Oh I totally agree. It takes a surprising amount of talent and discipline to just sing a melody straight, while still keeping the attention of the audience. When you already have a good voice, you don't need to disguise it with runs and pentatonic warbling.
That's a stupi the remark because Christina Aguilera can sing her butt off. She's up there with Celine and Whitney. HCJ may have his theory down but he's not a natural talent. There are a lot of you school musician types that suck butt when it comes to performance and raw gift for the craft. Y'all stick out like a sore thumb because you spend your time hating on the raw talents of the world. Music is not math problem.
@SrChalice It’s not about math. It’s about thinking about what you’re singing and why you’re singing it. But it seems like thought is a tough concept for you.
No he doesn't. He interrupted a beautiful performance of My Funny Valentine to talk about what the text means: the least important part of music, in fact the non musical part of it. That's overly intellectual, not emotional. What do you feel, when she intones this melody? That's emotional. He is a self important prick. That girl's voice was beautiful; her interpretation just gorgeous. What the lyrics mean ... least important thing to focus on. Stopping her was a pitiful and incompetent move. Her rendition was lovely. Her voice is far better than his.
@@ImaginationBlue, what are your credentials and experience to speak so confidently and matter if factly about a multiple Tony Award winning singer? Harry Connick Jr has forgotten more about music than most people ever learn in their life and that foundation of knowledge lets you KNOW the songs you sing. And for you to say lyrics don’t matter is incredibly disrespectful to lyricists and shows you only comprehend the low brow music we have in modern pop music. It’s catchy and snappy, but songs today have no soul.
I actually think Kara is a little underrated of a judge. She had some serious musical chops and gave great critiques at times but was scorned by the public. Paula leaving the next season and Simon planning to leave for a while didn’t help. Kara was also a little cooky/weird and when you’re a guy like Stephen Tyler you can get away with that but for women it can be more difficult. I was a little kid then but in retrospect I think we were all a little too hard on her.
I have to comment on this... Harry Connick Jr studied music with the Marsalis family. Ellis Marsalis was one of his teachers. He played music with Wynton and Branford Marsalis who happen to be the most acclaimed Jazz musicians of this generation. Growing up in the birth place of jazz New Orleans HCJ knows the music from the inside and can play it! He's the first real musician to be on the show and its about time. They really need to shut up and listen to what he's saying!
@@frankwilliams3036 I wasn't aware he studied with them which makes my comment on a different video on Harry's judging hilarious. Jlo said he knew to much, my comment was "just imagine if they had Wynton Marsalis judge.
I agree with Harry. There is wayyyyyy too much vocal gymnastics going on in these competitions. Just sing it. Give vibrato where it's needed and just sing the rest. If you have a good voice, it will show through and people will want to listen to you. When you become a legit star, then show us what you can do (with in reason).
Harry is so very good at what he does - and his critiques were spot on. Listening to the way Randy dismisses Harry Connick Jr. is so unprofessional I was stunned. Who would invite a guest mentor onto the show, then bash their coaching after the performances are done. Harry Connick can flat out sing the standards better than ANY of those judges and is respected industry-wide for his voice, musicianship and range singing various styles. Very glad Harry Connick Jr. called out the punitive critique Randy gave that 'she should have sang the Etta James version'...how unconstructive is that comment?
Harry knew what he was talking about. How would she craft her signature style by singing as another great, as Randy said? She should learn the original and interpret it in her own “bluesy” way, not copy/paste Etta’s version. That’s the difference in artistry, and why there were so many covers in the 60s and 70s yet each version had its own unique sound or feeling.
Simon Cowell may have been a great producer and judge of singers, but Harry actually knows the technicals and can judge people beyond first impressions. He should have been on the show long ago.
Simon cowell is a fantastic judge of what is saleable. Not what’s good. There are plenty of phenomenal singers he would never have signed. Harry is the type of person that given the opportunity, would have signed many of those artists cowell wouldn’t fuck with. If cowells output was a restaurant, he would be fast food. Harry would be a Michelin star restaurant.
Can't say I'm a fan of his singing just because it's not my favorite style, but holy shit I'm a fan of this man. He's trying to teach them how to be actual singers, not pop stars, and he's raising the musical IQ of the country too. If I was a singer on this show, I'd want to workshop my song with him for every minute they'd let me.
"Don't sing notes that are not in the chords." A literal and metaphorical lesson to live by. A profound statement. Find your individuality and personality in other ways. The chasm between knowledge and respect for music and wannabe singers never shined more brightly than when Harry was on this panel. Loved seeing those willing and able to learn.
Is Harry the first person to challenge contestants like this? I always wondered why judges never addressed the artistic aspects of the song being performed. They're usually just all technical or emotional.
Unfortunately AI was not really about music. It was always about the high notes and the number of notes one can shove in a phrase. Smoke and mirrors, but no substance.
So ironic that they made Harry, an extremely intelligent musician, the vocal coach and then the judges proceeded to completely disregard what he tried to teach the singers.
I just love this fateful moment when Harry first took his seat on the judges' panel. I remember watching this at the time and being so impressed with how smart, knowledgeable, logical, dispassionate, candid and funny Harry was. I remember thinking: "He would make an amazing judge!"
The man knows music structure. Knows when to to emphasize,when to tone it down and when to just let it flow and keep it simple. True musician right there
What Harry said here is totally right. My vocal coach also told me the same thing - understand the song, get the melody right first and put your interpretation accordingly. Avoid using runs unnecessarily and stop trying too hard to be someone else. Emulate first, interpret afterwards. Unfortunately nowadays excessive use of riffs and runs and in-tune yelling tend to get misinterpreted as soulfulness or emotional singing.
Its the same thing in dance, you have to have the foundation, the base before you even begin to understand how to build on it. My first dance teacher used to always say, "you can't build a house from the roof down.."
Ancient history for me, back in music school my homework included translating the italian, french and german songs for my voice lessons, as well as lots of time in the music library with headphones on listening to great lyric sopranos. Understanding the song, and having great models apply!
Stephen Sondheim said that many young people are auditioning for shows and struggle with the necessity of performing the original music as it’s written on the page. They want to put their own stamp on it.
As one of the great conductors of his time, George Szell, Cleveland Orchestra's 4th Music Director, honored the composers of what they intended with their music. I would like to add Julia Fischer, who honors them too, and some of the music I enjoy listening to her play are Max Bruch and Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's violin concertos.
The thing too is that there ARE songs that are written with the kind of emotion for belting and sass, and really nailing a vocal... "Think! Think about what you're trying to do to me." (Aretha). Or how about, "Don't you dare walk away from me, i have nothing...nothing...nothing" (Whitney). Those express the kind of emotion that a lot of these singes want to sing. But "I'm a little lamb that's lost in the wood," should not be belted while dancing around the melody like crazy. These kids have incredible talent, and have NO idea how to use it.
Just goes to show Harry Connick Jr. is a TRUE artist of the modern era. He's a good and true vocal coach and song interpreter. He learned from the best and those who learn from him will learn from the best too
He reminds me of ever great vocal instructor and/or instrument instructor I've ever had and he's not pretending to be overly kind for the camera. Just one more reason to love this man. Harry Connick is a national treasure.
Bloody hell. I've never seen this show, never even listened to this guy perform, but man, he deserves REAL respect for his insights and integrity. What a golden level of mentorship.
Here's the thing, if this was real vocal contest for aspiring professional singers, chances are Harry wouldn't have to tell the singers to learn the meaning of the lyric or learn the melody as it is. They know that already He is dealing with more of a raw talents here... someone with good natural voice/talent but has very little knowledge/ability in terms of what musicality is.. so he is right, these singers do need to learn the lyric/melody before they move on and do their own thing. btw I don't think harry is necessary against doing runs and "licks" per se, I think he just wants these people to make sure they have the basics right before they do that, and to be able to use them in such a way that it actually serves the music, and not just a tool to show off. After all, a lot of jazz is about making the song your own thing.
@@MrSF247 I think that's what he meant by " and to be able to use them in such a way that it actually serves the music, and not just a tool to show off."
We are talking about a man who inserts and extra beat into a measure to get the audience to clap in correct time. He is truly one of the great musicians.
I want Harry to be EVERYBODY'S vocal coach. The state of pop music would improve 1000%. He definitely knows MUSIC, and that's where a musician HAS to start.
Harry's words need to be relayed to those singing our National Anthem. The over-trilling and gratuitous embellishment drive me crazy. Sad that competitive singing shows like this force singers to over-do their interpretations in order to stand out. They could learn from Nat Cole, Sinatra, and Patsy Cline, among others, to learn restraint and truth.
this show would've been amazing w/ voice professors and educated musicians like harry. maybe then, the american public wouldn't spend $ on crap. so many people just can't recognize quality. if someone doesn't know what they're doing, they don't deserve your money. there are way too many pretenders out there, masquerading as pros.
Wow- Harry is a critic after my own heart! He is so real and tries to make these singer really understand the song they are singing. When you truly know about the song and have internalized it- you can sing with confidence and with passion!
It’s actually harder for most people NOT to add licks to their singing. It’s much more impressive to sing something straight and hold onto notes w/o excessive vibrato or trills.
I think being straightforward sounds boring but if u add runs and vibrato then it sounds better but only when it’s needed. I remember singing for church and my pastor said just keep it straightforward and I did but it wasn’t in me to keep doing that shit lol
Yes. Finally someone who cares about the art and true spirit of the sing. American Idol is about narcissism, however, so it makes sense that many of the singers just want to perform and don't really care about the intention of the sing.
Harry Connick Jr. is exactly what that show needs. Someone who really knows what they are doing and who can give these singers real guidance, not just some general I like it or I don't with no real reasoning behind it. I think he's giving the show a depth that it never had before.
WOW! Harry is a musician who actually knows what he is talking about. This was so refreshing! Maybe people will start to understand what it really takes to create great music.
Excellent constructive advice from Harry Connick Jr.. A lot of the time contestants are just singing the lyrics without getting into the real meaning behind the songs. I'm glad someone finally commented on that!
I remember listening to HCJ when I was young young kid, especially the christmas albums. But that is what trickled me into his work. He really is the best thing to happen to American Idol. He plays the critic, but for once. Actually knows what he is talking about when he is critical. Musicians wise, not corporate wise.
Sharp as a knife, this bloke, and he provides exactly what aspiring singers need to be told. Not knowing is a shortcoming; not being bothered to get to know is sinful.
I knew the moment Harry put Randy in his place that he'd be a good fit as a judge after this pitiful season. I think they need to get Mary J. Blige on there also because she too was good at offering support but at the same time still being able to explain ways to improve. Nicki and Steven can only compliment looks, and Mariah would just say things like "That was a good song choice."
Harry, you are so right on. Too many runs...lose the deep feeling shown in the notes and lerics. Harry was a favorite with my son (who was a great musician) and we shared his songs...and he put down a Mom's music..one being Harry's "Recipe for Making Love".....not on up on the shelf or in my grandma's kitchen...or something...Memories with my son who went to heaven are precious to me.
I love how Harry educates the masses on musical terms. The contestants need to learn a little terminology along the way if they already don't know some. Singing is not all about "riffs' and "licks", it's about skill, emotion, and sheer talent and sometimes songs should help you remember something special in your life.
Harry knows what he's talking about & I'm so glad he's Randy's replacement this year. He's a breath of fresh air! He's the only reason I'm watching AI this season.
I love Harry. I agree with him that all of those singers add unnecessary licks, and by doing so, it takes away from the emotional connection. I'm still working on that myself. I try to study the lyrics of songs before I sing to get a better understanding of the meaning.
Well 'being yourself' is the ultimate goal of all singers, but like what Connick said, if you are only emulating another cover version of the song, you are not being yourself. Unfortunately Randy and Harry did not seem to think in the same frame of mind.
+Timliu92 no, being a great singer is the goal. Everyone needs training and there's things about themselves that they need to change, not be. Sinatra for instance would never have been great if he did not work tirelessly to change his natural accent into clear english diction, a clarity that he became known for. This "be yourself" nonsense is getting out of control. Yes, seek the goals YOU want but make the necessary changes to yourself in order to reach your goal
@@TheJimmyClip Exactly!! Randy personifies why the major label record industry is dying a painfully slow death! Their attitude is “Let’s sell repetitive crap to people who don’t know music but who will buy it because it’s shiny and sounds like last quarters big cookie cutout performer and make a quick buck from “music fans” who they liked that song but who’s singers name they can barely remember because they are so interchangeable. But sadly and eventually, this “record buying” demographic will start to realize that all the music they like, sounds the same. And that will be true, because record companies don’t take many real chances on new sounds by true musicians unless it’s been sterilized, quantified, and strategized by non musical minded accountants for its money making ability based on research and statistics from last years quarterly report of this same musics genre. Then because simply sounds like last seasons flavor with a new hairstyle, that same “music fan” will opt to not buy their album but perhaps just get the single on a music buying platform or simply add it to their favorite playlist on Spotify, Slacker or Apple Music.. in which case the artist will get roughly 1/5 of a penny for the song while the owner of the platform will become a billionaire. All the while the truly gifted singers and songwriters will have to find other ways to generate a living which means non music work, or writing music for others ( if they’re lucky) or aiming for another musical demographic that no one including their long time supporting fans likes and then releasing an album that have critics calling a sellout or subpar material. Harry is asking the artist to be an musical artist! Not a smoke and mirror clone that will be big tomorrow then gone next week! The truth that Harry speaks might be what saves music in the long run!
Exactly right!! I enjoy him immensely but Randy is speaking like an industry salesman right now and this personifies why the major label record industry is dying a painfully slow death! Their attitude is “Let’s sell repetitive and non unique crap to people who don’t know music but who will buy it because it’s shiny and sounds like last quarters big cookie cutout performer , and make a quick buck from “music fans” who liked that song cause it’s familiar but who’s singers name they can barely remember because they are so interchangeable. Of course, sadly and eventually, this “record buying” demographic will start to realize that all the music they like, sounds the same. And that will be true, because these days, record companies Who are owned by non-musical mega corporations won’t take many real chances on new sounds by true musicians unless it’s been sterilized, quantified, and strategized by non musical minded accountants for its money making ability; based on research and statistics from last years quarterly report of this same musics genre. Then because this new hit simply sounds like last seasons flavor with a new hairstyle, that very same prized “music fan” will opt to not buy the artists album but perhaps, just buy the single on a music buying platform or more likely, just add the song to their favorite playlist on Spotify, Slacker or Apple Music.. in which case the artist will get roughly 1/5 of a penny for the song while the owner of the platform will become a billionaire. All the while the truly gifted singers and songwriters will have to find other ways to generate a living which means non music work, or writing music for others ( if they’re lucky) which means fewer releases by the artist or the artist aiming for success in another musical genre or demographic, that no one including their long time supporting fans likes. And then releasing an album that will have fans and critics calling the music a sellout or subpar material. I’ve been in this biz for 30+ plus years. This is not where it’s going. This is where it’s at and this is where it’s been for a while now. This is why your favorite artist keeps putting the same thing out over and over again, This is why they keep trying to do other styles that don’t work for them. And it’s why they don’t even bother releasing new albums and just tour, charging more fir tickets but just keep playing their old material.
Finally, somebody talking real sense on one of these shows!! Everybody now is trying to turn songs into soul versions!! Harry makes perfect sense. Learn the melody and simplicity!!!
@@rosselliottsmith3120 So true. This is why most song isnt straight up to the point. Most have hidden meaning and not knowing is the best way to learn. That why the saying "Live, Learn, and Never repeat."
I have to respect HCJ. The kind of shallow drivel that goes on on American Idol is quite frankly, beneath him as a musician. Instead of saying "I want no part of this crap" he instead chose to try and at least teach these singers something of value for once.
My sister is a vocal coach and this is one of the many techniques/critiques she has. Song the original tune. Sing like you yes, but not the you that wants to sound a certain way as in sounding like another artist. Know the song, feel the song. ... even, be the song. Act it out. Uhh. . Foolish people. .. Harry is really the only good judge ever.
there's a reason he's had a spectacular and successful career spanning more than two decades. he just gets it. i'm so glad he's on AI. I didn't even watch the show last season at all. Plus he doesn't BS what's going on but says it in a very sincere way if you listen to what he's actually saying. Very constructive criticism.
Harry, Thank god for you!. To tell this young people the truth is the best thing that you could do. You don't need made up vocal gymnastics to sing the great standards, The foundation first is to know the song and what the lyric is about and to stop tring to channel the stylist you like to sell it, does not work, bring what you naturally have to the table, nothing more. Teach Harry, TEACH!
I agree with Harry completely. The noodling and runs have gotten completely out of hand. There's singing, then there's "vocal gymnastics". We're seeing to little of the former and way too much of the latter. Listen to Billie, Lena, Aretha, Nat "king" Cole and the other greats.They are at their best staying true to the melody.
Love Harry's critiques - so bang on! I love these girls voices but Standards are so simple yet powerful and don't need the power voice to distract from their melodic amazingness! If you can sing a standard and connect you , the audience and the song then you are really an amazing singer!
This man was New Orleans born and raised. Classically trained. At nine could play any Beethoven or Bach. I saw him at The Jazz Festival in 1980 when he was 12. Too smart and too honest and way too much of a musician for American Idol.
He's what every singer actually wants in a judge on a show/talent contest... someone who won't let you walk out the door without giving you constructive criticism that you can work with!
Wow, Harry is a legit super qualified premium coach, all his comments made absolutely musical sense...!!!!! I'm a fan It's embarrassing when you see those clowns on the panel made uneducated comments....smh.
These YOUNGSTERS better listen to this guy because HE'S THE REAL DEAL !! He's just a THOROUGHBRED when it comes to his craft - some of the old Sinatra songs he does JUST AS WELL IF NOT BETTER then Frank ever did !!
At the end... I am 1,000,000% with Harry! He's so right! And this show needed someone to call attention to all the wishy-washy b.s. that the judges tell the contestants! And props to Harry for making Nicki and Mariah uncomfortable!!! So great!
@@frankburn6312 He is...but I think it’s clear that Harry comes from a more astute angle when it comes to the nuances and styles of music. I really can’t stand AI, but based on these clips Harry is more into musicianship and the qualities of what makes music art, as opposed to Randy being into image, what gets the quick applause and given the fade away manner that most of these “American Idol’s” find themselves in after the show, I think the latter is a bit disingenuous and honestly “Not for me Dawg.”
@@lateralus747 the thing is , most of music have based on “image and what gets the quick applause” ie “show business “ vs music and art , ie “classical music and jazz”.
@@frankburn6312 I don’t agree with that sentiment at all. To say something like “most music” is a sweeping generalization I think. I’d agree with your statement if it was a bit more detailed, maybe something along the lines of most music that is marketed for the mainstream or for reasons of mass consumption or commercialization. There is a lot of music that is geared for reasons of art and expression that don’t just sit in the realms of classical or jazz. I would say it’s just that music and entertainment marketing is such a multilayered endeavor that the business or to use your word, show business, makes it appear as to what the business has to offer or sell is the only thing music should or has to be. Not to say that there is anything wrong with making money from music...it’s how I make my living. But the industry has changed a lot. And what has been deemed good has also changed...a lot. I’ll leave you with this as an example. Imagine you were told your whole life that McDonalds gave you everything that you ever needed or wanted as far as food. Quality, flavors, nutrition etc. But then one day you magically come across a grocery store and find the variety of food that is available to you, is fresh and far more sustaining on so many different levels, more so than McDonalds. All I’m saying is most of the mass marketed mainstay that is the music industry bastardizes everything that is inherently valuable about what music is. It’s often overlooked by dollar signs and other gimmicks that people don’t realize is a McDonalds double cheeseburger when in fact a fresh burger would be so much more fulfilling and satiating on various levels.
I am surprised all these commenters are surprised... LOL!! You should all know Harry Connick's background. He is a child piano playing prodigy. He was playing with the best of them at a very early age so he has been taught the foundations of Jazz and Blues by real masters. He is a master class teacher.
When u know u know! HC jr is a proffessional musician and a talented freak of Jazz músic..Randy it was always a minority fill in as a black person on The judge pannel, Harry knows what's up and also showed all of us on national tv, that Randy has no idea of what a definition of music is!!
Perfect video to explain how jazz standards need to be perceived by young vocalists. I love Harry's approach and emphasis on "the original melody first" .
They have a panel full of people who don't really know musicality. The only ones I would trust in a critique would be harry or mariah. The rest are just smoke and mirrors.
I have NEVER heard an American Idol singer except for Michael Buble who could even come close to being able to sing American Standards. None of them have any concept of melody to speak of and for them to think that Harry Connick Jr. can give that to them in just a few days while I had to work my ass off at music school for FOUR YEARS to understand it is insane.
I now understand what Harry Connick was trying to advise Kree and completely agree with him - go to the basic version to understand the lyrics more and do it your own way afterwards. Randy has been a confusing judge all these time and especially those days when Simon was still around. It's really better for real artists to do the critique-ing as they're the ones who understand the craft better.
After this lesson I tried playing ‘All The Things You Are’ (Jerome Kern, Oscar Hamerstein-1939) on my guitar (chord/melody style) and to play it straight, (like I’m singing, like playing the lyrics). I was taught about this long ago but I often I still slip into licks and at that point I’m just exploring harmony and melodic possibilities. Then I’ve wandered off the path, lost the portent of the song. It’s self-indulgent and doesn’t honour the composer’s storytelling. When I play it straight, tracking the lyric in my head (not so easy to do) I feel it deeply and am moved to tears by the lover’s affection. MIX - Harry Connick Jr. on singing standards...a supportive reminder to any musician or singer.
Aretha was a just class. You're right about her taste and musicality. There was nothing comlicated about her runs however, they were harmonically correct and rhythmically very strong. If you want to hear complicated I think you have to leave the whole popular idiom. True some singers use excessive ornamentation but it's hardly ever complicated, usually rhythmically pedestrian harmonically basic(sometimes wrong) and irrelevant.
You can't "be yourself" when you're at the "copy your idols" stage of development, with nothing of your own to express, which was where these contestants clearly were. HCJ was actually trying to help them become better musicians. Randy's "advice" sounds helpful on the surface, but really only served to help him make a more informed decision regarding who to cut.
![ละลาย (LALALYE) - DAOU PITTAYA ต้าห์อู๋ พิทยา [OFFICIAL MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/wo6r9TgausI/mqdefault.jpg)
HCJ: trying to undo the "Christina Aguilerization" of young singers one young person at a time.
amen to that
Nola Chick thank God!!!!!
Oh I totally agree. It takes a surprising amount of talent and discipline to just sing a melody straight, while still keeping the attention of the audience. When you already have a good voice, you don't need to disguise it with runs and pentatonic warbling.
That's a stupi the remark because Christina Aguilera can sing her butt off. She's up there with Celine and Whitney. HCJ may have his theory down but he's not a natural talent. There are a lot of you school musician types that suck butt when it comes to performance and raw gift for the craft. Y'all stick out like a sore thumb because you spend your time hating on the raw talents of the world. Music is not math problem.
@SrChalice It’s not about math. It’s about thinking about what you’re singing and why you’re singing it. But it seems like thought is a tough concept for you.
Well, look at that. They put someone who knows about music into a shit reality show.
Harry is the Best!! And super hot!!
Yea what Happened lol
Man, this guy, he's the real stuff. He understands that music is not about the acrobatics first, it's about the emotion first.
AMEN!!!
...and the music is about deliberate choices to help enhance the content rather than fluff which takes away from or diminishes the entirety.
No he doesn't. He interrupted a beautiful performance of My Funny Valentine to talk about what the text means: the least important part of music, in fact the non musical part of it. That's overly intellectual, not emotional. What do you feel, when she intones this melody? That's emotional. He is a self important prick. That girl's voice was beautiful; her interpretation just gorgeous. What the lyrics mean ... least important thing to focus on. Stopping her was a pitiful and incompetent move. Her rendition was lovely. Her voice is far better than his.
@@ImaginationBlue, what are your credentials and experience to speak so confidently and matter if factly about a multiple Tony Award winning singer? Harry Connick Jr has forgotten more about music than most people ever learn in their life and that foundation of knowledge lets you KNOW the songs you sing. And for you to say lyrics don’t matter is incredibly disrespectful to lyricists and shows you only comprehend the low brow music we have in modern pop music. It’s catchy and snappy, but songs today have no soul.
@Tristan Luke he didn’t stop her. That’s just the edit. And everything you’ve said is utter nonsense, one hopes to hold you aren’t a teacher
I LOVE his critique. Finally someone on this show that has some serious music knowledge and caters to that.
puppylove2019 exactly
I actually think Kara is a little underrated of a judge. She had some serious musical chops and gave great critiques at times but was scorned by the public. Paula leaving the next season and Simon planning to leave for a while didn’t help. Kara was also a little cooky/weird and when you’re a guy like Stephen Tyler you can get away with that but for women it can be more difficult. I was a little kid then but in retrospect I think we were all a little too hard on her.
Amen 👏👐👐
Sssi ick ick eaaaoah iiiick of riffs. So sick of cheap riffs. It sicks.
I prefer Harrys critiques over all those pathetic judges😂
I have to comment on this... Harry Connick Jr studied music with the Marsalis family.
Ellis Marsalis was one of his teachers. He played music with Wynton and Branford Marsalis who happen to be the most acclaimed Jazz musicians of this generation. Growing up in the birth place of jazz New Orleans HCJ knows the music from the inside and can play it! He's the first real musician to be on the show and its about time. They really need to shut up and listen to what he's saying!
I concur. More like him (Connick). No more "music stars" who know nothing about music.
@@frankwilliams3036 I wasn't aware he studied with them which makes my comment on a different video on Harry's judging hilarious. Jlo said he knew to much, my comment was "just imagine if they had Wynton Marsalis judge.
But what does Marsalis look like??
@@eBaggy7 What?
I love how keith is just smiling. I would guess if Keith was more of an extrovert he would voice his agreement with Harry.
I agree with Harry. There is wayyyyyy too much vocal gymnastics going on in these competitions. Just sing it. Give vibrato where it's needed and just sing the rest. If you have a good voice, it will show through and people will want to listen to you. When you become a legit star, then show us what you can do (with in reason).
I agree. I'd much rather hear someone sing with passion, and in a way that makes me believe in what they're singing about.
J
Well said, fully agree
7 years later and sadly this is still true.
I totally agree! What people don't understand is that sometimes you can say more with a pause, or silence, or a whisper than singing dozens of licks.
Harry is so very good at what he does - and his critiques were spot on. Listening to the way Randy dismisses Harry Connick Jr. is so unprofessional I was stunned. Who would invite a guest mentor onto the show, then bash their coaching after the performances are done.
Harry Connick can flat out sing the standards better than ANY of those judges and is respected industry-wide for his voice, musicianship and range singing various styles. Very glad Harry Connick Jr. called out the punitive critique Randy gave that 'she should have sang the Etta James version'...how unconstructive is that comment?
Dude absolutely, just because you got the Jackson name at the end. Doesn't mean you're some sort of aficionado when it comes to anything music.
Harry Connick is singing and musical royalty and Randy is, well, not.
He’s not related to the Jacksons (Jackson 5) btw. That’s another Randy, in case someone else misunderstands the comment.
Harry knew what he was talking about. How would she craft her signature style by singing as another great, as Randy said?
She should learn the original and interpret it in her own “bluesy” way, not copy/paste Etta’s version. That’s the difference in artistry, and why there were so many covers in the 60s and 70s yet each version had its own unique sound or feeling.
Simon Cowell may have been a great producer and judge of singers, but Harry actually knows the technicals and can judge people beyond first impressions. He should have been on the show long ago.
Simon cowell is a fantastic judge of what is saleable. Not what’s good. There are plenty of phenomenal singers he would never have signed.
Harry is the type of person that given the opportunity, would have signed many of those artists cowell wouldn’t fuck with.
If cowells output was a restaurant, he would be fast food. Harry would be a Michelin star restaurant.
Not just the technicals. Harry knows the ART as well. The very heart and soul of music.
Can't say I'm a fan of his singing just because it's not my favorite style, but holy shit I'm a fan of this man. He's trying to teach them how to be actual singers, not pop stars, and he's raising the musical IQ of the country too. If I was a singer on this show, I'd want to workshop my song with him for every minute they'd let me.
"Don't sing notes that are not in the chords." A literal and metaphorical lesson to live by. A profound statement. Find your individuality and personality in other ways. The chasm between knowledge and respect for music and wannabe singers never shined more brightly than when Harry was on this panel. Loved seeing those willing and able to learn.
Is Harry the first person to challenge contestants like this? I always wondered why judges never addressed the artistic aspects of the song being performed. They're usually just all technical or emotional.
Unfortunately AI was not really about music. It was always about the high notes and the number of notes one can shove in a phrase. Smoke and mirrors, but no substance.
@@Timliu92nailed it. So few lasting stars for this exact reason.
I love the fact that Harry fought back against tidal wave of melisma that infects pop singing. Gratuitous is damn right.
"Tidal wave of melisma." Nailed it, King Lich, nailed it.
Finally. What a relief. Can he possibly be the first professional to think this?
So ironic that they made Harry, an extremely intelligent musician, the vocal coach and then the judges proceeded to completely disregard what he tried to teach the singers.
Because they don't know half of what Harry knows about music! They were intimidated by him, so they disagreed with him. Ego problems.
Absolutely brilliant! Never thought i would hear musicality taught on Idol :) Harry is a legend!
Lol when he said that some 14 year olds in the audience won't get it refering to the girls skilled singing, he's speaking the damn truth!
Much love ❤❤❤
I just love this fateful moment when Harry first took his seat on the judges' panel. I remember watching this at the time and being so impressed with how smart, knowledgeable, logical, dispassionate, candid and funny Harry was. I remember thinking: "He would make an amazing judge!"
The man knows music structure.
Knows when to to emphasize,when to tone it down and when to just let it flow and keep it simple.
True musician right there
What Harry said here is totally right. My vocal coach also told me the same thing - understand the song, get the melody right first and put your interpretation accordingly. Avoid using runs unnecessarily and stop trying too hard to be someone else. Emulate first, interpret afterwards. Unfortunately nowadays excessive use of riffs and runs and in-tune yelling tend to get misinterpreted as soulfulness or emotional singing.
Its the same thing in dance, you have to have the foundation, the base before you even begin to understand how to build on it. My first dance teacher used to always say, "you can't build a house from the roof down.."
Ancient history for me, back in music school my homework included translating the italian, french and german songs for my voice lessons, as well as lots of time in the music library with headphones on listening to great lyric sopranos. Understanding the song, and having great models apply!
Stephen Sondheim said that many young people are auditioning for shows and struggle with the necessity of performing the original music as it’s written on the page. They want to put their own stamp on it.
As one of the great conductors of his time, George Szell, Cleveland Orchestra's 4th Music Director, honored the composers of what they intended with their music. I would like to add Julia Fischer, who honors them too, and some of the music I enjoy listening to her play are Max Bruch and Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky's violin concertos.
The thing too is that there ARE songs that are written with the kind of emotion for belting and sass, and really nailing a vocal... "Think! Think about what you're trying to do to me." (Aretha). Or how about, "Don't you dare walk away from me, i have nothing...nothing...nothing" (Whitney). Those express the kind of emotion that a lot of these singes want to sing. But "I'm a little lamb that's lost in the wood," should not be belted while dancing around the melody like crazy. These kids have incredible talent, and have NO idea how to use it.
Just goes to show Harry Connick Jr. is a TRUE artist of the modern era. He's a good and true vocal coach and song interpreter. He learned from the best and those who learn from him will learn from the best too
He reminds me of ever great vocal instructor and/or instrument instructor I've ever had and he's not pretending to be overly kind for the camera. Just one more reason to love this man. Harry Connick is a national treasure.
Bloody hell. I've never seen this show, never even listened to this guy perform, but man, he deserves REAL respect for his insights and integrity. What a golden level of mentorship.
Here's the thing, if this was real vocal contest for aspiring professional singers, chances are Harry wouldn't have to tell the singers to learn the meaning of the lyric or learn the melody as it is. They know that already He is dealing with more of a raw talents here... someone with good natural voice/talent but has very little knowledge/ability in terms of what musicality is.. so he is right, these singers do need to learn the lyric/melody before they move on and do their own thing.
btw I don't think harry is necessary against doing runs and "licks" per se, I think he just wants these people to make sure they have the basics right before they do that, and to be able to use them in such a way that it actually serves the music, and not just a tool to show off. After all, a lot of jazz is about making the song your own thing.
But also not to do licks and runs for their own sake. The music needs to call for it. The emotional tone needs to call for it.
Well said.
@@MrSF247 I think that's what he meant by " and to be able to use them in such a way that it actually serves the music, and not just a tool to show off."
We are talking about a man who inserts and extra beat into a measure to get the audience to clap in correct time. He is truly one of the great musicians.
That's easy and obvious.
@@terri6854Is it that obvious or easy? Why hadn't anyone done it before?
I want Harry Connick Jr to be my vocal coach.
No kidding, right?! Class act and he gets it. Love that guy.
Aha! Fancy seeing you here sam!!
Me too! And I don't even sing!!
I want Harry to be EVERYBODY'S vocal coach. The state of pop music would improve 1000%. He definitely knows MUSIC, and that's where a musician HAS to start.
What a great teacher 👨🏫
Yes. This. So/too many people confuse positive feedback with constructive criticism.
Harry's words need to be relayed to those singing our National Anthem. The over-trilling and gratuitous embellishment drive me crazy. Sad that competitive singing shows like this force singers to over-do their interpretations in order to stand out. They could learn from Nat Cole, Sinatra, and Patsy Cline, among others, to learn restraint and truth.
Don't forget Tony Bennett ! And Andy Williams ! And Johnny Mathis !
this show would've been amazing w/ voice professors and educated musicians like harry. maybe then, the american public wouldn't spend $ on crap. so many people just can't recognize quality. if someone doesn't know what they're doing, they don't deserve your money. there are way too many pretenders out there, masquerading as pros.
Wow- Harry is a critic after my own heart! He is so real and tries to make these singer really understand the song they are singing. When you truly know about the song and have internalized it- you can sing with confidence and with passion!
It’s actually harder for most people NOT to add licks to their singing. It’s much more impressive to sing something straight and hold onto notes w/o excessive vibrato or trills.
I think you're right. The voice is susceptible to shaking when holding a note.
@@mistermastermind528 Both of you are correct. These licks actually cover up mistakes and a weaker voice, yet the laymen claps and is wowed by them.
I think being straightforward sounds boring but if u add runs and vibrato then it sounds better but only when it’s needed. I remember singing for church and my pastor said just keep it straightforward and I did but it wasn’t in me to keep doing that shit lol
@@martinrueda93 or at the very least learn it straight first, and then add licks later.
Randy wants to sell records, Harry wants to make them better musicians. Keith knows whats up this WHOLE time.
Randy wants $$$. Harry understands artistry. Worlds apart.
And Nikki is... there...
8:30
@@a2ndopynyn and music composition.
Yes. Finally someone who cares about the art and true spirit of the sing. American Idol is about narcissism, however, so it makes sense that many of the singers just want to perform and don't really care about the intention of the sing.
Harry Connick Jr. is exactly what that show needs. Someone who really knows what they are doing and who can give these singers real guidance, not just some general I like it or I don't with no real reasoning behind it. I think he's giving the show a depth that it never had before.
WOW! Harry is a musician who actually knows what he is talking about. This was so refreshing! Maybe people will start to understand what it really takes to create great music.
Excellent constructive advice from Harry Connick Jr.. A lot of the time contestants are just singing the lyrics without getting into the real meaning behind the songs. I'm glad someone finally commented on that!
I remember listening to HCJ when I was young young kid, especially the christmas albums. But that is what trickled me into his work. He really is the best thing to happen to American Idol. He plays the critic, but for once. Actually knows what he is talking about when he is critical. Musicians wise, not corporate wise.
Sharp as a knife, this bloke, and he provides exactly what aspiring singers need to be told. Not knowing is a shortcoming; not being bothered to get to know is sinful.
I knew the moment Harry put Randy in his place that he'd be a good fit as a judge after this pitiful season. I think they need to get Mary J. Blige on there also because she too was good at offering support but at the same time still being able to explain ways to improve. Nicki and Steven can only compliment looks, and Mariah would just say things like "That was a good song choice."
Harry, you are so right on. Too many runs...lose the deep feeling shown in the notes and lerics. Harry was a favorite with my son (who was a great musician) and we shared his songs...and he put down a Mom's music..one being Harry's "Recipe for Making Love".....not on up on the shelf or in my grandma's kitchen...or something...Memories with my son who went to heaven are precious to me.
6:25
"What version is your...?"
"It's the song"
Exactly! Ha
He single handidly is making this show more watchable.
HCJR is a class act and a TRUE MUSICIAN.
I love how Harry educates the masses on musical terms. The contestants need to learn a little terminology along the way if they already don't know some. Singing is not all about "riffs' and "licks", it's about skill, emotion, and sheer talent and sometimes songs should help you remember something special in your life.
Harry knows what he's talking about & I'm so glad he's Randy's replacement this year. He's a breath of fresh air! He's the only reason I'm watching AI this season.
I love Harry. I agree with him that all of those singers add unnecessary licks, and by doing so, it takes away from the emotional connection. I'm still working on that myself. I try to study the lyrics of songs before I sing to get a better understanding of the meaning.
Funny how after Harry shares his wise and insightful comments Randy utters that inspirational drivel "always be yourself" and everyone cheers...
Well 'being yourself' is the ultimate goal of all singers, but like what Connick said, if you are only emulating another cover version of the song, you are not being yourself. Unfortunately Randy and Harry did not seem to think in the same frame of mind.
+Timliu92 no, being a great singer is the goal. Everyone needs training and there's things about themselves that they need to change, not be. Sinatra for instance would never have been great if he did not work tirelessly to change his natural accent into clear english diction, a clarity that he became known for. This "be yourself" nonsense is getting out of control. Yes, seek the goals YOU want but make the necessary changes to yourself in order to reach your goal
How ironic that Randy stated 'Be Yourself' in an industry that tells you who to be in order to have a deal.....
@@TheJimmyClip Exactly!! Randy personifies why the major label record industry is dying a painfully slow death! Their attitude is “Let’s sell repetitive crap to people who don’t know music but who will buy it because it’s shiny and sounds like last quarters big cookie cutout performer and make a quick buck from “music fans” who they liked that song but who’s singers name they can barely remember because they are so interchangeable.
But sadly and eventually, this “record buying” demographic will start to realize that all the music they like, sounds the same. And that will be true, because record companies don’t take many real chances on new sounds by true musicians unless it’s been sterilized, quantified, and strategized by non musical minded accountants for its money making ability based on research and statistics from last years quarterly report of this same musics genre.
Then because simply sounds like last seasons flavor with a new hairstyle, that same “music fan” will opt to not buy their album but perhaps just get the single on a music buying platform or simply add it to their favorite playlist on Spotify, Slacker or Apple Music.. in which case the artist will get roughly 1/5 of a penny for the song while the owner of the platform will become a billionaire. All the while the truly gifted singers and songwriters will have to find other ways to generate a living which means non music work, or writing music for others ( if they’re lucky) or aiming for another musical demographic that no one including their long time supporting fans likes and then releasing an album that have critics calling a sellout or subpar material.
Harry is asking the artist to be an musical artist! Not a smoke and mirror clone that will be big tomorrow then gone next week! The truth that Harry speaks might be what saves music in the long run!
Exactly right!! I enjoy him immensely but Randy is speaking like an industry salesman right now and this personifies why the major label record industry is dying a painfully slow death! Their attitude is “Let’s sell repetitive and non unique crap to people who don’t know music but who will buy it because it’s shiny and sounds like last quarters big cookie cutout performer , and make a quick buck from “music fans” who liked that song cause it’s familiar but who’s singers name they can barely remember because they are so interchangeable.
Of course, sadly and eventually, this “record buying” demographic will start to realize that all the music they like, sounds the same. And that will be true, because these days, record companies Who are owned by non-musical mega corporations won’t take many real chances on new sounds by true musicians unless it’s been sterilized, quantified, and strategized by non musical minded accountants for its money making ability; based on research and statistics from last years quarterly report of this same musics genre.
Then because this new hit simply sounds like last seasons flavor with a new hairstyle, that very same prized “music fan” will opt to not buy the artists album but perhaps, just buy the single on a music buying platform or more likely, just add the song to their favorite playlist on Spotify, Slacker or Apple Music.. in which case the artist will get roughly 1/5 of a penny for the song while the owner of the platform will become a billionaire. All the while the truly gifted singers and songwriters will have to find other ways to generate a living which means non music work, or writing music for others ( if they’re lucky) which means fewer releases by the artist or the artist aiming for success in another musical genre or demographic, that no one including their long time supporting fans likes. And then releasing an album that will have fans and critics calling the music a sellout or subpar material.
I’ve been in this biz for 30+ plus years. This is not where it’s going. This is where it’s at and this is where it’s been for a while now. This is why your favorite artist keeps putting the same thing out over and over again, This is why they keep trying to do other styles that don’t work for them. And it’s why they don’t even bother releasing new albums and just tour, charging more fir tickets but just keep playing their old material.
Harry connick jr is absolutely right! I get so tired of everyone singing the same way on idol!
I like how Harry dropped 'Kim Burrell' in there. Kim Burrell is a really good singer to study if you wanna do really good riffs and runs.
Totally. And Kim can scat like Ella. I saw her live a few years ago doing jazz tunes and her intonation alone is amazing.
Deanna Witkowski I envy you. I would give anything just to hear her sing live. Too bad I live all the way over here in New Zealand.
Finally, somebody talking real sense on one of these shows!! Everybody now is trying to turn songs into soul versions!! Harry makes perfect sense. Learn the melody and simplicity!!!
Harry: "when you say My Funny Valentine, what does that mean?"
Girl: "like, your valentine is just like, funny"
smh
We don't need to shame people for not knowing things. Are you suggesting Harry's tutelage is useless? Let's not mock people for learning!
@@rosselliottsmith3120 So true. This is why most song isnt straight up to the point. Most have hidden meaning and not knowing is the best way to learn. That why the saying "Live, Learn, and Never repeat."
Frankly, these kids are probably not used to hearing meaningful, clever lyrics. That's why the standards are so great!
@@rosselliottsmith3120 We do need people who claim to be "artists" to do just a BIT of the work.
I have to respect HCJ. The kind of shallow drivel that goes on on American Idol is quite frankly, beneath him as a musician. Instead of saying "I want no part of this crap" he instead chose to try and at least teach these singers something of value for once.
My sister is a vocal coach and this is one of the many techniques/critiques she has. Song the original tune. Sing like you yes, but not the you that wants to sound a certain way as in sounding like another artist. Know the song, feel the song. ... even, be the song. Act it out. Uhh. . Foolish people. .. Harry is really the only good judge ever.
Harry brought honesty and high level a musical expertise. Love it!
there's a reason he's had a spectacular and successful career spanning more than two decades. he just gets it. i'm so glad he's on AI. I didn't even watch the show last season at all. Plus he doesn't BS what's going on but says it in a very sincere way if you listen to what he's actually saying. Very constructive criticism.
Harry, Thank god for you!. To tell this young people the truth is the best thing that you could do. You don't need made up vocal gymnastics to sing the great standards, The foundation first is to know the song and what the lyric is about and to stop tring to channel the stylist you like to sell it, does not work, bring what you naturally have to the table, nothing more. Teach Harry, TEACH!
I agree with Harry completely. The noodling and runs have gotten completely out of hand. There's singing, then there's "vocal gymnastics". We're seeing to little of the former and way too much of the latter. Listen to Billie, Lena, Aretha, Nat "king" Cole and the other greats.They are at their best staying true to the melody.
Agree
Agreed
Jeff Goldblum really knows his stuff!
Love Harry's critiques - so bang on! I love these girls voices but Standards are so simple yet powerful and don't need the power voice to distract from their melodic amazingness! If you can sing a standard and connect you , the audience and the song then you are really an amazing singer!
just shared it with my students, basic melody and what you are singing about, yes Harry, thx for sharing with us Beanton Swing Orchestra!
This man was New Orleans born and raised. Classically trained. At nine could play any Beethoven or Bach. I saw him at The Jazz Festival in 1980 when he was 12. Too smart and too honest and way too much of a musician for American Idol.
🏆🏆🏆🏆
He’s got SOUL! I’m also from New Orleans, ifs all about the delivery. The emotion
So refreshing to see some actually solid music coaching on that show. Great advice from Harry
OMG he has the most a.m.a.z.i.n.g way of encouraging while correcting! Oh to be schooled by Harry oxoxoxoxo
He's what every singer actually wants in a judge on a show/talent contest... someone who won't let you walk out the door without giving you constructive criticism that you can work with!
To me he was the best mentor and judge in Idol history.
Harry is the man, so it’s in their best interest to listen and take on Baird anything he has to say. Jazz is sacred and he knows that
Yes Harry!!! educate Randy!!! Its actually hilarious how clueless some of these people are
I liked the fact that Harry was really trying to coach and not just being nice and telling everybody was good
Wow, Harry is a legit super qualified premium coach, all his comments made absolutely musical sense...!!!!! I'm a fan
It's embarrassing when you see those clowns on the panel made uneducated comments....smh.
Harry Connick Jr. is spot on with all of his guidance here. And he nailed Jackson's contradiction by saying "Be yourself by being this person...".
These YOUNGSTERS better listen to this guy because HE'S THE REAL DEAL !! He's just a THOROUGHBRED when it comes to his craft - some of the old Sinatra songs he does JUST AS WELL IF NOT BETTER then Frank ever did !!
Thank you Harry. Your advice to your candidates apply also to me since I am now starting a music career at 65! There is NO AGE FOR MUSIC!
At the end... I am 1,000,000% with Harry! He's so right! And this show needed someone to call attention to all the wishy-washy b.s. that the judges tell the contestants! And props to Harry for making Nicki and Mariah uncomfortable!!! So great!
School these fake ass singers Harry, show them vocal gymnastics it isn't right, love to Harry!
It's a pleasure to listen to someone who knows what he's talking about - and with heart.
Real musician vs. Randy
If I recall he’s a pretty good bass player.
@@frankburn6312 He is...but I think it’s clear that Harry comes from a more astute angle when it comes to the nuances and styles of music. I really can’t stand AI, but based on these clips Harry is more into musicianship and the qualities of what makes music art, as opposed to Randy being into image, what gets the quick applause and given the fade away manner that most of these “American Idol’s” find themselves in after the show, I think the latter is a bit disingenuous and honestly “Not for me Dawg.”
@@lateralus747 the thing is , most of music have based on “image and what gets the quick applause” ie “show business “ vs music and art , ie “classical music and jazz”.
@@frankburn6312 I don’t agree with that sentiment at all. To say something like “most music” is a sweeping generalization I think. I’d agree with your statement if it was a bit more detailed, maybe something along the lines of most music that is marketed for the mainstream or for reasons of mass consumption or commercialization. There is a lot of music that is geared for reasons of art and expression that don’t just sit in the realms of classical or jazz. I would say it’s just that music and entertainment marketing is such a multilayered endeavor that the business or to use your word, show business, makes it appear as to what the business has to offer or sell is the only thing music should or has to be. Not to say that there is anything wrong with making money from music...it’s how I make my living. But the industry has changed a lot. And what has been deemed good has also changed...a lot.
I’ll leave you with this as an example. Imagine you were told your whole life that McDonalds gave you everything that you ever needed or wanted as far as food. Quality, flavors, nutrition etc. But then one day you magically come across a grocery store and find the variety of food that is available to you, is fresh and far more sustaining on so many different levels, more so than McDonalds. All I’m saying is most of the mass marketed mainstay that is the music industry bastardizes everything that is inherently valuable about what music is. It’s often overlooked by dollar signs and other gimmicks that people don’t realize is a McDonalds double cheeseburger when in fact a fresh burger would be so much more fulfilling and satiating on various levels.
@@lateralus747 I meant “most popular music”. (What American idol is based on).
Advise to Randy:
It is better to be quiet and thought an idiot than to to open your mouth and remove all doubt....
Harry Connick, Jr. is my hero!!!
I am surprised all these commenters are surprised... LOL!! You should all know Harry Connick's background. He is a child piano playing prodigy. He was playing with the best of them at a very early age so he has been taught the foundations of Jazz and Blues by real masters. He is a master class teacher.
Harry is the man. Been a fan of his my whole life. He makes it look like none of them know music. Love it.
When u know u know! HC jr is a proffessional musician and a talented freak of Jazz músic..Randy it was always a minority fill in as a black person on The judge pannel, Harry knows what's up and also showed all of us on national tv, that Randy has no idea of what a definition of music is!!
Getting mentoring from a real artist like HC Jr is probably the most valuable thing these contestants got from being on American Idol.
Perfect video to explain how jazz standards need to be perceived by young vocalists. I love Harry's approach and emphasis on "the original melody first" .
Serious jazz musician. So much respect for this man. Such great advice too - please just sing the melody and think about the lyrics.
HCJ I can say he is a legend...it really shows how he was properly and perfectly raised as a person... a perfect example to his children
I'm with Harry...
Wow te gek!
They have a panel full of people who don't really know musicality. The only ones I would trust in a critique would be harry or mariah. The rest are just smoke and mirrors.
I have NEVER heard an American Idol singer except for Michael Buble who could even come close to being able to sing American Standards. None of them have any concept of melody to speak of and for them to think that Harry Connick Jr. can give that to them in just a few days while I had to work my ass off at music school for FOUR YEARS to understand it is insane.
You are correct especially since harry has been honing his skills since he was a kid.
Yes he has. It never stops.
Gold for Harry! I have always loved teachers like him. Teaching the right way. Much respect
I knew I loved Harry Connick Jr. but this made me appreciate and love him more. Great coach!
best season of american idol, these are world class vocalists
So much respect for Harry. Nice to see someone who knows what they’re talking about
I now understand what Harry Connick was trying to advise Kree and completely agree with him - go to the basic version to understand the lyrics more and do it your own way afterwards. Randy has been a confusing judge all these time and especially those days when Simon was still around. It's really better for real artists to do the critique-ing as they're the ones who understand the craft better.
Harry is a musical god.
Harry Connick Jr. Is my Spirit Animal
I love this. Teach these kids something Harry.
So sick iiik eah ick of riffles
I hope those girls appreciate how lucky they were to get what was hands down the best and realest advice anyone ever got on that show
After this lesson I tried playing ‘All The Things You Are’ (Jerome Kern, Oscar Hamerstein-1939) on my guitar (chord/melody style) and to play it straight, (like I’m singing, like playing the lyrics). I was taught about this long ago but I often I still slip into licks and at that point I’m just exploring harmony and melodic possibilities. Then I’ve wandered off the path, lost the portent of the song. It’s self-indulgent and doesn’t honour the composer’s storytelling. When I play it straight, tracking the lyric in my head (not so easy to do) I feel it deeply and am moved to tears by the lover’s affection.
MIX - Harry Connick Jr. on singing standards...a supportive reminder to any musician or singer.
I absolutely L-O-V-E HARRY
This is great! Thank you for sharing Alicia
I always thought aretha had the best overall balance between melodic, emotional simplicity and complicated runs.
Aretha was a just class. You're right about her taste and musicality. There was nothing comlicated about her runs however, they were harmonically correct and rhythmically very strong. If you want to hear complicated I think you have to leave the whole popular idiom. True some singers use excessive ornamentation but it's hardly ever complicated, usually rhythmically pedestrian harmonically basic(sometimes wrong) and irrelevant.
You can't "be yourself" when you're at the "copy your idols" stage of development, with nothing of your own to express, which was where these contestants clearly were. HCJ was actually trying to help them become better musicians. Randy's "advice" sounds helpful on the surface, but really only served to help him make a more informed decision regarding who to cut.
Brilliant critiquing of these singers on how do a song. Learn the melody and know what the hell you're singing about. Simple!
"No, because it's silly."
Finally, a qualified judge!