Part 1/7 - Interview with a nazi ss officer - franz suchomel - Discussion of treblinka gas chambers
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 มี.ค. 2009
- A rare interview with nazi ss officer franz suchomel (Capitalization purposely unused), discussing his experience as an ss officer at treblinka concentration camp August 1942 - October 1943, thereafter sobibor. trieste 1944.
Sentenced to 6 years in 1965. Released in 1969.
suchomel was unaware that the interview was being remotely videotaped by the interviewer Claude Lanzmann's assistants in the Volkswagen bus shown at the beginning of Part 1 of the video.
Click on my profile to view the other 6 parts of the interview.
a very important interview by one of the SS perpetrators at the centre of the extermination programme- well done to Claude Lanzmann for obtaining this important testimony
Yeah. About as important and legit as all the narcissists on social media seeking similar attention. This interview is trash with zero historic value.
Yes the guard died 3 years later so excellent opportunity to get this interview on hidden cam. Difficult to pull this off in the seventies I'm sure.
@@bat__bat who was the man who beat up Lanzmann when he found out he was recorded.
"Important" and "obtained" for what or for whom?
i thank you alot for posting these 7 videos, i'm speechless....
It’s from a documentary. SHOAH from Claude Lanzmann. It’s a 9 hour masterpiece.
It’s all fake
@@Phoenix-pl6ysyou are a fake
@@commissary4196 and You are Jewish
@@commissary4196 and you are ✡️
0:50 That incredibly non-suspicious antenna.
this video is horrible, is an terrorist act , the war is end since 90 ys ago
Hey Nazi apologist Mauro how does 75 = 90?
@@MauroMarcenaro 90??
@@XxBloggs 1 and 2 ww are only one world war, Usa wanted enter in europe, so ... the Kaiser and Nazi helped Us to enter for 2 time in europe, is not hard to understand
“Secretly recorded”
Also only
Got 3/4 years for the alleged crimes, yeah sure absolutely believeble
The interviewer shouldnt interrupt so often. when the person was telling something , he was each time stopped.
this is for money, they don t care the true but what they want that is what who pay want
@@MauroMarcenaro what? Lanzmann worked 16 years doing this documentary. 5 years alone he edited the 350 hours of material he collected. You are in the best case naive worst case you're just cynical fascist
@@finallysomepurpose I guess he mean, that Franz Suchomel only accept the interview for receiving DM 500,-
@@finallysomepurpose"Fascist" is just the slurry talk of a Communist.
The correct term is National-Socialist.
When answering what his first impression of Treblinka was, he replies that it was catastrophic and, “We had not been told how and what...” and then he stops himself and inserts, “that people were being killed there.” I wonder what he was initially going to say. “We had not been told how and what _________”(fill in the blank). Did he interrupt himself because he came close to disclosing pre-knowledge of people being exterminated, or did he just find a better way of saying he didn’t know?
He said it was proven at his trial that he didn’t want to go to Treblinka, but he doesn’t say why. If all it was was guarding prisoners while they worked in factories, I’d be interested in knowing why he was so apparently strongly opposed to going.
I just sorely question his veracity regarding knowledge of the exterminations occurring.
There is no veracity to question, obviously he knew. Considering that this documentary astonishingly shows how every single polish farmer in a radius of X kilometers knew absolutely everything about the camps it’s totally obvious that a nazi official (who was already involved in Aktion T4 for god’s sake) had been briefed and informed long beforehand. You point out the contradiction too - how could he be so apprehensive about going that it’s judicially counted as a mitigating circumstance if he didn’t know anything about the crimes? I wonder what those prosecutors did at the trials… Absolutely useless… The nazis should’ve been extradited to Israel instead of being tried in the pseudo fascist state of West Germany.
That's not really what he meant in German lmao
Why because he had heard things most likely. And secondly Mabe he just had a bad feeling the guy was a tailor.
This old man's death machine didn't stop during WWII to ask questions. He saves his only indignance to claim not eighteen thousand dead per day, but only twelve to fifteen thousand. I can't imagine serving twelve thousand people in one day at the food pantry, much less murdering that many people. Not once does he show emotion or commitment to anything or anyone.
Numerical accuracy matters, especially when a nation is transgenerationally shamed.
THeambereye you've neve been aroudn that many people
Given similar sircumnstances, U probly would act in a similar way to this old man. We all would.
I've watched all 7 parts of this interview. The man is being led by the interviewer, one that didn't ask the hard questions, the contradictions on his descriptions of the events. He was happy with the answers, it suited his agenda and boasted the ego of this old man trying to find his own redemption. Just for this part one:
- He arrived in late August when Treblinka was operating at full capacity (Prt 1 - 2.27). Three trains arrived in two days, each with 3, 4 or 5 thousand people from Warsaw (ghetto being emptied) (Prt 1 - 2:55). At minute 3:04 he states: - other trains arrived from Kielce and other places. So now the trains did not come from Warsaw alone as stated a few moments before.
- Half of the people on the trains was dead (Prt 1 - 3:38) The rest was half dead or half mad. The dead (thousands) were piled up on the ramp like wood (Prt 1 - 4:24). The living were left on the station (Prt 1 - 3:24) were they would wait for 2 or 3 days because the small gas chambers could not keep up even though they functioned day and night (Prt 1 - 4:50). How many small gas chambers were there? Two? He does not clarify. As he does not clarify when the "new" chambers were built.
- On Part 2 he states: More and more people arrived in trains and the small chambers could no cope (Prt 2 - 3:28). So one has to assume that the pile of corpses on the ramp, like wood, grew and grew. Meanwhile the living, waiting there for 3 days foresaw their own death. You bet! As Mount Everest of corpses is there before their eyes on the ramp and the infernal smell from the camp spread for miles (Prt 2 - 2:38) one would assume death was near. Besides they heard the noise of the engine feeding the gas chamber - a tank engine that delivered the poison gas (Prt 4 - 4:45). So now, one engine means one chamber not two. At 4:20 of part 2 he states that women slashed their daughters wrists and then their own. Interesting to see that the mothers were only concerned about the daughters. The sons? Fuck them. Others poisoned themselves (Prt 2 - 4:33). Right, when they left the ghetto they made sure that they carried a cyanide capsule with them...just in case! Or maybe they went into the woods to stuff their noses with poison ivy.
But there are records that show that this SS Officer is way out of reality: - "The first transports to Treblinka came from the Warsaw ghetto. Between the 23rd of July and the 21st of August 1942, a total of 254 000 Jews from Warsaw and 112 000 from other parts of the Warsaw region were murdered here." (www.holocaust.cz/en/history/concentration-camps-and-ghettos/treblinka-3/) - so in less than a month 366 000 people were exterminated at Treblinka. Now let's do the Math. The new chambers - 10 of them in rows of five - out of which only one row was operating (Prt 3 - 00:43) could take each 200 people inside in one go (in accordance with the jews because he, himself, an SS Officer on duty at Treblinka had no fucking idea of how many a chamber could take - but the jews knew, apparently one of them came from the dead after cremation to unveil the magic number). So we get, in one go, believing the number, 1000 jews killed in the 5 chambers. Now how long does it take to remove 200 bodies from a chamber? Is it fare to say one minute each? 200 bodies equals 200 minutes, in other words, more than three hours before the chamber can be used again. In order to "process" 366 000 individuals during those 29 days, 12 621 would have to be killed every day non-stop. This matches is statement in which he claims that 12 to 15 000 were liquidated every day (18 000 was excessive) (Prt 4 - 4:34) but, considering that you can liquidate 1000 (5 x 200) per each 4 hours (the killing takes time as well), you would be capable of having 6 "sessions" per day max at full capacity with no engine breakdowns, no maintenance, no disruptions during a full month. That is half of the required turnover of 12.6 "sessions" per 24 hours. He states that everyday 100 jews were selected to drag the bodies to the mass graves (Prt 2 - 1:23) but in the evening they were gassed or shot by the Ukranians. So that means that during the night there was no one to remove and drag bodies to the mass graves, further reducing the killing rithm. Get the picture? Someone is lying.
Back to SS suchomel and his bullshit on Part 2 soon.
You wrote this moronic shit thinking someone will take it seriously?
u did it. U cracked the code. I told them u were getting close. But now with your amazing analytical ability u figured it out. Good for u...
"Those who cannot remember the past are condemned to repeat it" George Santayana
Wow...that was soooo deep
Yes, I remember this ! It is very true !
Jews repeat it, so Georgie must have been right.
Given similar sircumnstances, U probly would act in a similar way to this old man. We all would.
And now we have those with full exploited memory of their collective past doing likewise in their present,,?
Suchomel is SLAVIC name, he is German from Bohemia (Czechia), which was part of Austria before ww2. He did was in jail 6 years BEFORE this interview
Should have got the firing squad.
@@Ujuani68 what do you mean ?
@@zazie7672this recording is a scam. The rubbish people believe. Most people are stupid. Am so far above them in IQ.
@@antoneckhart4010sure
God this is horrifying! I am an educated man, a longtime history teacher-yet watching this man casually discussing his part in making sure the Holocaust ran smoothly is just nauseating. One thing to teach about it, another to see it in person. So many trains arriving so quickly made him work very hard (At killing people), and we are supposed to feel sympathy or at least understand that was just his job? Scum. Yet I get the feeling that the world is never far away from repeating this type of horror, based on the nature of humans. Tough watch, but important.
Agreed, you never know what's in a persons head. How did he escape the Nuremberg Trails? Totally disgusting it got away with three years.
Tell us what you would have done. You would have gone along with it too. It’s one thing to be at home watching this video when almost 100 years and an ocean separates you from the crime, quite another to experience what Suchomel and others like him experienced. You are either not as educated on the subject as you should be or you are just not being logical. There are very few heroes on the German side from that period. Many disagreed, but they kept their mouths shut. You would have been the same if you had been assigned to a death camp back then. Protest all you want, reality trumps you. Watch or read more perpetrator testimonies and read the book “Ordinary Men”. That might help.
@@Storytime2023x And how about you, would you have gone along with it also?
As if politicians, many of them Jews, even care.
@@user-ox7xr8nu4t Get help.
Why did he only get a six year sentence??? i wonder
You need to put the whole post WWII era in historical perspective. The Nuremberg trials were conducted by the Allied powers and it's not like the Nazis stood-up and suddenly admitted they were wrong after the war. Many Nazis or Nazi sympathizers retained positions of authority after the war. West Germany was reticent to conduct many war crime trials of their own accord until the 90s when the post war generation realized that the country had adopted a conscious level of amnesia to the war crimes. Hence the reason why many of the 'real criminals' were either given 'token' sentences, allowed to live peacefully in post-war Germany, or allowed to escape to other countries with new identities. When you see trials these days it's typically low level guards who were not active participants in the Holocaust. In a sense, modern Germany is soothing their guilt of not having done anything for decades by prosecuting a bunch of 80 and 90 year old men. Hope this helps...
@@johngrace199 This went on into the next generation: the young ones who asked the "wrong" questions, who criticised this amnesia, who wanted open discussions and clarification of responsibilities were often called criminal and accused to be communists. A standard sentence for blocking every critics was "If you don't like it here, go to the east" (east Germany and/or the communist countries). The old generation was fed up with war. They concentrated on building up Germany again, they wanted to work and then enjoy life, not to think about the past and feel guilty.
@@yunshuiseng8 Not sure where you're from...but I was struck by some of the language you used. The "if you don't like it go east" mentality...we see that it many segments of American culture today. For many...we have the ideals spoken of in the Declaration of Independence...ideals codified into legal law via the federal Constitution. Today...there are those like myself who 'point out' where we as a society have fallen short of those ideals. Not that we as a society are bad or evil...but that we should always strive to live up to what we could be. Whereas the other side...based out of fear, a protection of the status quo, or for any number of other reasons see that mentality as a don't like it, go somewhere else. Whether it's Germany, the US, or elsewhere...perhaps all cultures undergo the same social pressures. I agree with your statement by the way...
He agreed to lie
I don’t understand the "spy" dramatization in the wolks waggen is this a real interview?
Wenn ich mir das Interview anhöre, insbesondere wenn Suchomel seine Erfahrungen erklärt, ist es ziemlich schwierig zu sagen, wie er Treblinka wirklich empfand. Ich würde gerne mehr darüber erfahren, wie er als Person in Treblinka war und welche Aufgaben er hatte. Kommt er manchmal auch wirklich reuig rüber, obwohl man nicht absolut sicher sein kann? Ich finde die Interviews äußerst interessant, obwohl das einzige Wissen, das ich zu diesem Thema habe, das ist, was ich in der Schule gelernt habe. Grüße aus Namibia
The full interview gives an insight on this. It's about 4 hours long
I didnt say I didnt understand what happened I simply meant I dont understand how people can deny that it happened with so much evidence. Take a look below at the comment made by Scott. He says it all.
it happend like in japan 2 atom bombs in 2 cities , the same war the same ppl in germany and in usa uk and france, where are the good men ??
@@MauroMarcenaro you can’t fight evil without evil. How are you meant to stop an imperialistic nation that’s already invaded 15+ counties without fighting back? They dropped the bomb so they could end the war.... > which they did :)
The same way you ignore the camps in North Korea and CHina today. The same we ignore the suffering in Yemen. The same way we ignored the Genocidal actions in the Congo, Rwanda, ex-Yugoslavia, Cambodia etc. It is easy to put suffering of others out of mind.
@@billburr5881 Usa have build 2 war every 10 ys, always kill citizen for 80% of the dead , iraq abugraib ? Guantanamo?
@@billburr5881 So true
A few questions about this film: Why has Claude Lanzmann admitted that the German 'witnesses' of this film had been paid 3.000 deutschmarks (a considerable sum of money in the 70's) to 'testify' in his movie? Do 'History' and 'Truth' need money to be told? Wasn't money the first purpose of those late 'confessions'? Why are we lied and said that the video camera was hidden in a bag (what is obviously not the case)? What else are we lied about?
This is from the 11+ hour dokumentation Shoa.
Watch it, it's on youtube (8 parts)
Once I finish the 15 hour Stalingrad audio book on TH-cam I will
not 11, but 9 h
I have watched Lanzmann's Shoa-films decades ago and they left a life-long effect on my little existence. Some of his interviews hit me like a flash and left me utterly crying. I never read Hannah Arendt, but I believe Lanzmann in his films made visible the "Banalität des Bösen". His work was very important and will always be; it should be part of the curriculum of at least every German school.
How could he just get 3 years in jail for what he did ? Guess eternal judgment will be worse for him
I will say Stalin had the right mind set when it came to these people.
@@MrOuija-rr8kq Yeah Stalin was much better, not a monster at all.
Donitz did life in jail for litteraly nothing, don't be so quick, sounds strange to me as well but if we question justice with no basis we are doing populism, as them
Easy for u to ask in 2023 😂😂 u have no idea how the allies chose to deal with the Nazis lmao😂
@@mplslawnguy3389STALIN WAS WAYYY WORSE THEN HITLER
That interview is incredible!
Thanks! i always looking for it.
@43slax that is an outstanding point i never thought of. well done!
@HistorySpeaks4Itself i've read quite a few of your comments over several sites & i must say sir you're very insightful & knowlegable and i very much appreciate you posting this very interresting documentary. great job!
Suchomel war für die Haare zuständig(100Stühle!!!)Und ein gemeiner Sadiest!Schlimmer war nur Kurt Franz der seinen Hund Barry auf die Genitalien der Arbeitsjuden anrichtete!!!
"The victors write the history books."
Jacques M But it’s a loser who talks truth here.
Jacques M .the nazis wrote there own
You’re a f*cking idiot. This guy isn’t a victor is he? You don’t need to rely on history books, there are still survivors you piece of sh*t
@@klausfawkes5812 What you omitted "Klaus" is MURDERER!
Horrific hearing it from perpetrator but 1st hand testiment incredibly important.
Whatever You need to believe to feel comfortable and make Your thesis fit, Sir.
"Dedication" must be your middle name bro.
And thank you very much for this info
It appears Mr. Suchomel is a liar.
thanks for the upload
Oh, maybe this quote from the forensic investigation in 1945 will help:
"... In the northwestern section of the area, the surface is covered for about 2 hectares by a mixture of ashes and sand. In this mixture, one finds countless human bones, often still covered with tissue remains, which are in a condition of decomposition..."
Thank you for repeating that. Gives us a nice insight into the total disregard for human lives the Nazis displayed.
What an evil but fascinating dude.
Aus einem Podcast-Interview mit Sturdy Colls:
"CSC: I’ve identified a number of buried pits using geophysical techniques. These are considerable. One in particular is 26 meters by 17 meters.
JC:
That’s huge.
CSC: It is huge, that we’re talking a considerable number of bodies could have been contained within pits of that size."
Ich hab sie dir doch schon fein säuberlich aufgelistet, die Dokumente. ;)
Nachti!^^
This van is just set up for video, right? They weren't actually bugging the interview were they?
Suchomel was not aware, nor did he consent to being recorded. Lanzmann used a ruse to arrange this interaction.
Suchomel was put on trial, and anyone put on trial in Germany for these offenses was liable to be tried again if they ever changed their testimony. That's what happened to SS Oberhauser, who recanted his Belzec testimony later on. (That's why Oberhauser wouldn't talk to Lanzmann) Therefore, it is a certainty that Suchomel would not say anything to violate the mandated story, under threat that Lanzmann could make a complaint and have him put on trial again.
good point. why would anyone in his "predicament" (possible new trial and another prison sentence very likely) "come clean"..? he made sure he did not reveal anything that could further incriminate him.
Strange that this video has been made unavailable in UK or Germany. I had to use a USA VPN to watch.
Funny how wokeism censoring everything unwanted for the sake of the greater good.Thats exactly what they did in nazi germany,and the end was total appcalypse.
I'm watching from UK just fine bud, I also switched my VPN to Germany and it also worked just fine, think you have another issue
A Patriot... no probably not. I have great pride for my country as I expect you have for yours. We both live in young nations, both of which have gone through many struggles in their existences. I just believe that we need to look at what was done in the past both the good and the bad, and learn to make the world better. Understanding what our forefathers did wrong allows us to move away from doing making the same mistakes.
part 2+3 not available in germany.
good old censorship
Not true, Parts 2 and 3 do not seem to be available anywhere in the world, Reason?
Yeah UK too, I think somebody is hiding something, hmm look for another source!
th-cam.com/video/U411bgyzj1Y/w-d-xo.html
Full interview available. th-cam.com/video/jtgXqNsXsrE/w-d-xo.html
Found it instantly
Actually I was going to recommend it!
The Jewish population has notoriously been the scapegoats for governments (especially european) for over a thousand years. But if you were to look at Jews in Germany before the rise of Nazism how do you think they would identify themselves? The majority would say they were German, wouldn't you agree? As for Bolshevism, Jewish people were present of course, but so were Christians, neither Lenin nor Stalin were Jewish, and the Soviets were just as bad to their Jewish population as the Nazis.
@HistorySpeaks4Itself I just want to thank you for posting this. So many deniers and anti-semites around that sadly these videos are crucial really. Can't believe that these deniers and anti-semites exist even though in 2010.
I've now watched all of the videos. It does make me wonder what long term effect this had on the reporter?
He worked on this film for over a decade. Towards the beginning his close friends died. He used unused footage to release other films, including one a year before he died. So it followed him forever. If you don't know of him, he is French and Jewish, and was part of the resistance during the war.
"The death of one man is a tragedy, the death of millions is a statistic."
Joseph Stalin
He'd know.
How did they get the video? Is a camera in the room? The antenna is for the audio right? Not my expertise
For what they claim, how much coal do you think they needed?
More than the Germans had in reality, for sure.
Holocaust deniers: this old man being interviewed has nothing to do with you. His cruel indifference to the suffering of all people is obvious. He doesn't pause to rail against anyone or anything. He doesn't share your concern for the plight of the Palestinian. His words are passionless. He doesn't care about you, his victims, or anyone else.
Such a fantasy though. His claims are incredibly suspicious.
What the f are you rambling about? 😂
I hope people at least feel that 4 or five years was no where enough punishment for this coward.
He still had more work to do. Like Parton said, we fought the wrong enemy in WWII
@@Patrickstarrrrr69 bro go fix your receeding hariline before saying fucked up shit like that
@@Patrickstarrrrr69 no. We fought the right enemy.
@@OliverFlinn give it few more decades and we will all witness degenerate society we live in
He was just a guard, 4 or 5 years is about right
Years ago i saw an other part of this recording in which Suchomel was talking about watching a group of jews who were working as Sonderkommando. It were the very last weeks of Treblinka, the RedArmy was real close that moment. Suchomel said, he was talking with those Jews and told them something like "don't worry. You are safe as members of Sonderkommando. You will save your life when its over." And one of them answered to Suchomel "No, boss. We are nothing like deaths on vacation yet".
Better in German: Nein Chef, wir sind nur Leichen im Urlaub"
It seems a lot of the parts have been removed from TH-cam. Is there any other way to watch them?
it looks to me as if this was filmed with normal video equipment, but then played back on a CRTV and re-recorded.
How horrible to suddenly come upon this horror when you were just trained to guard not this.
Just trained to guard . Guard criminals? No . He was guarding Jews. Did he know why? Yes. The leader, Hitler, told him too. No questions asked.
The Jewish Encyclopedia: “Khazars, a NON-Semitic, Asiatic, Mongolian tribal
nation who emigrated into Eastern Europe about the first century, who were
converted as an entire nation to Judaism in the seventh century by the
expanding Russian nation which absorbed the entire Khazar population, and
who account for the presence in Eastern Europe of the great numbers of
Yiddish-speaking Jews in Russia, Poland, Lithuania, Galatia, Besserabia
and Rumania.”
Can you read?
Why wasn't Suchomel put on trial?If what he said is true he's at least as guilty as Demjanjuk.
Love how people can comment and pass judgement yet were no where near living during that time. So easy to say “ I would have done this or that etc.” bullshit cos in reality you have no fucking idea what you would or wouldn’t in that situation if you had to make choices right there on the spot.
franz suchomel (Capitalization purposely unused)
i like you lol.
Excellent reply.
the second part of this series can't be copied with clip grab, all the other parts can!
"Crime against humanity happened in our country? Damn, better deny the evidence and be ignorant!"
What evidence?
Some survivor stories from the same people and some edited photos?
@@dolarhyde More evidence than you could ever look at. 80,000+ pages of documents, and hundreds of thousands of photos in the archives in Jerusalem. The problem isn't lack of evidence, but your avoidance to acknowledge it.
Mike you nailed it. The deniers must have serious psychological issues wherein they are incapable of coping with reality. Maybe it’s too overwhelming for them. Maybe they were raised on a steady diet of hate. Or maybe they are just assholes looking for ways to feel superior as their “leader” hitler did.
@@TheCTBrotherhood Show me some of that evidence big guy
@@henen6711 Go to Yad Vashem in Jerusalem and you can spend the rest of your life looking at evidence. Thouands of witnesses, jewish and non jewish. Hundreds of SS men who documented their experience. Hundreds of thousands of photos, thousands of documents. Physical evidence. Are you going to ask for evidence that the sun exists next?
it is said this man is someone else. after seeing this interview, and seeing video's of survivors I managed to discover a big mistake told by this man. He said men and women were together in a gaschamber, but surivors and camp information spread over the internet is telling another story....... men, children and women were seperated after getting of the trains as what camp survivors have been telling......
"...spread over the internet" is not a credible source. Please don't expose your lack of using actual primary sources that way.
Not Treblinka mate. Treblinka had one function. There was no reason or need to separate people at Treblinka.
some sordid people have gone so
far as to say that the crucifixion of
Jesus Christ never took place because they were not there to see.
Everything I have ever read, even trusty old Wikipedia , indicates the men and women were separated. As the men were being killed, the women were having their hair cut, as the hair was used to make shoes and other necessities for the soldiers. This is the first I habe heard of men and women being killed in the same chambers.
The Nazi's interview refutes the denier liars.
Genocide is not mass murder. Genocide's legal definition is "acts commited with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such: killing members of the group; causing serious bodily or mental harm to members of the group; deliberately inflicting on the group conditions of life calculated to bring about its physical destruction in whole or in part..." (Article 2 of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, UN)
What did he say here? Nothing of any value as far as I am concerned. As someone further down the line mentioned if he just was moved there for guarding why he didn't want to go if he didn't knew anything? Doesn't make any sense. Sounds more like a setup how he talked, as he couldn't have been that old the way he got up easily.
How can anyone know for certain what happened unless you were there?
We all get force fed information in school, but yet nobody questions it and for the record, the allies weren't innocent either. Bombings in Dresden, Hiroshima, Nagasaki, and countless other places.
So unless you saw it with your own eyes then don't discredit anything.
Have you watched the video at all ??
er - try reading books. It is called 'education'
How can you be sure that Australia really excist ?? Have you been there ?? What about Guam ?? Been there ?? The moon ?? Himalaya ?? The deep seas ?? Does the world vanish when you close your eyes ?? Does a tree make a noise when it falls if there is nobody around to hear it ??
majungasaurusaaaa "how do you know the earth is round" ??
That is literally the stupidest logic I've ever heard. So I have to have seen everything that ever happened with my own eyes for it of be true? That is the logic of an imbecile
@khonfosh
"I don't speak German, but I can hear German, and I can tell you this guy is NOT German"
LMFAO!!!
Funniest comment in ages. Thanks for that one. As a linguist, you just made my day!
"His Gemran is spoken with Hebro accent"
You "hear Hebro" as well then?
Dear, oh dear, oh dear, oh....
Lol that was actually hilarious 😂
I'm from Denmark and I speak some German and honestly I did not think he sounded native German either. I googled him and apparently he was born in Czech Republic, so that explains the thick accent I guess.
@@ClaesN1973 LOL...German language has different unique forms depend of regions. Also please notice that pre-war Czechoslovakia was full of Germans.
@timpovikings
I'm trying to finish O'Neils 'book' it's slow going because I have to double check everything.You just can't trust anyone these days.
btw what do you suppose happened to the footnotes to chapter 7?
Why parts 2/7 blocked in Italy, 3 not exists... Subtitles other languages nothing...
He was probably being tortured.
Landon2013 I hope that is true.
Landon2013 he was paid 5000 dollars for the interview...he couldnt get a job because of his history in SS,this was his lifeboat
Landon2013 Notice how this video was supposedly taken with a 'hidden camera concealed in a bag.' A rudimentary hidden camera that accurate pans and zooms when he points at the board...
Warrior for Truth good point
Turd Ferguson why do you hope he was being tortured?
Treblinka : hell on earth!
Heaven compared to Tomsk
@JustinBieberisGOD1 It's mainly forgotten because of the extreme measures Stalin took to make himself look like a good leader. And also they allied w/ the U.S. in WWII to defeat Nazi Germany, so I think that might have some influence on how he is seen here in America aswell.
@julianmerriweather
Diesel Fumes (Cont'd).
Having said that, it was known by 1941 that diesel engines CAN be modified to produce the same amount of Carbon Monoxide as a petrol engine, by simply restricting the air intake - a five minute job for any competent mechanic. With this modification "Further increase in fuel-air ratio was accompanied by an increase in carbon-monoxide concentration until, at the fuel-air ratios greater than the chemically correct one,.."
This guy is a liar.
yes
The Mystic Trance Of course he is a liar!
Nope.
Gotta love how the Germans were able to destroy every document that would prove the holocaust, but at the same time, brought in newbie SS officers who weren't even briefed on what was going on, and let them see the worst of it on their first day of all days. Total. Nonsense. "The people fell out like potatoes" Like, come the fuck on. Ridiculous.
"What about it?"
Well, because while it changed over the years from 4 million, to 1.5 million, to 1.1 million, the total number always remained 6 million.
and in 1999, Australian scientists went to Treblinka, took ground samples and ground radar images of the whole "camp" .. and found... NOTHING! There was no camp there!
Treblinka was a simple killing station. they have the few buildings and foundations accurately mapped, and also have documentation from the Nazis as to the numbers killed there.
Of course. Germany did not exist either. And Hitler and Eva ran a Punch and Judy stall. Ignorant muppet.
Sabba Don't you remember the one movie with the all star cast named Escape From Sobibor?
Doesn't that film PROVE the Treblinka Death Camp existed?
you are a fucken arab
Sabba yep and the Koran is a made up comic book bible and Islam is a religion of peace, snicker snicker. Oh was that ignorant of me ? Guess i just dont give 2 shits.
"... During the inspection, which I made with the assistance of an expert in forensic medicine, it was determined that the ashes are without any doubt of human origin (remains of cremated human bones). The examination of human skulls could discover no trace of wounding.
At a distance of some 100 m, there is now an unpleasant odor of burning and decay."
@julianmerriweather
By the way, the original document for Hilberg's quote is in the National Archives, reference # NA RG 238, NO-600, and it also appears in 'Official Secrets' by Richard Breitman, pp 111.
We defeated the wrong enemy
No we didn’t. Shut up.
It's funny that Israel is doing the same to Palestinian
Not funny buy I know what you mean...
@HistorySpeaks4It So the bus has two antenna for recieving this video feed... one above the van and one inside. the technician continuously manipulates both of them to give the impression of bad reception. The reception is so poor that he cant even get a grip on the vertical hold when the "documentary" camera is facing the monitor, but when it switches to direct feed, the image is magically stable? lol. so whats the problem? the monitor? then why does he keep fucking with the antenna?
Lol, you're raving, bro! XD
What is it? Frustrated that an old Nazi incriminated himself? And that there is just not a single hint that he was lying for whatever reason?
Btw, of course you didn't care to listen or read properly: He didn't say that 2/3 of the train load died in every case, just in that particular train with the French steel cars that had to be sidelined for some time. People were just left in there and died or slit their wrists.
Quite a logical story - for a normal person.
@timpovikings
These people had been cremated, so they didn't have nice skulls with gleaming teeth to display. They had bundles of ash and bits of broken burnt bone. The archeologists weren't interested in those as objects. At that time, it was firmly believed that there was nothing you could learn from looking at cremated bone.
With closer analysis of those remains, even though they're burnt, we can work out people's approximate ages; we may be able to work out if they're male or female;
@HystericalSpeaks2Itself
Don't you find it more than a little incredible that in the matter of the alleged murders of millions of people you have nothing to offer in the way of evidence but verbal testimony?
@deconneurnot
The more the merrier, old friend. As you can see, our friend is trying every trick in the denier book, but he is 'different' because he relies on 'critical thinking' - unlike all the others. A formidable foe!
@julianmerriweather
Re: Diesel exhaust.
The diesel argument is one of the more amusing aspects of the holocaust debate (at least for me), because deniers have set themselves a trap which they cannot get out of: WWII tanks only ran on two fuels, petrol and diesel; historians are still unsure about which type of engine was used at Treblinka, and, assuming that diesel fumes are not capable of killing en masse, then what is the only alternative?
That's right.
Hi.... Is this from the film Shoah ? or this a separate film altogether ?
@kazan188
"Do you mean that the guards are supposed to have sabotaged the water system and then stayed there and waited for the arrival of the Brits?"
Nope. When the British were given permission to enter Belsen by German High Command part of the deal was that soldiers already stationed there would be allowed to leave and return to German lines once the camp had been fully taken over. The British kept to the deal and released the soldiers concerned.
Does anyone have a link to the others in the series please?
@deconneurnot "What criminals? The soldiers and guards sabotaged the water system as they left. The Luftwaffe bombed the camp a few weeks later."
Do you mean that the guards are supposed to have sabotaged the water system and then stayed there and waited for the arrival of the Brits?
The alleged bombing of the Bergen-Belsen camp by the Luftwaffe is not mentioned by any source, other than Monika Godeke, who wrote this in the Bergen-Belsen guidebook which is sold at the Memorial Site.
Thank you old timer for your service
You’re a wrong ‘un, little Jeff….
@julianmerriweather
"Neither does yours".
I never said it does. Which is why I prefer sourced and quoted material, instead of wild conjecture and speculation, which is so far all you have given.
I watched this interview before, and I need to make sure I watched the whole,.....ordeal in absorbing the, well, it makes me sick and speechless. But a true first hand historical account of what was done. People like this were part of the overall society that would accept being assigned to such death work,...I was unsure when watching if he was sickened by what he saw and did or how the smells and situations were repugnant to him. A clue to how the russians feel about Ukrainians and what has happened in Ukraine perpetrated by russian "nazi's" who also feel they are the master race on earth. This low level former soldier of course seems so low level, might not have had a choice apart from firing squad or death by russian front, like as a former soldier myself in the us army I felt like refusing to go to the first gulf war like a few others but the fear threat was not getting in their jails and not coming out alive somehow so soldiers will do whatever it takes to get a better chance of survival, the will to live is strong for everyone,...dunno.
“Here is a paradox . . . A most ingenious paradox: an ANTHROPOLOGICAL FACT,
many [Caucasian] Christians may have MUCH MORE Hebrew-Israelite blood in their veins
than most of their Jewish neighbors.” Jewish author, Alfred M. Lilienthal,
What Price Israel, p. 223
@fredhubner I meant Helmuth Hub(e)ner - he's worth being related to :>
Ehm, actually I see quite a few trees on most pics.^^
Jeez, you guys do not check things first!
Btw, what gives you the impression that there have to be lots of trees? Against what do you compare those pics?
why was capitalisation purposely unused?
(Capitalization purposely unused)??? why's that mate?
> I read debunking books
I am interested. Can you name some you've read?
> Too much coal for the amount of bodies they say they got rid off.
Are you talking about Rudolf Jährling's coke calculations on 1943? I am sure you know the documents very well.
Why are part of yhe interview not available?
Criminals in this country have been executed for being loosely connected with a murder (getaway driver). Here this unrepentant guard at a death camp, and most likely a killer, got a 4 year sentence , for his participation in 200,000 deaths.
This man is quite rare. Treblinka was staffed with very few Germans. Sometimes the entire SS contingent at Treblinka was a mere 25 Germans, just enough to control the 150-200 "selected" Jews who performed most of the manual labor and the sorting of property, cutting of hair, pulling gold teeth, etc. Not a lot of actual Germans, SS or otherwise staffed Treblinka since they did not maintain any considerable amount of prisoners. Most were killed within 2 hours of the trains arrival.
@HistorySpeaks4Itself
"No one has ever suggested that there was not a typhus epidemic at Belsen, that's what killed Anne Frank...hello?"
I don't think he is listening.
Wie kannst du sonst wissen, in welchen Kontext du Schriften wie jene Rudolfs platzieren kannst?
Where is part 2, 3 & 6?
@MSM4U2POM
I love the way he did an about turn with the water issue. He felt it necessary to mention that it was the Allies that caused the water problem in Belsen. Like all deniers I am no doubt sure he believes that the diseases were the results of Allied actions and not a Nazi lack of concern. The problem is that diseases and death were rampant in German concentration camps like Belsen from Feb 1945. there was no military action anywhere near Belsen until April!