Can we talk about Seohyun’s vocal more?? Her voice suits every genre!! That closer, closer, closer part was my absolute fave when i first heard this song and Seohyun does it so effortlessly!! She really needs more recognition in the music industry!!
Everyone's great, but I'm specially impressed with Sunny's vocal color and technique. She harmonizes so effortlessly yet her hums are so calming, such an eargasm..😇
I noticed that too, I've seen her in some variety shows but didn't know she had a great voice until I watched their Forever 1 recording. That's when I thought her voice must have been underrated but undeniably beautiful, sweet & eargasmic.
@@PilgrimsClique Even though I am absolutely not objective as a Sunny bias for the last decade or so, I feel like the best place to check out her full vocal range are the clips of her 2016-2017 musical Cafe-in where she shows so much versatility as a singer!
Can we stop saying she is underrated? 🤣 She is obviously not passionate about being a solo singer, its just not what she wants the most, even though she is one of the best singers in GG.
@@vk69525 she does really underated even among sone. Lot of sone discredit her for being vocal line, never admit that she's part of vocal line. That's why we keep saying she's underated because it's a fact.
It would be nice to see her sing a Korean version of a Disney OST. I am also a huge fan of AKMU's Suhyun. How lovely would it be to have her and Sunny duet!
she is a great singer, I hope she realease more songs cause her voice is beautiful:(( to me, she could do so well as Taeyeon but I assume she doesn't want it now or the company don't see her potential, her first mini album was no joke (and most songs were wrote by her)
yuri and hyo’s low notes, sunny’s bright and clear voice and seohyun’s ease for harmonising are def some of my fave things in snsd. I’m so glad we’re getting recording bts to see all that
Seohyun and Sunny got me on this recording. their voice really stood out the most (in my opinion). but of course, everyone has an amazing vocal as always.
Everyone in GG is so PERFECT!!! They totally deserve Nation's Girl Group title. They had/have insane visual,vocal,dance and charisma. 15 years yet they didn't lost there touch!
Wow taeyeon is a vocal genius, she really fix the details on that spot, the way she can deliver well every emotion for each of the lyrics, her polite attitude with a beginner mindset really amazed me
SooYoung was never the member I thought most about when it comes to SNSD vocals, but she comes off as the most perfectionist out of them. Her entire session here gets a really critical look at every enunciation xD Like she's grading her every sentence.
they’re all perfectionist. If you saw Taeyeon’s mood changed when she was having mic feedback and in ear issues during the fanmeet, Seohyun’s other recording clips for how many times she requested to repeat lol and don’t start with Tiffany as you should see her clip in Sisters Slam dunk. These girls worked hard that’s why they reached their status; Yuri perfectionist too mostly in dance routines, etc. But yes Sooyoung was even yelling and knitpicking at Yoona during their MV filming lol.They’re too harsh on theirselves, imagine when they were at their peak.
Sunny on her Golden years was one of the cutest idols on the industry, but she said a lot before she don't like work so... Probably because of that she is not a solo singer
GIRLS' GENERATION REALLY DESERVES THE "NATION'S GIRL GROUP" TITLE BECAUSE AT VERY FIRST,THEY WEREN'T NAMED AS "GIRLS' GENERATION" FOR NOTHING. THEY ARE LEGENDARY👑
Maknae Seohyun's voice/vocal is just so Angelic and out of this world 🤩💖 😍she's the harmonization queen ... The forever and ever talented golden Maknae Seohyun... The pride of GG and Soshi unnies 💗🥰❤️
The leader and maknae's voice is really great both in high and low note. Not to mention other girls are improving as well. SNSD always exceed the expectation!
I love Tiffany's voice and talents. Tiffany got the most dangerous lines and every bridges in every songs of this album. As expected Tiffany, my main vocal. 💗💓💞💕💘💝💝💝
@@RaffyPoohh same question! I thought i pressed the skip button or something but i didn’t.. Tiffany only appeared just 5 sec for real. I was waiting for her part tho. This is not fair 💔😭😭😭
SNSD have no bad songs, unproblematic groups,talented members, all visuals ,an elegance group, got siblings friendship,full potential...what make people stop from stanning this perfect group
Taeyeon have a privilege voice sounds almous angelical,,, her notes are high but the way she sings without efford,, her voice is so beautifull all the girls have beautifull voices they are no jokes they are talented ..seohyun voice is incredible too...all the girls are talented and beautifull...
TAEYEON is one of the best IDOL EVER!!! Hear her voice,it's OTHERWORLDLY. So satisfying! She was the ACE of GG,now a successful soloist. Keep up the great work Noona!
Excuse me ? Every girl has unique touch and color in her voices, to me personal don’t like her voice, I prefer Hyoyeon’s voice she actually has the groove and low voice that makes unique
@@aeD4RK if you said she is the best idol you’re saying that, that’s not true SNSD is knowing for having the best line in groups . So stop saying lies, she is not the best idol and not the best in the group.
OMG, Fairy-nim Taeyeon's close up "Hi" How does all that come from such a tiny person? Look at our girls working so hard to reach perfection. Seo and Tae's blended vocal tones really complement each other well.
Sunny's vocals color is so beautiful and unique. It's very calming, angelic and soothing. I love how effortlessly she sings. This song suits her voice really well.
Despite each member's busy schedules, all of them prepared this album with care to all details to produce the best result that we listen now, that's how sincere SNSD are to SONE ❤
Yoona has so so so sweet sound. OMG! I just got healed by her voice. Maybe she not having the great skill but it just so lovely to hear her sing! Love "Closer" so much!!!!
I wonder if Sunny and Seohyun keep on taking regular vocal lessons all those years because they are truly amazing!! Also it's crazy how much I love this 8 women!! Like evey girl that coming I keep smiling from ear to ear 💗💗💗
![[4K] Great job uri Fany Director-nim 💗🖤](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/dbUU4pq7FTc/mqdefault.jpg)
Taeyeon’s vocals is no joke. She is not just an idol. She comforts everyone with her voice. Even a smile of hers lights up my life.
True that. My favourite song for the album. She sang it so effortlessly yet so smoothly
Couldnt agree with you more
Trueee
탱구목소리 장난없지 암
This is one of the best comment ive seen on the internet.
미국애는 R 안했는데 내가 너무 졀했낰ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ하면서 r 덜어내러 들어가는거 왜케 웃김ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
근데 진짜 쫄깃하게 잘부른다 역시 확신의 SM 메인보컬 김탱구
Can we talk about Seohyun’s vocal more?? Her voice suits every genre!! That closer, closer, closer part was my absolute fave when i first heard this song and Seohyun does it so effortlessly!! She really needs more recognition in the music industry!!
I absolutely agree! Her first mini album was no joke and most of the songs were wrote by her.
She is really amazing 😍
@@himuraame so true!!!!;)
I agree
She has been my favorite from the start. No disrespect to the leader or the others.
Everyone's great, but I'm specially impressed with Sunny's vocal color and technique. She harmonizes so effortlessly yet her hums are so calming, such an eargasm..😇
I noticed that too, I've seen her in some variety shows but didn't know she had a great voice until I watched their Forever 1 recording. That's when I thought her voice must have been underrated but undeniably beautiful, sweet & eargasmic.
@@PilgrimsClique Even though I am absolutely not objective as a Sunny bias for the last decade or so, I feel like the best place to check out her full vocal range are the clips of her 2016-2017 musical Cafe-in where she shows so much versatility as a singer!
I almost broke my neck trying to see who was singing 🤣 love love love her voice 😭🤎💖
She needs to drop her SOLO album asap!! Like we're being robbed hearing her magical voice and that's a crimeㅠㅠㅠㅠ
@@lifetimesone108 now someone gets it!!! why is she hiding such a perfect voice TT
Seohyun has the best pitch control. You see singers who play instruments just have that benefit
Sunny's vocal color and technique is actually really great. She's very underrated vocally, I hope she can have her solo debut soon.
Yea i hope she will accept solo project next time. 😔
Nah she's the one that doesn't want to do solo work because she's only comfortable when she's with her members :((
agree with this
Can we stop saying she is underrated? 🤣 She is obviously not passionate about being a solo singer, its just not what she wants the most, even though she is one of the best singers in GG.
@@vk69525 she does really underated even among sone. Lot of sone discredit her for being vocal line, never admit that she's part of vocal line. That's why we keep saying she's underated because it's a fact.
Can we appreciate Sunny's vocal for a moment? . Her voice is really pretty and calming. I wish she could shine more
Yes!!!! Agree 💯💯💯💯
It would be nice to see her sing a Korean version of a Disney OST. I am also a huge fan of AKMU's Suhyun. How lovely would it be to have her and Sunny duet!
I hope she could release her own album. Her voice is so nice.
She snapped this album
All the time!!!
seohyun’s voice is probably my most fave from this comeback. her voice shines in every track 💖
Yes!!!!...
she is a great singer, I hope she realease more songs cause her voice is beautiful:((
to me, she could do so well as Taeyeon but I assume she doesn't want it now or the company don't see her potential, her first mini album was no joke (and most songs were wrote by her)
@@carlaespinola5364 She really has potential to be as succesful as Taeyeon, but SM didn’t see it
@@arafadhwang4119 so sad, she is really talented and has a great charisma, her performance with Magic was amazing 🤧
Seohyun really slayed this song. Her voice is so comforting.
yuri and hyo’s low notes, sunny’s bright and clear voice and seohyun’s ease for harmonising are def some of my fave things in snsd. I’m so glad we’re getting recording bts to see all that
Yuri's singing is also on point
Seohyun and Sunny got me on this recording. their voice really stood out the most (in my opinion). but of course, everyone has an amazing vocal as always.
내가 지금 보고있는게 소녀시대 클로저 레코딩 비하인드라니.... 소시 레코딩 비하인드? 이게 진짜 상상이 아니라 현실이 되는구나.... 진짜 감사합니다ㅠㅠㅠ 다른 노래 레코딩 비하인드도 기다릴게요ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 사랑해 소시야ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
제발 빌런 세븐틴....
Seohyun being the baby boss. 👏👏👏
The way Seohyun singing like it's nothing🤣This girl was active as an actress for 5 years wth🤣
Love them harmonizing all together but I’m always impressed by Seohyun and Taeyeon’s vocal consistency. They’re always stable and flawless.
This song is such an old school jam, I'm addicted. The melody is so nice and their smooth vocals.
Agree
I blinked and Tiffany was gone 😭
Please release Tiffany’s parts
Everyone in GG is so PERFECT!!! They totally deserve Nation's Girl Group title. They had/have insane visual,vocal,dance and charisma. 15 years yet they didn't lost there touch!
Seohyun and taeyeon so beautiful
Wow taeyeon is a vocal genius, she really fix the details on that spot, the way she can deliver well every emotion for each of the lyrics, her polite attitude with a beginner mindset really amazed me
Yup totally agreed with you.. she's really study in it... that's makes her become more successful singer...
i missed seohyun's vocals 😭😭😭 it's soooo angelic
써니 미쳤냐고요.... 개좋다고요.............이렇게 좋았나 진짜 너무좋아
태연이 저런 말랑말랑한 얼굴로 노래 너무 잘하는 거 아니냐구
Seohyun’s voice is just so perfect 😭
SooYoung was never the member I thought most about when it comes to SNSD vocals, but she comes off as the most perfectionist out of them. Her entire session here gets a really critical look at every enunciation xD Like she's grading her every sentence.
they’re all perfectionist. If you saw Taeyeon’s mood changed when she was having mic feedback and in ear issues during the fanmeet, Seohyun’s other recording clips for how many times she requested to repeat lol and don’t start with Tiffany as you should see her clip in Sisters Slam dunk. These girls worked hard that’s why they reached their status; Yuri perfectionist too mostly in dance routines, etc. But yes Sooyoung was even yelling and knitpicking at Yoona during their MV filming lol.They’re too harsh on theirselves, imagine when they were at their peak.
im loving sooyoung's vocal in this album❤
She did learn Japanese and one of the things that is important in that language is the pronunciation.
Sooyuong is a born to be Idol. Hadn't Routeθ disbanded it woulda been on Top Japan GG
They only want to serve a masterpiece song
This song match Sunny and Seohyun clear voice❤️❤️
For me, Sunny, Hyoyeon, Yoona and Seohyun really stood out in this song
Seohyun, please give us another album!!!
My jaw dropped at Seohyun's low octave voice. Like wow, it's so soothing.
21:15 seohyun's voice is so beautiful i could listen to it for hours
ARE WE GOING TO GET BEHIND THE SCENES FOR ALL THE SONGS OMGGGG???
🙏🙏🙏
Hope so🙏
I hope soooo! jeballlll~~~~
hope so. but we need forever 1 dance practice too.
Yes please
태연 음 잡는 것부터 완전 프로다👍👍💜 클로저 태연파트 최애 파트...💕 귀 녹아
Listening to Sunny singing reminds me so much why she was my first bias. Wish she had a solo album, I really enjoy her voice :(
Sunny on her Golden years was one of the cutest idols on the industry, but she said a lot before she don't like work so...
Probably because of that she is not a solo singer
@@cjent8 I guess I'll stay listening to her old ost 😭
@@susupanova Sunny does have 2 newer OST songs from 2021 :)
Seohyun grew up really well. When I became a SONE she was literally still a kid.
The timbre and quality of Sunny's voice is incredible--so talented!
Like... HOW DOES SUNNY NOT HAVE HER OWN SOLO CAREER?!
기여워 김탱구 ㅜㅜㅜㅜ 목소리 사기야 ㅜㅜ
Seohyun voice 😍
태연씨 진짜 확신의 메인보컬이세요
seohyun is reaallyyyy prettyyy!! and her voice??!! so soothing!
NOTE MEMBER TIMESTAMP
00:00 TAEYEON
4:18 YOONA
6:56 SOOYOUNG
10:31 HYOYEON
12:20 YURI
14:47 TIFFANY
15:09 SUNNY
17:41 SEOHYUN
2023 STILL WATCHING THIS
I love actress seohyun but Seohyun please sing more! I just love her voice.
Sunny should really do a solo. Her voice especially fits this kind of music genre
Sunny has always been so underrated in SNSD 😭😭😭
Taeyeon really put effort in every single word ❤️. I love seeing the process of recording a song
The ending encapsulates Seohyun's essence as their maknae. It takes you back to rookie Seohyun, she's still the same, she just grew up. ❤
Now, I need another Seohyun's album
Vocal seohyun gila sih 😍 please buat album solo lgi yuk ❤
태연이 살짝살짝 허밍하는 것도 넘 좋아💗
Yuri's low tone is so pleasant to my ears. I love it. Her high notes are sweet and heavenly.
GIRLS' GENERATION REALLY DESERVES THE "NATION'S GIRL GROUP" TITLE BECAUSE AT VERY FIRST,THEY WEREN'T NAMED AS "GIRLS' GENERATION" FOR NOTHING. THEY ARE LEGENDARY👑
Maknae Seohyun's voice/vocal is just so Angelic and out of this world 🤩💖 😍she's the harmonization queen ...
The forever and ever talented golden Maknae Seohyun... The pride of GG and Soshi unnies 💗🥰❤️
The leader and maknae's voice is really great both in high and low note. Not to mention other girls are improving as well. SNSD always exceed the expectation!
Seohyun's vocal TT.TT
저렇게 다인원인 걸그룹 중 멤버 전원이 전부 보컬이 쌉가능한 유일한 그룹…. 다인원인데 어쩜 이리 보컬 실력을 다 갖췄냐..
Seohyun's voice suits this song so muuch, and she sings it sooo effortlessly!
I love Tiffany's voice and talents. Tiffany got the most dangerous lines and every bridges in every songs of this album.
As expected Tiffany, my main vocal. 💗💓💞💕💘💝💝💝
I love Tiffany as well but why did she only get 5 seconds of footage this time around I feel like she has the best commentary 😭
@@RaffyPoohh same question! I thought i pressed the skip button or something but i didn’t.. Tiffany only appeared just 5 sec for real. I was waiting for her part tho. This is not fair 💔😭😭😭
what theeeeee Tiffany only appear in less than 10 sec... oh my....
I had to start it over again... thinking I skipped Tiffany's part 🥺
@@Anne-nj5nd yeah.. its so sad... I wait for Fanny bridge BTS but what I got is.... ah dont know how should I express this
SNSD have no bad songs, unproblematic groups,talented members, all visuals ,an elegance group, got siblings friendship,full potential...what make people stop from stanning this perfect group
💯💯💯💯💯💯💯
Unproblematic? Naah you're wrong, every groups have their own problems
@@Angga-ew1mh i know what u mean, but i also know what the main comment means
@@fadelengelen2217 that doesn't even make any sense. What do you mean?
Nonsense comment. Even the grammer use is bad.
Girls' Generation really creates a harmonious sound that is pleasant and soothing to the ears. their voices are so angelic. 💗💗
태연아 너무 잘해서 짜릿하고 소름 돋아😭💜
이번 앨범 수록곡중 최애곡 클로저ㅠㅜㅠ 유리써니서현 옥구슬음색 개미쳤음
서현… 너무 퀸카다…
Taeyeon always make every song looks so easy but the reality its hard song😌
Seohyun vocal is no joke 🔥 daebak 👏👏👏
태연언니 걍 음원 틀어놓은 것 같아 원래 잘하는 줄 알고 있었지만 더 잘한다 확신의 메보💜💜
Taeyeon have a privilege voice sounds almous angelical,,, her notes are high but the way she sings without efford,, her voice is so beautifull all the girls have beautifull voices they are no jokes they are talented ..seohyun voice is incredible too...all the girls are talented and beautifull...
18:21 20:31 seohyun's lower register sounds the best. she breezed through her recording lol
Seohyun's voice fit this so much
I love how the video starts with Taeyeon and then ending it with Seohyun 😍 their harmonies is one of the things I love about snsd ❤️🎶
TAEYEON VOICE is Gold! for the background vocal too !
seohyun's voice and tone is so glorious 💗💗💗 love that even the least vocalist member has decent skills and not just tone deaf like in a lot of groups.
Sunny's vocal is really smooth and clear.. It will be great if she makes a solo debut
소시 레코딩 영상 보는 날이 다 오네ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ 50주년쯤엔 또 어떤 새로운 모습을 보게 될까 앞으로가 너무 기대된다
그리고 이써니 노래해 계속해ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
클로저 태연 누나 파트 미쳤는데 이렇게 나왔구나ㅠㅠㅠㅠ 노래 너무잘한다
tiffany basically went “hi! lah lah lah lah lah aaa aiya ya aiya ya ya~ bye” 😭 wished her segment was longer
I wish seohyun sings more.. if sm only showcased her more shes a gem!
김태연 미챠ㅜㅜ 녹음실 안에 가둬 놓고 계속 노래 부르라고 할 수도 없고 ㅜㅜ
I love Taeyeon and Seohyun harmonies❤️❤️❤️
태연언니 목소리 미쳤다ㅠㅠㅠㅠㅠ
Taeyeon sounds heavenly!
이번 앨범에서 써니 목소리가 진짜 좋았어요.... 보물이야 보물
와 서현 ㄷ ㄷ 개인활동 하면서 노래도 계속 했으면 좋겠다ㅜㅜ 실력이 너무 아까워
Gosh seohyun 🔥🔥🔥
TAEYEON is one of the best IDOL EVER!!! Hear her voice,it's OTHERWORLDLY. So satisfying! She was the ACE of GG,now a successful soloist. Keep up the great work Noona!
Her vocal is no jokeeee!!!!!!!!❤❤❤❤❤
Excuse me ? Every girl has unique touch and color in her voices, to me personal don’t like her voice, I prefer Hyoyeon’s voice she actually has the groove and low voice that makes unique
@@tam-tampuka8125 excuse me I didn't say othe member cant sing. Don't jump to conclusions!
@@aeD4RK if you said she is the best idol you’re saying that, that’s not true SNSD is knowing for having the best line in groups . So stop saying lies, she is not the best idol and not the best in the group.
@@tam-tampuka8125 I said "One of the best" not "The best". Again,read properly and don't jump to conclusions.
가수 활동 꾸준히 하던 멤버는 물론이고 예능, 연기활동 위주로 하던 멤버들까지 보컬 늘어서 온거 너무.. 너무 소녀시대 답다ㅜ대단해
Seohyun's voice is just💯
OMG, Fairy-nim Taeyeon's close up "Hi" How does all that come from such a tiny person? Look at our girls working so hard to reach perfection. Seo and Tae's blended vocal tones really complement each other well.
Sunny's vocals color is so beautiful and unique. It's very calming, angelic and soothing. I love how effortlessly she sings. This song suits her voice really well.
Copy comment from above😅
strg+C strg+V...i see what you did there ;)
You don't have to copy and paste just create your own comment lmao, it's cringey 😬Sunny deserves better 😐
I'm so glad we still have Soshi content even though their comeback already over. Please post every song in the album 😁
Ikr! We need moreeeeeeee soshi content
YES, and the dance practice plsss
컴백 또 원하는 사람,,,,? 이번 컴백 너무 꿈같은 시간이었어,,ㅠㅠㅠ 영원히 소녀시대 포레버원 소녀시대 사랑해 소녀시댛ㅎㅎㅎㅎ
sunny’s voice is so underrated, her tone is so beautiful.
Bro their vocals are no joke !!! They are freaking GIRLS' GENERATION !!!
seohyun is so effortless great in everything
Taeyeon's smile made my day. Love you girls. The best girls forever 1 💜🤗
Taeyeon vocals always amaze me😭
sunny 목소리 너무 좋아요.
sunny singing very well.
please please please more behind the scene I love this album so much. ugh Seohyun voice in Seventeen opening...... chef's kiss!!!!
Despite each member's busy schedules, all of them prepared this album with care to all details to produce the best result that we listen now, that's how sincere SNSD are to SONE ❤
서현 진짜 녹음본이랑 똑같자나 너무잘해 반했어♡
Yoona has so so so sweet sound. OMG! I just got healed by her voice. Maybe she not having the great skill but it just so lovely to hear her sing!
Love "Closer" so much!!!!
I wonder if Sunny and Seohyun keep on taking regular vocal lessons all those years because they are truly amazing!!
Also it's crazy how much I love this 8 women!! Like evey girl that coming I keep smiling from ear to ear 💗💗💗
써니 진짜 잘하네,,, 음색요정이야🧚🏻♀️