Amber Heard's Psychiatrist Expert Witness Testifies in Defamation Trial Part One (Depp v. Heard)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 25 ก.ค. 2024
- During the defamation trial on Monday, Amber Heard's team called their expert witness psychiatrist to testify. Dr. David Spiegel spoke about his findings on how Johnny Depp's behaviors were consistent with substance use disorder and perpetrator of intimate partner violence.
#JohnnyDepp #AmberHeard
Listen to Court Junkie Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3NMVnpx
Spotify: spoti.fi/3Pv7lpc
Listen to Law&Crime's Sidebar Podcast on Apple & Spotify:
Apple: apple.co/3wMgRgB
Spotify: spoti.fi/3wITe7b
Written Coverage & Analysis of Johnny Depp & Amber Heard Trial:
lawandcrime.com/?s=Johnny+Depp
lawandcrime.com/?s=Amber+Heard
Sign Up For Law&Crime's Daily Newsletter! bit.ly/LawandCrimeNewsletter
Watch Law&Crime Network NOW on TH-camTV!
tv.th-cam.com/users/welcome?...
OTHER WAYS TO WATCH LAW&CRIME NETWORK IN YOUR AREA:
lawandcrime.com/where-to-watch/
READ MORE GREAT ARTICLES FROM LAW&CRIME NETWORK HERE:
lawandcrime.com
LAW&CRIME NETWORK SOCIAL MEDIA:
Instagram: / lawandcrime
Twitter: / lawcrimenetwork
Facebook: / lawandcrime
Twitch: / lawandcrimenetwork
TikTok: / lawandcrime
LAW&CRIME NETWORK PODCASTS: lawandcrime.com/podcasts/
SUBSCRIBE TO ALL OF LAW&CRIME NETWORK TH-cam CHANNELS:
Main Channel: / @lawandcrime
Channel B: / @lawandcrimeshorts
Channel C: / @lawandcrimetrials
Channel D / @lawandcrimebodycam - บันเทิง
Imagine going to this guy for psychiatric help, and then realizing he needs it more than you do.
Lmfao 😂
Frightening stuff!
HAHAHAHA Classic comment
@@capablanc scary. Certainly proof that simply having letters before or after a name means nothing without proof of the pudding.
😂
This guy is an excellent example why sometimes it's scary to go to the doctor
More scary than confronting your own demons? Please seek help, _capyaycaramba_ because *you* are in denial too.
He looks like a angry eagle.
He should see a psychyatrist
🤣
I quit my meds and therapy after watching this 🤣
How Heard's legal team concluded that it was a good idea to put this guy on the stand is beyond me.
😝
I think Amber used only the cheapest professionals she could hire, being told how high the bar is to prove defimation she saught defense on the cheap.
@@RexBlanchard she did a buy one get one free 😂😂😂
Definitely should’ve met up for dinner and drinks with him beforehand 😂
@@RexBlanchardshe really thought she had this.
Whenever I’m feeling down I come Back to this testimony and in 5 minutes I’m howling with laughter😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
I’m here in 2024 to do the same thing 🤣🤣🤣
@@lindseymitchell3995 right??😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Dude same I'm watching in 2024 and howlinggg 😭😂🤣🤣
Still hilarious march 2024. 😂
Its his facial expressions that make it so funny 🤣🤣
If they hadn't described him as a “psychiatrist”, I would totally think he’s a psychiatric patient 😨
Right? OmG he is something else 😳
They meant to grab the psychiatrist and grabbed the patient 😂😂😂
you said it!
It’s a fine line I’m sure.
😆😆😆😆
Its baffling to me that Amber's team could not find a single person that comes across as likeable and sincere. This guy came across as a lunatic.
LMAO how tf is someone who just snorted coke supposed to sound sincere?
Cause they found him outside
No one else would do it, no “real” dr would jeopardize their reputation but doing this.
💯
A hating lunatic at that
Johnny's lawyers are BRILLIANT.
THIS male lawyer did an outstanding job of challenging and confronting this doctor.
This lawyer actually outshines Camille in his ability to challenge this doctor and he's doing it without hardly ANY objections from Heard's legal team!
Agree!
Mr. Dennison is definitely the bomb!
He has a lot of trial experience
I’m also a Camille Stan but Mr. Dennison is the bomb!!!
this is waynes world they are just living in it...this trial is comparably small potatoes when you look at other cases he has handled. this trial is just more publicized which probably just makes the witnesses hes cross examining feel like they are being dragged out into deep water and slowly drowned. it is fascinating to watch how he comes out walking slowly and kind of fumbling his words and before the witness can even see the giant web being wove around them they are already trapped.
@@sluggerz he’s brilliant I’m so impressed
"Do some perpetrators of intimate partner violence try to minimise IPV?" Elaine asks the doctor..... "I was not punching you, I was hitting you, babe you were not punched" says Amber
Very observant! :) i agree, every question reminded me of some portion of actual evidence! You know videos of the actual fights, instead of Johnny on the set of a pirate ship!!
Imagine being this guy's patient... Most of them are probably "cured" by realizing 'Hey, I'm not that bad!'
Totally lol 😂
I'm dead ...🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Hilarious!!!
You are so correct!!! 😂😂😂😂😂
If nothing else, let us thank Amber and her team for showing us the “experts” to avoid in our own lives. 😂
I'll tell you one thing, this expert guy seems to have some kind of disorder. lol
yep the biggest "expert" you need to avoid is Depp = seems like many have made him their guru... an alcoholic, druggie, smirky arrogant narcissistic man and womanizer
Bredehoft is scraping the bottom of the barrel with this guy, but after hearing Amber's testimony & video no normal person would want to get involved with her case. Imo, her entire team & parade of witnesses are strange & nutty.
😂😂
Lol 😂😂😂
Johnnys lawyer cross examination he should get a “medal of honor” in the courtroom. This is unreal!
Agree
He's one of my favourite Depp's attorneys.The other ones are awesome too but he was given the hardest cross-examinations to deal with. He had to improvise without the questions written down the day before.
Columbo style 👌 !
Totally agree...
I'm a psychologist and this absolutely astounds and horrifies me
As it should. I'm a student in psychology, and I will never forget this guy's lack of ethics and professionalism in my life.
Do explain!
Careful Shannon. It is unlawful to call yourself a psychologist if you don't have the degree. Based on your more than extremely simplified comment, I doubt very much that you are what your claim. If I am wrong, please state your alma mater where you earned your degree.
@@danskehans I won't be sharing my personal information here other than I graduated with my doctorate in clinical psychology in 2015, completed my pre- and post-doctoral internships at the same location, have been independently licensed since 2016, and have been practicing in the field of forensics and clinical psychology including expert testimony since that time.
Bye.
@@danskehans ohhhh someone just got hit with a bunch of evidence and is probably going to deny it
Amber and her team really has motivated me. Because of them i feel i can become an actor, psychiatrist, and a lawyer now
agree! nothing is impossible with Amber😂
THIS!!! 😂😂😂
one of the best fromm this whole ordeal!! 💯
They're actors 😂
A+
And a model 😎( Isaac Baruch: "I didn't know she was a model" 😉)
As a long time nurse, I have to admit that most of the psych doctors I met were all this weird, and in desperate need of psych treatment themselves. LOL!
Johnnys reaction to the psychiatrist doing the tongue thing at 1:20:45 and beyond killed me. He squinted and leaned forward like, wtf is he doing 😭😭😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
This was one of my favorite parts of the entire trial. I was streaming this in school for the entire day! hahaha
Thank you for time stamping this 🤣 this was literally the best part.
came looking for this --- laugh every time
@@Crys_Kris it’s crazy. Like, did that really happen? What is this person doing 😭😭😭😭
Someone said he was a reptilian 🤣
I find it very strange that so far Amber’s witnesses haven’t actually “witnessed” anything 🤔
Exactly !
They are just expert witnesses that you can pay money to and they will watch the case and give their "opinions" which are totally not biased towards their employer
The purpose of an expert witness has nothing to do with "witnessing" anything. It is just the term that is used.
An expert witness is supposed to be a subject matter expert in his/her field of study to give an expert account of a topic in the case. This is why there are many objections during the examinations of the expert witnesses because they should not be giving their opinion outside of anything that does not relate to their field of expertise.
Regardless, this dude seems to be a subject matter expert of doing coke prior to a courtroom testimony.
They had and many of them were shown
Amber couldn't be a witness for herself convincingly... her own recordings ...her friends... couldn't do the job she tried for years to present to the public...
The fact that this man has a license to mess with people's minds when they are vulnerable, is an extremely scary thing. I hope he now, gets a review of his behavior by whatever organization he belongs too.
This Guy show us that, at first, anyone who attempt to get into the psychiatry should get an deep psychology analysis. Its disturbing to think that this man is responsible to treat sick people
Lol he looks like the patient that broke out and is pretending to ne a psychiatrist
@@dfvr4343 😂 he does omg loll
One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest, crazy, crazier, craziest!
He does not have a liceence. He was asked if he had a liceence and he said no. 🤣🤣🤣
Wayne Dennison’s presentation and style may not be as impactful as Camille’s, but he’s handled all the expert witnesses brilliantly which I think is much harder to do than we realise - because he’s basically challenging experts in their own fields and poking holes in their testimonies, when he himself knows nothing about their field. Can’t be easy to do at all and he knows exactly what he’s doing. Did such a good job!
I am very worried about what's going on in Dennison's world that he could go back and forth with this guy for hours seemingly. I really wanted to give Dennison a hug after this exchange to be sure he doesn't accidentally trip over to the dark side.
Exactly..this dr is bat 💩CRAY CRAY
He doesn't know nothing about their field. He's just not an expert in their field. His cross examination was excellent, and demonstrated that he thorougly understood some of the concepts the experts were testifying about. When you cross examine, you never ask a question in which you don't know the answer to. You either extract testimony favorable to your side, or you impeach. Mr. Dennison did both. He researched all of the issues that were testified to. He had a good understanding of the concepts, IMO.
@@brilliant13675 yes, I meant the same thing - he knows nothing about their fields and has to educate himself in each area purely to be able to cross examine and poke holes in each expert’s opinions. I think what he had to do was a lot harder than what the others had to and he did a brilliant job.
Yes i thought he was very wonderful and hes a really good lawyer
Johnny Depp spoke slowly and carefully, not only because he wanted to express himself correctly, but also because he was reliving trauma.
Samé time very polited all the time
Perfectly said.
Johnny Depp has always been a ‘considered thinker’, if you watch even older interviews with him he does tend to give very considered answers when the subject matter is serious.
It’s definitely not a new trait!
@@curlyKTJLuvsWatermelon 💯
More like "all eyes on me." "I'm the most important person in the room." Narcissist.
Amber: “if you lie for me in court, I’ll give you drugs. Just don’t do them before you testify.”
Him: “do them all before I testify, got it.”
😆 🤣 😂
Best comment yet
Haha
Hahaha I’ve just watched this and immediately thought the same 😂😂😂😂
His alpha hair doo 😂
AH team is the gift that keeps on giving.
She's gonna win so get used to disappointment
@@bethanyh.9489 I take the bet
Hahahahaha this is brilliant
@@bethanyh.9489 she's gonna win herpes... that's about it
🤣🤣🤣
Can you imagine walking into your first appointment and this guys the doctor! I’d never go to another.
Ben Chew and Camille Vasquez are rightly receiving tons of praise for a phenomenal job. I'd also like to take a moment to congratulate attorney Wayne Dennison ('John Wayne') who did the brilliant cross on this loon.
Congratulations Mr. Dennison for a well-deserved win and a phenomenal and thoroughly entertaining cross of this sentient caricature ~ you deserve every accolade as well good Sir!
Dennison is absolutely brilliant.
I concur! 6 months later lol
The entire deserves praise. Both Camille and Ben repeatedly stated it was the entire team that brought in the win.
@@daCubanaqtincluding those seen less often or even not at all in the court room!!
The scary thing is that this “expert” walked away thinking he won over the lawyers and would most certainly boost his ego much more. I feel sorry for his patients.
Wait til he sees all of the great memes that he is the subject of. That will certainly deflate his ego.
Something is wrong with this witness.... He doesnt seem oke!
@@Smitty_Time_24 they already started. Lol
I can't even imagine going to this guy and trusting him, then seeing this later. Absolutely awful.
I don’t understand who would go to this guy. His inappropriate, creepy vibe would send me running out the door. This guy should not be alone in a room with anybody.
This man's fantastic - pure entertainment. He's like a character from a sit-com about psychiatric practice.
Omg if SNL was worth a crap they’d be doing sketches from this every week. They’re no longer relevant though imo
Really loved him. I am not sure if he has any malice or what, but regardless, he comes across passionate about his area of expertise, and is just a fascinating character to watch.
"Isn't he dead."
Yep.....he played this lawyer like a fiddle !!!!!
@@vividdylan400 >> You SERIOUSLY saw that?!?!🧐 😲
I just saw the most arrogant, combative, ethics violating, desperately egotistical, shell of a pathetic man with only degrees to validate him, I have ever seen.
He wasn’t even ALLOWED TO DO what he did on the witness stand.
@@k.hendrickson8735 I found him to be normal under cross-examination, but when he was under direct examination from Heard's lawyer, that's when I noticed a lot of what you are saying.
But I wasn't, and still not, trying to say anything about his character or integrity. My point was merely that he was i
But, come on, you can have a specific kind of liking to even the worst of human beings. It's not common.
The attorney just absolutely loves turning this witness into to a psychiatric patient.
It’s comical that everything this doctor talks about is really describing Amber. From the alcohol to the narcissist behaviors is really describing Amber.Ambers smug look on her face during this trial was one of her downfalls. Victims do not act like that.
Exactly my thoughts. Just looking back at this after many months & JD couldn't be further from narcissistic; he's empathetic & caring, humble, social, etc whereas AH meets every narcissistic trait there is.
Lord of the ring Smiggle Okay😂😂😂❤
He’s fascinating to watch. Like an alien that has learnt to mimic humans but hasn’t quite gotten it right, something uncanny valley about him.
😂😂😂
LMAOOOO
You're almost expecting him to let out a high pitched screech while peeling apart two sides of his face to reveal a slimy green interior skin and a flickering forked tongue!
👀
like an alien? Scroll to the 14:30 mark.. For a split second he completely forgets how a voice box works and resorts back to his native language.
Its called “Creepy”…
I LOVE the way Johnny Depp & his team watch this man it's priceless they're like wtf is wrong with this 1?! 🤣
When he is describing narcissism, he is literally describing amber 😂😂 not Johnny
Also: very good cross examination!! Everything was on point !!
And every one on her team 😂
This guy terrifies me, I would never be alone in a room with this man.
Me too
That's what I thought when he said Johnny refused to talk to him twice!
😂😂😂😂😂
Lol me too.. freaking freaky.
He is going to talk you to death
Love how beautifully he describes AH as he lists the signs and symptoms of narcissistic personality disorder. 🤦🏼♀️🤣
I scrolled the comments just to see if anyone else noticed this. Her attorney should’ve avoided anything to do with the subject of NPD.
LOL i know right
Me 2. I was glad when the judge overruled
Very telling since Borderline is often called the female version of narcissism... XD
I would yeet you out so hard girl
I’m rewatching some of this trial and I have a hard time believing that Amber would have actually PAID millions for her witnesses and attorneys. I am beginning to believe that she went to the closest circus and just pick some of the circus clowns to play these parts. 😂
Seriously lol these were experts TF? 😂
I can tell you as an attorney in law firm, that you have no choice but to work on the case handed to you by your superiors. They will certainly have you work on it , since Amber is a high profile client. Even if it means that you have to go through these kinds of charades...very annoying. Don't you see that they are annoyed? They are not as passionate as Johnny's lawyers. The other attorney on Amber's side was not even focussing anymore (e.g. objecting to his own questions on another occasion... lol).
@@daniellak.7521 - When he objected to his own question, I almost fell over. Cracked me up... 🤣🤣
My guess, that is bc no reputable attorney would have heard her case and felt good about her chances! I'm guessing they would have acted ethical and let her know the risk evolved in this absolutely ridiculous campaign of terror against a beloved individual, with ABSOLUTELY ZERO truth behind it.. these clowns really didn't care enough to tell her the truth!!
And this, Ladies and Gentlemen is how you make sure to never, ever get asked to be an expert witness again. 😂
This guy is the embodiment of the crazy, evil doctor in movies and cartoons. The fact that he’s part of Amber’s team is very telling.
How did….just, how??? Who hired… I mean, wut? 🤦🏽♀️🥜
@@lampshade7874 My thoughts exactly.
please someone turn him into a cartoon character ! insane !
I expect that Amber's lawyers had a hard time finding credible witnesses willing to believe or support her claims
Judge Doom from Roger Rabbit
The more this psychiatrist talks about processing speed the more he demonstrates that he actually doesn’t have any idea what processing is.
Poor guy he been lamenting on reaction towards him, but his Patients stand behind him :)
I love Johnny Depp, I’m happy he won, but the guys not necessarily wrong. Idk what that necessarily has to do with whether AH was abusive or whether he was abusive though.
You can't get a fair diagnose without seeing the patient in person, that's a fact,
this lawyer Wayne Dennison is way underrated! He ripped all "expert witnesses" apart! I very much enjoy watching this!
I am a psychiatry resident (psychiatrist in training) and there are so many things wrong with this man's testimony. He said several things that were factually medically incorrect, his thoughts on the goldwater rule were just completely baffling to me, not to mention his combative and defensive attitude. Lots of my medical and psychiatry colleagues have expressed the same sentiments. I feel so bad for his medical students and residents. He sounds like the kind of attending that makes your life miserable in training
I agree wholeheartedly! So glad you have colleagues who agree with you.
Absolutely right! I have dealt professionally with psychiatric patients and have worked with numerous psychiatrists and psychologists, and this guy is a joke. Another smart move by Amber’s legal team!!🤔
Can you explain this approach to haircare, Doctor!?
Also, thank you for your contribution to society.
He got bam boozed by AH attorneys he thought it wasn’t going to be closed court and when he go court and it was televised.. not one attorney told Dr Spiegel prior to coming to court.. he felt slighted by the attorneys !
Apparently, his students just deem him eccentric - which troubles me that they may still take him seriously.
I can't believe this guy is actually being taken seriously by anyone. Hopefully there's some people in the jury that have their heads screwed on and see through him.
He’s a looney toon. Lol
I don't think many people are taking him seriously
I hope nobody would take him serious lol he goes in circles with every single question and needs to quit w the drugs he is consuming ha
It’s even worse he has made decisions that effect normal peoples life’s like us. People like him are why there are some many people locked away in a state hospital against their will
He is not a good as expressing himself, in fact he is horrible, but lots of the things he said are right. The guy is no likeable. That doesn't make him all wrong, the cross wasn't very good in here neither. Unfortunately he is not helpful.
With that kind of cocktail in drugs,, they are never sober, they are never there, their mood is always multiple and changing, they don't have real feelings.
This 'ol guy entertained the heck out of Johnny, lol.
I love how Johnny looked up to watch this one for the entertainment. He answers questions like Amber. I really hope the APA is investigating him.
I watched an older video of Johnny being interviewed and he spoke about when he first met
Marlon Brando, someone Johnny looked up to and respected. The two of them developed a
very close relationship and Johnny asked him to do a small part in a movie Johnny was doing.
Normally Brando wouldn't have done it but did it for Johnny. The two of them remained close
while Brando was alive. When I heard the attorney bring up Marlon Brando of all people I thought
to myself of all the people he could have asked about what would be the chances it would be
Marlon Brando, I knew that was going to upset Johnny and it clearly did as he put his head down
right away and covered his face with his hand and nodded his head a bit from side to side. I felt
so bad for him.
Me too! 😆
So 😂😂😂🎉❤💗💗🙏🙏📕🎭Johnny Depp, Marilyn Manson, Elon, Musk, Tom Cruise, Brad Pitt Yellowstone 🎥🌎are 🪧 single
Now every one had watched this defamation trial knowing they aren’t crazy 😜 and don’t needed psychiatric therapy !!??😂❤
I am a mental health nurse and this IS NOT "what we do in clinical medicine", having a direct one on one consultation/MSE (Mental State Examination) with a patient is crucial when evaluating the presence of cognitive impairment. Knowing whether an individual is under the influence of drug/alcohol is also extremely important (I'm sure its obvious) as this will greatly affect the findings.
Comfortably evaluating someone that you not only haven't consulted with or have spoken to but base your findings on scenes in movies they have acted in (ie not in a clinical setting) is beyond ridiculous and unethical practice.
I don't know the standards of practice guidelines in America but in Australia you would immediately be stripped of your medical licence.
I was going to say the same thing! Surely this testimony should be dismissed. And there is something very NQR with this man. Psychiatrist, my arse!
@@missy4663 He really seems quite the quack. I ordinarily dont like to poke fun but he reminds me of the Cocoa Puff Bird.
Thanks God somebody with Integrity!! Your comment is invaluable, is unfair that the court admit that guy like a real profesional.....i said him deserves be banned for his profesional practice in health servics!!, sorry but i cant believe guys like this are in the health field around.....
@@missy4663 IF THEY DISMISS THIS "TESTIMONY" IT WILL NOT LEND STRENGTH TO MR DEPP'S CASE..BY HAVING THIS CLOWN TESTIFY, AMBER'S TEAM LOST POINTS BIG TIME
@@Virtual_Reality_RL LOL, AND YOU WOULD PUT YOUR TRUST IN THIS "MEDICAL" DOCTOR HAHHAHAHAA
Why is nobody talking about how well Johnny‘s lawyer handled this witness?
Right? He hasn't gotten enough credit if you ask me.
Brilliant. He was like Colombo
He slowly decimated him. Brilliant!
He is great and consistently so. He murdered every exper in his cross examinations
He had control from the beginning of this horrible doctor. This lawyer deserves so much credit.
I have no idea why I continue to watch this over and over. I find this just so bizaar
This "expert witness" testimony should never have been allowed by the court... but in this case I'm so thankful that he was able to inlighten all of us. Most of all the jury 🙄🥴😅🤣😂😭🤔🧐🤭
Someone else said: "the real Dr. Speigel is locked up inside this guys basement"
Omg lmfao
Hearsay hahahaha
Yep
He is. 🤣🤣🤣
I'm dead 😂😂😂😂
1:09:23 starts getting tilted
1:09:45 realizing he is not prepared
1:10:32 tries his best to look educated
1:15:25 gets educated by the Judge!
1:18:18 he starts showing slow process speed in his brain
1:21:00 thinks of the word chocolate and tries to eat the air!!
1:23:45 tries his best to be TwoFace!
🤣🤣🤣😂😅
😂😂😂😂😂
😩😩😩🤣🤣🤣
This deserves more likes, LMAO!!!
Sounds like Legasov explaining the Chernobyl incident, "1:23:45, the cycle is complete."
Watching him made me realize that I’m actually not that crazy and if he can become a psychiatrist than I can be whatever I want.
I'm just dumbfounded that not one person he encountered that morning before going on the stand said "hey, you might wanna comb your hair". Did someone actually say "hey yeah, you look great!" and then let him go on the stand, while millions of people are watching live online, looking like a mad scientist or a patient that escaped a mental hospital 🤦🏼♀️🤷🏼♀️
Doc from Back to the Future
Yeah, I noticed it right away and wondered why he would do something so distracting.
It's his nonverbal that is the issue, if he was normal the hair would be irrelevant. But he acts mad and the hair just completes the painting
Depp’s team made this man go from seeming so intelligent to inconsistent, unethical and unreliable in a matter of minutes. He contradicted himself, admitted to misspeaking and just rambled for the purpose of trying to save face.
The last time this guy was a practicing physician was circa 1899.
😆🤣😂
Best comment so far!
Yesssss!!!! And he tested many of the substances on himself during his internship in 1805!
I’m sorry by Johnny’s and his lawyers reaction are freaking EPIC! The jury got this trial RIGHT! Congratulations Johnnys, his ENTIRE TEAM and mostly his 2 children! 💜💙💜💙
Johnny is looking at him so keenly. I wonder if he is going to base his next character on him 😀
This guy sounds like he became a psychiatrist not to help people but because he loves the sound of his own voice...
You cannot convince me he isn't a character from Arrested Development.
It seems like they got him straight out of the Arkham Asylum
Objection! We haven’t read the plea.
I want him to interview Anthony Todt and for the video be put on TH-cam. I would want to hurl my laptop into the sun, but it would also make me laugh.
Could this guy actually be a psychiatric patient, trying to pass as a psychiatrist?! I can’t even wrap my head around the fact that he is actually an “expert witness!”
You’re probably right. 😂 😂 Can you imagine? I’m literally crying.
Actually he does say at 1:05:58 that "we deny patients medications all the time without seeing them, we deny patients treatments unfortunately without seeing them, and I'm on the receiving end of that."
Which means that he has been denied both treatment and medication without being seen by a Psychiatrist.
It seems they only wanted him for his anti stance on prescribed medications. He is the dr that refuses treatment to patients.
@@holdonC yes!! Thank you. My psychiatrist won't admit fault or wrong opinions and has ignored advice from colleagues and denied me basic treatment basically. It's disgusting and he is also the head psychiatrist of the psychiatric ward I was on and on the board of governors and his wife is for the entire Midlands division in mental health in the UK. Yes we get free treatment and for physical health it is generally good care. Mental health is disgusting. I was told by a crisis team to go and have a bath and calm down. I got in the bath and overdosed and sliced my wrists and bled out 3 pints and ended up on life support for 2 weeks. It's wrong and disgusting 🤢🤮 he reminds me of that sadly x
99% of TheRapists are quacks & whack jobs.
Imagine being the Jurors and having him stare at you and talking. I would feel so uncomfy!!
The lawyer is a genius. He handles difficult professional testimonoes only and does them marvelously.
I can't conceive of a person in a schizophrenic outbreak having a minimally beneficial conversation with this "doctor"
Yeah that’s usually accompanied with a lot of anxiety & paranoia and this guy is stressing me out just listening to him….
😂
He seems like the kind of person who would say, "Go ahead and jump then."
It would be so incredibly damaging
This guy honestly reminds me of my dad.(sadly) he has schizo-effective disorder and how he carried himself reminds me of my dad. There is absolutely no getting through to my dad when he’s in the wrong or needs to correct his behavior/statements. Same of why this dude danced around each question when they weren’t open ended questions. A simple yes/no was all that was needed.
So he finds it hard to believe that actors are “fed their lines” through an earpiece but just moments before, when asked if he realized that actors rehearse their lines, he said he knows nothing about acting and couldn’t answer that question. There’s so much to talk about with this guy. I couldn’t stop laughing. What a nut!
Wait did I miss a episode of Seinfeld????
This lawyer is brilliant, wow was he prepared in educating himself. Johnny looks so confident in his team. If I were him I would just want to defend myself as I don’t trust a lot of people. This is nothing short of amazing!!!!
The way he spins his chair round to face the jury, everytime he's asked a question is so infuriating 🙄 It's like he's been waiting for this moment his entire life!! 😂
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
👍🤣🤣🤣🤣
Yes, He, the king of knowledge will explain to the simple souls how it works. Everything about this man in infuriating!
It’s his time to shine ✨ 🤣
Yeah, until they started ripping his testimony apart, then he was fixed on the dude asking the questions.
omfg, what he's describing is what she did. Apologizing, minimizing behavior "I was hitting you not punching you"..."i'm sorryyyyy ok?" PFFF she did that to HIM
Exactly what i was thinking as he was speaking
Someone should make a video on this
lmao bruh like clock work as he's describing her she looks dead into the camera can't make this up I swear 42:03 to 42:07
He describes her the whole time
His name is Spiegel. And spiegel translates from Dutch and Germain into English as mirror. Mirroring is exactly what he did.
If I can't find anything else to watch I turn this on for a laugh
Mr Dennisons cross examination was excellent. He let the weird doctor keep talking and that wasnt good for him at all. He really pulled his card.
This guy seems to have narcissistic personality disorder himself !! He HAS to be right on everything🙄 SO combative!! WOW
Due to the Psychiatric Association's Goldwater Rule you can only claim traits until a professional evaluation, please re-evaluate your statement.
His description of Narcissism was literally acted out while he was speaking the words. It was comic gold! Lol then that chin stroke like a movie villain 🤣🤣🤣
Yeah, wouldn’t you love to be seen by him?!?! 😫😧😮😲
Ego
Oh my Godness!🤯 He's the psy. of Amber Heard ??😳😳😳🤔
It's a caricature cartoons! 🤣🤣😅😂
He watched Johnny on TV as a base line and then gave his PROFESSIONAL opinion that he has a cognitive disorder!?!? Goodness this was a BIG waste the courts time!
I knoww😭😭😭 this witness is literally a comedy break from the trial😂😂😂
Same as youre doing on youtube
Just curious...do you subscribe to the behavioral panel?
Not sure, but I think that legally, a shrink can not diagnose a patient without meeting him/her and have a consultation.
I’m 6:35 in and already this is a waste of time. This is probably the first time this man has met Johnny in person 🤦🏾♀️
When your psychiatrist is the most unstable person in the room.
He and Amber both answer the questions they’ve been asked in the same manner while looking directly at the jury. The jury must of felt very uncomfortable having both these psycho’s staring at them.
That’s what I keep thinking. If I was a jury member I would be massively uncomfortable with the way they search the jury for eye contact and then stare
@@melissajsp everyone else including Johnny and Amber’s sister answered their questions while looking at the lawyer asking them. I bet the jury felt intimidated when Dr Psycho and Amber were looking at them it’s like they were sizing up the jurors. I really can’t understand how this Dr Spiegel is a practicing psychiatrist he looked and sounded like he’s the one who needs psychiatric treatment. The whole court case was crazy to be honest.
@@truthorconsequences3158 honestly that man legit gave me the creeps
@@melissajsp don’t worry you’re not alone he gives me major creep vibes. I certainly wouldn’t want to be a vulnerable young female alone in a room with him. There’s people who are eccentric and that’s cool because no two people are the same some of my friends are slightly eccentric and that’s what I love about them. This guy or should I say Doctor is a straight up creep I can judge a person’s character very quickly and I’m normally always right about what kind of person they’re. This guy gives me major red flags and I would steer clear from him.
As ridiculous as this was, my entire face hurts from laughing so much. Did AH's team go for a comedic break? His entire persona is just ...
I laugh since the beginning because his facial expressions & vibe really like an evil cartoon character
@@ainamajid8083 same 😆
@@ainamajid8083 I'd love to get into a debate with him for the lulz
It seems like they got all of them
out of Arkham Asylum
I laughed a lot at Johnny and his lawyer (Ben)
reactions at this creepy doctor 😂😂😂
He said J.D is a narcissistic but listen carefully where he says something like:"it does not matter what is written there, but what i am saying" ... soooo?
Kinda taken out of context.
yaaa.. exactly!
Imagine being this guy's patient...He would definitly make you feel better about being crazy,
It's amazing how fast he goes into defensive mode when Johnny's lawyer starts questioning compared to Amber's. Straight forward answers to wearing around any yes or no question
Dr. Spiegel is the most entertaining witness I've ever seen. He is a whole theater himself.
Wow! Just wow! Praying for this guy’s patients.
😂😂😂
He had a patient that was suicidal and their family member called him and he never responded. That patient killed themselves. The daughter wrote a review about this doctor.
Lets do it together!!!🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏😱😱😱😱😱
That’s not my problem! That’s your problem, not mine! You had three meals delivered, sorry! So guess what I have no money, and I am broke! So you can threaten me all you want!
Lol 😆 🤣 😂 😹
rewatching this testimony for the 3rd time and I just noticed how attentive Johnny Depp is here. Usually, during testimonies, he is drawing or looking bored. As someone who lives with ADD, I feel that. This psychologist is so animated and entertaining that it caused JD to sit right up. Probably why this is my second favorite testimony, second only to AH's cross examination.
@Johnnydeppofficial dude your not Johnny.
👍🏽
This dude reminds me of 'Doc' from "Back to the Future" full-stop!
Bahahahaha
He is like the doctor from an old joke: What is the difference between a psychiatrist and a psychiatric patient? The psychiatrist has the key from the room😅
😂😂😂😂
Lmao
🤣🤣
This is so accurate lmao 🤣🤣🤣
Thank you Johnny for insisting the trial be filmed 😄👏 Better than a tv show 🤣🤡
There's not a single shred of evidence presented thus far that would show Johnny fits ANY of the things described by this lunatic. So strange that he is describing her so aptly and her unprofessional representation is so lacking that they cannot see this that is so clear right in front of them.
Exactly!
Mr. Dennison’s presentation threw me off at first - like, wth with the choppiness. It’s not choppiness he’s clearly stating his questions and pinning people to the wall, very much like a parent when a kid tries to talk in circles. That’s good stuff!
I have been silently following this case. However, the way this so-called expert acted is beyond comprehension. He sure is very combative, argumentative, very unprofessional, arrogant, condenscending, among others. I feel bad for everyone in the room. I hope his patients (if there's any) are still fine. 😔
(Edit: I watched and listened to him again. Why does it feel like he is describing AH when he's trying so hard to put Johnny in a bad light?)
You should have stayed silently following, this “so called” expert receiver FELLOW status from the APA, a status far beyond the capability of your tiny tiny little pea brain, I’m team JD but you commenters on here are absolutely the lowest of IQ’s
Your right , his description perfectly fits Ms Hears
He got mad because he got told he was unethical to make a diagnosis about Depp. One of his basis was that he used is that he ate candy and drew pictures.😂😂
I thought the same thing when Elaine was asking about victim blaming and accusations of IVP!!! Elaine didn't seem to realize her line of questioning just bolstered Johnny's Depp's case. The doc said sometimes abusers make false accusations and/or victim blame and I'm like "yeah... I think we're all watching that right now." 🤦♀️
He's a hired witness. That's apparent
did this man realize he was describing Amber Heard EXACTLY with every example he gave while being questioned by the defense? Johnny's lawyers should have just stood up for cross and asked if everything that he just said could also apply to AH as well and just said thanks for proving our point.
When Dr. David Spiegel describes the traits of narcissistic personality disorder this description would actually fit much better to Amber Heard than it does to Johnny Depp.
When you go to Dollar General for an expert witness...
Interesting how the textbook psychology he's describing would be applied more to AH according to her behaviour and evidences than to JD...
Right??!
Boy, how quick his demeanor, body posture and attitude has changed...right at the start of the cross examination. He is combative and defensive. He also feels threatened by someone that he knows is not impressed with him and who is more than his equal in knowledge of their own field.
What did he do to the real psychiatrist...?
He seems like he is a patient that is taking his psychiatrists job. He even has the villain look lol
i really cannot put into words how difficult this was to listen to , let alone watch
Yes, I have physical pain due to the amount of cringe I endured during his testimony
A.H. lawyers after this testimony: Well, this didn't went as planned...
The most painful deposition to watch so far. Like... Wow. The guy showed bias, unprofessionalism, he looked insane, he showed complete disregard for the things he was testifying about (like saying he doesn't know anything about acting, to the point of not knowing if actors rehearse for roles, but testifying that using an ear plug is unusual in acting) and, at the same time, he described everything Depp claims Amber did as examples of behaviours of an ipv perpetrator. This was.. ooof.
This deposition should come with a warning directed to psychiatrists: "if you are a psychiatrist, or works in that area, this testimony can cause depression and severe PTSD just from watching it."
And May cause drowsiness and diarrhea
This is not a deposition. It is a direct and then cross examination of an "expert"(i guess) witness. Depositions are the video recorded statements/testimony taken prior to the trial outside the presence of the jury to be played in court at the time of trial.
@@jessedewell thanks for the legal correction
In one year when the jury’s identities are unsealed, I wonder if they’ll give interviews or write books. I would bet if they do and if they divulge how they came to accept what evidence are facts, if they 100% excluded this dudes testimony entirely after this cross. Wayne Dennison let him keep talking, as he leaned against the podium and watched the jury’s reaction to his senseless rants posing at answers 😂
This so-called doctor is nothing but a nut case. Who gave him a license?
Gosh! This was exhausting to watch and I’m sitting here watching this on double speed after my 12 hour shift at the hospital. I can’t imagine what it was actually like in real time sitting through this man talk endlessly.
This lawyer ACED it!!!!!
I could NOT stop laughing 😂😂😂
Judge A *serious tone* "You have to answer questions." Uhhh can someone give this woman an Emmy. I would like to watch this whole trial over but only watch Judge A's face. She's so awesome
Don’t u feel he described himself
This guy said he's 59 years old! I thought he was about 75 years old! Holy Crap! Has anyone asked this guy to produce a Birth Certificate AND a Valid Psychiatrist License? There's no way this guy gets paid to be a REAL DOCTOR! 🤣🤣
I agree!
There is no way this man was 100% sober on this testimony. Apart from the obvious narcissism and megalomania traits, he's just as incoherent as he's accusing Depp to be
Oulàlà he was a strange one, like Herman Munster or more of Doctor Tarr and Professor Fether?
He definitely appears impaired!
He is almost certainly used psychotropics heavily for a long time in the past or was under the influence of some sort of stimulant psychotropic drug.
@@ExternusArmy i feel it could be cocaine. just the mannerisms of how he is acting, i have witnessed people on the drug before and they can be very passive aggressive and hostile
@@shayalynn hypereactivity, facial dyskinesia, fidgety, lack of self awareness, exaggerated behavior. And he looks like Dr Doofenschmirtz
He was accurately describing AH's behavior. Pretty sure that's what everyone was thinking.
I'm starting to think Amber was set up because I swear to god her legal team and witnesses are too ridiculous to be for real
Is this dude….even sober? He looks really crazy, his eyes, his words and the way that he is talking 😵💫🤡
Most of the psychiatrists are like that..
He is crazy …
You walk into a shrink's office for your first appointment and find Dr. John MacEnroe... in a bad mood.
@@Chalshanaban007 Not sure where you get the statistics from supporting “most” are like that but…..oh well
@@User0899 i means most of them have psychiatric tendencies more or less