วีดีโอ

okay i swear like im being mandela effected with the way people talk about this move. because i was in medium roll and i remember this attack being fast sure but completely possible and consistent to dodge on launch. am i just misremembering? i thought you just had to input the roll at the earliest possible buffer window.

“Join the Serpent King, as family... Together, we will devour the very gods!” - Rykard, Lord of Blasphemy I have to give this some credit though this line was awesome in the way he delivered it I know this boss is kind of not worth it to some people because it's such a gimmick fight but in my mind it sticks out the most it was I think my favorite.

I didn't hear you mentioned dark eater Mideir, however it's spelled anyways my favorite dragon fight of all time.

I hate slave knight Gael so bad I love fighting him lol every time I have to fight him and doesn't times to beat him and then I don't go back to the game for a few months but when I come back it always takes me but a dozen times to get him figured out again lol I love it and hate it

I don't know or care what is better than what ...but, I like dark souls much better than elded ring and I really like Elden ring, it's really fun, Good game. But I really really love dark souls dark souls 2 and dark souls 3, a lot.

3:09 im sorry godrick scored the highest? I havnt watched the whole video yet, but this is seriously dumb imo. Radahn imo scored much better in all of your categories than mfing godrick. For me godricks design and moveset are both good but too easy to be 10/10. Music was forgettable to me but thays just an elden ring problem imo. Arena is cool so i can agree wjth that ranking and once again fun to master imo is too high because godrick is just simply too easy. Imo easy bosses arent fun to master since i can master them with low effort Onto spells. In all of your clips you heavily abused comet azur. Yes that spell is too broken but you do not have to use it. I think it's great to give options to worse players. Most of the magic in er is diverse and not super borken. Compared to dark souls 3, i think its magic is too boring. Pyromancy is cool tho. Last thing. I largely agree with your take on replayability. Elden rings replayability is tarnished (hehe) largely because majority of thr loot is useless and the map is so large remembering where everything you want is impossible. However, going into the game with a specific build/playstyle in mind and boss rushing i found the game to be very fun. Not wasting my time with a dungeon that gives me a talisman that ill never use made the boss rush more enjoyable as it also allowed for me to not be overlvled for the encounters. Ds3 overall has such amazing replayability at the start and end always a joy to go through. Though imo there is a slog with the tree, deacons, crystal sage and wolnir becausw imo theyre straight up boring.

Man, I had already broken the "like" button after the "bosses" segment, but I can't stress enough how right you are about the tone downgrade! After finishing Elden Ring, I was surprised at how shallow it felt compared to any Dark Souls game. One of the major problems, I think, is Elden Ring's tone and atmosphere. Despite being significantly older, Dark Souls 3 still manages to deliver amazing, rich visuals and a dark atmosphere, whereas Elden Ring feels, well, shallow...

7:32 ulcerated tree spirit from Elden Ring.

Why do monsters in Elden ring have to follow rules? That’s dumb they’re not professional wrestlers they’re monsters they can do what they want

Elden ring doesn’t mean old that’d be olden ring

Tonality? Just say atmosphere. Tonality is a dumb word

To be honest everything since DS3 and above felt like a drag to me. I come from classic DS1/2 where movesets and bosses are too easy by today's standard, no complex varying movesets, ultra aggressive enemies, etc. I have failed to feel like I actually learned a boss in DS3. I still cannot like it for my taste. I might end up finishing a boss after dying for 20-50 times and sometimes less, but I feel like I never understood the logic of the complicated movesets. DS1/2 movesets will seem very basic and boring by todays standard, yes I get it. Anyway,. because this kind of epic fights was moved to Elden Ring (but I agree with you, they are much better designed and more memorable in DS3, regardless I fail to enjoy them personally), I thought I'd have a hard time, but because exploring around makes you OP and you can summon spirit ashes and I didn't even use magic not know exploits but a basic good bleed weapon, I have a much better fun time with ER than DS3. But at the same time I don't feel like I ever learned the movesets of the bosses when I spam spirit ashes and maybe find a window of opportunity to jump attack and then mash attack and stagger the boss when he is distracted by the ashes. I am progressing well, I don't have rage-quit fests as with DS3, but the fact remains the same for both games. I don't feel like I learned much about how to properly dance around their attacks, and I don't feel I am making progress and I also don't enjoy this. I liked DS1/2 more because of their world and exploration and while they also used to consider hard, at this point they look much easier and cosy experiences than DS3. I thought after dying 20 times you should be able to anticipate the proper times to roll and heal or attack in these games but it never happened in DS3 for me while in ER the exploits made me actually skip this lesson :(

Melee way more fun. I don’t use spells for elden ring. Except the one that cures scarlet rot. I don’t really use the horse for battle very much either.

Elden ring is about the elites versus everyone else aka the tarnished deplorables. The golden lords that are soooooo much better than everyone else. The elites, who are actually a bunch of inbred, satanic, heathens. You can basically say it’s about whatever you want because it’s so vague.

Why do you have to compare to ds3? I loved Dark Souls 1, I played it in 2019 instead of its successors for a reason. The games are all getting way too fast.

I came to realize that Elden Ring's boss fights are the way they are because the game gives you a much, much broader range of options to fight bosses. Also Elden Beast is meant to be fought with Torrent! You can actually summon him and are supposed to!

To me it’s literally just a vibe thing I mean I’m sure I could find some mechanical reasons I like it more but I just live ds3’s vide the desolate thing appeals to me more

You really never played elden ring to say such stupid things

My Boss Design Rank 1. Move Set & Phases 2. Hitboxes 3. Camera 4. Character Design & Lore 5. Arena 6. OST 7. Cinematics

I've spent 300+ hours in Elden Ring. Elden Ring has cooler weapons, armor set and I think better PvE combat overall, but that's it. The open world sucks, the architecture of castles, churches, etc., so much less ornate and atmospheric, the environment doesn’t foster interest in the setting or lore. It's exuausting. I end up aggressively disliking it after playing a while. I was thoroughly enjoying the DLC, but by the end of it I just feel annoyed. NG+ feels purposeless

How do you feel about Shadow of the Erdtree now that it’s out? I felt like the DLC was more similar to dark souls in a lot of ways.

I strongly agree about the Darker tone a few sections of bloodborne and dark souls 3 were pretty creepy and scary to me lol

Great review. But the point-system, even though you calculsted sth together, still is subjektive. To me, there are a lot of great bosses in DS3. Sully, Friede, Gael, Midir, Soul, Champion and even Amour. Bit except of Abyss Watchers, the first 2/3 od bosses of the game are just bland. Tree, this teleporting sorceress whichs name i even forgot, yhorm, deakons etcetc. Beat everything except pontiff, friede, nameless, gael, midir and twin princess in 1st or 2nd try. I was glad that ER hat a spike and I loved the arenas and music of so many ER bosses and would rate maliketh, godwyn and many more a 38/40. Also i loved the tone of ER at least the same as DS. Coherent and beautiful approach to me. Great work with colours. But great video and lots of valid points.

6:53 I think the reason why Elden Ring was more successful than Dark Souls is because of the lacking Scare element. so a lot of gamers started their souls journey thru Elden Ring it's more of a fantasy rpg. so let's thank Elden for getting more people to the Soulsborne Genre

Your subjective view on rankings is not proof of anything. I'd understand if you did a poll, but your flawed system proves nothing as you already have a biased opinion

Elden ring, blood borne, ds1, ds2, demon souls > ds3 If i have to be honest which one i enjoy the most

ur best boss is godrick lmao yikes

What a dogshit video. That point system is so fk opinionated it’s insane.

My biggest gripe with Elden Ring is the open world. It was not made better by the open world, and a lot of problems come with it. I was surprised when you said that it was the best open world you’ve played because the only thing I can say positively about it is that it’s pretty. But all of From’s games are pretty. The open world is so empty and unsatisfying. Some of the best open world games have side quest, endless activities to do, and plenty of hubs but that just isn’t the kind of game Elden Ring is. Open world also lets you skip through any encounter that is too tough, there’s no more overcoming challenges and feeling satisfied unless you opt in to that challenge. What the hell is the point of going anywhere I can see out in the distance if all I get out of looking in every corner 90% of the time is some crafting item I won’t use or some upgrade material that I could just buy at the twin maidens. No more open world Fromsoft games please, these games were just fine as inter-connected levels

Well put - i use to have a sword and a shield and i cut my way through with them, but in Elden Ring, the shield is not as good unless you have a huge shield which it will slow your moves

Update: Consert Radhan is the biggest BS in the franchise

The DLC for Elden Ring breaks all of the Souls combat rules. I love the game but it ain't DS3!

Remnant 2 bosses are so much more fun than any bosses from these souls games.

I agree that DS3 is better. Even now, side by side, id mich rather be playing DS3 and i do. Im not alone either, tons of other players and pvp to enjoy. I keep trying to enjoy Elden Ring but it feels so boring and slow and lacks direction. It literally puts me to sleep. DS3 is much more fun and engaging and WAYWAYWAYWAY WAAAAAAY leas tedious. Elden Ring feels like chores compared to DS3.

Darksouls 3 is the best game ever

18:00 Beast Clericman

What ever FromSoft is cooking up next, I do hope it is going to be smaller scale.

Nice dodge i never figuired it out i dodge the first tanks the second dodge the 3rd

The armor drip in DS3 is so much better. Everyone in Elden Ring looks frumpy and homeless. All the knight helmets seem to have giant hood ornaments and the pieces all clash with one another. It’s hard to put an outfit together that’s cool and unique.

Bro doesn't know the difference between a read and a reaction

It’s very sad coming back to this video after the elden ring dlc and seeing that fromsoft did not take anyone’s complaints into consideration and tripled down on the bad aspects of the game

Lies of p imo is the closest to ds3

They fixed most these issue in SOE but the bosses are still not on par

I don't need PVP it's a stupid concept in general, should be removed, ruins the PVE!

sekiro is garbage

“Hopefully the dlc will improve the replay-ability” proceeds to drop the least replay-able souls dlc of all time. I was hoping the dlc would level ER with ds3 or even ds1, but the dlc was so ass that I might even take ds2 over ER. Still a great game, but it’s no dark souls

hey man, just watched ur elden ring vs dark souls 3 video and im completely w u on all aspects of ur opinion, curious to ask but whatd u think of the dlc so far compared to the base game? how would u compare it to dark souls? honestly imo i feel like the dlc does drastically way better than the base game

Elden ring gets boring i can replay ds3 100 times but i get bored playing 1 hour of elden ring

In my opinion it’s the worst FromSoft souls game. The levels are so easy to simply just run through and is essentially an extremely linear boss rush which Dark Souls 1 and Dark Souls 2 were nothing at all. The game is a reflex test all about abusing s and mashing R1. Magic, faith, and pyro builds have all been extremely gimped from their prime in Dark Souls 1 or 2. Seriously offensive miracles are so bad and pyro is so bad until almost 2/3rds of the game. There is really only one way to play by using sharp infusions quick weapons because there’s no poise and just hyperarmor so it just becomes a R1 mash fest. Shields are also useless since any attack drains your shield so easily and lets you become guard broken in just 2-3 hits. Seriously shields are at their worst ever in Dark Souls 3. The bosses are the only thing this game has going for it and so many of them are easily parryable. On top of that the game is a very grey mess which hates any other color but grey. This game is nothing but Bloodborne with Dark Souls 1 characters. So disappointed but not surprising since this game was only released in one year after Bloodborne. The least replayable souls game sadly