She sure knows about all the bad news out there. But when she is so happy with a good health i believe it is insulting the public not even show up and say something.
Guy who filmed them has come forward and stated it is Catherine and William. Also Rose Hanbury has retained lawyer to put a stop to the rumors about her and William. Just on nightly news. So now eat your own words trolls.
People are truly unwell, they love the excitement and mystery of a conspiracy.. She lost a lot of weight, that’s why she looks different! She is beautiful and elegant and people are freaking out that she looks relaxed.. “why is she not back at work if she is well,” they ask.. because you can look normal and still need healing!
@@lr2ldn And how many photoshopped pictures have M&H published? Dozens -Meghan with no freckles or wrinkles, Harry with a full head of hair, children with distorted limbs and ever changing hair colour, Christmas pic on kill notice. Hypocrite.
He made a nice chunk of change from the Palace PR team. lol Why no other shots of them, looked busy at the market... would have been the photo of the year. You couldn't miss them, she was almost skipping, whilst swinging her bag. The Palace lied, got busted and now make the public feel guilty. Now watch your free speech fade away more, as they go after social media. You are being gaslit !! Geez
You are a good man. Princess Catherine deserves all the respect in the world. She's done nothing wrong but try to come back from a health crisis, and the media and the haters have treated her horrendous.
You must know a lot of bad men if you class this one as good. Not only is he not truthful (3 conflicting versions of his story) but he claims he respects privacy and then proceeds to sectretly film and sell the footage so it can be shown all around the world.
I stand with POW too - let’s leave the sugary trolls to their delusions and leave them to bask in the absolute glory of their magnificent, sincere,authentic Kween - they deserve each other !!
@@elsands9774wouldn’t you? People in glass cages etc. At least he has told the truth & seems a nice man. Who just happened to be in the one place to take that video ,very jealous media & paparazzi will attempt to undermine this guy.
@@richardwait1206How do you know he's telling the truth?, he's just some random bloke who thinks he saw two people in a shop lmao. I'm sure the guy that filmed the footage of bigfoot was sure it was him too As for "people in glass cages" yeah, someone filming a couple without their consent and selling it off to the media lecturing everyone else about backing off and leaving them alone certainly lives in a giant glass cage This whole stupid thing wouldn't have blown up if he didn't do that, eh?
Probably more likely speaking because he has been paid handsomely to do so. No better than the gutter press - except they would be penalised for publishing what this man has.
It's a pity he has trouble telling the truth. It's also alarming that he claims he respects other people's privacy but he then secretly films then and sells his footage so it can be shown around the world.
The trolls saying it’s not her? Seriously? And now the hospital staff has accessed her medical records. Wonder how much they were paid ? Media goons will do anything to get what they want. They’re pathetic. If they print or release them I hope they are sued, arrested for obtaining records illegally
I agree, there are a lot of pathetic people amongst us. Regarding the subject of medical records potentially being compromised to people simply disrespecting Princess Catherine's privacy from the moment she was hospitalized....it's all shameful. I'm a former medical professional who took my oath seriously....and I'm now a patient who is permanently disabled. I just shake my head if someone did breach confidentiality in regard to the Princess's records. I am not however a 'troll' - despite you thinking so. I don't know if the video reflects Catherine or not; however, from moment one I have stated I don't think it is her. Do I KNOW that?! Of course not. No-one knows one way or the other.
@@og87 they said she was undergoing abdominal surgery and wouldn't be carrying out public duties until after Easter, I call that honest. Do you advertise your medical status to the world and his wife, because I know I certainly don't, it's my private business and none of theirs.
@janrogers8352 I totally agree with you. The press need to leave them alone & stop the bullying. We the public maybe pay their wages (£1.50 or something each) but we don't own them. Catherine's medical records are her business nothing to do with anyone else. As for the photo it was imo just a family snap on her social media for mother's day I don't give a dam if it had some photo shopping done to it. Most photographers do that to their photos.
7 หลายเดือนก่อน
Nope, they are not required to give out private information, who do you think you are?? How about H&M product their invisible children and proof of DNA - no valid sightings for 2 years, no official photos, no kids. @@og87
It's got nothing to do with whether you like him or not, what's important is if he's actually telling the truth. The first thing I'd like to kniw is if he's been paid anything in relation to the video footage or him giving the "interview".
Can you please explain the reason why you like this guy? The media are not allowed to willy nilly film the royal family and publish footage. Yet this guy secretly films the royals when he says himself that he thought they wanted privacy. Not only that he then he decides to "share" (sell?) his secretly filmed footage so it can be publicly shown by The Sun. I'm struggling to find anything in these actions that makes him likeable. If anything, it would be the opposite.
@@Michelle-xm6no What are you taking about? I was referring to the truth and there is hardly anyone I know that does not consider the truth to be important. Maybe you're not like the vast majority of people I know and the truth is not important to you.
@@Michelle-xm6no Also I don't live in a conspiracy world. When determining the credibility & reliability of a statement, an important consideration is whether there is any conflict of interest. These are absolute fundamentals in many walks of life, e.g. Justice/ courts, scientific papers, exker witnesses, salesman, etc. Etc.
Yes and also tell 3 different versions of his story. The one in this video, the different one the Sun newspapers quotes him telling and an even different one that TMZ quotes him telling!! Add into the mix that he's 40 and he describes 2 people older than him as a "young couple". Perhaps he has a script writer that is quite old?
People should take lessons from this gentleman. He respected the Prince and Princess of Wales by giving them their space and not confronting them. Yes he took a video to show to his family. Only after speaking to others and reading about the negativity did he decide to share the video with the public. He had only kind words to say about Catherine and William. For and those who continue to bully and make false claims, like this gentleman said get a hobby.
It is this "gentleman" that seems to be making false claims. What he says in this video is different to what he is quoted as saying the Sun article, which is also a different version to what TMZ quote him as saying. I suggest that what he says is taken with a gigantic mountain of salt, particularly if the claim that he was paid a substantial sum are true.
Yeah, when i want to bang on about respecting peoples privacy i like to whip out my old 2010 iphone and make terrible quality videos of people in private and then sell it off to the media who then splashes it on every front page in the country Because you should totally respect privacy, guys
Sorry, but he doesn't seem to credible, 'want to give them privacy' but starts filming them ,he also insults people that are speculating ,human curiosity, yet intrudes on the couple ,without permission and how did Tmz obtain this footage, did Mr judge here, sell it to the media and wouldn't that be hypocritical ?
Thanks to this gentleman for speaking up. He is the only person that makes any sense amongst all the BS thats our there. Leave Princes Catherine alone and respect their privacy😊
@TheSun you need to listen to shopper in your video and do some investigative journalism and try to track down the source of the bot/trolls. Last year here in the US, there was a situation in which someone used bots to verbally attack one of the cast member's child on a reality show (Real Housewives of Beverly Hills) via this route. It is my understand that they were able to identify the source of the attacks. someone might want to do the same for the bot attack on Catherine. It would be interesting to see where the funding for this originated.
Very well said, Mr. Silva👍. People should stop being busybodies and just let Prince William and Princess Kate breathe and give them som space. After you have had surgery, you just want to relax and decompress and not be stressed. Probably she wants to do a social detox even for few months and lead a normal life for once, with her family.
I believe the British media have an agreement not to invade their privacy by photographing them when they are engaged in private activities - since Princess Dianna the media guidelines (re photographs at least) have changed. That’s why the UK media did not publish the pap shot of POW and her mother in the car whereas US media did, and why UK media do not photograph them at school drop off etc. Which illustrates the absurdity and deceit of Meghan Markle’s assertion that if she had stayed in the UK there would have been hoardes of photographers taking photos when Archie was taken to school (she wishes!)
So, the rest of us should mind our own business and "get a life." Yet this guy's the one who followed them and clandestinely shot a VIDEO from his CAR and ultimately published it for world viewing. OKAY. 👀
Love The Sun for this interview!! Not only releasing the video but also interviewing the man who witnessed their outing . It's a very nice interview and a very nice young man.
@@cillamurfin258When said human records people in private, sells it off to the media for a quick buck (£200-£300K, not too bad is it) who then splashes it on every front page in the country WHILST telling us he respects their "privacy"? C'mon, pull the other one lmao
Not saying it wasn't her,just weird that such a popular figure would be recognized by one shopper in the market, the people that were sitting there did not even glance at them
Hi, Neil! 👋 The man who took the video of Catherine at the Farm Shop is Nelson Silva. The Sun has an 8 minute TH-cam video interviewing him. He is very credible. Catherine was extremely slender to begin with, and probably hasn't had solid food for 2 months. It totally looks like her to me, exactly the way I would expect her to look. I love you, Neil, but you're wrong on this issue. ❤️🌹🥰🇺🇸
Did this guy ask them if they minded being filmed. Did he get money for this? He said he realised they wanted their privacy, then gave the video to the SUN! It's intrusive.
He likely got paid a fortune. Dodi and Diana photos on yacht sold for $6,000,000. This is a bigger story. Ethics and values can be dimmed when that much $ is involved.
$. Big $. The guy who photographed Diana and Dodi on a yacht was paid $6,000,000 for photos. And this is a much bigger story. This guy is probably set for life.
for the same reason that he made the video, in the first place. He wanted the big pile of money which he already knew TMZ would pay. And here he is in an interview, collecting more money, for telling other people to be more respectful.
Then he shouldn't preach about people not being "good" by questioning his video... because they "can" and it's not "good" to video a person without their knowledge.
Why is everyone so shocked that catherine is up and about? Shes not bedridden just because of getting chemo ? SHES NOT AN INVALID !!ITS GOOD FOR HER TO BE UP DOING THINGS SHES ABLE TO DO.GET A GRIP !!!
Not bad for someone who knew nothing about them, to recording them, to selling it to the Sun, to telling everyone they should believe it was Kate. Getting all the background from his family? Yeah right! A simple hello to them at the meat counter would have been more appropriate.
That video is likely worth millions. The grainy stills of Dodi and Diana on a yacht netted $6,000,000 for the photog. Values and decency have a tendency to take a back seat to the opportunity to rake in millions in a day.
Well this is the difference between H&M and the Prince and Princess of Wales. They both get scrutinised, but H&M whinge about it and the W&K keep stoic👏🏻
Because Catherine is not a wannabe starlet. She's the future Queen of England and always dignified, she will thank everybody in her own time. Something you should learn about.
I suspect Nelson Silva is Portuguese, and as a fellow Portuguese, I guarantee we don't suffer fools gladly, we are not starstruck, and we don't have aggressive paparazzi. This is the reason why so many VERY famous people come to live here and are left in peace. This young man is the perfect example of wanting to give them space and being respectful. Thank you, Nelson!
You say he's the "perfect example" of having respect. Yet he secretly films a couple (that he merely thinks but does not verifu if they actually are Kate & "William) then he he sells the footage to media outlets that he knows will publicise it to everyone around the world, which will be the cause of gossip and opinion. I suggest that your perception of having respect is different to that of most decent people.
@@robbomax1143 How do you know he didn't get permission to sell it? Do you think he would risk having the Royal legal team on his back? He's trying to put an end to the drama. I thank him.
@@cilajoao1 You have ignored the point I was making which was that what you consider as having respect is not aligned with what most decent people consider it to be. I never mentioned anything about permissions for him to sell his footage. He does not need any permission from anyone to sell his video footage to media outlets. If (and it's a big if) the "royal legal team" are going to be the back of anyone it *would not be Nelson.* It would be the Sun & TMZ (and other media outlets) for publishing the imagery. But that would only potentially be the case if the people filmed are actually William & Kate. You say he's trying to bring a end to the drama. Do you think the publishing of this video brought the drama to an end or created more drama & speculation? If you are uncertain which then I suggest you read the rest of the comments on this video. Since Nelson admits himself that he does not take any interest in the royal family then it is extremely peculiar that he suddenly gets involved in something he has no care for and he thinks it is his responsibility to "end the drama".
They told the truth but people didn't want to believe it, deciding to speculate and come up with ludicrous theories. Maybe next time they shouldn't say anything at all.
@@janrogers8352 And that’s why the truth must be known. It’s Not fair to leave people in the dark about someone who is recognized as a leader or a special value to society. Kate IS valued by society! She’s greatly loved and respected! Those who hide her truth are dogs!
I am so happy that Princess Catherine is well and happy After her surgery. A great Thank you to this Man For taking this video to show us. May God bless you with health and happiness. I am for team "Wales" . 😊❤
Something is odd about the video. He just happens to return to the car and have the perfect angle to record them at the exact right time? Not a single picture was taken? No one else even noticed them? No, I don’t buy it. This is not believable.
I am not surprised. Harvey the head of TMZ has been praising Meghan and Markle and has a hatered for William because he asked for a seize fire in Gaza. He has nothing good to say about the Royal family because of it and is singing Meghan praise on Piers Morgan show and talking lies how America has now embraced Megan.
It doesn’t look like her and definitely not the same unwell Kate we saw in her recent video. She looks younger and in perfect health here which is unfortunately not the case…
This man is so lovely! Thank you for being a decent human being. Thanks for your honest interview and for calling out the trolls ( I include the horrible British and American media ) involved in the bullying of Catherine, Princess of Wales. I also call out the American celebrities who have gone after Catherine: Steven Colbert, Kim Kardashian and Blake Lively, you are part of the bullying.
Man records couple without their consent or knowledge then sells it off to the papers for a quick buck, whilst tellling everyone he respects their privacy LMAO, where you dropped on your head as a child?
Good for both of them🙏❤️😇. It’s really nice to see 🤩💐.? From here in America, keep up the good job Prince of Wales to take good care your Princess of Wales . More power to the both of you 🙏❤️😇🥰
I agree with him. Those trolls including Tiktok influences, celebrities and news outlet who spread false rumours should back off and feel responsible for the damage they are causing in people's lives.
It's odd that you agree with somebody that's not truthful and who claims he respects the couples privacy yet he sectretly films them then sells the footage so it can be shown around the world.
@@dianax266I mean, that's the bigger picture here If he wanted to respect their privacy then i think selling the footage to the effing SUN (one of, if not the worst papers in the uk) is kind of the wrong way to go about it
The shopper who took the video seems like a nice guy. In a way it’s good he took the video as it helps put an end to the frenzy and all the rumors. And he seems truthful and it wasn’t a pap set up like the other one across the pond routinely seems to do.
If it was me, I wouldnt film them. I would give them the RESPECT AND PRIVACY. Filming them is the opposite of it. People should learn to admire from a far and keep your videos to yourself. Stop monetizing them at their expense. You did this with Princess Diana, now you’re doing it to our Prince and Princess of Wales. Just back off and it’s no one’s business! People should stop being so nosy!
This guy seems very rational down to earth and normal. Doesn’t come across as a sensationalist, but wants to allay all the misinformation rumored. Thanks you Mr Silva.
So he doesn’t know for sure who she is, but then go ahead and recorded her and company while sitting on his car…hmm that’s a little problematic recording people you don’t really know who they are.
he's fibbing...he knew very well who it was and he knew he could make a lot of money...it's been all over the news non stop for a few months and he didn't know who they were?????????????????
I wanted to give them their privacy so I filmed them. Maybe next time you go shopping some people will start to film you out of respect for your privacy.
I am confused, the UK press don't publish a photo taken by the paparazzi but they do publish this clip from a tourist. How are these 2 photos different, neither were approved both were an invasion of privacy.
I wish this video had never been taken. He was paid a lot for it by the Sun and sadly it is going to encourage others to try to get more footage to sell to the highest bidder.
The man who took the video and said what he said on here has made more sense than anything I’ve heard about this situation from anyone !!! 👏👏
TMZ retracted the video on Fox 5
@janwhite6038 Who cares what Fox 5 does.
He shouldn't have filmed them. He obviously sold the video so he profited from this breach of their privacy. Not impressed.
Probably did it for WME...
Yes! You nailed this situation in 26 words! 👏 bravo!
Princess Catherine is a public figure not public property she deserves her privacy
Perfectly put!
She sure knows about all the bad news out there. But when she is so happy with a good health i believe it is insulting the public not even show up and say something.
It’s the simplest answer that doesn’t need explaining !
Guy who filmed them has come forward and stated it is Catherine and William. Also Rose Hanbury has retained lawyer to put a stop to the rumors about her and William. Just on nightly news. So now eat your own words trolls.
Regardless it's not Kate, so whatever. It's very sick what they're doing. Someone should be worried about the lady.
People are truly unwell, they love the excitement and mystery of a conspiracy.. She lost a lot of weight, that’s why she looks different! She is beautiful and elegant and people are freaking out that she looks relaxed.. “why is she not back at work if she is well,” they ask.. because you can look normal and still need healing!
Grrrrrr
Of course you look better when you've healing but you are still bound by Dr's orders to ensure total healing.
@@MissusChanandlerBongshe looks like she has the same face. You need a brain operation to restore the brain cells you must be loosing...
Oh dear please wake up!
Because you need to get your health back, after a major operation, you can't go back to work straight away. People need to get real.
Thank you. How cool for you. Thanks for sharing with us.
The media needs to apologize to William and Catherine in my opinion the bullying is despicable
Most of all lunatics on social media and especially americans
No they don't. Her photoshop photo was on a KILL NOTICE by HIGH PROFILE news agencies. They are a laughing stock.
@@lr2ldn And how many photoshopped pictures have M&H published? Dozens -Meghan with no freckles or wrinkles, Harry with a full head of hair, children with distorted limbs and ever changing hair colour, Christmas pic on kill notice. Hypocrite.
They need to start with Harry & Meghan first. You really have the nerve!
@@THECROWNROYALSHollywoodFashion🙄🙄
A no nonsense humble Portuguese guy who is more interested in soccer then royalty
Now a bit richer than he was a few days ago
Uh huh
He was paid £200,000 for his little video.
Gosh, the “jealousy bug” has really bitten so many of those viewing Princess Catherine videos again. Worse than COVID!!!!
@@CaliWeHowow so much 🤑🤑
Great to see this! Good for this man talking, hope this will close -down all those stupid, rediculous theories. Go Catherine! ❤
Well done that young man, thank you.
I don't think so. The SUGARS n closet Megan's reporters/"journalist" will still say NOT! Or else no....
Thank you for passing on the photo.
You're so naïve
He made a nice chunk of change from the Palace PR team. lol Why no other shots of them, looked busy at the market... would have been the photo of the year. You couldn't miss them, she was almost skipping, whilst swinging her bag. The Palace lied, got busted and now make the public feel guilty. Now watch your free speech fade away more, as they go after social media. You are being gaslit !! Geez
You are a good man. Princess Catherine deserves all the respect in the world. She's done nothing wrong but try to come back from a health crisis, and the media and the haters have treated her horrendous.
He’s got more moral and humane than many journalists and media that’s for sure!!
You must know a lot of bad men if you class this one as good.
Not only is he not truthful (3 conflicting versions of his story) but he claims he respects privacy and then proceeds to sectretly film and sell the footage so it can be shown all around the world.
@@dianax266👍
Thank you for speaking out. It is lovely to hear your story. Love it.
Guys , we need to give this couple a break , respect their wish to be left alone for some time .
Tell this guy he invaded their privacy. He is a hypocrite
People are going to believe what ever they want. Time to ignore all the ignorant mean spirited trolls. I stand with Cathrine ❤
I don't believe what I "want".
I believe what I see with my own two eyes.
I see an impostor.
You need glasses...
@@DD-dq1ed is that for when I _see_ Kate, or for when I see somebody who _looks like_ Kate??
I stand with POW too - let’s leave the sugary trolls to their delusions and leave them to bask in the absolute glory of their magnificent, sincere,authentic Kween - they deserve each other !!
I stand with Harry and this man's a liar 😂
You are a great guy and this video really shows that William and Kate are doing well. Thank you so much for your heart warming words. ❤️💫❤️
“great guy”! He video taped two individuals, and then sold that video. Where is the “great” in that?
@@elsands9774wouldn’t you? People in glass cages etc. At least he has told the truth & seems a nice man. Who just happened to be in the one place to take that video ,very jealous media & paparazzi will attempt to undermine this guy.
@@richardwait1206 , Actually NO. I would never, nor have I ever videotaped individuals without their knowledge and consent. Not my thing.
@@richardwait1206How do you know he's telling the truth?, he's just some random bloke who thinks he saw two people in a shop lmao. I'm sure the guy that filmed the footage of bigfoot was sure it was him too
As for "people in glass cages" yeah, someone filming a couple without their consent and selling it off to the media lecturing everyone else about backing off and leaving them alone certainly lives in a giant glass cage
This whole stupid thing wouldn't have blown up if he didn't do that, eh?
@@elsands9774👍
THANK YOU for someone to step up and insert some sanity in this Hot Mess the world has created
The Medea created it Not the World
Great to see Prince William and Princess Catherine out and about ❤
You’re easily fooled
@@andreaclarke161 jump on the troll band wagon, maybe she's on holiday on the moon . 😂
You did it right
I’m glad he shared it and is now speaking, because he’s being very honest. People need to shut up.
Probably more likely speaking because he has been paid handsomely to do so. No better than the gutter press - except they would be penalised for publishing what this man has.
@@maryblencowe- are you also Lillibet200??
How do you know he's being "very honest"?
I suggest that anybody that specialises in Statement Analysis may not concur with your conclusion.
@@cillamurfin258Don't have to be Harry and Meghan fanboys to know that the British press are ravenous vultures who care nothing for the truth
I’m so happy to see Princess Catherine out and about. We have missed you so much and I hope you are feeling so much better.♥️🇨🇦♥️
This guy spoke so well about our Royals!!! Thank you for being you. Please, the media needs to disappear
It's a pity he has trouble telling the truth. It's also alarming that he claims he respects other people's privacy but he then secretly films then and sells his footage so it can be shown around the world.
The trolls saying it’s not her? Seriously? And now the hospital staff has accessed her medical records. Wonder how much they were paid ? Media goons will do anything to get what they want. They’re pathetic. If they print or release them I hope they are sued, arrested for obtaining records illegally
I agree, there are a lot of pathetic people amongst us. Regarding the subject of medical records potentially being compromised to people simply disrespecting Princess Catherine's privacy from the moment she was hospitalized....it's all shameful. I'm a former medical professional who took my oath seriously....and I'm now a patient who is permanently disabled. I just shake my head if someone did breach confidentiality in regard to the Princess's records. I am not however a 'troll' - despite you thinking so. I don't know if the video reflects Catherine or not; however, from moment one I have stated I don't think it is her. Do I KNOW that?! Of course not. No-one knows one way or the other.
The royals should have been honest then from the beginning. They could have laid this to rest weeks ago.
@@og87 they said she was undergoing abdominal surgery and wouldn't be carrying out public duties until after Easter, I call that honest. Do you advertise your medical status to the world and his wife, because I know I certainly don't, it's my private business and none of theirs.
@janrogers8352 I totally agree with you. The press need to leave them alone & stop the bullying. We the public maybe pay their wages (£1.50 or something each) but we don't own them. Catherine's medical records are her business nothing to do with anyone else. As for the photo it was imo just a family snap on her social media for mother's day I don't give a dam if it had some photo shopping done to it. Most photographers do that to their photos.
Nope, they are not required to give out private information, who do you think you are?? How about H&M product their invisible children and proof of DNA - no valid sightings for 2 years, no official photos, no kids. @@og87
What a sensible understanding compassionate young man!!
He made money off the video with full intention. How’s that a “compassionate young man!!”.
Good for you, Nelson. You are a kind person.
When will these evil individuals leave the royal family END OF.leave them alone😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡😡
When everyone leave Meghan alone
Those poor poor poor parasites with their literal BILLIONS in their castles and palaces
I like this guy. He expressed what many of us think. Happy to see William and Catherine together.
It's got nothing to do with whether you like him or not, what's important is if he's actually telling the truth.
The first thing I'd like to kniw is if he's been paid anything in relation to the video footage or him giving the "interview".
Can you please explain the reason why you like this guy?
The media are not allowed to willy nilly film the royal family and publish footage. Yet this guy secretly films the royals when he says himself that he thought they wanted privacy. Not only that he then he decides to "share" (sell?) his secretly filmed footage so it can be publicly shown by The Sun.
I'm struggling to find anything in these actions that makes him likeable. If anything, it would be the opposite.
@diana - What’s important to you, does not apply to everyone else. Not all of us live in the conspiracy world.
@@Michelle-xm6no
What are you taking about?
I was referring to the truth and there is hardly anyone I know that does not consider the truth to be important. Maybe you're not like the vast majority of people I know and the truth is not important to you.
@@Michelle-xm6no
Also I don't live in a conspiracy world.
When determining the credibility & reliability of a statement, an important consideration is whether there is any conflict of interest. These are absolute fundamentals in many walks of life, e.g. Justice/ courts, scientific papers, exker witnesses, salesman, etc. Etc.
"I wanted to keep their privacy to themselves" so....the logical thing to be done is...film them and sell the images to the media 😅
Yes and also tell 3 different versions of his story. The one in this video, the different one the Sun newspapers quotes him telling and an even different one that TMZ quotes him telling!!
Add into the mix that he's 40 and he describes 2 people older than him as a "young couple". Perhaps he has a script writer that is quite old?
People should take lessons from this gentleman. He respected the Prince and Princess of Wales by giving them their space and not confronting them. Yes he took a video to show to his family. Only after speaking to others and reading about the negativity did he decide to share the video with the public. He had only kind words to say about Catherine and William. For and those who continue to bully and make false claims, like this gentleman said get a hobby.
It is this "gentleman" that seems to be making false claims. What he says in this video is different to what he is quoted as saying the Sun article, which is also a different version to what TMZ quote him as saying.
I suggest that what he says is taken with a gigantic mountain of salt, particularly if the claim that he was paid a substantial sum are true.
@@robbomax1143 👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼 👍
Yeah, when i want to bang on about respecting peoples privacy i like to whip out my old 2010 iphone and make terrible quality videos of people in private and then sell it off to the media who then splashes it on every front page in the country
Because you should totally respect privacy, guys
Sorry, but he doesn't seem to credible, 'want to give them privacy' but starts filming them ,he also insults people that are speculating ,human curiosity, yet intrudes on the couple ,without permission and how did Tmz obtain this footage, did Mr judge here, sell it to the media and wouldn't that be hypocritical ?
Thanks to this gentleman for speaking up. He is the only person that makes any sense amongst all the BS thats our there. Leave Princes Catherine alone and respect their privacy😊
Thank you. I honestly don’t understand the conspiracies. This is a woman on sick leave. She should be left alone.
Good to have proof that Kate is healthy and well, that matters👏👏👏
Thanks mate for your honest opinion.
@TheSun you need to listen to shopper in your video and do some investigative journalism and try to track down the source of the bot/trolls. Last year here in the US, there was a situation in which someone used bots to verbally attack one of the cast member's child on a reality show (Real Housewives of Beverly Hills) via this route. It is my understand that they were able to identify the source of the attacks. someone might want to do the same for the bot attack on Catherine. It would be interesting to see where the funding for this originated.
Yes well said from Adelaide South Australia 👏👏👋😊🇦🇺
Also from Adelaide, South Australia- I suspect we can all guess where the bot attacks originated.
@@margaretk1962 absolutely over in California, were you born in 1962 ? Just curious as im 1961 😊
Very well said, Mr. Silva👍. People should stop being busybodies and just let Prince William and Princess Kate breathe and give them som space. After you have had surgery, you just want to relax and decompress and not be stressed. Probably she wants to do a social detox even for few months and lead a normal life for once, with her family.
TMZ said that is not Kate and William. They have retracted what they said.
Hope they're now feeling ashamed of themselves!
They can’t possibly prove it’s not them
No they haven’t!! Stop with the lies
@@erikaclaudia7981 Haha, good one. TMZ didn't retract anything because the story they ran accepted that the video was of PW and PC. Nice try.
TMZ DIDN’T RETRACT ANYTHING 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 LIES LIES LIES LIES
It wasn't her.
A stranger managed to film them yet the media who have people all hours trying to get a shot could not????
I believe the British media have an agreement not to invade their privacy by photographing them when they are engaged in private activities - since Princess Dianna the media guidelines (re photographs at least) have changed. That’s why the UK media did not publish the pap shot of POW and her mother in the car whereas US media did, and why UK media do not photograph them at school drop off etc. Which illustrates the absurdity and deceit of Meghan Markle’s assertion that if she had stayed in the UK there would have been hoardes of photographers taking photos when Archie was taken to school (she wishes!)
No the British media is not stalking her the way you insinuate. They have an agreement with the royal family about access.
He makes zero sense.
Bravo to the young man.
He is obviously honest, it is clear. Many people are glad he filmed them AND shared it.
So, the rest of us should mind our own business and "get a life."
Yet this guy's the one who followed them and clandestinely shot a VIDEO from his CAR and ultimately published it for world viewing.
OKAY. 👀
Love The Sun for this interview!! Not only releasing the video but also interviewing the man who witnessed their outing . It's a very nice interview and a very nice young man.
I really like this guy, he seems very kind ❤️
And a good liar 🤔 he thinks
@@wafo133- is it so difficult to say something decent about another human being??
@@cillamurfin258 not when the human being is an outright LIAR 🤥
@@wafo133Hello sugar
@@cillamurfin258When said human records people in private, sells it off to the media for a quick buck (£200-£300K, not too bad is it) who then splashes it on every front page in the country WHILST telling us he respects their "privacy"?
C'mon, pull the other one lmao
Not saying it wasn't her,just weird that such a popular figure would be recognized by one shopper in the market, the people that were sitting there did not even glance at them
People are discreet, have some sense. Not everyone is a screaming teenager.
May GOD bless HRH Catherine Princess of Wales and her family ❤️🇺🇲🙏
Hi, Neil! 👋
The man who took the video of Catherine at the Farm Shop is Nelson Silva. The Sun has an 8 minute TH-cam video interviewing him. He is very credible.
Catherine was extremely slender to begin with, and probably hasn't had solid food for 2 months.
It totally looks like her to me, exactly the way I would expect her to look.
I love you, Neil, but you're wrong on this issue.
❤️🌹🥰🇺🇸
She looks like different person
Good to see u Princess of Wales. U look great! All the best & love from USA 🇺🇸
Love Catherine & William 👑👑💖💖, glad to see them happy and well. Thank you for your account 😍
Wow princess Catherine looks beautiful as always
@@spudspuddywere you the surgeon?
It's 3 months now that she has been gone, so she should be healing whatever surgery she had done, probably.@@spudspuddy
Cry harder sugar! It is absolutely Catherine and she's on her way back so deal with it! @@spudspuddy
Spud are you a bot?? You keep saying the same thing...over...and over...
@@Julie-q1z 😂
Thanks for sharing 👍🏻
Not her at all
You need glasses.....
Go away troll
Did this guy ask them if they minded being filmed. Did he get money for this? He said he realised they wanted their privacy, then gave the video to the SUN! It's intrusive.
He likely got paid a fortune. Dodi and Diana photos on yacht sold for $6,000,000. This is a bigger story. Ethics and values can be dimmed when that much $ is involved.
Oh wow good job, telling people to just stop trolling is bound to make them stop. After all, we know how gracious and considerate trolls are 💀
How can you tell someone to not troll anyone, when he video taped individuals, and then sold that video tape? It’s all about money 💰
Why did he sell the video of Kate and William to the Sun in the first place?
$. Big $. The guy who photographed Diana and Dodi on a yacht was paid $6,000,000 for photos. And this is a much bigger story. This guy is probably set for life.
Because he can.
for the same reason that he made the video, in the first place. He wanted the big pile of money which he already knew TMZ would pay. And here he is in an interview, collecting more money, for telling other people to be more respectful.
Then he shouldn't preach about people not being "good" by questioning his video... because they "can" and it's not "good" to video a person without their knowledge.
He said it . For his family. My guess BP or KP were asked and sad they wouldn ´t intervene if it would go public. A win / win
Nice Gentleman, Perfectly Complentry an on larger than life normal glimpse. TU for sharing. C
She looks well
That picture is not Kate
Loving Kate being so on trend with the socks over the leggings !! 👍
I didn’t know it was a trend. I’ve been wearing the same thing to teach yoga for years 😀
Why is everyone so shocked that catherine is up and about? Shes not bedridden just because of getting chemo ? SHES NOT AN INVALID !!ITS GOOD FOR HER TO BE UP DOING THINGS SHES ABLE TO DO.GET A GRIP !!!
Really good interview, very nice young man.
He said he wanted to keep there privacy to themselves but then he sold the footage to THE SUN He is a very nice guy
Hope he made lots of money. Not a very nice guy
I sure af would have sold too
Not bad for someone who knew nothing about them, to recording them, to selling it to the Sun, to telling everyone they should believe it was Kate. Getting all the background from his family? Yeah right! A simple hello to them at the meat counter would have been more appropriate.
He's an A Hole
That video is likely worth millions. The grainy stills of Dodi and Diana on a yacht netted $6,000,000 for the photog. Values and decency have a tendency to take a back seat to the opportunity to rake in millions in a day.
Well this is the difference between H&M and the Prince and Princess of Wales. They both get scrutinised, but H&M whinge about it and the W&K keep stoic👏🏻
You need to apologize to both of William and Catherine
If she supposed of had surgery and she seems to be OK walking about normal why hasn't she been on tv thank ing people who in the Catherine fan club.
Because Catherine is not a wannabe starlet. She's the future Queen of England and always dignified, she will thank everybody in her own time. Something you should learn about.
@@cilajoao1 lol
@@heatherives8646 lol back at you.
@@cilajoao1 have a nice day 😊
@@heatherives8646 Likewise.
I suspect Nelson Silva is Portuguese, and as a fellow Portuguese, I guarantee we don't suffer fools gladly, we are not starstruck, and we don't have aggressive paparazzi. This is the reason why so many VERY famous people come to live here and are left in peace. This young man is the perfect example of wanting to give them space and being respectful. Thank you, Nelson!
You say he's the "perfect example" of having respect.
Yet he secretly films a couple (that he merely thinks but does not verifu if they actually are Kate & "William) then he he sells the footage to media outlets that he knows will publicise it to everyone around the world, which will be the cause of gossip and opinion.
I suggest that your perception of having respect is different to that of most decent people.
@@robbomax1143 How do you know he didn't get permission to sell it? Do you think he would risk having the Royal legal team on his back? He's trying to put an end to the drama. I thank him.
@@cilajoao1
You have ignored the point I was making which was that what you consider as having respect is not aligned with what most decent people consider it to be.
I never mentioned anything about permissions for him to sell his footage. He does not need any permission from anyone to sell his video footage to media outlets.
If (and it's a big if) the "royal legal team" are going to be the back of anyone it *would not be Nelson.* It would be the Sun & TMZ (and other media outlets) for publishing the imagery. But that would only potentially be the case if the people filmed are actually William & Kate.
You say he's trying to bring a end to the drama. Do you think the publishing of this video brought the drama to an end or created more drama & speculation? If you are uncertain which then I suggest you read the rest of the comments on this video.
Since Nelson admits himself that he does not take any interest in the royal family then it is extremely peculiar that he suddenly gets involved in something he has no care for and he thinks it is his responsibility to "end the drama".
Why are they without securit?
Good point
Just without make up. 👌😊
Answer: "When someone comes out and declares the truth!" This has gone beyond the need for privacy!
They told the truth but people didn't want to believe it, deciding to speculate and come up with ludicrous theories. Maybe next time they shouldn't say anything at all.
@@janrogers8352 And that’s why the truth must be known. It’s Not fair to leave people in the dark about someone who is recognized as a leader or a special value to society. Kate IS valued by society! She’s greatly loved and respected! Those who hide her truth are dogs!
He is sticking up for prince william and Princess catherine good for him
Do you really think people are blind and idiots?
How wonderful to see her/them. Together
I am so happy that Princess Catherine is well and happy
After her surgery.
A great Thank you to this Man
For taking this video to show us.
May God bless you with health and happiness.
I am for team "Wales" .
😊❤
Something is odd about the video. He just happens to return to the car and have the perfect angle to record them at the exact right time? Not a single picture was taken? No one else even noticed them? No, I don’t buy it. This is not believable.
Royals in Windsor is like celebrities in Hollywood. People notice them. And shrug.
@user-ny3on8vh1v It's called English discretion. Learn about it.
Is it true he was paid
£220, 000 for his supposedly video of W&K.
I would say good on you mate for the scam, but the Sun and the Palace are obviously part of the set up
❤️Kate❤️
LIES, LIES, AND MORE LIES
Every 5 min a new lie to cover the previous o e…..
Any evidence
That was not Kate. It has been proven!
Tmz is now claiming they dont know if that is kate or not.
Its 💯 not her
Just a set up to fool everyone and palace played along or directed this
I am not surprised. Harvey the head of TMZ has been praising Meghan and Markle and has a hatered for William because he asked for a seize fire in Gaza. He has nothing good to say about the Royal family because of it and is singing Meghan praise on Piers Morgan show and talking lies how America has now embraced Megan.
Tmz said its her!
It's Not her
If my wife had just had major surgery, would you let her carry bags like that.
He said young couple, they are middle aged now. Weird.
Are you serious? Those bags are lightweight, it's a sign Catherine is feeling much better. What's weird is your brain, that's all.
The truth doesn’t fit their narrative. That’s why the trolls keep trolling.
It doesn’t look like her and definitely not the same unwell Kate we saw in her recent video. She looks younger and in perfect health here which is unfortunately not the case…
This man is so lovely! Thank you for being a decent human being. Thanks for your honest interview and for calling out the trolls ( I include the horrible British and American media ) involved in the bullying of Catherine, Princess of Wales. I also call out the American celebrities who have gone after Catherine: Steven Colbert, Kim Kardashian and Blake Lively, you are part of the bullying.
Man records couple without their consent or knowledge then sells it off to the papers for a quick buck, whilst tellling everyone he respects their privacy
LMAO, where you dropped on your head as a child?
Okay now leave her and her family alone. Let her recover in private.
Good for both of them🙏❤️😇. It’s really nice to see 🤩💐.? From here in America, keep up the good job Prince of Wales to take good care your Princess of Wales . More power to the both of you 🙏❤️😇🥰
I agree with him. Those trolls including Tiktok influences, celebrities and news outlet who spread false rumours should back off and feel responsible for the damage they are causing in people's lives.
It's odd that you agree with somebody that's not truthful and who claims he respects the couples privacy yet he sectretly films them then sells the footage so it can be shown around the world.
@@dianax266I mean, that's the bigger picture here
If he wanted to respect their privacy then i think selling the footage to the effing SUN (one of, if not the worst papers in the uk) is kind of the wrong way to go about it
@@michealhunt6607 I suggest you're being too kind saying "kind of wrong" as its absolutely wrong.
I havent a clue who you saw it wasnt kate that pic is 20 years younger in that pic
Why you always lying meg??
I agree. This wasn’t Kate.
So he should feel like a fool. This was obviously not the same person who announced that she has cancer.
That was an AI video.
The shopper who took the video seems like a nice guy. In a way it’s good he took the video as it helps put an end to the frenzy and all the rumors. And he seems truthful and it wasn’t a pap set up like the other one across the pond routinely seems to do.
We all love Princess of Wales. Wishing her a speedy recovery.
Great interview and yes people should be accountable for what they are saying about the Princess of Wales.
Lots of people have doubles and you would never know
That's not Kate. Who paid this guy to lie!!!!
Do they think we're blind? What is the Royal Family hiding from us???
Is that really Catherine?
If it was me, I wouldnt film them. I would give them the RESPECT AND PRIVACY. Filming them is the opposite of it. People should learn to admire from a far and keep your videos to yourself. Stop monetizing them at their expense. You did this with Princess Diana, now you’re doing it to our Prince and Princess of Wales. Just back off and it’s no one’s business! People should stop being so nosy!
Propaganda!!!!!!!!
This guy seems very rational down to earth and normal. Doesn’t come across as a sensationalist, but wants to allay all the misinformation rumored. Thanks you Mr Silva.
So he doesn’t know for sure who she is, but then go ahead and recorded her and company while sitting on his car…hmm that’s a little problematic recording people you don’t really know who they are.
he's fibbing...he knew very well who it was and he knew he could make a lot of money...it's been all over the news non stop for a few months and he didn't know who they were?????????????????
I wanted to give them their privacy so I filmed them. Maybe next time you go shopping some people will start to film you out of respect for your privacy.
🤦♂️
I believe it was her.
That is not Princess Catherine!
You are not you. Now show me evidence.
I am confused, the UK press don't publish a photo taken by the paparazzi but they do publish this clip from a tourist. How are these 2 photos different, neither were approved both were an invasion of privacy.
Easy. The Sun got greedy and decided to ignore Royal Privacy policy. It is not like The Sun is in the royals good books to begin with.
"I wanted to keep their privacy" Is that why you filmed them and sold it?
He was doing it for his family and to stop all the crazy theories, we should thank him for that.
I wish this video had never been taken. He was paid a lot for it by the Sun and sadly it is going to encourage others to try to get more footage to sell to the highest bidder.
he betrayed them with respecting their privacy!!
He sold it to the highest bidder. @@sallie6