วีดีโอ

@Philthorn Future can changed ya know In main story, Eren hold back his Founding Titan power and let his friend doing whatever they think they can win and make them become Hero of the world for saving 20% humanity left and living in peaceful life ( he choose care for his friend ) In AnR, Eren determined want to destroy all humanity so he didn't hold back and bring even more titan Shifter to stop them and the titan who captures Armin stay in Colossal Titan mouth is prove that Eren is very determined to end Cycle of Hated ( he choose freedom Eldia )

@storyshiftchara8672 so, you could say yes, kruger did say those words to grisha, supposedly because eren can send memories to past attack titans. But even if that was true, now because of historia and his soon to be formed family, he'll be more conflicted about his decision to save which one, for he will be forced to go against those words

@Philthorn I have theory that Mikasa and Armin need protect because they are only his 2 childhood friend helping Eren getting strong and when the time has come, he will need to choose one of two path

​@@storyshiftchara8672by one or two path, you mean choose to kill one of the two, or kill both of them to save his people and family back in paradis?

Remind me of that girl who was screaming for her dad before getting eaten.

Yeah. A lot of ending defenders think that Eren was guilt tripping her and I never believed it. I was never a shipper of Eren and historia, but when people started to make theories on how Eren could’ve been the father of her child and looking back at previous scenes and their interactions that’s when I realized that it makes a lot of sense. And given the ending, I would’ve preferred it now.

@UnknxwnXL0 hence, why aotnr exists, to slowly but surely give us that alternative

I’ll look into it 👍

@@UnknxwnXL0she may not talk a lot in some points of the video, but when she does, it's must listen

​@@UnknxwnXL0in some points of the video she may not talk a lot, but when she does, it's must listen

@@Philthorn noted.

​@@UnknxwnXL0Fantastic, see ya then

Np. The vid is still there. You can watch it anytime

@@UnknxwnXL0I know. As of right now, I'm responding while rewatching the entire thing

Go at it!

@@UnknxwnXL0you know it

I think it was coincidental too, but if he meant to be symbolic for something, that would be stupid because it would seem that he didn’t want to flesh out certain aspects of the story for some dumb number

@@UnknxwnXL0yeah, just for the sake of some "deep meaning" behind a f'ing number. "Hidden" details? More like overrated, exaggerated details

Yeah for me, I don’t care about themes at all. I would never call a story good just because of the themes that are in it.You could find any theme in any story no matter how little importance it may have in the story. Like I said in the livestream, themes are like a garnish on a dish or a cherry on a sundae,It could make the story slightly better because of the themes and how it’s executed but that shouldn’t be the crux or one of the key factors of what makes a story good.

@@UnknxwnXL0if only this fact was shared by more people

@@Philthorn I know right? 😂

@@UnknxwnXL0but no, "a non-theme focused story is stupid and pointless"

@@Philthorn I know right?Anyways, I got a question I don’t know if i asked you this but do you think that Historia’s pregnancy subplot was important at all? because I talked about it briefly and that if it was removed, the story would not have been impacted at all. Edit: given the ending. What do you think?

I know what characterization is.I don’t need the definition. Okay, if every single character was characterized, plz list me at one substantial characterization point for each character in the class. There’s not that much world building in this series so far. What tests do you have to take in order to be qualified to enter the rangers academy? Are their multiple ranger schools or just this one? From what I remember, I know what a ranger is but is there different types of rangers?Do they have a ranking system? Do they have superpowers? From the latest intro song, it showed one of the characters creating a green ball of energy, so it might be foreshadowing the use of superpowers.But if so, how do they get them?Are they born with them?If not,Do the rangers get to choose one or is it random depending on some factors? An issue that I talked about in this episode was the school schedule. What was their subjects? We spent 4 episodes and almost a whole semister in-universe, only seeing them train. But then we find out that they have another subjects that they take as well. So,what’s the school subjects then? Because we only see two or three MAX and by then almost a whole semester passed. Okay, so just because there might be future episodes, I can’t talk about my current issues with the side characters? Yeah my laptop lags,I need to get the battery replaced but it’s over 200 dollars plus tax and I ain’t got the money to replace it, so if you can send me the money to get fixed then sure I can get it done, but until i have enough money, I’ll do with what I got.

Carmen - Spiteful and vindictive towards people she doesn’t like like Hope and helpful caring and polite to people she does like Itsuki it’s simple but affective Arthur - A stubborn, arrogant, rambunctious, reckless, quick tempered, playful, selfish and rude man who has a competitive streak that effects even his own teammates and leads him to making impulsive decisions. He blames other people for his faults because he can’t admit his own mistakes, yet will belittle people for their minor ones. He is shown to be somewhat shallow and can be easily swayed by reputation, quickly buying into the rumors that Hope cheated her way into Cosmos Academy without evidence and using it as an excuse to mess with her. His attitude makes him a really great source of conflict for the story and it gives more characterization for other characters which is something really only he can do at the moment because his personality is much more different from the rest of the cast, but in the first episode it shows that he isn’t a completely insensitive person giving him even more depth. Alex - laidback, compassionate and insightful and despite having a soft spoken demeanor he can be somewhat assertive Amai - A sweet girl on the surface unless someone pushes her buttons or messes with her friends Chris - Intelligent, snarky and upbeat but despite being intelligent he has shown he can be really immature Sebastian - Intelligent friendly and very laid back and he specifically became a ranger to discover truths about the universe Jeff - A laidback and snarky guy who doesn’t like feeling left out Kayleen - Stoic disciplined and observant Being physically fit and being close to the top of your grade that’s why people don’t like hope because she wasn’t and only got in because Carmen’s dad said she had potential so she took her friends place. They don’t mention other schools like cosmos but other schools existing or not doesn’t matter to what the main characters are up to at the moment Professor strong and Sebastian already told us want it is in the 3rd episode they travel and study and galaxy while taking down alien monsters and space pirates(was mentioned in episode 2) and they get powers after they pass from the orb. Supernatural powers such as teleportation(Professor Strong) pyrokinesis(Maria) and the Azul force which is seemingly powerful but we aren’t suppose to know what it does yet They clearly learn the normal subjects while learning about certain creatures in space why would you want to see all of them just in class that’s boring and the training was so the character could interact with each other That’s if they have issues if they have problems with they’re writing sure but with the four episodes we got they are fine the way they are Edit: The characters I listed were the ones you considered nobodies I knew they’re personalities and roles because I payed attention

the fact that you can only give a sentence for most of the side characters and only talk about their personality, which is the BASIS of characterization proves my point that they're basically nobodies. You only talked about the QUALIFICATIONS of entering the academy, not the TESTS that they have to take to be in the academy. You didn't answer my question. Ok, so they don't mention other schools. Worldbuilding does not have to relate to the plot to be important. So, you didn't refute my other school issue. Yes, I know what Rangers do but you didn't answer my questions. Are there different types of rangers? Do they have a ranking system? in what episode did the teacher talk about the orb? I don't remember him talking about that and you STILL didn't answer my questions, Do the rangers get to choose one or is it random depending on some factors? You're assuming that they learn the normal subjects. Matter of fact, name me all the subjects that they do. Because from what I know there are 3 which PR, training and cooking class. You do realize that they can also interact in other classes too, right? Not just training. there are more issues in the story than just the side characters as I mentioned above. Again they can be solved in future episodes,that's why I said CURRENT issues. Matter of fact, I actually talked about what I knew about the characters later in the vid for almost 10 minutes (36:36 - 45:10)? And I know I do because I went back multiple times to compare the voice of the black guy, how Carmen could've gotten sick during the test, How the writers wrote the WRONG type of principal on the director's badge and the consistency of Jasmine's build between wearing the suit and her school uniform. So I do pay attention. P.S you used to wrong affective it's effective.

You asked for one characterization point that’s one trait I added more and characterization is the description of the character so I didn’t need multiple sentences I just added multiple sentences to characters that had more to talk about I thought you already knew the definition of characterization because that’s what you put but I guess not also me proving you wrong does not mean you proved your point I said they had to be near the top of their grade as Carmen mentioned so they had to be smart and fit obviously because if they can’t keep up they get removed so they were great at normal subjects taught in schools which made them qualified. Cosmos is like a college you apply and if they think you can handle it they will accept you and that’s why some people don’t like hope because she wasn’t at the top of her class or even that physically fit Ok but they don’t have to as far as we have been told Cosmos is the only space academy I did answer your question about if there are other types rangers by implying they do the same thing. And wouldn’t it make more sense if they mentioned a ranking system (which they most likely don’t) it WHEN they became rangers and it’s like you want it to be world trigger or some shit just dumping a whole bunch of exposition because you can’t keep up with it being subtle Alex talked about the orb in episode 3 while talking to itsuki in the locker room and no they don’t get to chose that wouldn’t make much sense wouldn’t most of them get the Azul force because that’s implied to be powerful PR, PE, chemistry, space study, and home economics but them learning Math or history DOES NOT MATTER TO THE PLOT WHAT YOU ARE ASKING FOR IS FILLER they showed us the subjects that matter for character development why are you nitpicking things that don’t matter and won’t ever matter and no they can’t interact normally in they pay attention to what ever the teacher is teaching and when they do interact in class it’s either brief or before or after the teaching begins There is no current issue because they serve their purpose for the story Also as I keep mentioning you don’t pay attention I put a whole sentence together for the characters with like 36 seconds amount of screen time because I pay attention And know you don’t because you thought Alex and Jeff were the same character just because their hair style was somewhat similar so that’s a lie “that black guy” was just speaking in a lower tone that Carmen bit was so obvious the principal bit was literally in our faces and I noticed jazmines arms to your not special P.S don’t blame me because auto correct is stupid

ok, that's my fault for being too generous on that one. Personality is just step 1 of characterization, congrats. At most, there's like what, there's like 1 or maybe 2 things that we know for maybe each character? (I'm being generous again). There's not much to these side characters. That's barely explaining the process. Does the commission have to compare every student in every high school all around the world? again, they don't have to but it's still a worldbuilding issue because there's only ONE space academy that can take only 12 students for the ENTIRE world where there might be billions of people living on Earth? It makes no sense. Also, Jazz talked about the second years taking the exam, where are they at? Why is the academy in outer space? It makes no sense economically. Never seen/read World Trigger so that reference meant nothing to me and exposition isn't inherently negative. I don't see anything wrong with a bit of exposition. Well, we don't know what the Azul Force is or the qualifications for getting the ability, so you're just assuming that most of them would get the Azul Force. Again, if they don't get to choose, what are the factors to getting a specific ability? Is it based on personality or what? you said the normal subjects so that means Math and History. Tell me how History and Math don't matter because, for science, math is important. I think a History class does matter because, for the audience, it could add some world-building to the series like the history of rangers which we could learn more about Itsuki's family since his father was a well-known ranger. What about Mechanics? Is there a class for mechanics like building weapons out of scrap or something? How does cooking matter for development? There was only one scene and they did interact during the class. What's wrong with a bit of filler? Filler could help flesh out characters like seeing their dynamics with each other, Not everything has to matter for the plot to matter. For example, what does Hope and Itsuki speaking Japanese matter for the plot? The plot would not change at all if they couldn't speak Japanese. It adds characterization. Scenes can have different purposes than just for the plot. Somewhat? Their hairstyle is basically the same, except Jeff's hair is dyed golden blonde. I never said I was special, stop putting words in my mouth. Funny how you couldn't defend the writers writing the wrong type of principle, it would actually be principal or director on the badge, like do the team creating this not see this obvious mistake despite having a whole shot looking at the badge? Like do not they not care enough to search up the proper word? lol P.S. That's still your fault because you can still go back and fix the word anytime. So yeah, you're still the blame for it. Edit: so about the Carmen thing, can people have more than one ability or was there secret poison in the glove that he wore?

Yes it is in multiple ways, it was never established that founding Titan can use all the abilities of the other titan shifters. And the only way to gain those abilities is eat the shifter’s spine but somehow the founding Titan is the exception, for what reason? We will never know.It’s just the way it is.

@@UnknxwnXL0I asked because some use the argument that it's not, and that eren already did that back in 2nd season when he touched Dina and was able to use the founding titan power, even for a short time

@Philthorn doesn’t matter. It’s never established prior that the founding Titan can use all of the other shifters abilities. So it’s still a plot hole either way

@@UnknxwnXL0and finally, do you think ymir had something to do with that?

@Philthorn that’s the only way for it make somewhat sense. But then again Ymir is an issue because you’re saying that throughout 2000 YEARS, there was no relationship similar to own, except where a victim is standing up against their abuser? That’s extremely bullshit.

I’m fine.

@@UnknxwnXL0in case you have future videos planned, mind if I suggest something new I recently came across?

@Philthorn sure

@@UnknxwnXL0they're called "Fixing Attack on Titan's Ending" by Uniquenameosaurus. I say they because it's two separate videos, 2 parts Unfortunately, they're almost 2 hours long each, so I don't know if you'll have enough time to stream it let alone react to the whole thing. All I can say for now is that it's an amazing scenario and I recommend it

@@UnknxwnXL0if you think you can't do it, it's ok, I was just suggesting

did they not read ch.130? She literally told Eren to think about the innocent people who would be collateral damage and even compared them to his mother. Aotnr part 2 continues this convo so to understand it completely the reader has to read 130 before going to part 2. in part 2, she told Eren that the MPs will decide who will father her children. So, taking Ymir's message into account "living your life with pride" and becoming more selfish, she took back that decision and chose Eren, the person who stood up for her in the hizuru meeting while everyone stayed silent. they call her a submissive sheep, yet she's the one who proposed the idea of having a child? Make it make sense.

@@UnknxwnXL0guess they don't or cannot see it that way, it's sad, but I won't force them to change theur minds

​@@UnknxwnXL0guess they can't see it that way (maybe because aotnr didn't have that canon line in there), it's sad, but I won't force them to change their minds either

​@@UnknxwnXL0they should at least be more open minded to it, like Always TRYHARD, king bullet, anime balls deep and many others

Aye what’s up homie?

Yeah Ive been thinking of doing it at least monthly or maybe bi-weekly at most

@@UnknxwnXL0sure, whatever suits you more bud

Interesting… I’ll look into it 👀

@@UnknxwnXL0appreciate it, just tryna give you anything interesting to look into. Wish I could give you more, but it was all that came up at the moment

@@UnknxwnXL0proven wrong, just found another great video: Ten problems with attack on titan's ending by TheGamingArchaeologist

Was these quotes about AOTNR in a recent community post?😂

@@UnknxwnXL0someone else is also doing his homework

Oh nah, that was an educated guess since I hear those types of negative comments a lot on the Aotnorequiem twitter page

@@UnknxwnXL0man, that sucks

@Philthorn it sucks but I’m not surprised.don’t really care either.

Fresh and Fit had beef with Aba and Preach for a while now so I wouldn’t call them obsessed

@@UnknxwnXL0 it all started after they did a hit piece after Aba was on the show.

I forgot that Aba was on the show at one point

So true

Fresh & Zesty started it after speaking badly of Aba, and FNF continued relentlessly slandering them to the point of setting up a fight, but chickened out, and interjecting A&P by simulating them by being racist and mocking them…Do your research, before you spew nonsense and deception…

Already saw it. Amazing vid. Can’t wait for the full version

@@UnknxwnXL0me too. Then let's do the full version once it comes out

@Philthorn for sure