วีดีโอ

in what way? LOTR is all about races. why is it racist? nevermind. you're just looking to make your shitty life somehow relevant.

What a profoundly stupid comment.

Your revisionist leftist nonsense has had its day. Wokeism peaked 2009 to 2022 and is about to go away.

??🤨

Army of the dead

That's an interesting point! The phrase 'you will suffer, me' could definitely be seen as a pivotal moment, highlighting the stakes of Aragorn's challenge to the ghost army. It captures the weight of their decision perfectly. I'm curious, do you think this was the turning point that ultimately led the ghosts to side with Aragorn? Would love to hear your thoughts!

Aragorn says “you will suffer me”

You will suffer me ffs

Well said.

"You raise a valid point about Galadriel’s age and experience. In Tolkien’s lore, she’s certainly one of the wisest and most powerful Elves by the time of the Second Age, so her portrayal in Rings of Power as more impulsive has sparked debate. It’s important to remember that adaptations often take creative liberties, and while not all changes sit well with fans, they do aim to resonate with a broader audience. That said, Tolkien’s works are indeed timeless, and many of us agree that staying true to the spirit of his characters is key to preserving their legacy. Balancing adaptation with respect for the source material is a challenge, but it’s what makes or breaks a series like this for longtime fans."

Thanks for your comment! You’re right-Boromir did admit to Aragorn that he was wrong in the end, and that’s a big part of what makes his character so compelling. His desire to protect Gondor led him to a moment of weakness, but in his final moments, he acknowledges that mistake, showing real growth. It’s what makes Boromir a tragic yet honourable hero. Appreciate you sharing your thoughts-Tolkien’s characters always give us a lot to think about!

Absolutely, you’ve nailed it! Boromir’s actions make a lot of sense when you think about the sheer pressure he was under. Gondor was hanging by a thread, and here’s the One Ring-the very thing that could either save his people or doom them. The idea of taking it all the way to Mordor and tossing it into a volcano? A near-impossible task, and it’s no wonder he thought using the Ring might be the better option, even though we know how dangerous that is. You’re right-it’s a miracle that so many things didn’t go horribly wrong on the journey. Boromir’s struggle shows how hard it is to resist the Ring’s power, especially when you’ve got a city on the brink of destruction to worry about. Thanks for sharing your thoughts-Tolkien really knew how to make his characters face impossible decisions, didn’t he?

Thanks for your comment! I appreciate your perspective on Denethor’s mental state-Boromir’s death definitely played a huge role in his eventual unraveling. My take in the video was more about the gradual pressure Denethor was under as Sauron’s forces closed in, which I think set the stage for his later downfall. That said, I totally get that opinions differ when it comes to interpreting these characters! Always happy to have a deeper discussion about Tolkien’s world-thanks for sharing your thoughts!

Haha, love the football analogy! You’re right-Boromir’s focus on protecting Gondor was a classic case of prioritizing his team over the bigger picture. It’s like he wanted to win the cup for Gondor, but forgot that if the league crumbles, nobody’s playing football anymore! As you said, a great captain for Gondor, but maybe not the best commissioner for Middle-Earth’s survival. And yeah, stealing a nuclear arsenal and attempted murder does tend to put you in the “bad decisions” column! Boromir definitely had a moment of weakness there, but hey, at least he realized his mistake before it was too late… well, kind of. Thanks for the comment-really enjoyed the analogy!

Aye, Boromir definitely had his moments, didn’t he? He made an arse of himself for sure, but he was no doubt one of Gondor’s greatest heroes. Recapturing Osgiliath, standing against the forces of Mordor-Boromir was a man of action, and that can’t be denied. And you’re spot on about Denethor in the books-he was much more complex than the tomato-munching madman we got in the films. As for your “what if” scenario, if Frodo had fallen and the Fellowship had taken the road to Minas Tirith… now that’s something to think about! The combined might of Gondor and Rohan could have crushed Sauron’s armies, no question. And if Aragorn had cast the Ring into the fire with that iconic “For Frodo,” it would’ve been a poetic end. It’s always great to imagine these alternate paths Middle-Earth could’ve taken! Thanks for sharing that-loved your take!

Aye, winter is coming!

Haha, aye, I see it too! Boromir and Ned Stark definitely share that rugged, noble warrior look-plus, they both had their moments of ahem questionable decisions. Maybe it’s the Sean Bean effect: always the honorable hero with a tragic twist! Thanks for the comment-glad to see I’m not the only one who noticed that resemblance!

I thought he looked like 006 from Goldeneye

Thanks for your comment! You’re absolutely right-Boromir’s intentions were always clear, and it’s true that most people wouldn’t call him a traitor. His desire to protect and heal Gondor was never in question, and as you said, the real issue is the Ring itself and how it corrupts anyone who comes near it, no matter their intentions. The tragedy of Boromir is that he was a good man trying to do the right thing, but the Ring’s power was too much for even him to resist. It’s a tough reminder of how dangerous the Ring really is, no matter who holds it. Appreciate you sharing your thoughts-Tolkien really did an amazing job with these complex characters, didn’t he?

Thank you for your detailed and insightful comment! You're absolutely right in pointing out that the Elves originated in Middle-Earth at Cuiviénen and that the invitation to Valinor wasn’t compulsory. Tolkien’s world is rich with these intricate details, and I appreciate you bringing this up-it adds so much to the conversation. As you mentioned, the Noldor’s weariness was certainly influenced by their rebellion against the Valar, and their fate was quite different from the other Elves. The Sea-longing, though it eventually calls to all Elves, does seem to strike the Noldor in a particular way due to their complex history of exile and return. The idea that all Elves eventually face a choice-either to seek peace and bliss in Valinor or remain in Middle-Earth as spirits-is one of the more haunting elements of Tolkien’s lore. It speaks to that underlying theme of longing and loss that runs through the Elves’ story, and I find it fascinating how Tolkien wove those deeper truths into his mythology. Thanks again for sharing such great points! It's always a pleasure to discuss these finer details with fellow fans who appreciate the depth of Tolkien's world.

@@MiddleEarthMinute You are very welcome sir.

@bendavey8719 I agree. I tried explaining my thoughts to a friend recently who is in the hate it because it's not accurate camp, and I don't think I could ever change his mind, but if it's taken away from the greater Lore it's not to bad as it's own thing.

It is hard to try and ignore it straying so much from the books and I believe I would be a much better series if it was closer but I can also see that the writers had their hands tied with what material the Tolkien estate would let them actually use.

@@bendavey8719 I completely understand where you’re coming from-it’s definitely tough to see the story stray from the books so much, especially when Tolkien’s lore is as rich and detailed as it is. A closer adaptation would have likely satisfied a lot of long-time fans (myself included!). That said, you’re spot on about the limitations the writers faced with what material they could actually use. I imagine it’s like trying to paint a masterpiece, but you’ve only got a handful of colors and can’t touch half the palette! It certainly makes things tricky. At the end of the day, while we may not get the purest translation of Tolkien’s world, hopefully, the show can spark enough curiosity in new viewers to dive into the books and experience the true depth of his creation. And hey, maybe one day we’ll get that more faithful adaptation we’ve all been hoping for! Thanks again for your thoughtful reply-I always enjoy discussing Tolkien’s world with fellow fans who appreciate the beauty and complexity of his work.

I THINK THEY JUST DONT HAVE THE RIGHTS TO THE FULL STORY SO THEY HAVE TO COME UP WITH THEIR OWN

@@MONKEYSCHANNEL327 I agree with this to an extent from what I understand they only got access to certain parts from the Tolkien estate.

Good morning, and thank you so much for your incredibly thoughtful and well-articulated comment! Your insights are deeply appreciated, and I completely agree that critiques, especially of something as beloved as Tolkien’s works, should be done with charity and humility. That’s exactly what we strive for on this channel-fostering a space for meaningful discussions without falling into negativity or divisiveness. You’ve raised some excellent points, particularly about Galadriel's portrayal in The Rings of Power and how it contrasts with Tolkien’s depiction of her wisdom and strength. I absolutely agree that Tolkien’s Galadriel, even in her youth, possessed a depth of thoughtfulness and restraint that seems to stand in stark contrast to what we see in the show. As you mentioned, her refusal to participate in the Kinslaying is a prime example of her early wisdom-one that highlights her deep sense of morality and foresight. The intention behind our comparison was to explore how both portrayals attempt to showcase different kinds of strength, but you’re absolutely right in suggesting that we should rely on Tolkien’s evidence over our feelings. It’s clear that the ROP version of Galadriel is a significant departure from the Galadriel we know from the texts, and many fans, like yourself, feel that this version undermines her character’s established wisdom and grace. We’ll certainly keep refining our approach to such comparisons, and your input helps us do that with more depth. Again, thank you for your kindness and for contributing to the conversation in such a thoughtful way. Wishing you all the best, and I hope we continue to explore the depth and beauty of Tolkien’s world together! Cheers, Middle-Earth Minute

@@MiddleEarthMinute I appreciate your taking the time to respond so thoroughly and with such consideration. It is yet another sign of the good disposition behind your videos and your channel. And I just want to clarify that I had no intention of criticizing your video or even your comparison of the two kinds of power portrayed. I rather appreciated it very much. If anything was lacking it was simply a very subtle matter of precision of language in distinguishing the things that I mentioned. Keep up the good work!

@joshuaelzner Thank you so much for your kind words! I deeply value thoughtful discussion surrounding Tolkien’s works, and I encourage all forms of engagement-whether it's praise, critique, or suggestion. Each comment provides a wealth of insight, and I will gladly take on board any suggestions that help improve the channel and bring you content that resonates with your love for Middle-Earth. As I continue on this journey, I’m committed to keeping the spirit and style of the channel intact. At this point, I’m still finding my footing and working to refine the content. With time and as I become more familiar with the tools at my disposal, I hope the quality of my videos will grow and evolve, much like the stories and characters we all hold dear. Once again, thank you for your support-it means more than I can say. I look forward to bringing you even more engaging explorations of Tolkien's world!

@@MiddleEarthMinute I've been reflecting on what precisely I could say were I able to suggest how to deepen and improve the quality of your channel as it grows. And I think I have a bit of an answer. It is this: Storytelling and fantasy is never merely an enclosed world, a mere escape into imagination, but it also always says something about reality, about the truth of the world in which we live. Thus even in a Tolkien lore channel, the ultimate topic of conversation--at least at a certain level of depth and realism--cannot be merely facts and figures in the world of Arda, but our own pursuit of the truths expressed therein. (I'm not saying you're failing in this, merely sharing some thoughts of my own.) This means that you won't be able to please everyone by keeping a merely "neutral" ground, but must take a stand both in speaking about the truth of reality and the truth of Tolkien's creative world. Do not be afraid, therefore, to criticize or disagree where you see it appropriate, for this is but a flip-side of the love of truth. "Speak the truth in love." In summary, what I want to say is this: the depth and beauty of your channel shall be directly dependent upon your own pursuit of goodness, beauty, and truth in your own life, and the love with which you communicate this to others. I hope you find something helpful in what I have written!

@@joshuaelzner Thank you for taking the time to share such deep and thought-provoking reflections. Your words truly resonate with the essence of what makes Tolkien's world so captivating-not just as a fantasy escape, but as a mirror that reflects timeless truths about our own reality. I wholeheartedly agree that Middle-Earth, while a fictional creation, carries with it profound messages about the nature of good, evil, beauty, and truth. You’re absolutely right in saying that a Tolkien channel shouldn’t merely focus on the facts and figures of Arda, but on the larger truths that Tolkien so masterfully wove into his world. As the channel continues to grow, I’m constantly reflecting on how best to balance the lore we all love with the deeper, more universal themes that Tolkien intended us to consider. Your point about not shying away from criticism or disagreement is especially well taken-it’s something I’ll keep in mind as I work to foster meaningful conversations around the nuances of both Middle-Earth and our own world. At the heart of it all, it is my goal to share a love for Tolkien’s works with as much truth, beauty, and integrity as I can, and your encouragement to pursue that deeper goodness is a reminder of what truly matters in this journey. I am grateful for your insights and will carry them with me as I continue to craft the content for this channel. Thank you again for sharing such thoughtful advice-it truly means a great deal.

@I.P.Freely-xn9vf 😄 I'm sure he didn't stoop that low, haha.

@@MiddleEarthMinute "Elrond Hubbard" 😁

Alright, let's break this down Middle-Earth Minute style! Is the Arkenstone a Silmaril? Well, not quite, and here’s why: One vs Three: The Hobbit makes it clear there’s just one Arkenstone, while there are three Silmarils. Light Difference: Silmarils glow with a mix of gold and silver light, whereas the Arkenstone shines with a bright white glow. Fate of the Jewels: The Silmarils are locked away in the sky, earth, and sea until the end of time, but the Arkenstone? Found well before that. Burning Flesh: Silmarils will burn mortal hands that try to hold them, but the Arkenstone? No such trouble. Craftsmanship: The Dwarves cut and shaped the Arkenstone, but the Silmarils? Completely unbreakable-stronger than adamant itself. Now, while Tolkien may have drawn some inspiration from the Silmarils for the Arkenstone, that’s all it was. Inspiration. The evidence just doesn’t add up for them being one and the same. For a deep dive, everything Tolkien ever wrote about the Arkenstone is right there in The Hobbit.

This actually gave me a great idea for a deeper dive into that subject I will be posting the video later on if you're interested.

I was attempting to Discuss the tie between the fate of Númenor and the fate of Thorin I'm not sure it plays out as I intended. In my mind Tolkien does explore themes of lust for power and treasure, both in the downfall of Númenor and in Thorin's obsession with the Arkenstone. The love of treasure-and its dangers-is something that runs through both stories, so there’s a thematic echo. But the stone itself? No Númenorean link. It remains a gem of Dwarven lore, found and crafted by their hands, with no Númenorean history attached. I appreciate your comment hopefully as I gain more experience with this TH-cam malarky my videos will improve in quality.

I think it was drunk on the day I made this one.

@@MiddleEarthMinute definitely

@Harshsharma-qj4bu I agree it's an irreplaceable role. I'm glad he is so involved with the new movies it may give us some hope for some actual good movies.

@GoldenroseGuild they really do. Hopefully, it doesn't become another disappointment.

@@Claz-mate that's a potential if such beings have such relations.

@@MiddleEarthMinute sooo pretty much, since they probably wouldn't have titles like that

Well in a literal sense, I would say "no". They didn't share the same biological mother or father, mainly because no biological birth took place for either of them. But figuratively speaking, seeing as they of the same origin, you could say that they are brothers.

@MiddleEarthMinute yeah I would say so too, and if not like, brothers, but to go as far as acknowledged relatives.. like all of beings in their class would be considered in that regard. The astari being all created the same and all, and so forth with the others. Melkor was the only one in his "class" of being who didn't follow the path in the beginning, but Mairon was created the same as the others, but eventually was heeaaavily influenced once melkor became morgoth and twisted him up with the ideas of conquering the world

@@GaiusMarius65 she was indeed.

Lúthien Tinúviel was the only daughter of King Thingol of Doriath and Melian the Maiar.

Frodo came of age as Bilbo left the Shire. Frodo inherited Bag End and Bilbo's ring. Gandalf, uncertain about the origin of the ring, warned Frodo to avoid using it and to keep it secret. Frodo kept it hidden for the next seventeen years, and it gave him the same longevity it had given Bilbo.

In J.R.R. Tolkien's works, the Blue Wizards' ultimate fates are unknown. this is one theory but there are others unfortunately we will never know the truth.

​@MiddleEarthMinute In the middle earth games it said that sauron killed them both but I'm not sure if the games are part of the main story or not but we should find out in rings of power

@007donut5 I played those games a long time ago, so I couldn't remember exactly, but according to the book Lore, it is unknown.