วีดีโอ

This catastrophe has been going on for to long, i do believe that it will come to an end when the racist ideology of Zionism no longer exists, period.

Love what these guys are doing ✊

USA was better at killing the natives so they din't have the same issue? Nope. There IS definitely a current segregation of the indigenous peoples of America, so is there in Canada. It is NOT a gone issue. The difference is that the power imbalance between the groups are vastly different. Indigenous people in North America have next to nothing, and a fair size of their small numbers live in the streets of the big cities, and are often seen as alcoholic, lazy, etc. Which is wrong. I am Canadian.

Ireland is jealous of israel. The Israeli's even speak their own language, unlike the Irish. 🇮🇱🇮🇪

Thank you for this discussion . It was good to see the type of person trying to tug on the DC steering wheel … That is - idealistic with a functioning moral compass , but measured and comfortable With compromise . But . I wanted the gloves to come off - this seemed like a conversation straining to be polite and inoffensive . The reality in the world today IS offensive , and the US role in that is doubly offensive , especially to a US citizen that feels responsible. It felt like too much was left unsaid here in the interest of tact .

✊ It’s OUR Job to DEMAND ARMS EMBARGO NOW! 🪖💰💥

Genocide just expanded to the West Bank as of last night 👀

Decolonize Your Mind 🔞Stop voting. Completely de-register as a voter. ❌Stop using a colonial title to your body. ⭕Stop saying that you belong to/on a so-called sovereign state. ✅Go for the no cult state solution. Remember that a statement of sovereignty is not secular. ✡Is the Israeli shekel legal tender in Palestine? ℹPublish, MONOPOLY = SLAVERY, on so-called sovereign monopoly money. 🟢End Global Apartheid

Be real on Palestine. This is pap talk. You'll never get change that way.

Free Palestine

Nonsense. just talk.

Gives me some confidence that my very simple, naive solution to ‘peace in the Middle East’ has turned out to be the same as US insiders and Palestinian diplomats. Just enforce the law. To the letter. It’s the opposite of complicated.

i have the same crabapple poster in my classroom 🥲 #fuckfascism #solidarityforever #freepalestine

Thank you ❤

In some jurisdictions it is a defence to the charge of murder that the person was provoked. Commonly known in the past as 'battered wife syndrome' (yikes) more known now as the defence of provocation. Some people try and use it as the gay/trans panic defence but in my situation i apply it to people who grew up in in a giant concentration camp. Even Nurit Peled Elhanan whose daughter was killed in a suicide bombing agrees - the responsibility lies at the feet of the occupation. I stand with Norman Finkelstein on this, especially given the level of atrocity propaganda that was used that we now know.

Same thing happened to some italian and greek immigrants in Australia. To avoid racism, became racist towards anyone else from the Mediterranean all because of not being the 'right kind of white' like how mizrahim arent the 'right kind of jewish' for the zioniat state

Rape denial on the part of two women, one of whom is an apologist for the regime in Tehran. The message is clear: believe women who claim to have been raped - unless they happen to be Jewish women. Disgusting.

The American presence in the region can only act as an accelerent for conflict. Underwriting the security of a failing Jewish state in the holy land is exactly what George Washington meant by foreign entanglements to avoid

These communities are clearing using a tribal model in their communities which sets the rules and dispenses punishment at the direct discretion of “community leaders aka “tribal elders” Just look up middle eastern tribal system and it breaks down exactly how this works - The police aren’t challenging it, because there is absolutely no working model that allows a state or outside institution to oversee the tribal model ! These are things that should have been taken in to account when taking in refugees! These structures are not compatible with western state model , this is why you most definitely have two teir policing- they will never ever admit to it though because that means they need to fix it and there is no solution they can employ for this, Hense why they allow it to continue operating

Very commendable. He is the kind of true American that I respect and admire.

To say the Israelis had no plan in November is probably incorrect. As in the past, Palestinian terrorism was used as the basis to build new settlements or advance other objectives. 10-7 was on a scale that allowed establishing "greater Israel". Something that could not be acknowledged. The horror of the world slowed it down. A ceasefire could not be easily broken and with the Americans talking about an agreement, "greater Israel" would be put at risk.... again, motive to be kept secret. If Hamas was indeed destroyed the "security" deception would be countered. Claiming "again, again, and again" served to keep the "existential threat" alive. As if a future letting of the guard down could happen. Tunnels are defensive positions, as are schools and hospitals, not existential threats.

What a pleasure to hear this young man not only accept responsibility for US past actions, but to give an insightful and rational explanation of what could be a much better approach. I am more than aghast at Biden's enabling of a right wing Israeli government's brutal and continuing rampage.

Hamas themselves have repeatedly denied targeting civilians on October 7th and evidence coming out since has supported that. We need a full independent inquiry, which Israel is blocking, but just based on the evidence we have, Hamas’ claim is plausible enough to be considered and many of Israel’s claims have been disproven.

Peter Beinart is an enemy of the Jewish People

I lost ahmed when said Hamas resorted to terrorism. I don't think Hamas ever offered a peace agreement, or any sort of long term cooporation plane. Neither did the plo. So it did not resort to terrorism, it chose nothing else, building infrastructure for decades designed to start a war and end jewish existence in the levant.

So, the number of dead Israeli civilians has fallen from 1,200 to 800. How many of those civilians were victims of the Hannibal Directive ? How many were reservists, albeit in civilian clothes ? It is the case that every Israeli over 18 has to perform military service, men & women. Perhaps Hamas should have waited for "civilians" to don a uniform & pick up a weapon ? The fog of war or deliberate action ?

Wow, he comes right out of the box with 2 huge fallacies. 1. The conflict is unique. It’s a conflict involving religious holy land, some claimed by both. 2. Its coverage inversely outsizes that of other conflcits compared to the land involved and population; 3. The UN was instrumental in the creation of the initial boundaries; 4. The conflict began in earnest ever since the UN created Israel. Next your wrong about Hamas. The argument that Hamas uses terrorism as a tool and thus they are not inherently “evil” is as odd as it is a misstatement of the issue. Terrorism is a tool of force implemented by killing your opponent without a definable set of rules. Terrorism is abhorrent to a civilized society. Civilization has slowly refined itself over the centuries in many ways. One of which is to resolve conflict between humans without force by using the adherence to rules. Bluntly, terrorism is getting your way through murder, the ultimate price. Terrorism, in my opinion, is also uncivilized, as it kills through betrayal and deceit. It takes advantage of civilization by pretending to be part of it to disguise itself and then kill. Terrorism also preys upon the innocent including those it claims to be fighting for. How could anyone accept a terroristic group into civilization by this method. Are we to accept terrorism as just another tool of warfare? The people who speak so highly of Hamas have also used the claim of war crime against others. Even in civilization up to this point war happens. But even in that awful act rules are set up. Geneva conventions. Terrorists abide by no set of rules, not even Geneva conventions. Nothing. I would have a more open ear towards their goals if they weren’t terrorists. And even tho they are terrorists, I still think about the abstract principles of the right and wrong the underpins their fight. But I cannot nor will I ever support a group who lacks basic civility. Who is so selfish as to put their wants above societies basic norms. Killing, kidnapping and other atrocities because a group is upset they aren’t getting their way is a disgusting display of inhumanity.

I read this book, and the story is heart wrenching. This video does a much better job at explaining the purpose of the book than the book did. I feel for Abed. Here is my review of the book. I wish I had watched this video before I read the book though. th-cam.com/video/YPze5rUlL44/w-d-xo.htmlsi=oOenoXTkw3VBzqqH

A really critical discussion. Thank you!

Very boring and unproductive interview, why not bring a real Gazan, this outsiders opinion means nothing to Gazans or Israelis.

Thank you for introducing me to Ahmed Moor, this interview was powerful. His argument to de-exceptionalize the conflict is so important, and I haven’t heard it explained this clearly and persuasively by anyone before. His ability to critically examine the most difficult questions, while resisting the temptation to dehumanize is monumental. It gives me hope in these horrendous times.

The President of the US and his Republican opponent are both racist. Shame😢

My father's mother was Jewish! But I was not circumcised and was baptized as a child! I am anti-Zionist! And I don't really like Judaism because they call themselves the chosen people which sounds to me very racist! But Zionism is basically chosen people by race which is a massive problem! And I had a few Jewish friends growing up but they seem to really love themselves! And I just didn't like it! I'm a Christian anyway!

Thanks Peter. It is important to learn more about the thinking that has led our US government down a path that has turned out to be so historically horrific. You were so apt in your questioning and responding questions. One can only hope some light has been shed.

What a great webinar. It is now mid July 2024, but I got so much out of this discussion that still rings true. President Biden has been so good on most other issues, but he has truly an uncritical, underdeveloped, and enabling view of what is truly going on in Gaza. It makes me wonder, when he says he's a Zionist, if he backs the extreme right wing Israeli government's goal of taking over all of the Palestinian lands for a "Greater Israel," not unlike a "Greater Serbia" many years ago. He seems totally blind to the two million Gazans who inhabit the land and are trapped in a bomb pit with nowhere to go.

In the beginning of this conversation as Israeli I really hoped to hear some things that make sense and after 10 minutes of watching I could hear same propaganda again. Waste of time.

THIS SHOULD HAVE BEEN ENTITLED: "THE CORE LIES ABOUT PALESTINE-ISRAEL"

NOT WORTH LISTENING TO THESE REVISIONIST LIARS. EVERYTHING IS CONCOCTED WITH SMUTTERINGS OF TRUTHS TO CONVINCE YOU.

When the Palestinian man says Hamas are not terrorists and just want land etc and mentions their 2017 charter, isn't that charter the one that calls for the destruction of all Jews???

I have heard about this persons brave, passionate activism from another channel I follow. Thank you for highlighting her story on this podcast.

Every new story I hear galvanizes my understanding of the hard lives the Israeli government imposes undeservingly upon the Palestinian people. So thank you for presenting this heart wrenching story. I am trying to learn as much as I can to counter the narrative that is told by the western media in order to dehumanize the people who Israel oppresses.

There doesn't seem a Palestinian appreciation for the power of narrative. For example Tlaib, in a unique position to understand, let it stand that the Palestinian motive was annihilation.... with the silent OK of other elites.... wounding the aspirations of the Palestinian people.

Add it to the other magnificent contributions of Palestinians to world culture: Yasser Arafat and Bella Hadid.

Excellent , Intelligent discussion .🙏 Both of you possess great understanding of the dynamics and political realities , combined with balance , compassion , and a desire for solution . Unfortunately too rare in public and media voices . Thank you !

Lie at 5:18. Israel has affirmative action for Arabs, and education is not segregated.

It is NOT a secret of the nature of Arabian PeninsulaArab patrimony rooted colonial settlers invasion of North Africa and Southwest Asia -Mideast nations. You guys are so ridiculous ostentatious flamboyant ostentatious and condescending pretentious. Amazing individual persons who are purely racist kkkkansmen.

This is very informative analysis thank you both for providing perspective to your viewers..

The USAmerican Federal government, the people and country, did NOT kill all of the native indigenous peoples. Millions are very alike. Navajo code talkers helped defeat The Empire of Japan of The Second World War WW-2. Furthermore, plenty of Native indigenous peoples of North America and South America, identify with Israel. Arabist empire colonial settlers are NOT native indigenous people of Zion Judaean Hebrew Israel. PalestineArabs are NOT native indigenous people of Zion Judaean Hebrew Israel. Jewish Judaeaic Judaean Judahite people are native indigenous people of Zion Judaean Hebrew Israel.. Genetics 🧬, prooves that Zion Judaean Hebrew Israel is NOT separate from Jewish people of Judaea. PalestineArabs are on balance, a plurality of Arabian PeninsulaArab patrimony. That does NOT mean that PalestineArabs are totally separate from Zion Judaean Hebrew Israel However, the distinct margin of difference, defines the plurality of PalestineArab genetics 🧬,vas Arabian PeninsulaArab patrimony. Your Hanan Ashwari or how ever she pells her name, she is a racist. It is really amazing that you still regard her as legitimate. That's precious. You are NOT serious. Your only hope is dissidents against the totality of PalestineArab kkkkansmen. You are lucky I am NOT the Israeli prime minister. You are NOT serious. You are racist.

Quite helpful for American perspectives

You have a whole bunch of nerve, talking about genocide. Your PalestineArab kkkkansmens' manifesto, is The Palestine Liberation Organization Charter-PLO Covenant. That PLO Covenant, The Palestine Liberation Organization Charter, says PalestineArabs are NOT separate from The Arab Nation. That includes the totality of all Arab peoples. That Arab Nation, includes the totality of all Arab peoples. That makes all Arab peoples, part of one Arab Nation. Furthermore, The Palestine Liberation Organization Charter-PLO Covenant says PalestineArabs are The Vanguard of Arabist activism. That makes PalestineArab activism, the vanguard of Arabist empire colonial settler occupation over North Africa and Southwest Asia -Mideast nations. That is manifest in the Arabist empire, current slavery over North Africa. That goes hand in hand with The PalestineArab vanguard of Arabist empire gassing of The Kurdistanis under Arabism's imperial occupation. That goes hand in hand with The PalestineArab vanguard of Arabist empire colonial settler destruction of native indigenous Maronite Lebanese. You should know that AramoCanaanite language, includes Aramaic and Canaanite. Canaanite includes Judaeao-Canaanite Hebrew and Phonecian Punic Lebonese Canaanite. Maronites still use Aramaic for Maronite Lebanese cultural purposes. That's just scratching the surface.