- 107
- 85 539
Cosgrove's Cosmos
United States
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 6 ก.ค. 2021
Astrophotography can be an awesome thing. Just think about it - an everyday person sets up some gear on their driveway and captures some photons that have been traveling for thousands, and in some cases, millions of years through the universe before they entered their telescope and were captured by their camera! You can create images that, until now, you only saw produced by professional observatories.
In 2019 I retired and started my journey into Astrophotography. It was a bit like Alice falling into the looking glass: Choosing gear, assembling it into a useful configuration, setting up, polar alignments, pate solving, meridian flips, camera cooling, focusing methods, binning, Sequence control, calibration frames, stacking, image preprocessing, & Image processing - it can make your head spin if not explode.
I finally sorted all of that out - and I plan to use this channel & my website to share my results & learnings.
Visit my Website: /www.CosgrovesCosmos.com
In 2019 I retired and started my journey into Astrophotography. It was a bit like Alice falling into the looking glass: Choosing gear, assembling it into a useful configuration, setting up, polar alignments, pate solving, meridian flips, camera cooling, focusing methods, binning, Sequence control, calibration frames, stacking, image preprocessing, & Image processing - it can make your head spin if not explode.
I finally sorted all of that out - and I plan to use this channel & my website to share my results & learnings.
Visit my Website: /www.CosgrovesCosmos.com
Observatory Update: Custom Telescope Piers III - Painted and Complete!
This short video update shows the completed custom piers for my observatory project.
The last step - sandblasting and painting is now complete!
My friend Gary, who has been instrumental in the fabrication of these piers, just delivered them from the painters the other day.
This video shows the final result!
The last step - sandblasting and painting is now complete!
My friend Gary, who has been instrumental in the fabrication of these piers, just delivered them from the painters the other day.
This video shows the final result!
มุมมอง: 388
วีดีโอ
Observatory Update: Breaking Ground! Excavation Complete!
มุมมอง 371หลายเดือนก่อน
After a very long effort, my observatory project is now getting under way! We have now broken ground! Over a period of two days, the Excavator did a great job in removing topsoil, creating a level building pad that was 3' larger than the observatory footprint, and laying a bed of compressed gravel! This video attempts to show the work that went on over two days in just a few minutes! Next, we w...
Observatory Project: A Last Update Before Breaking Ground!
มุมมอง 2672 หลายเดือนก่อน
This is an update on my observatory project, which is probably the last one before we break ground! This is also a video companion to a post on my website that can be seen here: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory/final-update-before-breaking-ground Covered is tree work, an update on my custom piers, a new set of stamped plans, the building permit, and some more hardware that is ready, and some fin...
Observatory Project: Opening The Roof!
มุมมอง 3662 หลายเดือนก่อน
This is a video companion to a blog post I wrote a few days ago about the roof opening system for my observatory project. This blog can be seen here: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory/opening-the-roof In previous videos, I have talked about hardware selections for the roof tracking system - in this one, I talk about my selection of the SkyRoof System by InteractiveAstronomy.
Observatory Update: Final Roof Track System Hardware Selections!
มุมมอง 3813 หลายเดือนก่อน
This video is the next in a series documenting my Rool-Off-Roof Observatory Project. While a previous video showed my initial thinking on hardware selection - continued research caused me to change some of my selections to get a more cost effection and capable set of hardware. Most of this hardware is now in hand, and I wanted to share a quick video showing where this came out. Note that after ...
Custom Telescope Piers - Part II - Cutting Parts with a 4000-Watt CO2 Laser!
มุมมอง 2473 หลายเดือนก่อน
This video is part of my Observatory Project Series, and is the second video discussing the construction of four custom steel piers for use in my observatory. The previous one talked about the design of the pier, and that can be seen here: th-cam.com/video/9KCKRyNYWWA/w-d-xo.html The blog for this can be seen here: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory/piers-1 This video delves into the intricate pro...
Cutting my Telescope Pier Parts Parts from 1/2-inch Plate Steel with a 4000-watt CO2 laser!
มุมมอง 2273 หลายเดือนก่อน
As part of my Observatory Project, I am building 4 custom telescope piers from Steel. This shot shows the bottom flange and the top plate being cut from 1/2-inch plate steel using a 4000-watt CO2 laser! It does an amazing job with really clean edges! You can see how the piers were designed here: th-cam.com/video/9KCKRyNYWWA/w-d-xo.html A full report on the cutting of these parts will be posted ...
Observatory Update: Designing a Custom Steel Pier - Part I
มุมมอง 3563 หลายเดือนก่อน
This video complements my blog post describing the design of 4 custom piers that I will be making for my observatory build. That blog post can be seen here: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory/piers-1 In this video, I share my thinking on what piers I will use for the four telescopes that my observatory will support. While I started with concrete piers in my design, I have since shifted to the crea...
Observatory Project: Galvanic Corrosion and a Change in Track Selection!
มุมมอง 3524 หลายเดือนก่อน
In my previous video, I talked about my hardware selections for the Roof tracking system. After that, I ended up doing some research on Galvanic Corrosion, which ultimately caused me to change my track hardware selection. This video will discuss what Galvanic Corrosion is and why I changed my track to prevent issues. At one point in the video, I show a table of metals that can cause this effect...
Observatory Update: Hardware Selections for the Roof Tracking System
มุมมอง 5004 หลายเดือนก่อน
This is a video companion to a blog post on my website where I discuss the hardware I will be using for my Roll-Off-Roof Observatory Project. This observatory is 16'20' in size and will house 4 telescope piers. That blog post can be seen here: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory/design-track-system In this video, I discuss the hardware selection I am making for the roof tracking system, which allow...
Observatory Update: Land and a Plan - Now How Do We Get Started?
มุมมอง 3845 หลายเดือนก่อน
This is the third video in my observatory series. In my previous videos, I discussed generating the initial observatory plans and searching for land. Now that I have Land and a Plan, how the heck do I get started? This video will cover the first steps I have taken to get things in motion. Written Posts on the observatory project can be found on my website: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory The ne...
My Observatory Quest: Sucess! The Search for Larger Skies!
มุมมอง 4565 หลายเดือนก่อน
In my last video on the Observatory Quest, I shared the design I had developed for a Roll-Off-Roof Observatory. In this video, I will discuss our search for land over two years, how we had a mid-course correction on what we were looking for, and what we ended up with! I hope this might be of some help to others who are starting a similar search. This video is a companion to several blog posts o...
Designing my Roll-Off-Roof Observatory!
มุมมอง 1K5 หลายเดือนก่อน
For the past two years, I have been on a quest to build my own observatory. This quest was complicated by the fact that I not only had to design the observatory but also needed to find land suitable for this project. We finally found the property that would meet our needs! We have moved, and now I am beginning to move forward with the project. While I have blogged about this effort on my websit...
A New House: Setting Up My Dream Astrophotography Man Cave!
มุมมอง 4876 หลายเดือนก่อน
I have not been creating new content for a while - and that is because my wife and I finally found a new property that would allow me to build my observatory! We placed the offer in mid-October, and since then, we have fallen down the rabbit hole - totally absorbed by the work to close on the new house, packing and moving, prepping the old house for the market, and so on. We are just coming out...
March 2024 Talk to the Hertford Astronomy Group Astrophotography Section in Hertfordshire, UK
มุมมอง 3357 หลายเดือนก่อน
March 2024 Talk to the Hertford Astronomy Group Astrophotography Section in Hertfordshire, UK
Astrophotography From My Driveway: My 12-11-23 Talk at Monroe Community College in Rochester, NY
มุมมอง 67910 หลายเดือนก่อน
Astrophotography From My Driveway: My 12-11-23 Talk at Monroe Community College in Rochester, NY
A Quick Blink Analysis for My WR134 Imaging Project!
มุมมอง 221ปีที่แล้ว
A Quick Blink Analysis for My WR134 Imaging Project!
A Blink Analysis for My NGC 6914 Imaging Project
มุมมอง 169ปีที่แล้ว
A Blink Analysis for My NGC 6914 Imaging Project
A Blink Analysis for My SH2-112 Imaging Project
มุมมอง 165ปีที่แล้ว
A Blink Analysis for My SH2-112 Imaging Project
Tough Year for Astro Captures? Then Discover Better Images Hidden In Old Data!
มุมมอง 362ปีที่แล้ว
Tough Year for Astro Captures? Then Discover Better Images Hidden In Old Data!
Blink Analysis for the DWB 111/119- The Propeller Nebula - A Reprocessing Project!
มุมมอง 131ปีที่แล้ว
Blink Analysis for the DWB 111/119- The Propeller Nebula - A Reprocessing Project!
2-Minute Tutorials: Using Color Masks to Enhance Image Details!
มุมมอง 1.1Kปีที่แล้ว
2-Minute Tutorials: Using Color Masks to Enhance Image Details!
2-Minute Tutorials: Using LinearFit to Prepare NB Images for ChannelCombination
มุมมอง 1.1Kปีที่แล้ว
2-Minute Tutorials: Using LinearFit to Prepare NB Images for ChannelCombination
2-Minute Tutorials: Dealing with Horizontal Banding in Your Images!
มุมมอง 1.4Kปีที่แล้ว
2-Minute Tutorials: Dealing with Horizontal Banding in Your Images!
Blink Analysis for the SH2- 101 - The Tulip Nebula - Reprocessing Project!
มุมมอง 207ปีที่แล้ว
Blink Analysis for the SH2- 101 - The Tulip Nebula - Reprocessing Project!
2-Minute Tutorial: Using Masks on Your Mask? Another lesson in masking!
มุมมอง 415ปีที่แล้ว
2-Minute Tutorial: Using Masks on Your Mask? Another lesson in masking!
Join Me as I Setup 3 Telescope Platforms in My Driveway for a Night of Imaging!
มุมมอง 777ปีที่แล้ว
Join Me as I Setup 3 Telescope Platforms in My Driveway for a Night of Imaging!
A Blink Analysis for my Messier 102 - The Spindle Galaxy - Imaging Project
มุมมอง 176ปีที่แล้ว
A Blink Analysis for my Messier 102 - The Spindle Galaxy - Imaging Project
A Blink Analysis for my Messier 104 - The Sombrero Galaxy Imaging Project
มุมมอง 180ปีที่แล้ว
A Blink Analysis for my Messier 104 - The Sombrero Galaxy Imaging Project
Messier 27: How Reprocessing of Old Data Led to NASA APOD!
มุมมอง 618ปีที่แล้ว
Messier 27: How Reprocessing of Old Data Led to NASA APOD!
Hi.
Thanks, just what I needed before Windows does another automatic update!
After calibrating frames you don't have to register and stack "manually " You can put calibrated frames back in WBPP without any calibration frames, and just check weighting, local normalization, registration and integration in the pipeline. As long as there are no calibration frames present it won't try to re-calibrate the frames. Also remember that if you're shooting OSC and you debayer as part of calibrating, you need to treat them as mono if you load them back into WBPP for integration.
Good tip! Thanks!
I wish you made a video for one shot camera process through astap grexpert Siril Ps
I mostly make videos about the tools and methods I personally use, and since I don't use some of the suggested tools, it is unlikely that I will get to that. Thank you for the suggestion. I may add an OSC to the mix at some point, so you may see that come along.
Great work
Thank you
Thank you for the tutorial!
Glad it was helpful!
Awsome setup!
Thanks Much!
Amazing video. Thank you very much :-)
You are welcome! Glad you found it helpful!
Thanks for a great video - I'll definitely add these options to my workflow!
You are most welcome! Glad you found it helpful!
That is badass! Can’t wait to see it come together.
Thanks! Me too!
They look really nice!!
Thanks so much!
Looking Good! Nice Color.
Thanks - I didn't want to go with the traditional Black or white...
Excellent…👍🏻
Thank you 👍
Same story. I ended up with 34 hours of data and still it wasn't enough to produce nice image. I used osc camera and think 100 hours is required to get good result. For me it's semi failed project.
Wow - 100 hours - for me - would be a 3-year project with our weather!
Very excited for you Pat!
Thanks! I am pretty pumped as well!
Looking good. Congrats on the progress!
Thanks! I am actually setting up my smaller scope on the pad tonight to image!
@@cosgrovescosmos Awesome. I think I'm near the same part of the world as you - I'm just east of Toronto. Can't believe we are getting 4, maybe 5 clear nights in a row. Scope is working overtime!
It is, indeed, LONG over due!
Are you planning on cutting any of those trees down or just looking at the zenith?
If you take a look at my previous posts, you can see the skyline better. In fact I just had tree work done that removed 7 large trees, 14 smaller trees, and bobbed some other. So it is now much better than it looks here, as my SE, S, SW, and NW horizons are pretty open. I am blocked to the North, but that is OK as the light dome of Rochester is there, and I will get those objects when they are higher in the sky. My East view is blocked by trees, but I can pick up targets as they get 40 degrees of elevation there. Compared to the narrow driveway view from my old place, this is heaven!
You must (have been) rich!
@@mikehardy8247 Well, they say the best way to become a millionaire when doing astrophotography is to start out as a billionaire! That sounds about right! So people retire and buya fishing boat. You know what I am spending my retirement on! 😃😃
Nice!! Going to be alot nicer than using the driveway! As always best wishes!
Thanks, Pete! Yes, it sure will beat the driveway!!!
What you had done in 2 days took three of us over several months of digging (rock hard soil)/trenching , leveling, adding gravel (lots of individual bags) rolling/compacting and later pouring hand carried, hand mixed bags (50 60lbs bags) of cement for the pier. Worth every joule of it! Then the real fun started when we built the observatory. I got a thrill out of watching your plan start to come together. You must be really charged up!
Just reading your account is causing the arthritis in my knees, back, and shoulders to flare up! Having done all of that - the rewards must be all the sweeter!
Looks like some great progress. Thanks for keeping us updated. You might just inspire me to get busy on my new location lol
Thank you! Hopefully, everything will move quickly now with little or no surprises!
This was excellent. I got lost a couple of times...that's on me, but this was very helpful in process development instead of the typical "click this and enter this".
Thanks much! BTW - Most of my imaging projects on my website have full, detailed, and annotated process walkthroughs if you think that might be helpful to you.
That looks like it's gonna be a BIG roll off!
Very exciting times…I bet it will move on pretty quickly now 👍🏻
Thanks - I hope all goes smoothly!
Excellent series and follows almost exactly my plans as well. Had originally thought I would go with the concrete foundation and with the cost estimate also decided to go with the pole barn design. I have an open 10 acres so just have to make my wife happy about where it is all going to go and with the hopefully soon decrease in the west Texas heat will start drilling some holes and filling them back up with concrete. Keep it coming and hope it does all come together in the next month or so for you.
Bruce, Thank you so much! I am a bit envious of your 10 acres of clear Texas skies, but I don't think I am as envious of your heat this time of year! Best of luck with your project, and I will keep my fingers crossed on mine. The excavator is due to break ground on Thursday of this week, weather permitting! Clear skies, pat
Thank you for the update. It's exciting to see what you are doing.
Thanks so much! I'm pretty excited to get this thing built... finally! :-)
Thank you for the tutorial...my version came out really good compared to what I did a couple of years ago. Clear skies!!!
So glad to hear that you found this useful!
Just what I was looking for. Thanks.
Glad I could help!
Enjoyed ur video. I have multiple mono cameras. I use a zero width 54MM adapter to directly attach my 2600MM to my EFW. I then can change cameras very quickly just by unscrewing the camera from the EFW body rather than removing 4 screws. Of course u need to leave tilt plate on. What do u think?
Thanks for your comment! If you can afford to leave the tilt plate on, this can be a great solution. I was concerned about whether my unmounted 36mm filters would vignette the field, so I wanted to absolutely minimize the distance between the sensor and the filter. I sacrificed the tilt plate and bolted the camera right onto the EFW, as you saw. This has turned out well for me. The mounting is solid, and I have no significant vignetting. I also did not need to use the tilt plate. I also tend not to shift my gear configuration around or change cameras. I treat the camera and EFW as a unit, and bolting them together works well for me. With your approach, you have a much greater ability to change cameras around. And you can use the tilt plate should you need it. The only downside I can see is that the camera can loosen its connection with the EFW and rotate a bit. I have run into this before myself. In the past, I set my scopes up in the driveway each night for imaging, so the rig's movement may have caused this. Clear Skies, Pat
I would put the motor on the center. It will bind otherwise.. I had to change mine. Speaking from experience. Not to mention the fact that your rollers do nothing to hold the roof to the building .
Thanks for your comment. I don't expect it will bind as I am not using two V-groove tracks-just one-to avoid being over-constrained. This was recommended by Jim Collins, who builds the motor system I am using. He has done this for tons of observatories and seemed confident that this was fine. I also had this looked at by a mechanical engineering friend, who recommended placing the drive near the V-groove track.
@@cosgrovescosmos thank you for the explanation. I, of course,am talking to you from Florida . Everything has to be built up to code and I had to contract an engineer to draw my plans so that it is hurricane resistant( up to code); we’re talking 10 x 16 Obsy. I had to use Simpson ties in every corner, floor anchors as well as garage roller tracks in order to keep everything in place and code compliant. Now, if a hurricane comes, I know where to take my family. I hope you’re having half as much fun as I did 😊
I can imagine building such an observatory in an area with hurricanes is a real challenge! Sounds like yours is bomb-proof!
Nice, getting closer to breaking ground….👍🏻
Thanks - yes - getting very close now!
Thank you very much for this very interresting video. Your explications are very clear and the detail on you site is amazing!
Thank you for your kind words! I really appreciate the feedback!
Any update to this?
The dynamic paintbrush, alas, is no longer available or supported. I made another video showing how to use the Clonestamp tool. This can be seen here: th-cam.com/video/t2duU4MOMGU/w-d-xo.htmlsi=2xDudelPSZvfQ7Oz
I was wondering if you ever considered the FRA500 or was that scope n ot wide enough enough? I am trying to decide between the two
Definitely not wide enough for what I wanted. But the 500 was not availible at the time anyways while the 400 was - which sealed the deal.
Beautiful image!!
Thank you!
Did you ever consider the FRA500 or was that not wide enough? I am trying to decide between the two
I don't think the 500 was available when I got my 400, but I did want something wider. Right now, the 400 covers about 2X the area of sky my AP130 covers, and my WO132 with a reducer sits smack dap in the middle of those two, so I like my coverage options that way.
Well done👏
Thank you 😁
You have made Saṃsāra visible to us, and not just it ~ so thank you. You have no idea what kind of impact you have so please ~ keep up the good work. If you find strength within ~ do even more of this region since NGC 6334, NGC 6357, NGC 6374 (NGC 6405 aka M6🦋 cluster) with Sh 2-12, Sh 2-13 are those of the most significant meaning to the lost knowledge of ancient civilizations. Trust your eyes when even when you invert colors, but also rotate or mirror the images. Thank you for the work you've done so far ~ I hope You will find out one day where did it lead to and what mysteries that work reviled to some, hopefully ~ many to come in near future.
Thank you for your kind words!
@@cosgrovescosmos oh, more over thank You for yours and for your deeds even more :) :)
Excellent tutorial !! 👍🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Thank you so much! Glad you found it useful!
Can you include the links in the description? Looking for these parts for my project right now!
The Amazon link is shown in short form at the end of each section. If you would prefer clickable links, you can find those in my companion blog for this topic on my website. I added this to the header, but I will include it here as well: cosgrovescosmos.com/observatory/design-track-system-final
Great update Patrick 👍 Coincidentally, as I was watching this, my observatory roll-off-roof just went on, which is a flat roof. The builders started Sunday afternoon, delivering the pre-made panels, floor and roof frame, and right this minute adding the roof boards ready for the EDPM covering. The observatory will be finished by Wednesday. Excitement is replacing months of overthinking and planning 😂.
Kevan - I am so glad to hear that your observatory is becoming a real thing you can work with! Outstanding! I think I am now done overthinking (I am really obsessing about this) and ready to move on to overthinking my electrical layout! Send me some photos of your project - would love to see it now that it is becoming real!
@@cosgrovescosmos Hi Patrick, I produced a lengthy reply to your last reply, but don’t know where that has gone? Can’t remember what I said now 😂. I will send some photos to you. The observatory build will be finished today. Next jobs for me are roof automation, alarm and CCTV, cabling up everything thing. I’m having cable tray fixed to two walls to keep everything neat.
Sounds great! Can't wait to see it!
Living the dream! It shows that you are very much enjoying this project. You’re doing a great job and inspiring me to take on projects of my own. I took a week off work and started putting together a man cave in my garage. I bought my first soldering iron, multimeter, a nice workbench and a few other things all so I could start a few DIY projects of my own. First project completed and tested tonight - PWM motor controller for an electronic focuser. 😊
Living in an area of too many clouds, it is great to have projects and things related to Astrophotography to work on to keep the juices flowing. There are a lot of things I can do on my own - and have - but mechanical things and metal work are NOT in my tool box. That is where friends come and are willing to help. Having that help and doing a project in more of a team mode make it so much more enjoyable and rewarding! Having a good Man Cave is a must for projects! I'm glad to hear that you've created yours and finished your first project! Congrats! Now that you've started, I'm sure your mind is swirling with possibilities for what to do next! Enjoy!
What fun
Great Video Sir. Very Interesting Laser Cutting. Loved how you even showed the pulses from the co2 tubes. Glad to see things moving along for you.
Thanks so much! Over so much time in planning, it is good to see things happening!
Wow, love watching that laser doing its thing, reminds me of being back at work at 3M UK, .we used lasers for cutting all the abrasives, albeit a little smaller, but not much…great video. 👍🏻
DId not even know they used lasers for creating abrasives - but as I think about it - it makes perfect sense! Thanks Much!
@@cosgrovescosmos not for creating, but for cutting the smaller discs and such like that fit into your home sanders and grinders, from larger sheets..👍🏻
Ahh - I get it now. I suppose using a traditional cutter for that kind of work would be self-defeating - the abrasives on the sheets would always be wearing down the blades. Kind of tough to wear down a light saber!
If you go to your local metal recycling place they will most likely sell new and USED metal in all kinds of shapes and sizes. Usually for a few bucks a pound. I bought a 4 in and a 6 in metal tube, cut to length on the yards bandsaw. They even have offcut scrap. I found some perfect triangle pieces to use as supports and also a square plate 1" thick and a round plate 1" thick. What I brought home was already cut and the plates had holes in them for bolts. I paid 90 bucks for all the steal. Using the flat square plates on the bottom and the round on the top with the triangle pieces to support the bottom. I use all thread embedded in the concrete and I turned a cast iron adapter that is IDENTICAL to the top of my tripod so my mount would bolt to it with the same adjustability as I would have on the tripod. I used elongated holes on the base to allow for some rotation adjustment. And I used large bolts with a series of two nuts on each bolt to the round adapter plate to allow for some leveling adjustment. Once it's all set, and polar aligned, I should be able to forget it.
Oh, and I filled my steel tube with expanding foam to cut down on vibration and ringing.
Great tips! Thanks for sharing it!
I have not head of this option - again - thanks for sharing!
Interesting
Nice work Mr Cosgrove. I would like to share my solution to the pier perhaps you can improve something in your design.
Thanks! You can contact me at Contact@CosgrovesCosmos.com.
Another great video and nice to see it moving forward, FWI the pier does not have to be perfectly level, that’s what polar alignment is for….👍🏻
Thanks so much! I know that polar alignment and the alt-az adjustments on the mount can compensate for level and such - I was just a little paranoid that the foundation and bolts would go in wrong, and then I was in trouble. And I would be if the error was greater than the alt-az adjustment ability of the mount. So this way, I can tame my paranoia! :-)
An excellent and valid point. It amazes me how many people are convinced that a perfectly level pier is absolutely essential for accurate polar alignment. As you say, it doesn't matter one iota!
I wanted to follow your workflow of creating a SHO - Image using the Color Combination tool. Unfortunately PI refuses to CC stating that it works only with RGB - Data. I tear my hair out with PI!
Hmmm - not sure what is happening there. ChannelCombination really does not know what you are feeding it when you select the files for the so-called r, g, and b fields. Are you sure you ae grabbing the right tool? You mention "Color Combination" and "CC" - CC usually refers to a color calibration tool, and that one does care about it being an RGB file. ChannelCombination takes 3 mono images and combines them to form a 3-layer color rgb image. If the files you hand it are really S2, Ha, and O3 ( aks SHO), then it will form a color file with those. But the input files must be single-channel mono files.
@@cosgrovescosmos Thank you so much for your answer. Yes I meant Channel combination, CC was just for short. Yes, the files are single channel mono ones in S, H and O respectively.
Very strange - I am not sure why you are running into this problem. I do this all of the time, and in fact, as a sanity check, I just went over and tried it again. Worked without problems. Sorry - I seem to be no help to you for this one!
Hi, thanks for the intersting video. My question: In your workflow (0.21 min into the video) the shown starless images are already nonlinear. Is LF then appropriate to use as it's no linear data anymore?
Great Question! Linearfit sounds like it is used just for linear data. However, the name is really just referencing the numerical methodology used to put the best straight line through the data being modeled. It can do its job as long as there IS a linear relationship between the two data sets (in this case, the reference image pixels compared to the target image pixels). Now - it is more likely to work best in the linear domain as the mere act of stretching introduces nonlinearities. However, that does not mean it is not useful in the nonlinear domain. Some of the areas of nonlinearity are concentrated towards the toe and shoulder of the curve, so by clipping those, we concentrate on the middle portions of the curve, which can be fairly linear. The example workflow shown here is one I had used extensively for NB images. I should point out that BlurXtermintor has caused me to change my workflow. It does its best job when dealing with three color layers at the same time. So, I now create my SHO images in the linear domain, run BXT, and then go nonlinear. When I want to work on individual color channels, I extract them from the color image, enhance that layer, and then recombine them. So, these days, I tend to do this in the linear domain, and linearFIt is used there. But the key takeaway here is that LinearFit can be useful any time you are attempting to combine unlike images. Thanks, Pat