วีดีโอ

The biggest issue with JetStarfish's videos is he always wants to restrict things into a far more linear and forced style of gameplay. He wants everyone to spawn in and rush gear for the Ender Dragon fight. To him, anything other than that linear style is a problem and needs to be changed. Minecraft is a sandbox game. There is no requirement for any one playstyle and trying to claim that other playstyles are incorrect or problematic is just wrong. I regularly clear out Ancient Cities before I even get diamond gear due to the value of that loot being much higher early on. There is no reason to make the player wait until the end of progression to be able to find them when it doesn't really require any gear to begin with.

you know what else went on for too long? the list for THE 12000....

Kill the Al voice

enchanted golden apples are NOT more valuable than swift sneak lol if youre going to the ancient city youre probably strong enough to where you basically cant die to anything that isnt a boss swift sneak is overall infinitely more useful

I honestly think that the recovery compass doesn't get enough credit. Like, one time I died in some random area thousands of blocks from my base in the late game. If I had a recovery compass(and an elytra) I probably would not have lost my stuff there. I really do think it's underrated. That being said, it is pretty weird how most likely, the players who need the recovery compass the most, need to go find it in one of the hardest areas of the game. Swift sneak is nice to have and Jet really shouldn't make mistakes like leaving swift sneak out again in the future. That is one of the biggest reasons I and many others go to the ancient city and he just forgot. I really do think that ancient cities are often made out to be more useless than they actually are, but their loot still needs to be better like Hayze says. I also think that saying "all overworld biomes are basically the same," is a crazy take from Jet, like NO THEY ARE NOT. Different biomes offer all sorts of exclusive materials, environments and mobs, there are plenty of reasons why you would want to leave your base to go somewhere else. Overall all, I mostly agree with you.

Whats worse about his "i cant mod" excuse is that he can *EASILY* search up tutorials on how to mod

The recovery compous is useful for the worse players (Me) i will die with full dimond armor to a random spider in a random cave and need it to refind it. Not useful for experienced people but glad they thought of the smaller people. Agian not the most useful but still rather have it and not need it then need it and not have it.

side note but what voice is that text to speech?

i had a recovery compass but lost it when i died😓

a reaction to a reaction someone should react to it

As someone who has used the recovery compass in survival Minecraft, it's a helpful item that has definitely saved my stuff from time to time. Even if I know where my stuff is, it's nice to have an exact pointer to it, as long as I remember to actually use it.

One thing The Hayze missed in their analysis - fossils can generate in desert, swamp, and mangrove biomes, with fossils deep underground generating diamonds instead of coal, giving even more ore specialization to biomes

I should point out the ice highways also cannot go vertically whatsoever, which is another balance, much like minecarts you have to build the infrastructure but then youd have trade offs, the speed of iceboats but limited to the same elevation for a 2 way track while minecarts may be slower but you have more options to go with the terrain

I'm just gonna say, I don't think most people go into an Ancient City for specifically enchanted golden apples. Especially when every structure has around the same spawn chance for them. If you are going into any structure specifically 9/10 times you're going for things that are specific to that structure (Trims, Swift Sneak, Recovery Compass, Totems, Mace, whatever else I missed) you aren't really going to go in there for things you can get literally everywhere. Also the recover compass isn't that hard to get. The warden and skulk are like the most explained and easiest to get mechanic in the game, and this is Minecraft a game where literally nothing is explained to you ever.

Funny thing about the recovery compass is if you died and ur like 500hours into the world you just press F3 and note your coordinates. you can do that while on the death screen

Fun Fact: Armor trims are completely useless if you're playing in singleplayer and not recording a video.

youre clearly not a builder hayze is a builder thats why seift sneak is so important

"Jet: Damn, it sucks that in a game called Minecraft, a lot of the solutions to your problems are to mine"

5:35 That got dark real quick

I'm curious, how would preventing blue ice from melting balance nether highways? Wouldn't it just force all people who want to build a nether highway into using the fastest possible option for ice? I feel as though this would have the opposite effect you were going for.

Hayze acts extremely rude in the video honestly, gives me very bad vibes, I agree that Jet has no idea what he's saying but Hayze acts like Jet is a straight up criminal, sure some practices are scummy but it feels like adding an entire lie counter just crossed the line a little in terms of cruelty.

E

I have always hated 1.18 the caves and cliffs update part 2, that's the reason why I started to play old Minecraft

Why is it #nsfw?

Fun fact: Woodland mansions can actually rarely contain a diamond block encased in obsidian

restriction is a bad idea for sandbox games of any sort, imagine if gmod only allowed you to subscribe to addons after getting 5 achievements.

when is someone gonna make a response to this video lol

Just the response video with a text to speech guy saying "agree"

Hardcore:👁️👄👁️

Generally speaking I agree more with Hayze on this one. At least he was not being dishonest and lying like Starfish was.

This video is exactly what I was thinking they both have points that I agree with and disagree with

Good video still some stuff I disagree with you but much stuff you said made much more sense but an opinion is an opinion

Swift sneak is good enchatment and is on level sharpness 3-4 it makes looting another ancient city easier and Faster, it also makes building and bridgeing Faster its a good enchantment

10:30 Except plate tectonics isn't even the right field of study, but go off king.

Swift sneak is extremely important, but only in endgame when making farms and megabuilds. Unless you have that playstyle, it's useless, but if you do, it's lowkey more important than netherite tools

The AI voice makes this video 10x funnier and enjoyable

Is your voice AI generated? It sounds kinda robotic and text-to-speech-like to me

2:01 i watched both videos and I was waiting for someone to say that The Hayze was overhyping swift sneak so hard. I get that Jet left it out, but is it really that important that you have to rant about it that much?

Here is my view on this: JetStarfish made a video promoting his ideas for a better exploration experience. Obviously this is adressed at the people who are not so happy with the sandbox playstyle of the game. Not at the people who love minecraft for what it is. That's why I think making Ancient citys rarer and post end locked is not a bad move. It's an optional mod for those who seek this kind of playstyle afterall. So everything concerning the actual content of the mod is just part of personal preference and does not influence the quality of the mod or the capability of JetSt. Yes puting the Mod behind a paywall was a bad move, leaving several things like swiftsneak and copper distribution in Dripstone caves out was a bad move. (Although a lot of these "lies" I do think aren't intentional but just badly frased. Example following) I do think, JetSt pit thought and effort into a mod and video that would make minecraft better in his opinion. (Remember, this is still an optional mod. Putting in content you don't agree with does NOT make him a bad person) Hayze's video: In my eyes his video literally is nothing but hate. There is barely anythin constructive in it and more of: "I don't like this. You are wrong. Let's move on." (In a way to agressive and straight up rude tone imo. For example: "this makes everything so much f_ing more terrible" and "it was so much worse than I thought" is just not ok to say to someone who put genuine care, thaught and effort into a passion project.) Like I said, all of the complains he had about the contnents of the mod are just personal preference. Noone can tell anyone what is better and what is worse. It as an optional download after all. If you don't like it, just don't play it. The "lies": Personally I think some of these lies are purely to push the number up, I mean: "The Warden doesn't onehit you... It twohits you." What's the difference? Jet's point is you are basically dead if he attacks you. "He left out the ore distribution" [+ 1 lie] (2 seconds later) "Ah, he mentioned the ore distribution... he's contridicting himself" [+ 1 lie] What's that? That's literally what someone would mention in search of the smallest case of bad frasing to push up the number. (Also he himself lies about the "crime". Probaply unintentional but if he doesn't get flamed for this that you should give JetSt the benifit of the doubt too) I do think JetStbdid some bad moves (mostly the stuff about the paywall. Again, nothing to do with the contnts of the mod) Hayze only did bad moves 🤣 To me it looks like a video purely ment to stir up controvercy and hate. (Which, I'm sad to say, worked. If you look at the comments under Jet's video most of the comments from more than 7 days ago where overwhelmingl, positive. Most of the comments from 7 days ago or less are blind hate) I don't know if he wanted to use the popularity of Jet's video to grow his own channel but it devinatly was NOT a constructive critique. Talking about Jet's jokes isn't even part of the mod so what has that to do with anything? So to me, even though nobody is perfectly innocent, the "bad person" in this controvercy definatly is Hayze. He just wanted to create hate.

10:13 this part doesn't make sence. Aint nobody gonna try to find a mesa biome for gold, usually while caving normally you will get enough gold to atleast craft gold boots. And all the gold you need for trading with piglins is found in bastions.

THE "The Hayze's "JetStarfish's "the exploration is TERRIBLE - here's why" is TERRIBLE - here's why" is TERRIBE - here's why" !!!!!! THE "The Hayze's "JetStarfish's "the exploration is TERRIBLE - here's why" is TERRIBLE - here's why" is TERRIBLE - here's why" IS REAL!!!!!!!!

Why does this video have #nsfw?

This video is stolen btw

Things are i will see on my things/mind (bedrock user) (never use mod/addon) I make woodland mansion as minigames and just turn it hard mode so im good as seeing as easteregg like you know exist then you can explore it. but more idea make the ominous potion how much effect make it more harder and can add another dimension for more harder for more geared. like the new trail stuff. shiftsneak is the best like sharpness are good making mob easy to kill so is there like 2x of ratio they make. Shift Sneak - good enchantment for building Recovery Compass - good literally i have dementia in cords. Every Cave and Cliff - many many goods in building and lava farms Biome Ore - botched research from the original video never use boat skating because by foot exploration is more fun like i never use elytra only in the end take note i never use elytra because of heart attack in bugrock As whole feedback in the mod putting as an paywall mod in java is shitty and i think the creator mod i think is blaming an people who work on the mod if they really exist. i can right java script and i know modding bot java and bedrock these things they add are easy to add. i know they need a profit you can add supporting pay thing if they want to and putting as paywall and put "note they really put work the mod" anyway thats sarcasm. animation/ nope, never texture in my life the texture are bad when you have a pallet in game,like the codes stuff yeah they are in beginner like you can search for these in youtube how to write. also anyway bad english welp not my first language

Bro wtf are those hashtags? wdym #nsfw and #illegal 💀

A response video to a response about a video, this is interesting.

Fun Fact: in the video "Why Minecraft Isn't Fun Anymore", he suggested that the Ancient City should start generating only after killing the Ender Dragon..........i"ll never forget that

I actually discussed about the idea of mansion providing a little bit loot from other structure with my friends.But we found out this could potentially make mansion lose its own identity and possibly make other structure less relevant???

It’s always undermining out of disagreement.

erm, what the sigma?