วีดีโอ

Great collection of edge cases

The city is the ultimate test. If it can do that well it is robo taxi ready.

Good test. Maybe speed up or edit out the long uneventful highway parts. Part of what you are suggesting is that it knows specific locations rather than a purely general ability and I think that can actually work but they might already more or less be doing that if part of its input is the GPS location. A neural net can do a blend of general and local ability. But the more specialized knowledge the more they might have to manually make decisions for every special location in the world. And they are sort of doing that. Chuck's turn has a series of similar turns along that highway and they have started running cars through all those locations many times. For years basically.

12.5 pls

10:10 wow. I did not see that coming. You did not see that coming either. I am impressed.

it got scared in the end?

Hello why do you move right to left? is that standard practice. I was asked to do a riser diagram and I had no clue where to start.

I experienced the similar issue, in my case, the road divider is a 6 inch high and in white color, FSD seems think it is just a white solid line, and run straight into it.

WOW!

Thank you for sharing this valuable information. I noticed that you weren’t reporting your findings to Tesla after the disengagements by pressing the right button on the steering wheel and saying what the car did wrong. It seems that the issues may get resolved quicker if this feature is utilized more often. In any event, I enjoyed this video and your descriptions of the issues.

Good tests at the end, you can probably skip the highway parts because it's not v12 anyway and typically uneventful.

여러번 개입이 있었나요?

등들을 신호등으로 착각 안하나요? 이젠? 그리고 신호등 빨간신호등 점멸등 어떻게 됐나요?

Very cool future is here I will buy a tesla tomorrow after watching this.

That ending was scary!

You're not showing the display so how do we know that you're in FSD?

FSD has problems in NYC at night: 2:45 FSD has missed an easy right turn (for a human) 13:35 FSD stalled on right turn, Human must intervene 14:50 FSD totally fails at a blocked road. Human *must* intervene FSD cannot anticipate how many other cars are around it, and then take action *earlier* . FSD cannot go in reverse, that is a big problem.

14:20 FSD was about to drive off a 7-inch high curb. Human must intervene. FSD cannot recognize a very steep curb. Louis says that is a very dangerous situation.

Even getting as far as it did is really impressive. I can’t even drive well in a lot of NYC. Times Square is another level with the amount of pedestrians there.

make a document where fsd could not handle well .and list them to docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1wlN0hqmFRp_ZRZNWrqfZMP--OV4u083hmXI_0mGUUJg/edit?usp=sharing

I cannot see the high curb on the video either. So you would probably need stereo vision for that. Cameras could provide stereo images, but this might be an edge case. Not sure how you see it. Do you really see it or just know it is there? Oh, and last column situation seemed fine on the video. Watching it calmly from my seat, I say it would make it!. :)

let me test it out in Chinatown too.

more video every day

more video 99$\month

Do you have it on chill, average or assertive? Your complaints so far in the video (missing lane changes, too slow at going when it's clear etc.) could maybe be fixed by switching to average or assertive. Please always mention that in the start of the video and don't cut the boring parts, just speed them up. Thanks !

Thank you for this, queens has some of the weirdest and complicated intersections and I’m glad to see it put through its paces here and not on car friendly cities like SF and LA

Tesla amazing tech…I am blown away

People are doing at FSD all wrong. Most people are assuming they are better drivers than FSD , the truth is, most are not. Listen to a lot of the critique, it’s all about why isn’t FSD speeding or it needs to follow car in front closer etc. It’s already better than 99 percent drivers

fantastic! it’s tough situation to fsd，and it did great

Night time, rainy, and in Times Square. Possibly the most challenging scenario, pleasantly surprised tbh

I noticed that there are several traces of editing in the video. Could it be that FSD encountered difficulties during driving and could not continue driving, and then did you take over? And then you edited out this part of the takeover?

A mezing nice towns

gotta have balls to test it out in nyc

pretty good

MOST PEOPLE DON'T... ...make turns a second or two after the red. I can"t speak for NY drivers but most London (UK) don't. Not even Swansea, a smaller but more vicious UK city for driving. It is not just a case of Tesla following the law, driving through red traffic lights is *moronic* and choosing to put others at risk. Sorry, but needs saying.

This is the type of fsd video we want to see, not the same bs fsd driving on a cookie cutter suburban road with no one around. Keep making those videos in nyc, but why the cliff hanger, did fsd stop?

Please do more test in NYC

Impressive!

Wow, it's more comfy around those bikes than I would be! But I saw that bus lane 😏

Yikes

Uh, it's a more than a little confusing EVERYWHERE in this clip 😵‍💫

Dude WTF is going on over there?? NYC is a certified madhouse! =0

It malfunctioned at the end. It should not have stopped for a pedestrian J walking. And then it stalled and I assume the driver had to intervene. It’s cool technology. But not worth $200/mo. And it’s far from ready for robo taxi.

💞Wow💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💛

It's like chatgpt 3, surprises everyone, soon after we got gpt 4 which is a much better model, the same thing will happen with fsd, it will progress aggressively, fsd 12.4 will be much better than 12.3.3. that's why elon is confident on model 2 fully autonomous. We are lucky to live in a generation having these kinds of innovations.

A high school kid could have drove this route, easily. FSD still has a long ways to go.

Still multiple disengagements needed. Wow. Maybe v12.4 will offer some real improvements?

Robotaxis should come in a year or 2 from the looks of this progress. Amazing tech.

I am new to FSD with the free trial. Perhaps previous users of version 11 see how much it’s improved, but I see that it’s not there yet. Until I feel comfortable closing my eyes while the car drives, I’m not ready to buy it. While I’m happy to trial it, I think Tesla should’ve waited for more refined version before releasing it generally.

I am impressed how quiet the cabin of the Tesla is. I am familiar with the areas you drove on, all loud and noisy.