Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Facebook - facebook.com/gauravgargeducation Follow Prashant Dhawan on Facebook: facebook.com/prashant.dhawan.79 Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Instagram - instagram.com/tirelesssoul/ Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Twitter - twitter.com/GauravGarg888 Follow Prashant Mavani on Facebook: facebook.com/PrashantTMavani/ Follow Prashant Mavani on Twitter: twitter.com/PrashantMavani
Study IQ education This is good step taken by court to bring similarity among all races , community, caste . Every body should respect court verdict But my concern is about "compiling reason"is that reason include the economic condition or economic status of that sc / ST candidate.before giving them promotion Does backwardness can just be represented by caste or by thier economic status ??if not then why this promotion But instead of giving such promotion & resrvation govt should give free & better education to SC /ST student so that they can fight for govt job. IF THEY DONT STUDY HOW THEY WILL BE QUALIFY TO WRITE GOVT EXAM so govt should focus more on giving them better eduaction rather than giving reservation in promotion If they will not get eduaction then how on what basis they will eligible to write govt exam
तुम्हारे बिज़नस पे कोई नुक्सान न हो इसलिए सच का साथ छोड़ के भी "Politically Correct" रहने वालों, कभी तुमको भी ईश्वर की ऎसी थप्पड़ पड़ेगी कि ये सारी चालाकी धरी कि धरी रह जायेगी.
Sir video to bahut achha banaya hai aapne. Me kota Rajasthan se belong karta hu aur Jodhpur se Mene engineering ki hai..but sc/st reservation me creamy layer and non-creamy layer ka concept hona chhaiye. Otherwise sc/st me jo sahi me poor hai wo kabhi na badhenge aage..balki jiske maa baap already govt job me hai wo hi reservation leta rahega.
Agree and let everything that forward class has goes to backwards and provide forward class with reservation so that instead they would stop wasting time mugging up but die of hunger in the first place
But prosperous people like Tina Dabi also getting the benefits of reservation. It is a political gimmick which will never allow us to be a inclusive society.
iasey toh general category ko loss ho jayega, or bakio ko fayda kyuki OBC 41% hai usko 41% Reservation miljayega SC 29% hai unko 29% reservation mil jayega or general jinko 50% seats k liye moka mil rha h unke pass sirf 30% reh he jayengi think before u write something
auril k i am going abroad on the basis of my skills which i devoloped due to my hardwork and not on basis of my caste or creed. wat a pathetic comment..huh
auril k the company that I am going to serve in Canada had identified my talent and not my caste. so keep crying for reservation , cause that's the thing you do best. I know that this country is not going to be good for my lifestyle in future.
I'm also an civil engineer, preparing for UPSC ESE , recently I gave an state government exam in which cutt off were:- There were 190 seats in which seats for open boy's were 39 yes 39/190 you are reading it correctly.😂 Cutt - off Open - 69/100 OBC- 67/100 SC/ST- 13/100 GIRLS- 01/100 yes 01(one/100)& (YES there is reservations for girls also, ie 33% of total seats 😠 . Apart from SC/ST RESERVATIONS) SO, my point is people who scores 13/100 doesn't even know C of civil engineering (common sense), and they are taking important positions in government and building government's projects like road's, bridge, buildings etc, I want to ask one thing will you ride your bike or car on a bridge which was built by a engineer who's score was 13/100.
Ye kon se exam mei 1 number pe ho gaya??? As far as I know for woman reservation girls have to get 35% marks minimum or else they are disqualified and the seat which is not filled by girls transferee to boys….. 🤔 Matlab bhai oppose karna hai to kijiye bilkul… kyuki pahale to reservation hi hata dena chahiye aur reservation rakhna hai to bhi amendment required hai bade aster per kyunki jinko actually milna chahiye unhe mill nahi raha reservation….
Hamare pass bdske Civil engineer ka C btata hu History ke impact se hmm bhi rote hai tu bhi role . Papa ki jagir nhi h tere phle bhi raj karo aur agge bhi moz kro😠 Inequality ka बीज tum logo ne hi boya hai abb wo पेड़ ban gya hai Uski hi छत्र छाया me rhna sikh lo Ya bula lo apne indra god etc ko reservation hatane k lie .
निष्कर्ष: 1. एक OBC =GEN 2. एक OBC/GEN का आदमी चाहे कितना भी गरीब हो फॉर्म का पूरा पैसा लगेगा। 3. चाहे ST/SC के परिवार में पहले से ही सरकारी नॉकरी कर रहा हो फिर भी इसके संतान को आरक्षण से नौकरी। 4. चाहे SC/ST कितने ही बड़े पद में क्यों न हो हम उसको छोटी जाती का ही समझते हैं। 5. सचिवालयों में किस तरह भाई- भतीजावाद होता है ये सब जानते है। 6. मुसलमान चाहे 300000000 हो जाये वो अल्पसंख्यक ही रहंगे। 7. आरक्षण का एक ही इलाज है खुद PM बनो और इसे खत्म करो या खुद ख़त्म हो जाओ नही तो जिंदगी भर बस comment ही करते रहो।
सर, इतनी महत्वपूर्ण जानकारी देने के लिए धन्यवाद। 81 में से केवल 5 होना साफ साफ दिखाता है कि देश मे जातिवाद और भ्रष्टाचार अपनी चरम सीमा पर रहा है और अभी भी है। ST और SC कर्मचारियों के CR को जातिगत कारणों से कम मार्किंग कर खराब कर दिया जाता है, जिससे उन्हें प्रोमोशन नहीं मिलता। मेरे कुछ साथी यह भी कह रहे हैं कि Reservation खत्म होना चाहिए जो की सही भी है, पर मेरा मानना है कि उससे पहले देश से जातिवाद और भ्रष्टाचार समाप्त हो, अन्यथा 5 की जगह 0 ही दिखेगा।
YO YO roxs tere baap nei india mei reh kr kya aukad liya abhi tak bhik mang re ho tum dum h toh competition kr chutiya bhik kab tak mangega aukat ni h teri hamare se competition krne h tabhi toh bhik k dum pr je rahe ho
vinay bajaj After lots of research i think India is the only country in the world that made for Minoritys only I feel shamed as an Indian majority I know Now some people's ll replay me to say Then leave the Country And i wanna say yha i ll I m saving money for that And i think lots of mature and intelligent peoples Doing same from 1947
@@vinaybajaj6067 chutiye hain ye salle deserving ko jobs dena nahi hai and bolna hai india is developing india is the worst country thats why i will shift some other country on future
government have to give all the private sector and public sector job to these so called social backward people who is only socially backward for reservation . government has to stop mockery with general categories people. general categories people get older at the age of 22-25 but these st/sc are life long younger. we are leading this country towards civil war.
Mukund Kumar : it is good that private sector don't implement reservation policy ... In private all caste are equal and selection took place on the basis of candidate capabilities & knowledge.. I think all caste are doing jobs in private sector also..
S.C. 7% STP 10% STh 5% OBC/MOBC 27% Physically Handicapped 3% (subject to condition prescribed by the Govt.) Women 30% (against reserved and unreserved categories. I believe worst condition is for general male candidate,, who gets old at the age of 26..(as per govt).. Changes to kabhi nahi ayega due to political issues... Black money, corruption, reservation, gdp these topic repeated in every 5year election..now upliftment of already uplifted person going on. Ab toh kheti bhi nahi kar sakte. Faulty start up programe,,
Jo deserve kare unko promotion mile... Make it merit wise. Job toh mil hi Gaya SC ST Ko, they have attained the same platform as general candidate. After that how they woek should be valued
@@khirod84 bhai jo yogya h uska selection hoga ab ye randi rona band karo abhi tak ek bhi essa case nahi aaya h, aur aaya hota toh abhi tak desh mein aag jati
Mantu kanhar rural population me general wale b aate hai..unko b Dena chahiye...Kewal tumhare jaise chutiyo Ko nahi..jo biased statement paas karte hai...aur saare general wale Ambani ki aulad nahi hai...bhikhariii (reservation wala)
Thanks for providing the holistic view Sir! I think Honorable Supreme Court Has taken a judicious verdict. If we glance at the background of most SC/ST they are far behind from the mainstream. Anyhow they are completing their studies and seeking for government jobs to make their live sustainable. They don't have enough assets or funds to open any business or to opt for any other occupation. While the approach of a general person has been higher since primordial. If we see the parallel development of all sections then without Reservation in Promotion SC/ST remains status quo. . In India You won't find any name of SC/ST who is either a business tycoon or Any achiever. And their representation is very low as per statistics. Along with this the anguish among General regarding reservation yielding despair and making the moral down of SC/ST. Government Job is not the ultimate of success but for these sections it is just a first step on success ladder. The race should start from same line. If not than the infirm should be provided immunity.
chutiye hain ye salle deserving ko jobs dena nahi hai and bolna hai india is developing india is the worst country thats why i will shift some other country on future
@@genius8960 32% h beta Zo Reservation Thakuro Ko milna Chahiye wo tumhe kaise mil Rha Kewal 10% h hme 40% Chahiye Kewal Thakuro ko Sare Thakuro n chaha 50% Reservation chin lenge ya alag Desh banayenge Tum log n kon sa company khada Kiya itna reservation s bhi Hadap rhe Ho General ka Seat bhi
Shivam shivam ye vote bank politics nahi hai.... kyu ki general class to sc/st se jada hai but wo vi to ussi govt. Ko vote de rahi hai na koi ye to nahi bol raha ke jo reservation khaatam karega usse hi vote denge jo sc/st baale kaar raahe hai.....news mein kyaa dikhate hai....bus fook diya bike fook diya...aagar aisa hoga to hi baat banega.
Mera ek exam mei 136/200 aya tha phir bhi selection nhi hua pr 130,124,100 Wale obc, sc St sbka selection ho gya. At the end, aisa lagta h mere baap Dada bade ameer log the jo mujhko chinta krne ki zarurat nhi. I am stupid, undeserving because I m general category. IRONY!!!!
सबसे पहले मैं आप का धन्यवाद करना चाहूंगा क्योंकि सर आपने सबसे ज्वलंत मुद्दा लोगों के सामने लाने का प्रयास किया है अक्सर लोग चाहे वह जनरल से हूं या वह भी SC ST जनरल वाले कहते हैं कि ओबीसी एससी एसटी उनकी जॉब पर हक जमाते जा रहे हैं और सारा आरक्षण नहीं को दिया जा रहा है वह भी CST यह कहते हैं कि उनको आरक्षण नहीं मिल रहा है सही से जितना मिलना चाहिए इतिहास उठाकर देख लीजिए अंबेडकर जी की जीवनी पढ़ कर देख लीजिए शुरू से ही सोनू ने पिछड़ों और दलितों पर अपना अधिकार जमा कर रखा है जिसके चलते भारतीय संविधान में SC ST OBC को उठाने के लिए आरक्षण का प्रावधान दिया है और इसी प्रावधान के चलते इन को आगे बढ़ाया जा सकता है या उठाया जा सकता है परंतु सिस्टम में आज भी सामान्य वर्ग के लोगों की मानसिकता इतनी दूषित है इतना भेदभाव करते हैं इसकी गणना करना मुश्किल है लोग कहते हैं कि आर्थिक दृष्टि के अनुसार आरक्षण देना चाहिए आर्थिक दृष्टि से कौन करेगा वही करेंगे जो सिस्टम में बैठे हैं सिस्टम में कौन है ऊंचे पदों पर केवल जनरल प्रतिनिधित्व ज्यादा है अपनों को फिर भरना चालू कर देंगे क्योंकि अपनों को ही वह आर्थिक कमजोर दिखाकर अपनों को लाना चाहते हैं
Don't worry bro though they get reservation still toppers are from general, see top 50 in upsc cse are mostly general , general candidates work hard to suceed
@@dikshit2056LET me correct you, The reason why reserved candidate are not among the toppers in cse because prelims and mains are handwritten no one can alter, but interview is not like that... Y don't u think,let there is a discrimination in that alsoo brother😉That's y we r still developing. Hope u understood🙂
RESERVATION IS THE BIGGEST CORRUPTION IN INDIA........SO RESERVATION MUST BE REMOVED...... POOR PEOPLE SHOULD BE GIVEN FREE EDUCATION UPTILL COLLEGE (GRADUATION).....THE PERSON/ CASTE WHO DOESN'T WANTS TO WORK HARD DEMANDS FOR RESERVATION..... !!!!!!!!!!!
SATYAM SINGH Thank you for telling the truth of our society. You have represented the forward class with your comments. It is because of you people reservation is required. And you have literally spoken the truth
Sahi toh bol ra hai. Kabhi socha hai unn logon ka jinpe farzi SC/ST act lagta hai? Bechare ban na chhodo. Kaabil bano. Reservation ki ghutti ek time tak acchi lagti hai. Ek time k baad phir wahi log aage nikalenge jo kaabil hain. Accquire skills, develop a winning mindset. Reservation ka chutiyapa already desh duba raha hai. Ab aur dubaega.
SATYAM SINGH After lots of research i think India is the only country in the world that made for Minoritys only I feel shamed as an Indian majority I know Now some people's ll replay me to say Then leave the Country And i wanna say yha i ll I m saving money for that And i think lots of mature and intelligent peoples Doing same from 1947
auril k yes the truth has been spoken and you guys literally deserve this ! have you ever wonder why some modern Indian society still agrees to this? it because or the reservation only! several failures even after a lot or hardwork made a common student to jump into the conclusion that his/her sc st counter part is successful just because hi is privileged , he would never see hi hardwork and believe me this is the reality ! the more you guys are supporting caste based reservation the more you are degrading yourself socially ! you will get on high posts but your hardwork will always be suppressed by you sc st tag , even by your lower colleagues! sorry to say but this is the truth
बहुत बहुत धन्यावाद सर लोगो को सही आकडे बताने के लिए काश आपके जैसे वास्तविक विचारधारा वाले सभी लोग होते तो । देश मे आरक्षण को लैकर जो गृहयुद्ध जैसा माहौल बन रहा है वो कभी नही बनता
I think we all general category people should drop our government job and dont go for job till the government end this reservation system..... Let us see that how far our nation will go by reserved ones rather then deserved ones.....
आरक्षण के कारण भेदभाव बढ़ेगा , अभी भी भेदभाव hain पर नए जेनेरशन & टाउन/सिटी में बहुत कम था , पर अब ये caste-पॉलिटिक्स के कारण बढ़ रहा हैं मेरे दोस्त स्कूल तक एक दूसरे का कास्ट नहीं पूछते थे , कॉलेज के बाद एक-दूसरे से नफरत करने लगे hai
I m sc category student and i m belong to middle class but fir bhi me sath abhi tak sc bolke mere friend (jo obc-gen ke hain) ke ghar jaane nahi dete... Infect mere father ka sath bhi bahut hoota h...btaoo tum kiya kru me....tu hoota too kiya krta??
Ye to bhut galat hai esa nhi krna chahiye hmare bhi bhut friend hai but hmare society me esa nhi hota but iske liye reservation me promotion ki nhi mentality change krne ki jarurat hai
I am a general category Gr. C employee in Indian Railways. I am against this policy of reservation in promotion because it really hampers the efficiency of govt offices. SC/ST peoples are getting promoted without securing PASSING marks on the ground of 'BEST AMONG THE FAILED CANDIDATES'. This brings down the working mentality of others who might have done far better in the exam.
1:- With regards to supreme court observation about introduction of Creamy Layer with respect to SC/ST reservation, talks should be conducted with all stakeholders before moving ahead on such a contentious issue. 2 :- As far as promotion are concerned, as of now there is a ambiguity and vagueness in promotion process and hence there is a need for a comprehensive law to be enacted in line with the Supreme Court judgement.
jo mc bola hain...ki hm pak chale....un sab bsdke wlo ko ye pta hona chahiye...freedom of india main sabse jyda khoon hm swarne ne bahyaa hain.......ye india jo hain na (80%+ people reserved caste hain...........ye reservation is country ko barbaad kr degaa........only 5 year main..
Sc/St :- kis jaati se ho bhai saab? Sikh person:- Sikh hu bhai. Sc/St:- ye Sikh kisme aate hai. Sikh person:- paisa ho to Audi me aate hai....naa ho to bus me aate hai...Lekin arakshan ki bheekh mangne road par nahi aate...😂
Nitin Dahikar savidhan ne sirf 10 saal k liye diya hai uske baad se to bheekh hi kha rahe ho saare...general wale na ho to tumhari gand fat jayegi kaam kar kar k..jhaat b naa ho tumse kaam😂😂
deepak jain bhai wo sc/St waale nahi hai.... Wo general waale the jo reservation kelie bhik maang rahe the Waise v sc/ St waale koi v promotion mei reservation kelie nahi aaya.... E to BJP waale politics khelke promotion mei v reservation daal dia
Sir, your video is very informative. Is video ke comments ko dekhakar pata chalata hai ki abhi bhi general walon ke dimag main kitani galat dharana hai sc /st ke prati. Mana reservation main kai khamiyan hain lakin tathya spasht bata rahe hain ki abhi sc/st ko paryapt sthan nahin mil pa raha hai. In general walon ko ye bhi to dekhna chahiye ki reservation keval gov. Jobs main milata hai jo kul (gov.+ Private) jobs ke 5% se bhi kam hai. In comments ko dekhakar ye bhi pata chalata hai ki is chennal par jo ki bahut hi gyanvardhak hai upsc etc . Preparation ke liye par sabase jyada log general ke hai.
Sir aapke question ka ans he "yes" reservation de na chhiye 1)pahela reason ye he ki mere gav me sc,st,aur obc cast vale ke sath bahat buri tarah se treat karte he aur un logo ki life style hum se bahut buri he so me ye kahena chahta tu ki vo log us cast me born hua he usme unki kya galti un logo ko bhi hamari tarah freedom aur acchi tarah jine ka haq he so me agree hu 2)aur dusri bat ye he ke un logoki family me jese ek person ko job mile to un family ke liye reservation bandh kar deni chahiye because aur ek example ye he ki mare gav 40 family he to usme ek family 6 logo ka he to usme 5 person ne reservation ka profit leke job lag gayi aur baki 39 family se 9 log ko hi job he to aesa nahi hona chahiye uske liye goverment ko kuch karna chhiye aur general me jo log BPL ke under me aatma he uska bhi kuch sochna chahiye.
Benefits of Reservation in promotion :- 1) Empowerment of Backward class which was suppressed socially and economically even after 69 years of Independence. 2) It enable them to take their own decision . 3) Person with SC/ST/OBC background knows the challange of their society better than General category. Cons of Reservation in Promotion:- 1) Will affect the administrative efficiency since it is caste based promotion not talent or experience based , Problem of Ego clashes will hurt the fluidity of administration. 2) There is a chance of more discrimination against the backward So it has Reverse effect also. 3) "Equality of opportunity" would be questioned. There should be proper implementation of all the pre existing laws. If the more volume of people will enter into the administration it will automatically create a chance of promotion of Backward class. Most importantly The policy will not affect our socio-cultural fabric which is our Strength and identity as well.
I think instead of just working on the numbers based on quantifiable data, we should work on the quality of reservation system 1. How the reservation should reach the needy ones not the greedy ones. Those data should be taken like how many govt jobs in one particular family of SC or ST. How many families are left which don’t have any member in govt jobs. 2. There should be limitations such that the same person can’t take the benefit of reservation more than 3 times or some no because it is seen that some few people reap the benefits a no of times in their lifetime and some never. 3. There should be creamy layer concept in any kind of reservation
Yes ! There should be reservation in sports as well. Lets assume that in a cricket team of team of 14 the reservation should be as follows OBC - 27% - 3 seats, SC - 5% - 1 seat, ST - 5% - 1 seat, Local Majority Caste - 16% - 2 seats (like Maratha in the state of Maharashtra), Muslims - 5% - 1 seat, Kinner - 5% - 1 seat, EBC - 5% - 1 seat, Nominated by Queen - 5% - 1 seat and Open Category - balance 27% - 3 seats. Some changes should also be made in cricket rules - like For open class batsman, the boundary distance would be 75 - 85 yards where as for reserved category it should be 37-43 yards,Reserve category batsman would get 2 free lives i.e. twice he should be given not out even if he is clean bold,If a reserve category bats man scores 25 runs it should be considered as half century and 50 runs as century,A reserved category bowler will be allowed to bowl under arm and only under arm deliveries will be bowled to him,An LBW appeal will not be made against a Kinner,In stead of neutral umpires we will have 1 OBC, 1 nominated, 1 representative of majority backward caste and 1 from open category,A separate cricket control board should be set up for their cricket and a separate world cup will be arranged for such a team No there isn’t any quota system for the following: Cricket TeamBeauty ContestArmed Forces (army, navy, airforce)Professional courses like CA They only choose deserved not reserved. We are all humans should rise above caste and creed. That’s what our democracy tells us to. This reservation is providing immense benefits to SC/ST/OBC but immense loss and pain to the GENERAL category citizens With a wish to abolish reservation I end here Hope you have a nice day!
Dear sir, you deliver the most valuable information but people still not understood the actual structure of the reservation. Number's says all, why SC ST OBC need reservations in job.
Bro to understand this plz go through hiatory or u can simply go through constituent assembly debates ....you will get most of the answers...or govt को बोलो की caste based census जाहीर करे और सारी castes की social economical और पोलिटिकल conditions को जाहीर करे.......किसको कितनी जरूरत है सब पता चल जायेगा.... पर govt ये नही करेगी ब्रो.... फिर लोगो को confuse कैसे करेंगे... divide and rule कैसे काम करेगा
I'm ao civil engineer, preparing for UPSC ESE , recently I gave an state government exam in which cutt off were:- There were 190 seats in which seats for open boy's were 39 yes 39/190 you are reading it correctly.😂 Cutt - off Open - 69/100 OBC- 67/100 SC/ST- 13/100 GIRLS- 01/100 yes 01(one/100)& (YES there is reservations for girls also, ie 33% of total seats 😠 . Apart from SC/ST RESERVATIONS) SO, my point is people who scores 13/100 doesn't even know C of civil engineering (common sense), and they are taking important positions in government and building government's projects like road's, bridge, buildings etc, I want to ask one thing will you ride your bike or car on a bridge which was built by a engineer who's score was 13/100.
yes he is Correct .jisko fyda milna chahiye unko to milta hi nii h .. its all depend on system that how to manage this reservation policy .and thank you mahipal sir
Roaster system represents the backwards classes representation for promotion, root causes are SC's inefficient adjudication . Today, as i think reservation should be upgraded by finding an extremely backwards sections in backwards sections and promotions should be based on nondiscriminatory working experiences ranking for any categories.
Dr.Mahipal Singh rathore great work by you..its my personal opinion you may disagree with it that...Its totally funny things that some time people say we should save dalit and backwards but when we talk to government job(life security) almost everyone stood against sc/st(reservation).......and the reason behind this our education system and unemployed growth....both are lagging behind too much....suggestions are always welcome
Reservation cycle 1.form ka fee gen -1000 ,obc - 600 ,st/sc-250 2.reservation in 10 to 12 th level less cutoff percentage ... 3.at iit and graduation level reservation 4.at job placement time again reservation. while they get scholarship from govt also 5.again in promotion reservation 6.and in every govt policy they benifit everything ... country is surly going to civil war kahi ek baar hi reservation do aur jis family ko ek baar mile use gen catogary mein daalo baki aur janta hai jisko kuch nahi mila... sab leaders bus yaha khel rha hai janta ka saat
Thank you very much that you explained us so well. Now I am convinced that the Study IQ is just only one platform that tells us any news that its depth.
Bhaiyo chinta na karo...ab rashtriya star par general+ OBC walo ki "Samta andolan samiti" ban chuki hai...bas sabhi log adhik se adhik sankhya me isse Jude..aur arakshan rupi rakshas Ko is Desh se hatane me apna sahyog de...anyatha hamara aur hamare aage aane wali generation ka satyanash hona tay hai...
I belong to oc. In my view there should be reservation(only in govt-jobs) for SC,ST & OBC. Cuz there is still more discrimination in our society. Private sector only take talented and deserved candidates, then what abt rest. Even there is a high chance for these talented guys to get a govt-job. If govt implement this correctly then in our coming decades we may be able to remove this reservation and be a good economy like USA.
CGL this year only 13℅ general candidates were qualified,, and they (reserved) enter at higher age ( age relaxation) so they didn't get that much promotions so not reach at higher levels ,,
सर अगर ऐसे ही आरक्षण चलता रहा तो सामान्य वर्ग वालों को तो आतंकवादी बनना पड़ेगा क्यूँ कि वहाँ आरक्षण नहीं हैं। और ये आरक्षण वाले उसे सातों जनम में नहीं पकड़ पायेंगे।
sribanta Tripathy tumhare jo bjurag the woh manusamriti na bnate...toh aaj sab kuj thik hota....na Ambedkar G class se bahar baith k study krte...na reservation hota yeh reservation bhi tum genral walo ki den hai....
People from SC ST OBC get to be placed for gov. jobs in general category if they get good score in merit like they are treated as a general public. The rest from reserved categories who get their merit score below the cutoff of general category are to be placed in their own respective reserved category decided by the Laws which r 15, 7, n 27. Now the final picture comes in, the SC ST OBC are present on both sides, the general and the reserved. Now the words "general category" become "general public" that means SC+ST+OBC+Unreserved. When somebody raises hands n point out general seats r full means people from all cast together r placed in general category accordingly to their merits . Don't get confused n don't let others to be confused
SC ST wala ghar mein agar 1 Banda officer post par AA Gaya, toh uska PURA khandaan executive post main AA jaata hai.... And this is counted as 1 house!! WTF
Q arises here 1- what is the cast of the person who made this video? 2- From which sources he got all the information 3 - While he is making video ,he is not biased by his cast or people. To make a video n spread rumours is easy but to collect right information is a difficult task.
This is serious and sensitive topic. I have done research on ground level and met many people in this regard. What I found was disturbing that there is a friction between upper caste and lower caste in departments themselves. Anti reservation propaganda is mainly responsible for polarizing views. Everyone is not the same some are good and some are bad in general category. Most SC/ST say that they are being made scapegoat for other's mistakes because higher level management have prejudices against them and accept what ever report is sent by upper caste employees which gives bad name for SC/ST and they have to go to high court to clear their name. I have met many SC/ST in service and retired (I don't want to disclose their identities) say most of them only one promotion in their entire service in which some even have service of 38 years. We need to integrate there people in our society and not to polarise already fractured society on caste and religion lines. Army have segregated units on caste bases which have performed very well like Sikh LI and many others which are for dalits only (lower levels) but promotion are on level of performance in army operations, sports, etc. But I don't think this solution will be possible for civilians. However reservation has proven effective but slow but considering caste system existed for more than 3000 years it will take some time. As for alternatives I found nothing more effective than reservation policy however intercaste marriage children are solution but we have seen case of Rohith Vemula and our society is not ready for it yet. As for those who want to know when Reservation policy will end the correct ans. will be when intercaste marriage between upper caste and lower caste be normal and considered common and caste stigma vanishes.
Sunny Singh What rubbish and biased opinion are you putting out..! I have seen people get 3-4 promotions in 10 -15 years due to sc/st reservations in Karnataka due to which the high court of Karnataka asked the government to demote all those people. Intercaste marriages are taking place all over India but you have no rights to make it a compulsion. It's all up to the individuals..
fact I know it's really hard for some to accept reality as it is. It is not your fault we are constantly bombarded with biased opinion and anti reservation propaganda to fracture society and polarize them for vote bank purposes by political parties. Eg.- Mr. Kajriwal Delhi CM used to openly announce to end reservation when he was running for Delhi election but when he was campaigning for General election he openly advocated for reservation and promised it will not end. There is irrational fear that some how reservation is resulting in general category unemployment but really is even if reservation ends general category will still be unemployed because it is irrelevant and this theory is created by hate which is towards lower caste upliftment. There are always few exceptions in everything. Even If you found some that doesn't reflect the whole picture.
Reservation on the basis of economical condition is acceptable but reservation on the basis of caste is not acceptable . It is heading towards a civil war.
Reservation is a affirmative action to increase representation of oppressed people in the society. And by this will never lead to civil war since most of people come in reserved category.
Sumit Kumar Oppressed people? Living in SOUTHCITY APARTMENTS( one of the biggest apartment in Kolkata), and you are calling them oppressed ? Please tell me one who is earning lakhs of money per month and crores of money per year, how can be oppressed?
Those who are saying reservation will destroy the country, I want to ask few questions to them. Almost 70% of the top posts under Goverment are occupied by General Category and almost 90% of the posts under private sector are occupied by General category. If general category people are so efficient then why our country is still struggling? Why corruption is still there? Don't blame SC/STs. A reserved category student competes within 49.5% although the total population of of reserved category is more than 50%. Similary, a general category student competes for 50.5%, although the total population of general category is less than 50%. Now, who is facing more competition??? Top students from reserved category get jobs under reserved category, similarly Top students from general category get jobs under general category. Those general category students who can not compete under general category, only they are shouting and opposing reservation. They want to abolish reservation for their own sake, they don't want improvement of reserved category same like their ancestors.
गरीब हमेशा गरीब ही होता है चाहे वो किसी भी जाति का हो....भाई अगर कोई जनरल का गरीब है इस समाज में उसे भी कोई नही पूछता और अगर किसी ओर कास्ट का हो तब भी नही...अब लोगो की सोच जाति तक सीमित नही है वो लोगो के समाज मे रुतबे...उसकी नौकरी से बदल जाति है..तो ये कोई हल नही समाज मे समानता लाने का...सरकार को इससे इतर कोई हल लाना चाइये...ये काम कोई सुप्रीम कोर्ट नही कर सकगे...हाँ ये फैसला जातिवादी वैमनस्य पैदा जरूर कर देगा....
Yes honi chahiye Q ki jb India apne constitution ko follow krti hai tb svi area me constitution rule honi chahiye Q ki hm Indian hai aur jise jo milna ho wo jrur mile Jai hind
Bhut shanadar Promotion me reservation hona chahiye Ex- #agr-aaj highcourt me sc/st/obc ke candidates hote to itni तानाशाही nhi hoti kitni bdi bat hai 4 senior judge media se khte hai ki देश का लोकतंत्र खतरे में हैं l #इस-देश-मे-हो-क्या-रहा-है
Affirmative actions are necessary for healthy democracy & egalitarian society, but it should not put efficiency of system at stake.Right place to provide affirmation is before appointment. Then competence of cadet must be criteria
deepak jain par bhai yeh hakikat hai india ki kitna bhi kanun ban gya par logo ka mindset aaj bhi vo hi hai yeh tab change hoga jab k brhaman sc/st join keraga par vo ni kerega le to safh bath hai ki st/sc unke liye nichli jath hai
All we do is complain but youth has been never a vote bank...... if we want change then hum logo ko vote bank banna hoga.....we never give vote to gov. ko sirf kisan aur garib hi dikhte h......itne sare young log h is desh me agr apne pe aa jaye to gov. to reservation end karna hi padega jesa bangladesh me hua pr hum sirf compalin karte h ghr pr betb kar aur kuch ni
If really wanna stop reservation upgrade the education system in rural area cos its totally worse with that we can't give competition n make free the higher secondary free also if really don't want reservation cos afford hi nahi kar paata atche school mai paadne ke liye so aabhibhi dekho jitna bhi reservation delo kabhi equal nahi hoga kyuki backward logo ko government educated karna hi nahi chata
I think reservation should be there because discrimination still exixts in our society..bt candidates capabilities should also be considered, not just the caste..because country's growth depend on them..and one another fact is that reservation doesn't guarantee the social equality..Social equality and equal opportunity is what everyone is in need, being of any caste and category..I think caste system is the root cause of the problem..and I am unable to find out how this problem can be solved..in quora I have read about a few who have shared their incidents of discrimination, and they were not just belonging to sc or st.. Even brahmins were there..tribals and north eastern people were also among them..
Shefali Verma reservation sud b there ..true..bt d prsn who is already there in d govt services ,r they need reservation in promotion? Govt need to form such policies so tht ppl lyk us dnt hv to waste our energy nd precious young age in dreaming aspiring nd wrking fr those things which can nvr b ours.😭 . Ultimately policies lyk these r perpetuating d haterates towrds these so clld sc st sections of d society. ✌
in every 100 job vacency,only 20 to 30 post are reserved for obc,sc and st's.it means 70 post is for general categories.Those who are shouting are hyprocates who cannot compete these maximum(70)posts are blaming caste reservation system.This is not given on the basis of rich and poor.it is given to bring social justice and equality to those people who are deprived from centuries on the basis of their caste...and still they are not given equal status in society.Be logical...don't just shout.....thanks all...
Yes reservation should be there because in rural area education system is totally worse with that we can't give competition n also we have lack of money to study in good college I am saying it as my personal experience
Equality and equity are two different concepts where the former refers to equal sharing between all while the latter represents equal proportions in the sharing with respect to its population,backwardness economically or socially. Here as the data shows there is no adequate representation of SC/ST at all the levels of Govt. Jobs especially Group A/B, so therefore there must be reservation in promotion or at entry level for SC/ST so that it could serve the purpose of principal of equity/fairness. Let me give an example:- Suppose there is a cake which is to be distributed among 10 people of whom 5 are Genearal,3 are OBC,1SC and 1ST. Divide the cake into 10 pieces and give them. What happened in reality 50% of the cake goes to Gen category and the remaining 50% are shared by SC/ST/OBC. WHAT we did is we divide the cake in proportion to the People, that is the principle of equity which ARTICLE 16 intends to serve prescribing equality and at the same time giving parliament the power to enact any law favouring certain classes.
Tumse jyada time tak mehnat भी करते h. तुम jaha शादी ब्याह me maje lete rahte ho us samay gen. Vale घर बैठकर किताबों me apni आँखे फोड़ रहे होते हैं. Talent के दम पर select hote h, भीखमंगो की तरह हाथ nhi फेलाते
मुझे तो सब से गलत ये बात लगती है कि एक तरफ तो एक समूह जनसंख्या बढ़ाता जा रहा है बिना कुछ भी सोचे समझे और फिर उसी आधार पर आरक्षण की मांग की जा रही है। क्या यह उस वर्ग के साथ अन्याय नहीं है जो अपने देश की तरक्की और खुशहाली के लिए जनसंख्या नियंत्रण को जरूरी समझते हैं। पता नहीं सरकार कब न्याय करना सिखेगी।
Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Facebook - facebook.com/gauravgargeducation
Follow Prashant Dhawan on Facebook: facebook.com/prashant.dhawan.79
Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Instagram - instagram.com/tirelesssoul/
Follow Dr Gaurav Garg on Twitter - twitter.com/GauravGarg888
Follow Prashant Mavani on Facebook: facebook.com/PrashantTMavani/
Follow Prashant Mavani on Twitter: twitter.com/PrashantMavani
Study IQ education This is good step taken by court to bring similarity among all races , community, caste . Every body should respect court verdict
But my concern is about "compiling reason"is that reason include the economic condition or economic status of that sc / ST candidate.before giving them promotion
Does backwardness can just be represented by caste or by thier economic status ??if not then why this promotion
But instead of giving such promotion & resrvation govt should give free & better education to SC /ST student so that they can fight for govt job. IF THEY DONT STUDY HOW THEY WILL BE QUALIFY TO WRITE GOVT EXAM so govt should focus more on giving them better eduaction rather than giving reservation in promotion
If they will not get eduaction then how on what basis they will eligible to write govt exam
तुम्हारे बिज़नस पे कोई नुक्सान न हो इसलिए सच का साथ छोड़ के भी "Politically Correct" रहने वालों, कभी तुमको भी ईश्वर की ऎसी थप्पड़ पड़ेगी कि ये सारी चालाकी धरी कि धरी रह जायेगी.
Sir video to bahut achha banaya hai aapne. Me kota Rajasthan se belong karta hu aur Jodhpur se Mene engineering ki hai..but sc/st reservation me creamy layer and non-creamy layer ka concept hona chhaiye. Otherwise sc/st me jo sahi me poor hai wo kabhi na badhenge aage..balki jiske maa baap already govt job me hai wo hi reservation leta rahega.
Study IQ education .
Let there be 100 % reservation so that most of general categories wouldn’t waste their precious Jawani in mugging up.
Agree and let everything that forward class has goes to backwards and provide forward class with reservation so that instead they would stop wasting time mugging up but die of hunger in the first place
Apne baap dadao ki jameeno ko beech kr kaam kr lo kuch. Hamare paas zameene nahi hoti tum general walo ki tarah
But prosperous people like Tina Dabi also getting the benefits of reservation. It is a political gimmick which will never allow us to be a inclusive society.
shubham verma chuitya title to you... from an assamese general.
iasey toh general category ko loss ho jayega, or bakio ko fayda
kyuki OBC 41% hai usko 41% Reservation miljayega
SC 29% hai unko 29% reservation mil jayega or general jinko 50% seats k liye moka mil rha h unke pass sirf 30% reh he jayengi
think before u write something
I am delighted that i am shifting to canada next month.
I will now keep me and my family safe from the curse of this devil RESERVATION.
SANKALP RATHORE yes because if you were a backward class you probably won't even dream of going to Canada. Kudos to your privileges. Identity yourself
auril k i am going abroad on the basis of my skills which i devoloped due to my hardwork and not on basis of my caste or creed.
wat a pathetic comment..huh
auril k the company that I am going to serve in Canada had identified my talent and not my caste.
so keep crying for reservation , cause that's the thing you do best.
I know that this country is not going to be good for my lifestyle in future.
Congrats sankalp Rathore.... Pls, give some suggestions so that we also get job ... This reservation is bullshit
Aare bhai..itna dimag waale ho aap , apart from govt job, aur dhusra job nahi hai kya India meh? Private sector job mein reservation hai?
100% SC/ST reservation kr do jisse hum khalli private field main focus kr ske
One day will come we General category peoples become in backward classes
Dukhi mat ho yaar
Government ko sab ko dekh ke chalna parta hai
Ye sahi hai 100 percent dedo reservation unko yato fir reservation hi khatam kar do.
Roo kyu Raha h Bai private Kya tughe iit Americans company Mai bhi araksan de diya jayega
Nahi nahi tuge to Google ke present mD ko hata kr tughe betha Dena chahiye...
sir actually thats why genral people dont want to stay in country of stupids i m engineer and going to amrica for my job
I'm also an civil engineer, preparing for UPSC ESE , recently I gave an state government exam in which cutt off were:-
There were 190 seats in which seats for open boy's were 39 yes 39/190 you are reading it correctly.😂
Cutt - off
Open - 69/100
OBC- 67/100
SC/ST- 13/100
GIRLS- 01/100 yes 01(one/100)& (YES there is reservations for girls also, ie 33% of total seats 😠 . Apart from SC/ST RESERVATIONS)
SO, my point is people who scores 13/100 doesn't even know C of civil engineering (common sense), and they are taking important positions in government and building government's projects like road's, bridge, buildings etc, I want to ask one thing will you ride your bike or car on a bridge which was built by a engineer who's score was 13/100.
Yes it's right but then what about management seats which r bought with money
Ye kon se exam mei 1 number pe ho gaya??? As far as I know for woman reservation girls have to get 35% marks minimum or else they are disqualified and the seat which is not filled by girls transferee to boys….. 🤔
Matlab bhai oppose karna hai to kijiye bilkul… kyuki pahale to reservation hi hata dena chahiye aur reservation rakhna hai to bhi amendment required hai bade aster per kyunki jinko actually milna chahiye unhe mill nahi raha reservation….
Hamare pass bdske
Civil engineer ka C btata hu
History ke impact se hmm bhi rote hai tu bhi role .
Papa ki jagir nhi h tere phle bhi raj karo aur agge bhi moz kro😠
Inequality ka बीज tum logo ne hi boya hai abb wo पेड़ ban gya hai
Uski hi छत्र छाया me rhna sikh lo
Ya bula lo apne indra god etc ko reservation hatane k lie .
निष्कर्ष:
1. एक OBC =GEN
2. एक OBC/GEN का आदमी चाहे कितना भी गरीब हो फॉर्म का पूरा पैसा लगेगा।
3. चाहे ST/SC के परिवार में पहले से ही सरकारी नॉकरी कर रहा हो फिर भी इसके संतान को आरक्षण से नौकरी।
4. चाहे SC/ST कितने ही बड़े पद में क्यों न हो हम उसको छोटी जाती का ही समझते हैं।
5. सचिवालयों में किस तरह भाई- भतीजावाद होता है ये सब जानते है।
6. मुसलमान चाहे 300000000 हो जाये वो अल्पसंख्यक ही रहंगे।
7. आरक्षण का एक ही इलाज है खुद PM बनो और इसे खत्म करो या खुद ख़त्म हो जाओ नही तो जिंदगी भर बस comment ही करते रहो।
Smart Tech Tech ham St SC OBC ek hai mulnivasi baki videshi ham logo ko Salah na de.
Reservation nhi hona chahiye jo jitna able h use usi k according job honi chahiye
General wale apni behn betiya sc st walo se byah de sc/st wale reservation chhod denge..
Sart laga lo..
Wese b akbar se byah hi chuke ho history me..
Smart Tech Tech bhai te commets krte raho
Kavya Singh I don't understand
सर, इतनी महत्वपूर्ण जानकारी देने के लिए धन्यवाद।
81 में से केवल 5 होना साफ साफ दिखाता है कि देश मे जातिवाद और भ्रष्टाचार अपनी चरम सीमा पर रहा है और अभी भी है। ST और SC कर्मचारियों के CR को जातिगत कारणों से कम मार्किंग कर खराब कर दिया जाता है, जिससे उन्हें प्रोमोशन नहीं मिलता।
मेरे कुछ साथी यह भी कह रहे हैं कि Reservation खत्म होना चाहिए जो की सही भी है, पर मेरा मानना है कि उससे पहले देश से जातिवाद और भ्रष्टाचार समाप्त हो, अन्यथा 5 की जगह 0 ही दिखेगा।
A country for reserve not for deserve
YO YO roxs tere baap nei india mei reh kr kya aukad liya
abhi tak bhik mang re ho tum
dum h toh competition kr chutiya bhik kab tak mangega
aukat ni h teri hamare se competition krne h tabhi toh bhik k dum pr je rahe ho
vinay bajaj
After lots of research i think India is the only country in the world that made for Minoritys only
I feel shamed as an Indian majority
I know
Now some people's ll replay me to say
Then leave the Country
And i wanna say yha i ll
I m saving money for that
And i think lots of mature and intelligent peoples
Doing same from 1947
very good
@@vinaybajaj6067 chutiye hain ye salle deserving ko jobs dena nahi hai and bolna hai india is developing india is the worst country thats why i will shift some other country on future
Now what kinds of reservations are left?
Reservation on Food and water
Reservation on Oxygen
Reservation of excretion
Reservation on buying products
Good
government have to give all the private sector and public sector job to these so called social backward people who is only socially backward for reservation . government has to stop mockery with general categories people. general categories people get older at the age of 22-25 but these st/sc are life long younger. we are leading this country towards civil war.
Mukund Kumar : it is good that private sector don't implement reservation policy ... In private all caste are equal and selection took place on the basis of candidate capabilities & knowledge.. I think all caste are doing jobs in private sector also..
Abhishek Raghuwanshi.. na bhai naa Meena, Gurjar, jarewal etc. Kabhi nahi dikhenge private me kyo ki inse mehnat nahi Hoti
Mukund Kumar truth has be told
reseratvation vale murakh hai unako padna to kuch hai nahi bus naukari chaiye....tum sale chaparasi bano sc st obc
S.C. 7%
STP 10%
STh 5%
OBC/MOBC 27%
Physically Handicapped 3% (subject to condition prescribed by the Govt.)
Women 30% (against reserved and unreserved categories.
I believe worst condition is for general male candidate,, who gets old at the age of 26..(as per govt).. Changes to kabhi nahi ayega due to political issues... Black money, corruption, reservation, gdp these topic repeated in every 5year election..now upliftment of already uplifted person going on. Ab toh kheti bhi nahi kar sakte. Faulty start up programe,,
Jo deserve kare unko promotion mile... Make it merit wise. Job toh mil hi Gaya SC ST Ko, they have attained the same platform as general candidate.
After that how they woek should be valued
Saurabh Ranjan SHARMA There no question of deserving people because because sycophants nd bootlickers are promoted up the higher echelon
Sumit Kumar yeah, very truly said.
Saurabh Ranjan SHARMA.. So general people will decide SC ST logon ka maap dand lenge..???
@@khirod84 bhai jo yogya h uska selection hoga ab ye randi rona band karo abhi tak ek bhi essa case nahi aaya h, aur aaya hota toh abhi tak desh mein aag jati
Thanks you government for this final nail in the coffin of a general student
I didn't expect more from you guys
Priyesh Jha same was the verdict against SC St law and they are trying every thing they could to retrieve it
Yes, reservation hona chahia otherwise rural peoples can't improve.
Mantu kanhar idiot do u know anything about "sarcasm"
Mantu kanhar rural population me general wale b aate hai..unko b Dena chahiye...Kewal tumhare jaise chutiyo Ko nahi..jo biased statement paas karte hai...aur saare general wale Ambani ki aulad nahi hai...bhikhariii (reservation wala)
Thanks for providing the holistic view Sir!
I think Honorable Supreme Court Has taken a judicious verdict. If we glance at the background of most SC/ST they are far behind from the mainstream. Anyhow they are completing their studies and seeking for government jobs to make their live sustainable.
They don't have enough assets or funds to open any business or to opt for any other occupation. While the approach of a general person has been higher since primordial.
If we see the parallel development of all sections then without Reservation in Promotion SC/ST remains status quo.
.
In India You won't find any name of SC/ST who is either a business tycoon or Any achiever. And their representation is very low as per statistics.
Along with this the anguish among General regarding reservation yielding despair and making the moral down of SC/ST.
Government Job is not the ultimate of success but for these sections it is just a first step on success ladder.
The race should start from same line. If not than the infirm should be provided immunity.
Make reservations 100% . Why just only 50% for those backward classes.. let general category die..
R.I.P general category
chutiye hain ye salle deserving ko jobs dena nahi hai and bolna hai india is developing india is the worst country thats why i will shift some other country on future
@@feox1308 deserving to wo log bhi the jinka sab kuch cheen liya gaya tha unhe achoot bol ke tab kanha tha tu
@@genius8960 tu Achoot h hi
Hmlog s kya h ab
50% seat to ab bhi bhadvo ko hi mil rahi hai 😂😂😂😂😅 jabki hai sirf 15%
@@genius8960 32% h beta
Zo Reservation Thakuro Ko milna Chahiye wo tumhe kaise mil Rha
Kewal 10% h hme
40% Chahiye Kewal Thakuro ko
Sare Thakuro n chaha 50% Reservation chin lenge ya alag Desh banayenge
Tum log n kon sa company khada Kiya itna reservation s bhi
Hadap rhe Ho General ka Seat bhi
It's only vote bank politics
AMIT MEENA आप क्या कहना चाहते हैं कृपया साफ-साफ बताएं
Right . Aaj promotion main reservation hai . Kal exam main mark rakhne ke liye reservation ki jarurat padegi 😂😂😂
Shivam shivam ye vote bank politics nahi hai.... kyu ki general class to sc/st se jada hai but wo vi to ussi govt. Ko vote de rahi hai na koi ye to nahi bol raha ke jo reservation khaatam karega usse hi vote denge jo sc/st baale kaar raahe hai.....news mein kyaa dikhate hai....bus fook diya bike fook diya...aagar aisa hoga to hi baat banega.
Right bro
*💯% reservation dedo aur hospital,shop,malls, school, public transport,roads, Inn jageh pe BHI reservation do,,,aur humme goli mar do*
💯💯💯💯
Mera ek exam mei 136/200 aya tha phir bhi selection nhi hua pr 130,124,100 Wale obc, sc St sbka selection ho gya. At the end, aisa lagta h mere baap Dada bade ameer log the jo mujhko chinta krne ki zarurat nhi. I am stupid, undeserving because I m general category. IRONY!!!!
Totally vote bank politics by government
सबसे पहले मैं आप का धन्यवाद करना चाहूंगा क्योंकि सर आपने सबसे ज्वलंत मुद्दा लोगों के सामने लाने का प्रयास किया है अक्सर लोग चाहे वह जनरल से हूं या वह भी SC ST जनरल वाले कहते हैं कि ओबीसी एससी एसटी उनकी जॉब पर हक जमाते जा रहे हैं और सारा आरक्षण नहीं को दिया जा रहा है वह भी CST यह कहते हैं कि उनको आरक्षण नहीं मिल रहा है सही से जितना मिलना चाहिए इतिहास उठाकर देख लीजिए अंबेडकर जी की जीवनी पढ़ कर देख लीजिए शुरू से ही सोनू ने पिछड़ों और दलितों पर अपना अधिकार जमा कर रखा है जिसके चलते भारतीय संविधान में SC ST OBC को उठाने के लिए आरक्षण का प्रावधान दिया है और इसी प्रावधान के चलते इन को आगे बढ़ाया जा सकता है या उठाया जा सकता है परंतु सिस्टम में आज भी सामान्य वर्ग के लोगों की मानसिकता इतनी दूषित है इतना भेदभाव करते हैं इसकी गणना करना मुश्किल है लोग कहते हैं कि आर्थिक दृष्टि के अनुसार आरक्षण देना चाहिए आर्थिक दृष्टि से कौन करेगा वही करेंगे जो सिस्टम में बैठे हैं सिस्टम में कौन है ऊंचे पदों पर केवल जनरल प्रतिनिधित्व ज्यादा है अपनों को फिर भरना चालू कर देंगे क्योंकि अपनों को ही वह आर्थिक कमजोर दिखाकर अपनों को लाना चाहते हैं
Scored high percentile in entrance still sitting at home thanks to my open category
Don't worry bro though they get reservation still toppers are from general, see top 50 in upsc cse are mostly general , general candidates work hard to suceed
@@dikshit2056LET me correct you, The reason why reserved candidate are not among the toppers in cse because prelims and mains are handwritten no one can alter, but interview is not like that... Y don't u think,let there is a discrimination in that alsoo brother😉That's y we r still developing. Hope u understood🙂
RESERVATION IS THE BIGGEST CORRUPTION IN INDIA........SO RESERVATION MUST BE REMOVED...... POOR PEOPLE SHOULD BE GIVEN FREE EDUCATION UPTILL COLLEGE (GRADUATION).....THE PERSON/ CASTE WHO DOESN'T WANTS TO WORK HARD DEMANDS FOR RESERVATION..... !!!!!!!!!!!
100% reservation de doge phir bhi pechare hi rahege 😀
SATYAM SINGH Thank you for telling the truth of our society. You have represented the forward class with your comments. It is because of you people reservation is required. And you have literally spoken the truth
Sahi toh bol ra hai. Kabhi socha hai unn logon ka jinpe farzi SC/ST act lagta hai? Bechare ban na chhodo. Kaabil bano. Reservation ki ghutti ek time tak acchi lagti hai. Ek time k baad phir wahi log aage nikalenge jo kaabil hain. Accquire skills, develop a winning mindset. Reservation ka chutiyapa already desh duba raha hai. Ab aur dubaega.
YO YO roxs Aaj bhatta p Kam karne nahi gaye kya😁
SATYAM SINGH
After lots of research i think India is the only country in the world that made for Minoritys only
I feel shamed as an Indian majority
I know
Now some people's ll replay me to say
Then leave the Country
And i wanna say yha i ll
I m saving money for that
And i think lots of mature and intelligent peoples
Doing same from 1947
auril k yes the truth has been spoken and you guys literally deserve this ! have you ever wonder why some modern Indian society still agrees to this? it because or the reservation only! several failures even after a lot or hardwork made a common student to jump into the conclusion that his/her sc st counter part is successful just because hi is privileged , he would never see hi hardwork and believe me this is the reality ! the more you guys are supporting caste based reservation the more you are degrading yourself socially ! you will get on high posts but your hardwork will always be suppressed by you sc st tag , even by your lower colleagues! sorry to say but this is the truth
बहुत बहुत धन्यावाद सर लोगो को सही आकडे बताने के लिए
काश आपके जैसे वास्तविक विचारधारा वाले सभी लोग होते तो । देश मे आरक्षण को लैकर जो गृहयुद्ध जैसा माहौल बन रहा है वो कभी नही बनता
I think we all general category people should drop our government job and dont go for job till the government end this reservation system.....
Let us see that how far our nation will go by reserved ones rather then deserved ones.....
Shandar sir bhot acche se smjhayaaa apneee yese smjhate rho bhot bhot dhnywad
आरक्षण के कारण भेदभाव बढ़ेगा , अभी भी भेदभाव hain पर नए जेनेरशन & टाउन/सिटी में बहुत कम था , पर अब ये caste-पॉलिटिक्स के कारण बढ़ रहा हैं
मेरे दोस्त स्कूल तक एक दूसरे का कास्ट नहीं पूछते थे , कॉलेज के बाद एक-दूसरे से नफरत करने लगे hai
School main v puchhajata hai.gaon Jake dekho abhi v bachhon ko teacher cook ka student ka discrimination ka samana karna padta hai
I m sc category student and i m belong to middle class but fir bhi me sath abhi tak sc bolke mere friend (jo obc-gen ke hain) ke ghar jaane nahi dete... Infect mere father ka sath bhi bahut hoota h...btaoo tum kiya kru me....tu hoota too kiya krta??
Ye to bhut galat hai esa nhi krna chahiye hmare bhi bhut friend hai but hmare society me esa nhi hota but iske liye reservation me promotion ki nhi mentality change krne ki jarurat hai
@@himanshusekharnag308 me rural area se hun koi nahi puchta gao me bhi
@@chouhanvlogs reservation se ye kam kaise hoga jara ye bata do
I am a general category Gr. C employee in Indian Railways. I am against this policy of reservation in promotion because it really hampers the efficiency of govt offices. SC/ST peoples are getting promoted without securing PASSING marks on the ground of 'BEST AMONG THE FAILED CANDIDATES'. This brings down the working mentality of others who might have done far better in the exam.
1:- With regards to supreme court observation about introduction of Creamy Layer with respect to SC/ST reservation, talks should be conducted with all stakeholders before moving ahead on such a contentious issue.
2 :- As far as promotion are concerned, as of now there is a ambiguity and vagueness in promotion process and hence there is a need for a comprehensive law to be enacted in line with the Supreme Court judgement.
Sabhi forward caste ko road pe aana hoga apne haq ke liye humare saath bhed bhaw ho raha iss desh me.
😂😂😂😂
To bhag jao pakistan
jo mc bola hain...ki hm pak chale....un sab bsdke wlo ko ye pta hona chahiye...freedom of india main sabse jyda khoon hm swarne ne bahyaa hain.......ye india jo hain na (80%+ people reserved caste hain...........ye reservation is country ko barbaad kr degaa........only 5 year main..
hum(Marathas) toh aachuke he abb baki sabKi der hey sab aagye toh kuch ho payega
ROYAL PRODUCTIONS बिल्कुल सही किया अगले महीने राजस्थान में राजपूत व ब्राह्मण समाज भी करणी सेना के नेतृत्व में आ रहा है
Sc/St :- kis jaati se ho bhai saab?
Sikh person:- Sikh hu bhai.
Sc/St:- ye Sikh kisme aate hai.
Sikh person:- paisa ho to Audi me aate hai....naa ho to bus me aate hai...Lekin arakshan ki bheekh mangne road par nahi aate...😂
FYI , Sikh bhi SC hote hai
deepak jain kab bheekh mangi hai zara batana bhaiya
Learn & Fun Abhi saare Patel Gujarat me aaye the bheekh mangne fir Gurjar Rajasthan me...
Nitin Dahikar savidhan ne sirf 10 saal k liye diya hai uske baad se to bheekh hi kha rahe ho saare...general wale na ho to tumhari gand fat jayegi kaam kar kar k..jhaat b naa ho tumse kaam😂😂
deepak jain bhai wo sc/St waale nahi hai.... Wo general waale the jo reservation kelie bhik maang rahe the
Waise v sc/ St waale koi v promotion mei reservation kelie nahi aaya.... E to BJP waale politics khelke promotion mei v reservation daal dia
1⃣4⃣.5⃣8⃣➡️ Secretary level Officer भी अगर आरक्षित श्रेणी से लग गए तो देश पूरी तरह गर्त में चला जाएगा।
इसलिए सरकार भी..............
Government job walo ko bhi reservation!!!? Ab wo bhi backward hai Kya?
Ankit Shukla . Bilkul sahi bola bhai 👍👍👍..😅😂😅😂
Ankit Shukla seriously dude. this vote bank politics will end up eating the worthy candidates' future.
Ajay Singh be prepare now there will be a civil war and there will be 90% reservation for Sc St in death. Fuck off.
YO YO roxs तू चमार होकर क्यो नौकरी मांग रहा है जाकर जूता सील
Papa Mahadev well said, like what happened during time of ranveer sena
Great
Higher education
Jobs tak theek tha
Promotion me bhi reservation 👏🏼👏🏼
agreed
Supreme Court wants to continue discrimination in India
Sir eligibility BHI to honi Chahiye..
Koi base to Hona Chahiye promotion k liye...
Sir, your video is very informative. Is video ke comments ko dekhakar pata chalata hai ki abhi bhi general walon ke dimag main kitani galat dharana hai sc /st ke prati. Mana reservation main kai khamiyan hain lakin tathya spasht bata rahe hain ki abhi sc/st ko paryapt sthan nahin mil pa raha hai. In general walon ko ye bhi to dekhna chahiye ki reservation keval gov. Jobs main milata hai jo kul (gov.+ Private) jobs ke 5% se bhi kam hai. In comments ko dekhakar ye bhi pata chalata hai ki is chennal par jo ki bahut hi gyanvardhak hai upsc etc . Preparation ke liye par sabase jyada log general ke hai.
RIGHT TO EQUALITY
BUT INDIAN GOVERNMENT SAVE VOTE BANK🔥
Sir aapke question ka ans he "yes" reservation de na chhiye
1)pahela reason ye he ki mere gav me sc,st,aur obc cast vale ke sath bahat buri tarah se treat karte he aur un logo ki life style hum se bahut buri he so me ye kahena chahta tu ki vo log us cast me born hua he usme unki kya galti un logo ko bhi hamari tarah freedom aur acchi tarah jine ka haq he so me agree hu
2)aur dusri bat ye he ke un logoki family me jese ek person ko job mile to un family ke liye reservation bandh kar deni chahiye because aur ek example ye he ki mare gav 40 family he to usme ek family 6 logo ka he to usme 5 person ne reservation ka profit leke job lag gayi aur baki 39 family se 9 log ko hi job he to aesa nahi hona chahiye uske liye goverment ko kuch karna chhiye aur general me jo log BPL ke under me aatma he uska bhi kuch sochna chahiye.
I'm just waiting for the time when being SC/ST will allow people to act as King over general category
Yeah 🙏
Zada din chalega nhi ye
Usse pehle hi Desh ka batwara hoga
50% Bharat General ka
Bahut badhiya Baat aapane Kahi Bhai Main Bhi anusuchit jaati hun itni acchi baat to Aaj Tak Kisi Ne Nahin Kaha hoga
Yes, reversation to hona chahiye. It's important to make equality in promotion opportunity
Benefits of Reservation in promotion :-
1) Empowerment of Backward class which was suppressed socially and economically even after 69 years of Independence.
2) It enable them to take their own decision .
3) Person with SC/ST/OBC background knows the challange of their society better than General category.
Cons of Reservation in Promotion:-
1) Will affect the administrative efficiency since it is caste based promotion not talent or experience based , Problem of Ego clashes will hurt the fluidity of administration.
2) There is a chance of more discrimination against the backward So it has Reverse effect also.
3) "Equality of opportunity" would be questioned.
There should be proper implementation of all the pre existing laws. If the more volume of people will enter into the administration it will automatically create a chance of promotion of Backward class.
Most importantly The policy will not affect our socio-cultural fabric which is our Strength and identity as well.
If people stop castism in promotions, then there is no need of reservation for perticular category...
Jai Hind
I think instead of just working on the numbers based on quantifiable data, we should work on the quality of reservation system
1. How the reservation should reach the needy ones not the greedy ones. Those data should be taken like how many govt jobs in one particular family of SC or ST. How many families are left which don’t have any member in govt jobs.
2. There should be limitations such that the same person can’t take the benefit of reservation more than 3 times or some no because it is seen that some few people reap the benefits a no of times in their lifetime and some never.
3. There should be creamy layer concept in any kind of reservation
i agree "one family one govt job"....!!!
must be applied on all the categories including general catagory....
Well explained...
Yes ! There should be reservation in sports as well. Lets assume that in a cricket team of team of 14 the reservation should be as follows
OBC - 27% - 3 seats, SC - 5% - 1 seat, ST - 5% - 1 seat, Local Majority Caste - 16% - 2 seats (like Maratha in the state of Maharashtra), Muslims - 5% - 1 seat, Kinner - 5% - 1 seat, EBC - 5% - 1 seat, Nominated by Queen - 5% - 1 seat and Open Category - balance 27% - 3 seats.
Some changes should also be made in cricket rules - like
For open class batsman, the boundary distance would be 75 - 85 yards where as for reserved category it should be 37-43 yards,Reserve category batsman would get 2 free lives i.e. twice he should be given not out even if he is clean bold,If a reserve category bats man scores 25 runs it should be considered as half century and 50 runs as century,A reserved category bowler will be allowed to bowl under arm and only under arm deliveries will be bowled to him,An LBW appeal will not be made against a Kinner,In stead of neutral umpires we will have 1 OBC, 1 nominated, 1 representative of majority backward caste and 1 from open category,A separate cricket control board should be set up for their cricket and a separate world cup will be arranged for such a team
No there isn’t any quota system for the following:
Cricket TeamBeauty ContestArmed Forces (army, navy, airforce)Professional courses like CA
They only choose deserved not reserved.
We are all humans should rise above caste and creed. That’s what our democracy tells us to.
This reservation is providing immense benefits to SC/ST/OBC but immense loss and pain to the GENERAL category citizens
With a wish to abolish reservation I end here
Hope you have a nice day!
सवर्ण भारत के तृतीय श्रेणी के नागरिक है, जिनकी समस्या कोई समझने वाला नही है
Great Video with a very impartial analysis .
Dear sir, you deliver the most valuable information but people still not understood the actual structure of the reservation.
Number's says all, why SC ST OBC need reservations in job.
Bro to understand this plz go through hiatory or u can simply go through constituent assembly debates ....you will get most of the answers...or govt को बोलो की caste based census जाहीर करे और सारी castes की social economical और पोलिटिकल conditions को जाहीर करे.......किसको कितनी जरूरत है सब पता चल जायेगा.... पर govt ये नही करेगी ब्रो.... फिर लोगो को confuse कैसे करेंगे... divide and rule कैसे काम करेगा
Apni behno betiyo byah kahe nhi krte ho..
Reservation chhod denge ye log
so lets remove reservation from urban area atleast
I'm ao civil engineer, preparing for UPSC ESE , recently I gave an state government exam in which cutt off were:-
There were 190 seats in which seats for open boy's were 39 yes 39/190 you are reading it correctly.😂
Cutt - off
Open - 69/100
OBC- 67/100
SC/ST- 13/100
GIRLS- 01/100 yes 01(one/100)& (YES there is reservations for girls also, ie 33% of total seats 😠 . Apart from SC/ST RESERVATIONS)
SO, my point is people who scores 13/100 doesn't even know C of civil engineering (common sense), and they are taking important positions in government and building government's projects like road's, bridge, buildings etc, I want to ask one thing will you ride your bike or car on a bridge which was built by a engineer who's score was 13/100.
Thts also d reason y India z still developing country..
Very Very Thanks Mahipal Sir ji.
yes he is Correct .jisko fyda milna chahiye unko to milta hi nii h .. its all depend on system that how to manage this reservation policy .and thank you mahipal sir
Roaster system represents the backwards classes representation for promotion,
root causes are SC's inefficient adjudication .
Today, as i think reservation should be upgraded by finding an extremely backwards sections in backwards sections and promotions should be based on nondiscriminatory working experiences ranking for any categories.
Dr.Mahipal Singh rathore great work by you..its my personal opinion you may disagree with it that...Its totally funny things that some time people say we should save dalit and backwards but when we talk to government job(life security) almost everyone stood against sc/st(reservation).......and the reason behind this our education system and unemployed growth....both are lagging behind too much....suggestions are always welcome
Promotion should be given on basis of talent not caste, this itself is systematic discrimination in the system.
Sc is in favor of discrimination
Reservation cycle
1.form ka fee gen -1000 ,obc - 600 ,st/sc-250
2.reservation in 10 to 12 th level less cutoff percentage ...
3.at iit and graduation level reservation
4.at job placement time again reservation. while they get scholarship from govt also
5.again in promotion reservation
6.and in every govt policy they benifit everything ...
country is surly going to civil war
kahi ek baar hi reservation do aur jis family ko ek baar mile use gen catogary mein daalo baki aur janta hai jisko kuch nahi mila... sab leaders bus yaha khel rha hai janta ka saat
Nice information 👌
Thank you very much that you explained us so well. Now I am convinced that the Study IQ is just only one platform that tells us any news that its depth.
Bhaiyo chinta na karo...ab rashtriya star par general+ OBC walo ki "Samta andolan samiti" ban chuki hai...bas sabhi log adhik se adhik sankhya me isse Jude..aur arakshan rupi rakshas Ko is Desh se hatane me apna sahyog de...anyatha hamara aur hamare aage aane wali generation ka satyanash hona tay hai...
deepak jain ✌
Obc people will never come with u feudal casteist chauvinist who have oppressed us as well along with sc and St .
Sumit Kumar Aisa tujhe lag raha hai pagle..par OBC wale b dukhi hai reservation se...is samiti me Sabse jyada OBC hi Jude huye hai
Sumit Kumar Rahi baat oppression ki to mene ya mere pitaji ne kisi ka oppression nahi Kiya..for your kind information
deepak jain bhai ese chutiyo ko samjhne se matlab nhi hain, in behn k lodo ki jab kud maa chudegi tab hi aayenge apne paas rote hue
already government offices have low efficiency and if reservation in promotion will be provided it will become more less
I belong to oc.
In my view there should be reservation(only in govt-jobs) for SC,ST & OBC. Cuz there is still more discrimination in our society. Private sector only take talented and deserved candidates, then what abt rest. Even there is a high chance for these talented guys to get a govt-job. If govt implement this correctly then in our coming decades we may be able to remove this reservation and be a good economy like USA.
Praveen Kumar Lol..You are oc..Best joke...OC's knows the pain of reservation... Don't talk shit you fool..I am sure you are low caste begger.....
Kuch log video poori dekhe bina hi comment kar rahe hain un logo se anurodh hai ki kripya video poori tarah dekh le tab apna rona roye
Very good discussion i agree with you. Thank you very much!
Yes. It should be . Logical and reasonable. Why should reservation in promotion. Reason given in census.
CGL this year only 13℅ general candidates were qualified,,
and they (reserved) enter at higher age ( age relaxation) so they didn't get that much promotions so not
reach at higher levels ,,
just rational arguments .........glad to hear........
First of all toh reservation he khtm Kar Dena chaiye.....
Gaurav Jaiswal taki sabhi job general wale kha jaye
jaswinder singh general wale kese khaenge.....jo acha karega use job milega
jaswinder singh dum h to bina reservation lekar hard work krke job nikal k dikhao na .....
सर अगर ऐसे ही आरक्षण चलता रहा तो सामान्य वर्ग वालों को तो आतंकवादी बनना पड़ेगा क्यूँ कि वहाँ आरक्षण नहीं हैं। और ये आरक्षण वाले उसे सातों जनम में नहीं पकड़ पायेंगे।
sribanta Tripathy tumhare jo bjurag the woh manusamriti na bnate...toh aaj sab kuj thik hota....na Ambedkar G class se bahar baith k study krte...na reservation hota yeh reservation bhi tum genral walo ki den hai....
People from SC ST OBC get to be placed for gov. jobs in general category if they get good score in merit like they are treated as a general public. The rest from reserved categories who get their merit score below the cutoff of general category are to be placed in their own respective reserved category decided by the Laws which r 15, 7, n 27. Now the final picture comes in, the SC ST OBC are present on both sides, the general and the reserved. Now the words "general category" become "general public" that means SC+ST+OBC+Unreserved. When somebody raises hands n point out general seats r full means people from all cast together r placed in general category accordingly to their merits . Don't get confused n don't let others to be confused
SC ST wala ghar mein agar 1 Banda officer post par AA Gaya, toh uska PURA khandaan executive post main AA jaata hai.... And this is counted as 1 house!! WTF
Saurabh Ranjan SHARMA tujhe jo data mahipal sir ne dikhya wo samajh nahi aaya kya...kon se chasme se dekhta hai duniya ko...
Saurabh Ranjan SHARMA tujhe bhi to 27% chhut h
Sc st wale gand mar rhe hi kya be
Manjeet Kumar haha, SC ST walo main itna dum kaha ki wo khud mar sake...Sarkar ne Jo unko "strap on" de Rekha hai...usse dar lagta hai...😂😂
Tum log insaan ki tarah socho janwaro ki tarah nhi reservation public percentage k hisab se hona hi chahiye...Sabhi posts par
Q arises here
1- what is the cast of the person who made this video?
2- From which sources he got all the information
3 - While he is making video ,he is not biased by his cast or people.
To make a video n spread rumours is easy but to collect right information is a difficult task.
This is serious and sensitive topic. I have done research on ground level and met many people in this regard. What I found was disturbing that there is a friction between upper caste and lower caste in departments themselves. Anti reservation propaganda is mainly responsible for polarizing views. Everyone is not the same some are good and some are bad in general category. Most SC/ST say that they are being made scapegoat for other's mistakes because higher level management have prejudices against them and accept what ever report is sent by upper caste employees which gives bad name for SC/ST and they have to go to high court to clear their name. I have met many SC/ST in service and retired (I don't want to disclose their identities) say most of them only one promotion in their entire service in which some even have service of 38 years. We need to integrate there people in our society and not to polarise already fractured society on caste and religion lines. Army have segregated units on caste bases which have performed very well like Sikh LI and many others which are for dalits only (lower levels) but promotion are on level of performance in army operations, sports, etc. But I don't think this solution will be possible for civilians. However reservation has proven effective but slow but considering caste system existed for more than 3000 years it will take some time. As for alternatives I found nothing more effective than reservation policy however intercaste marriage children are solution but we have seen case of Rohith Vemula and our society is not ready for it yet. As for those who want to know when Reservation policy will end the correct ans. will be when intercaste marriage between upper caste and lower caste be normal and considered common and caste stigma vanishes.
Sunny Singh
What rubbish and biased opinion are you putting out..! I have seen people get 3-4 promotions in 10 -15 years due to sc/st reservations in Karnataka due to which the high court of Karnataka asked the government to demote all those people.
Intercaste marriages are taking place all over India but you have no rights to make it a compulsion. It's all up to the individuals..
fact
I know it's really hard for some to accept reality as it is. It is not your fault we are constantly bombarded with biased opinion and anti reservation propaganda to fracture society and polarize them for vote bank purposes by political parties. Eg.- Mr. Kajriwal Delhi CM used to openly announce to end reservation when he was running for Delhi election but when he was campaigning for General election he openly advocated for reservation and promised it will not end.
There is irrational fear that some how reservation is resulting in general category unemployment but really is even if reservation ends general category will still be unemployed because it is irrelevant and this theory is created by hate which is towards lower caste upliftment.
There are always few exceptions in everything. Even If you found some that doesn't reflect the whole picture.
Thank you
Aysa संविधान bhaad me जाए..... Jai hind
Thank you Dr.Mahipal...this was a Marvelous video..perspicuously explained...
reservation on economically backwards not on caste
Ajay Singh how can change it's discrimination all are indian
Reservation on the basis of economical condition is acceptable but reservation on the basis of caste is not acceptable .
It is heading towards a civil war.
Reservation is a affirmative action to increase representation of oppressed people in the society. And by this will never lead to civil war since most of people come in reserved category.
Sumit Kumar
Oppressed people?
Living in SOUTHCITY APARTMENTS( one of the biggest apartment in Kolkata), and you are calling them oppressed ?
Please tell me one who is earning lakhs of money per month and crores of money per year, how can be oppressed?
awsm , huge knowledge , first time getting such a clearity on this topic. THANX GBU SIR
yes ofcourse..
if there have no reservation for sc and St after sometime they will social exploitated by another upper costs
nice video,sahi tareeke samjhaya alone,descriptive papers aur interview k point of view se ye jaankari important hai
After watching this video you guys are still criticizing SC and ST
this is real discrimination
Or isi discrimination ka 10 guna fayda uthate ho tumlog
Maurya kam se matlab tak talent hi upar aayega
Car mein ghumte ho aur reservation pe palte ho aur phir v tumhe lagta hai ki tumhare sath bhed bhaw horaha hai
Nice annalisis
Had last hopes .........!!! Respected supreme court .....woh bhi bikau Nikla .....
Those who are saying reservation will destroy the country, I want to ask few questions to them. Almost 70% of the top posts under Goverment are occupied by General Category and almost 90% of the posts under private sector are occupied by General category. If general category people are so efficient then why our country is still struggling? Why corruption is still there? Don't blame SC/STs. A reserved category student competes within 49.5% although the total population of of reserved category is more than 50%. Similary, a general category student competes for 50.5%, although the total population of general category is less than 50%. Now, who is facing more competition??? Top students from reserved category get jobs under reserved category, similarly Top students from general category get jobs under general category. Those general category students who can not compete under general category, only they are shouting and opposing reservation. They want to abolish reservation for their own sake, they don't want improvement of reserved category same like their ancestors.
गरीब हमेशा गरीब ही होता है चाहे वो किसी भी जाति का हो....भाई अगर कोई जनरल का गरीब है इस समाज में उसे भी कोई नही पूछता और अगर किसी ओर कास्ट का हो तब भी नही...अब लोगो की सोच जाति तक सीमित नही है वो लोगो के समाज मे रुतबे...उसकी नौकरी से बदल जाति है..तो ये कोई हल नही समाज मे समानता लाने का...सरकार को इससे इतर कोई हल लाना चाइये...ये काम कोई सुप्रीम कोर्ट नही कर सकगे...हाँ ये फैसला जातिवादी वैमनस्य पैदा जरूर कर देगा....
तुम सही हो |
Yes honi chahiye Q ki jb India apne constitution ko follow krti hai tb svi area me constitution rule honi chahiye
Q ki hm Indian hai aur jise jo milna ho wo jrur mile
Jai hind
Bhut shanadar
Promotion me reservation hona chahiye
Ex- #agr-aaj highcourt me sc/st/obc ke candidates hote to itni तानाशाही nhi hoti
kitni bdi bat hai 4 senior judge media se khte hai ki देश का लोकतंत्र खतरे में हैं l
#इस-देश-मे-हो-क्या-रहा-है
Nice video
Gud collection of data
All the party in India will do anything for their vote bank either it is correct or not. Very disappointed news from supreme court
Affirmative actions are necessary for healthy democracy & egalitarian society, but it should not put efficiency of system at stake.Right place to provide affirmation is before appointment. Then competence of cadet must be criteria
Jinko arakshan chayie sc / st join kar lo 😂😂
Okad ho to
Change your cast
deepak jain bhai me khud obc se hu or hume koi jayda aarakshan ni milta I hate government jobs
deepak jain par bhai yeh hakikat hai india ki kitna bhi kanun ban gya par logo ka mindset aaj bhi vo hi hai yeh tab change hoga jab k brhaman sc/st join keraga par vo ni kerega le to safh bath hai ki st/sc unke liye nichli jath hai
YO YO roxs na mne to mjak me dala par yo yo hunny tera baap jarur lag reha hai
😂😂
Agar Aap log reservation khatm karna chahte to.,.........
,....,
Please
Please
Please modi ko vote dijiye 2019
Har har modi
Ghar Ghar modi.....
All we do is complain but youth has been never a vote bank...... if we want change then hum logo ko vote bank banna hoga.....we never give vote to gov. ko sirf kisan aur garib hi dikhte h......itne sare young log h is desh me agr apne pe aa jaye to gov. to reservation end karna hi padega jesa bangladesh me hua pr hum sirf compalin karte h ghr pr betb kar aur kuch ni
Pooja Vishwakarma I Totally agree with you. True said. End Caste Based Reservations Indian people should Protest against this.
If really wanna stop reservation upgrade the education system in rural area cos its totally worse with that we can't give competition n make free the higher secondary free also if really don't want reservation cos afford hi nahi kar paata atche school mai paadne ke liye so aabhibhi dekho jitna bhi reservation delo kabhi equal nahi hoga kyuki backward logo ko government educated karna hi nahi chata
Thank you so much sir.... Jitni jankari dene ke liye🙏🙏
I think reservation should be there because discrimination still exixts in our society..bt candidates capabilities should also be considered, not just the caste..because country's growth depend on them..and one another fact is that reservation doesn't guarantee the social equality..Social equality and equal opportunity is what everyone is in need, being of any caste and category..I think caste system is the root cause of the problem..and I am unable to find out how this problem can be solved..in quora I have read about a few who have shared their incidents of discrimination, and they were not just belonging to sc or st.. Even brahmins were there..tribals and north eastern people were also among them..
Shefali Verma reservation sud b there ..true..bt d prsn who is already there in d govt services ,r they need reservation in promotion?
Govt need to form such policies so tht ppl lyk us dnt hv to waste our energy nd precious young age in dreaming aspiring nd wrking fr those things which can nvr b ours.😭
.
Ultimately policies lyk these r perpetuating d haterates towrds these so clld sc st sections of d society.
✌
in every 100 job vacency,only 20 to 30 post are reserved for obc,sc and st's.it means 70 post is for general categories.Those who are shouting are hyprocates who cannot compete these maximum(70)posts are blaming caste reservation system.This is not given on the basis of rich and poor.it is given to bring social justice and equality to those people who are deprived from centuries on the basis of their caste...and still they are not given equal status in society.Be logical...don't just shout.....thanks all...
Yes reservation should be there because in rural area education system is totally worse with that we can't give competition n also we have lack of money to study in good college I am saying it as my personal experience
Phele education system tikh karo and then baand karo reservation
oi johora.. ,amar sakori khai aso toi
partha choudhury first of all mind your language n then come to talk
thang swargiary eta ktha kosun.. thote suali general caster lorar tat kiyo bia dibo nukhujo???....hei2 ko
i did ask you something, waiting for your reply... why don't you ppl let general guys to marry your daughters or sisters????...
Equality and equity are two different concepts where the former refers to equal sharing between all while the latter represents equal proportions in the sharing with respect to its population,backwardness economically or socially.
Here as the data shows there is no adequate representation of SC/ST at all the levels of Govt. Jobs especially Group A/B, so therefore there must be reservation in promotion or at entry level for SC/ST so that it could serve the purpose of principal of equity/fairness.
Let me give an example:-
Suppose there is a cake which is to be distributed among 10 people of whom 5 are Genearal,3 are OBC,1SC and 1ST. Divide the cake into 10 pieces and give them. What happened in reality 50% of the cake goes to Gen category and the remaining 50% are shared by SC/ST/OBC. WHAT we did is we divide the cake in proportion to the
People, that is the principle of equity which ARTICLE 16 intends to serve prescribing equality and at the same time giving parliament the power to enact any law favouring certain classes.
Group A job main 69.3%
Group B job main 67.4%
General wala fir vi claim karte he aur kya chahiye bataoo...
chal sala chutiya
Suresh dalai cut off differences to blo
Tumse jyada time tak mehnat भी करते h. तुम jaha शादी ब्याह me maje lete rahte ho us samay gen. Vale घर बैठकर किताबों me apni आँखे फोड़ रहे होते हैं. Talent के दम पर select hote h, भीखमंगो की तरह हाथ nhi फेलाते
Sari job hi st SC l le koyi paresani ni h pr Apne talent s le reservation s ni..... it's nt about % of job it's about procedure...
@@mahikabisht5136 also its about why sc and St are socially backwards and also economically that's resion of general caste then you have to compare
Great description 👍👍
Lekin Supreme court ko ye kyo ni dikh rha hai ki Jo sanvidhan me Samantha ka adhikaar Mila hai uski dhajjiyan udd rhi hai?
मुझे तो सब से गलत ये बात लगती है कि एक तरफ तो एक समूह जनसंख्या बढ़ाता जा रहा है बिना कुछ भी सोचे समझे और फिर उसी आधार पर आरक्षण की मांग की जा रही है। क्या यह उस वर्ग के साथ अन्याय नहीं है जो अपने देश की तरक्की और खुशहाली के लिए जनसंख्या नियंत्रण को जरूरी समझते हैं। पता नहीं सरकार कब न्याय करना सिखेगी।
ekdm honii chahiye...bhed bhav hota hai really..india bahut sare aise village hai jaha sc/st ka bahut bura hal hai..
According to me qualifications, proficiency, efficiency should come first. Cast creed, religion should not overcome the above mentioned.