouring house in my colony has constructed their gate at least 3 metres ahead of their land and because of them the road has become conjusted it was much wider before
Good topic
If news channels would have Focused on this we could have developed ourselves
I think Indian City ko vaapas Redeveloped krna chahiye 🇮🇳
We should plan like Europe not America. America has a declining infrastructure with a car dependent system. In a country with a population like India, car dependence is simply unsustainable, we should strive for better public transport
Good video 👍. Keep it up!!! 👏🏻
राजनीती ऐसी चीज़ों को कभी होने ही नही देगी।
I can connect to this man verry well because I also want that India should look verry well like dubai🔥
Change is the only constant and together we can make our cities lot better and enriching with conscious design interventions. Challenges will always be there and that can only turn in to motivation drivers for desirable and enviromental compliant implements.
In my city people dont have a common parking space so everyone parks their car/bikes on foot path and then ppl walk on roads due to which traffic increses.
A major intrinsic argument in this video is that the poor planning of Indians is because of the "Urban land ceiling act" because that did not allow the private players to develop "Planned" infra. That may be a biased view. Take Gurugram for example. Arguable a very developed city where the Urban Land ceiling act was not a problem, but still that city is infested with a lot of planning challenges. Within the builder-developed land pieces, the planning is phenomenal but the city infra right outside that township is still very poor. While reasons for that may be many, it is sure not the Land ceiling act. The same is the case with Bangalore. To date, the planning there is in a pathetic state. And I am not talking about the old city area. The newer areas being planned in the outer regions still face the same issues.
Nice informative video for me as a aspirants of town planner 👍.
Bhai can u make a video on what r the compliance we have to follow for builder to make a building in Mumbai & why it takes so much time to make a development
Could you please make a video on cluster redevelopment policy of Maharashtra and is it possible to transform our cities?
Yes soon Thane cluster work is going to start let's hope for best
Also cantonment has a lot of unused lands under it which can be used for other projects
But remain dormant
Converting all major cities is not possible because of over population and living standards (rich &medium,poor)are not same so it's seems impossible but it's possible in separate areas
If its a chanel about city planning, I just wanna say - Im from close to India and would like to understand these discussions. If there was English subtitles, id understand.
While what you said is 100% correct but i also understand the reasoning behind the law. If rich builders brought up all the land, established their buildings and huge projects, most poor and middle class people wouldn't be able to afford them. Instead we got smaller buildings and apartments, which most people can afford.
In my 11th class I wanted to pursue Bachelor of planning so that I can somehow contribute a little to make our cities and town beautiful
Ab CAT ke preparation kar raha hu bhai log job nahi hai is field me india me
I Was Waiting For This Type Of Vedio From Long Time.
Thanks 🙏👍
India isn't the only democracy in the world. Duniya ke bahut saare democratic countries ne apne cities mein drastic transformations kar ke dikhaya hai, that's why they are ahead. Humare desh mein problem ye hai ki hum ANARCHY ko bhi democracy samjhte hain! One of the latest victims of it is Line 3 of Mumbai Metro!
Mumbai Metro itself is causing huge problems to people and environment.
Roads in villages at M.P are way much better than the roads even in city areas of Pune (where i am currently living ) .
Systematic Planning, Good infrastructure and basic amenities is not the core issue. Most important issue is population per square kilometers. IF today India population is about 40 to 50 core,then imagine how much prosperous and rich each citizen would be.
Please put English captions, the entire India needs to see this
In old cities, replanning and reorganization is very difficult, time consuming and costly.
It's better to construct new planned cities nearby old cities to shift the population and activity ( business / services etc ) load.
Automatically population of old cities will reduce and then reorganization of those old cities will be easier and cheaper.
BEST VIDEO :) I always searched for this topic and now it's available
We also need to have better building codes.
Bro.You always made amazing video for us. 💖💖👍
As Indian Citizens, we should focus on increasing the Human Development Index. Urbanization is easy when the quality of the population improves. India is still suffering from public littering. However, many urban areas are as clean as those in the first world countries. Education Sector of our country needs investment and talented human resource.
Further, each system is unique , we should never compare with the countries where population, culture and poverty levels differ. What can be done is that further encroachment can be curbed, the already existing pattern can be bettered by creating more sewage network, water connectivity and transitional camps for the moving population such as labourers.
Make ❤️ INDIA ❤️ Great again as earlier days ( Time )
Sir planning ho raha hai . Aap gujarat k Ahmedabad me ho rahi tp scheme k bare me search kijie. 20 se jyada town planning scheme chal rahi hai or Rajkot me bhi tp scheme chal rahi hai
Very needed. Need underground transport systems for war times. In case...
Aurr banao socialist policies. Socialist policies sunne me boht achhi lagti hai ki government sabko protect karegi but kabhi result achha nahi hota
The problem with local government
আমি আপনার চ্যানেলের অনেক পুরনো সাবস্ক্রাইবার 👀❤️
( I'm very old subscriber of your channel)
Next, we do not want wide roads which increases private vehicles .. whereas we only want better connectivity with medium sized roads. This can be done by increasing public transport not only bus metro but also govt taxis and govt autos at ceiling rates.
The city planning should not be car oriented but pedestrians.
Indian cities can be replanned in a way that a new neighborhood should be planned and developed than people from old neighborhood should be moved that newly built neighborhood and the old vacated neighborhood should be demolished and rebuilt and so on. Heritage sites and Historic landmarks should be preserved.
But still newly developed area in cities are still not planned. for e.g. many cities which are expanding are still not planned.