Jayant Bhandari: “Understanding India” (PFS 2024)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 10 ต.ค. 2024
- This talk is from the 18th Annual (2024) Meeting of the Property and Freedom Society, Bodrum, Turkey, Sept. 19-24, 2024.
Jayant Bhandari (Canada): “Understanding India”
propertyandfre...
More people should listen to this gentlemen jayant
Love how honest Jayant is.
Brutally honest.
Honest in his perspective does not mean he is telling the truth
@@carolqiu9586 i concur with his perspective. I have observed the same.
If he goes to India every year, can’t he see the improvement in front of his eyes?! No country is perfect , but India has been developed so much in every aspect! That is the reality. Plus the India government never really forbids him get into India , what does that tell you?
There certainly might be situations where the police show apathy. But you have to realise that conservative families prohibit the girls/women from venturing out alone even during day times in some parts of rural India. But the situation is certainly not the same in the metropolitan cities with a lot of girls/women in the workforce.
There is this unwritten rule of avoiding certain areas of trouble and/or troublesome people and going to the police is the last resort.
It is unfortunate that you hold an unsolved cold case memory that seems to be bothering you.
Unfortunately Eastern cultures, especially in India do not prefer to talk about controversial topics unless of course there is a big time profit angle to the same.
Just to give you some advice. You ought to research the number of rapes that are either not reported or hushed up involving sports athletes in USA schools/colleges to prevent a generational reputational damage to the school sports program. Sports is big time money in the USA. NCAA sports is as big as it gets in college sports anywhere in the world.
Me too. An absolute reflection of indian society.. indian social media can easily confirm of " strenght is might" and that is all it matters...
As an Indian myself I can confirm that Jayant Bhandari is 100% correct in his assessment of India....I know many Westerners might feel that he is exaggerating but he is 100% correct
Westerners don't understand the Indian psyche properly because they get treated differently by Indians due to being white.
A lot of comments here saying he’s wrong but not giving any reason why
Ask him to post statistics. He never does that, all this arguments are rhetorical and low iq
Because he sounds very judgmental towards India and the people, no one is perfect!
Because he is
It is easy to Differentiate someone from genuine hate and self loathing
he is probabily 100% right, i live in Brazil and things are not that different
@@samarthbagwe1736What did he say wrong? In India operates on two fuels CORRUPTION and CONNECTIONS.
It is a very strong statement when he said showing kindness and doing things properly is a show of weakness.
Which brave soul, listening to this, will think they are able to fix this country?
What an amazing and revealing talk. I knew quite a bit about Indian history and culture, but this explains it to you at another level.
As an Indian, this self loathing and prejudiced clown is the last person to lecture others on India and its culture. He’s an admirer of Christianity and has a deep seated prejudice against Hinduism and other native belief systems. A lot of his sweeping statements based on isolated incidents are outright lies. Not to mention he doesn’t live in India anymore. He seems to be mentally disturbed.
Midwit take
gRape culture
@@ancapistanowns696 As an Indian, this self loathing and prejudiced clown is the last person to lecture others on India and its culture. He’s an admirer of Christianity and has a deep seated prejudice against Hinduism and other native belief systems. A lot of his statements are outright lies. Not to mention he doesn’t live in India anymore.
@@ancapistanowns696 As an Indian, this self loathing and prejudiced person is the last person to lecture others on India and its culture. He’s an admirer of Christianity and has a deep seated prejudice against Hinduism and other native belief systems. A lot of his statements are outright lies. Not to mention he doesn’t live in India anymore.
Fantastic speech and I learnt a lot from Jayant.
He is a mid-wit abused dog with trauma who made his irrational self-hate his personality. Only a low IQ individual would find his speech profound. Partial truth is more dangerous than a lie.
You have not learned anything. 😂
@@myutube1962 You must be from Indian then
You could be better off learning from a stray cat in a public park than listening to this chimpanzee. Atleast the cats are cute looking
@@myutube1962agree, only bunch of unfair judgemental personal experiences
Just look at the behaviour of their media. Full of cheap talks and no substance.
Works to show how inportant ideology and philosophy can mold an society. So extreme.
No, wrong.
He’s a congressi 🐕
@Mechrobox4 ... I don't drink. Just google up human sacrifices.. Some part of india has this ritual since ancient. I though hindu can never be so evil, but was told if you visited ancient hindu temples in nepal,.... you ll see the blood of such sacrifices.
@@garryj7845 his family did business with bjp
@@lowersaxon very right
Struggling to live through the Indian mindset ,one can find answers through the explanations provided in this speech . Society and its primitive culture is primarily responsible for this situation.
> Understanding India
No, thanks :)
why make the decision to click on the video, let alone comment?
Pls do whatch, it will explain much
He is just criticizing the indian culture.
You should unterstand this power house, especialy when they narrator ist so honest.
Some people call India a shirthole, for example this teller here.
@@gladiol-iq4cb The problem is the lack of shirtholes and the willingness to shirt outside of holes.
@@gladiol-iq4cb It was a joke. You saw the smiley, right?
Brazil is similar, but not that bad
Are they this? india is fascinating... how they simply lock up people before election or other time. .. loads of street justices.... lynching... mass sx assault becauses they love brotherly bondings.. terrible for female but her child will have many dads. paying tributes and accepting or demanding them as a sign of respect... you may think it is corruption.. but it is practice as a culture... looting foreign firms or domestic' technologies... watchout, when they want your tech. Human sacrifices.. just googled it up.... the only moral is "am I strong or am I am weaker" It is like going to another world.... just unbelievable.....
Even Nigeria is infinitely better than india
maybe because Latin America was more deeply assimilated by the "West"?
@@OlJackBurton Maybe. But interestingly, Brazil was not so bad morally 50-60 years ago. Things went downhill since the 80s. Maybe it is the same pattern in other Latin American.
Any more human sacrifices in brazil?... voodoo?
9:11 Indians use big words
It seems like there’s a lot of self-criticism happening. While much of what’s being said is true, it applies to most European or Western countries, just to varying degrees. What surprised me is that the speaker only focused on the symptoms, not the root causes behind them. It would have been more interesting to hear their thoughts on what exactly leads to these kinds of issues.
No wonder these institutions are struggling now a days, living in their dreams. Aspirations are dead and dumbness has overtaken everything important. Wishing luck for many more endeavors.
This guy desperately needs counseling 😅.
He spoke the truth..
@biggpicture2930 🤣 Of course, wonderfully.
@@AlokAmmeYou need to examine your head and mind.
For what? to become like him 🤣
It often happens that passionate, subjective and biased speeches like this one, nevertheless provide an interesting point of view that enriches the conversation.
He is as right as the George bush about iraq
he spoke the truth... but george bush lied.
Have lived in India for 19 years as an employee of Suzuki, more than half of what this person's saying seems artificial & inflated. It's almost as if he's been given a platform to spew hate against his own country.
He is a brown Sepoy all he does all negative 24/7 about the country.
Ps: he said that he left Indian 30 yrs ago, does that mean he never come back since? If that’s the case , all what he said even could be true , then that was a reality 30 years ago not present Indian
He’s a self loathing person. He seems confused or suffering from strong prejudice. Most things he says are outright lies.
@@carolqiu9586Mr Bhandari left India more than 30 years ago at a time Indian economy was in shambles. He also comes to India every year. But good thing we longer have such people in India. That is the reason India was the first country to send a professional rescue team to Turkey after a major earthquake struck them!
@@chander3338 He should reflect on the fact that despite speaking about India in this way, the Indian government still allows him to return safely every year. In some countries, this wouldn't be possible. Shouldn't he be grateful for such tolerance?
I am Chinese, raised in the UK and actively lived in India between 2010-2020 & did business with local ultra rich crooks in india. While what he said is partially true and I have seen it with my own eyes, I don’t understand why he must bring in the “European and Christian” superior in play as if India has no moral foundation of its own to begin with? Indian still has loads of autonomy in active benevolence and I have seen it potently in daily level , much Good Samaritan - far more in some part of the west , where I was under weekly racial assaults - Hello UK! (there are good experiences in the west too) . Sex and money - at the age of 14, my lady dorm mate were looking at “Britain’s best penis” in a girl’s magazine targeted towards underage girls and invited them to vote. Talk about Sex and money - UK wasn’t doing any better . So where is this European value which allowed such obscene voting contest be published on a national level???
Does he wish to trash india in such a way that He would be happy only when India becomes another China - with all the craps of human fallacy and people aren’t even free to judge whether a situation is right or wrong? “Amoral “ in India? Has he seen China?
@azram7403 Reported by
Shailendra Singh
· Veterinarian at Government of Jharkhand
Is human sacrifice still practiced in India?
Hold your breath. I have been a witness to such incident and can say with certainty that human sacrifice in India still exists as a ritual.
I am not talking about stray incidents of human sacrifice here and there by some 'tantriks' aur 'aughads'. This is about a ritual which needs one human sacrifice every year. The incident is from 21st century and occurred only 100 kilometres away from Ranchi, the capital of Jharkhand.
You're a jeet not chinese 😂
Must be a brain dead 💀 after years of western brainwashing.
@@biggpicture2930 Just becaues one part of China (Yulin, Guangxi) actively promote dog eating culture doesn't mean that the entire China condones and supports it.
@@soundyoucantouch It is totally one's liberty what one chooses to eat or drink as long as it is legal in the country you reside, so if you live in india, nobody can stop you from eating cow poop and drinking gomutra.
Well, you encapsulate perfectly not just India but the whole of South Asia including mine(Bangladesh).
India is a rising power
Bangladesh is a basket case
@@samarthbagwe1736 🤣🤣🤣🤣 India rising... thanks for make me laugh today.... there's no civic or hygiene in that country and 800 million people live on daily ration from govt. If this free ration isn't around famine would be every year phenomenon in the country.
Yes Muslims are cleaner.. Mughals cleaned up the blood stained hindu temple...hindus complaint about their destruction.
@@samarthbagwe1736 yes india is super power, is not 1st world country club but still ahead of 90 % countries in the world, western nations can’t digest anyone success…….
@@milladurrahmanmubin4698 Actually famines were quite common in India.
laughs in turkish inflation
Turkey is a gone case In the lap of Europe
Inflation is part of growth but some time it’s pure greedification
@@Goku65027 you're wrong. Inflation is anti-civilisational. It's indirect theft.
Well, the entire talk is a giant spouting of pent up emotions on the degraded state of indian society and culture. There is no analysis of the causes for the poor state of affairs that prevails. There is also no suggestion or hint of any solutions to the problem. This is understandable given that the speaker does not state any underlying reasons for the rot in indian culture. So, now allow me a hearing for my own thoughts on the matter. Everyone is welcome for discussion and debate.
1. "India is devoid of rational and scientific temper which is an exclusively western discovery." Well, we may safely agree that the scientific method was first discovered in europe by ionian (greek) natural philosophers and by scientists like galileo and newton during the renaissance. But to say that rational temper has at present and also in the past no footing in India is an exaggeration at best. With the greeks, indian society is the only one where logic was discovered and pursued as a subject. Why did we need logic ? For effective inter-religious dialogue and debate between hindus, buddhists, jains, sikhs, lingayats etc. Entire systems of indian philosophy (The Nyaya and the Vaisheshika) did valuable work on argumentation, syllogisms etc. One may say, "how many people read nyaya and vaisheshika philosophy nowadays?" That is a part of the problem...
But anyhow, it is a reasonable supposition to say that the society which was among the first to pursue logical investigations in philosophy is more than capable of learning and applying the scientific method in the endeavour to expand our knowledge. We only need to educate each other for that with the passage of time.
2.) "Indian society was and is amoral". The society that produced and was in turn closely influenced by people like gautama buddha, vardhaman mahavir, raja ram mohan roy etc. was not amoral. Why did India produce more religions and religious sects than any other country in the world. When Christ taught compassion, he was crucified by the romans. The Buddha did the same in India and died peacefully in bed surrounded by his disciples. Was it because we were amoral back then?
But what about our present day state of affairs ? Surely something has gone wrong, has it not? Yes. That will be the content of my next comment.
I also love western ideas , especially libertarianism of smith,mises,hobbes, rothbald etc but I don't be slave to west and sell my soul to criticize homeland. There exists many worst things here, but I won't Leave like coward i will fix it
Well said 30:24
Bhai jab tujhe India pasand nahin to itna dimaag kyon lagata hai, chup kar ke baitha rah wahan.
I don't drink. Just google up human sacrifices.. Some part of india has this ritual since ancient. I though hindu can never be so evil, but was told if you visited ancient hindu temples in nepal,.... you ll see the blood of such sacrifices.
Pasand jinko nahi hota unke birudh kam Kiya jata hain.. unnhe chora nahi jata! Chore bhi Kyun tereko? Tu pura duniya ke liye ek threat hain!
He gets paid by the chinese to do this. It's best to avoid him.
Woww I was in US for 10 years from 1990 to 2000. Iam glad I made the shift to India in 2001.
Under Which rock did this guy from? He is still in Plato's cave. Please don't listen to these losers and make up your mind about India.
Come to India and experience before you form an Indian opinion.
The rock of truth....
"I visited india so you don't have to"- bald and bankrupt.
A debase race
india is fascinating... how they simply lock up people before election or other time. .. loads of street justices.... lynching... mass sx assault becauses they love brotherly bondings.. terrible for female but her child will have many dads. paying tributes and accepting or demanding them as a sign of respect... you may think it is corruption.. but it is practice as a culture... looting foreign firms or domestic' technologies... watchout, when they want your tech. Human sacrifices.. just googled it up.... the only moral is "am I strong or am I am weaker" It is like going to another world.... just unbelievable.....
Watch bald and bankrupt recently india visit video…….
Someone in india hurt this mans feelings.
All his points are: one indian guy did something mean to me...
Indian police officers average 525 usd a month. Be mad at them for not being prompt😂😂
Ur soooo mad at those police people for not enforcing the law above and beyond😂😂
Indian hands typed this comment
@@themememaster5369 Indian hands also typed this comment, I agree with the presenter.
@@gamingtemplar9893 turkish inflation is so low wow
@@noSirIDontLikeItmy guy here literally defending thulle.
i dont know where in india jayanth was born ..Im thinking bihar cuz his drain inpsector report on india doesnt match what the rest of the country has experienced in the last 30 years...
Bhopal
Ah Bihar. Is that the state where so many bridges collapsed recently, right? Irrationality and superstition prevents Indians from improving themselves and their country and instead they create these nonsensical arguments in justifying their backwardness and irrationality.
Zakir Naik 2.0
😂😂😂😂😂😂
Listening to jayant bhandari to understand india is like listening to Americans to understand china.
You just won the internet!
Saw Mr. Bhandari liked.Unfortunately soros don't like what your carrying into