วีดีโอ

I choose the M1 Garand

Got both already

It depends. Am I with others and is it an infantry hob along with a large scale attack? Garand. This allows me to take down targets from farther, while being louder than the .30 round it should still be masked by the gunfire of enemy MG's. M1 carbine would be a stealthier weapon as it would be real quiet with a suppressor, and also excels since it has a beeg magazeen :)

Pacific, carbine. Europe, Garand

Carbine, I don’t trust my shot enough for a 8 round mag 😂

Garand. All day every day

I love the feel of the 30 carbine my grandpa had one he wasnt a vet or anything but i think he bought it off of a veteran i still have it and my grandpa is long gone

M1 garand for europe and africa. Carbine for the jungle,urban or natural.

All in all, I'm taking the M1 Carbine. Garand has range and power but almost every other attribute goes to the Carbine. Weight, round weight, magazine fed, smallest magazine is still two rounds more than the Garand's clip, ease of movement and handling.

Depends on the task. Clearing the bunkers and trench systems along the coast....carbine.

I want both

Garand

The Beretta BM59 308

I’m going with the carbine 😊

M1 garand

M1 grand

For home defence I prefer the carbine.

If ur paying $2.09 for “garand safe” 30-06. Ur looking in the opposite direction dudes. That’s RIDICULOUS Legit .89¢-$1.10 MAXIMUM is a more realistic commercial price Easily available too. So you’re actually paying MORE than commercial Garand safe ammo to make your own currently Congrats

Depends on how far ive gotta travel

I heard that Marines that got their hands on a Carbine would not give them up.

M1 Carbine if it's in an urban area

medium to long? M1 Garand Up close and personal? M1 Carbine

Grand ❤❤❤

M1 carbine

carbine

Cable

I’d love to see this comparison done between a Garand and an M14!

Personally, I prefer the M1 carbine

Garand. One shot one kill

m1garand

Carbine

I choose the Garand...

M1 garand no hesitation, that gun is so accurate you dont even jave to try to aim it WANTS to hit the target. I shot my buddies in 30-06 at the East Coast Night Shoot in November last year and it was no fuckin joke. Recoil wasnt even bad. Dinging steel at almost 200 yards no probleiroith irons. Its no wonder that gun was standard issue.

M1 Carbine for CQB M1 Garand for more Dopamine

M grand

M1

Use strips of conveyor belting or fire hose……. Fender washers for the hardware.

i'd probably try something like tow straps, cut them to the needed length and burn a hole through the cut pieces to bolt it to the plate and stand, i just thought of it so i cant say with and cofidence it'll work but the idea is that it'll survive multiple shots from any normal caliber like 50 bmg and under simply because one shot wont be enough to completely cut the strap due to size alone and they're rather durable so the impact from the round on the plate shouldnt bother it nor the weather

I would probably choose the carbine because ive always had a soft spot for it, im not sure why

I’d rather have either over the kar98

I'll take the m1

M1 Garand stops things so dose the m1 Carbine just not in the same way...

In a war? The Garand. For everyday use? The carbine.

"Car Bean"

There’s a lotta ancient fudds in this comments section 😂 “stopping power” and “knock down power” are a myth. Shot placement is what matters. A .30 Carbine would be better for almost every situation compared to a 30-06 in the same way .45ACP is useless compared to 9mm.

My ego says garand but my degenerative shoulder says carbine

The M1 grand

Apparently because 90% of what a solder does with his rifle is carry it they loved the carbine

It depends on what kind of battle I will be in. Carbine for town or close combat. M1 maybe in something like the Battle of Buldge

Frozen Chosin. In the book The Last Stand of Fox Company, it's noted that the Carbine, when shooting at the enemy in heavy coats, was not always reliable. Just know that as a potential issue. Personally, I carry the smallest caliber for every weapon intended for self-defense. More rounds = more practice shots, and everyone around me on my side has the knockout round while I have the suppression. Just a strategy. At the end of the day, a well placed shot with any round can kill.