- 385
- 526 124
Troubadour Channel
United States
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 28 เม.ย. 2012
Elevate your life and understanding of the world through art in all its forms.
Defending Free Speech: Professor Tara Smith on the First Amendment and Intellectual Freedom
Join us for an enlightening conversation with Professor Tara Smith, a University of Texas philosopher and an expert on Ayn Rand’s Objectivism, as we delve deep into the First Amendment and the imperative of intellectual freedom.
You can buy Tara's book, which includes essays and contributions by Onkar Ghate, Greg Salmieri, and Elan. Journo a.co/d/0GdyqOU
Tara Smith is a Professor of Philosophy at the University of Texas at Austin. Specializing in moral, legal, and political philosophy, she is a prominent scholar on Ayn Rand’s Objectivism. Her latest book, The First Amendment: Essays on the Imperative of Intellectual Freedom, explores the critical importance of free speech and intellectual freedom in today’s society.
🔔 Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more in-depth interviews and discussions!
0:00 Introduction and Tara Smith’s Journey
10:16 Debunking First Amendment Misconceptions
25:02 The Imperative of Intellectual Freedom
35:00 Critiquing John Stuart Mill’s View on Free Speech
41:42 Religion’s Role in the First Amendment
49:04 The Problem with Religious Exemptions
57:04 Modern Challenges: Social Media, Cancel Culture, Academia
1:07:04 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
---
RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THE VIDEO:
The Great Courses Course: “Freedom of Speech: Understanding the First Amendment”
• Description: A comprehensive lecture series that explores the history, principles, and legal cases shaping the First Amendment and free speech in the United States.
• Instructor: Professor John E. Finn, Wesleyan University
Tara Smith’s Other Books:
• “Judicial Review in an Objective Legal System”
• Description: Tara Smith examines how judges should interpret and apply laws within an objective legal framework, advocating for principles that uphold individual rights and the rule of law.
• “Ayn Rand’s Normative Ethics: The Virtuous Egoist”
• Description: This book delves into Ayn Rand’s ethical philosophy of rational egoism, exploring the virtues that support human flourishing and a moral life.
• “Viable Values: A Study of Life as the Root and Reward of Morality”
• Description: Smith provides an analysis of the foundation of values and morality from an Objectivist perspective, emphasizing life as the standard of value.
FIRE’s “So to Speak” Podcast Episode with Tara Smith
• Description: In this interview, Tara Smith discusses the importance of free speech, intellectual freedom, and the challenges they face in contemporary society.
John Stuart Mill’s “On Liberty”
• Description: A seminal work advocating for the protection of individual freedoms and expression, discussing the limits of authority over the individual.
John Milton’s “Areopagitica”
• Description: A historic pamphlet arguing against censorship and advocating for the freedom of the press, written in 1644.
Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE)
• Description: An organization dedicated to defending and sustaining the individual rights of all Americans to free speech and free thought.
Third Thursday Events in Austin
• Description: Monthly gatherings in Austin where discussions on philosophy, literature, and Objectivism take place, fostering intellectual engagement.
• Note: Specific details may vary; check local listings or community groups for more information.
Literary Canon Club
• Description: A group focused on reading and discussing significant works of Western literature, emphasizing the importance of understanding diverse philosophies and historical contexts.
Tara Smith’s New Paper on Misinformation
• Title: “Freedom of the Press in an Era of Misinformation - Cognitive Problems, Legal Solutions”
• Published In: Social Theory and Practice (October Edition)
• Description: Smith explores the challenges of misinformation in the context of free speech and argues against government regulation as a solution.
• Access: Available through academic journals or university libraries.
www.pdcnet.org/soctheory/onlinefirst
The Podcast “So to Speak: The Free Speech Podcast” by FIRE
• Description: A podcast series that covers free speech issues, featuring interviews with experts, case analyses, and discussions on current events.
You can buy Tara's book, which includes essays and contributions by Onkar Ghate, Greg Salmieri, and Elan. Journo a.co/d/0GdyqOU
Tara Smith is a Professor of Philosophy at the University of Texas at Austin. Specializing in moral, legal, and political philosophy, she is a prominent scholar on Ayn Rand’s Objectivism. Her latest book, The First Amendment: Essays on the Imperative of Intellectual Freedom, explores the critical importance of free speech and intellectual freedom in today’s society.
🔔 Don’t forget to like, share, and subscribe for more in-depth interviews and discussions!
0:00 Introduction and Tara Smith’s Journey
10:16 Debunking First Amendment Misconceptions
25:02 The Imperative of Intellectual Freedom
35:00 Critiquing John Stuart Mill’s View on Free Speech
41:42 Religion’s Role in the First Amendment
49:04 The Problem with Religious Exemptions
57:04 Modern Challenges: Social Media, Cancel Culture, Academia
1:07:04 Conclusion and Final Thoughts
---
RESOURCES MENTIONED IN THE VIDEO:
The Great Courses Course: “Freedom of Speech: Understanding the First Amendment”
• Description: A comprehensive lecture series that explores the history, principles, and legal cases shaping the First Amendment and free speech in the United States.
• Instructor: Professor John E. Finn, Wesleyan University
Tara Smith’s Other Books:
• “Judicial Review in an Objective Legal System”
• Description: Tara Smith examines how judges should interpret and apply laws within an objective legal framework, advocating for principles that uphold individual rights and the rule of law.
• “Ayn Rand’s Normative Ethics: The Virtuous Egoist”
• Description: This book delves into Ayn Rand’s ethical philosophy of rational egoism, exploring the virtues that support human flourishing and a moral life.
• “Viable Values: A Study of Life as the Root and Reward of Morality”
• Description: Smith provides an analysis of the foundation of values and morality from an Objectivist perspective, emphasizing life as the standard of value.
FIRE’s “So to Speak” Podcast Episode with Tara Smith
• Description: In this interview, Tara Smith discusses the importance of free speech, intellectual freedom, and the challenges they face in contemporary society.
John Stuart Mill’s “On Liberty”
• Description: A seminal work advocating for the protection of individual freedoms and expression, discussing the limits of authority over the individual.
John Milton’s “Areopagitica”
• Description: A historic pamphlet arguing against censorship and advocating for the freedom of the press, written in 1644.
Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression (FIRE)
• Description: An organization dedicated to defending and sustaining the individual rights of all Americans to free speech and free thought.
Third Thursday Events in Austin
• Description: Monthly gatherings in Austin where discussions on philosophy, literature, and Objectivism take place, fostering intellectual engagement.
• Note: Specific details may vary; check local listings or community groups for more information.
Literary Canon Club
• Description: A group focused on reading and discussing significant works of Western literature, emphasizing the importance of understanding diverse philosophies and historical contexts.
Tara Smith’s New Paper on Misinformation
• Title: “Freedom of the Press in an Era of Misinformation - Cognitive Problems, Legal Solutions”
• Published In: Social Theory and Practice (October Edition)
• Description: Smith explores the challenges of misinformation in the context of free speech and argues against government regulation as a solution.
• Access: Available through academic journals or university libraries.
www.pdcnet.org/soctheory/onlinefirst
The Podcast “So to Speak: The Free Speech Podcast” by FIRE
• Description: A podcast series that covers free speech issues, featuring interviews with experts, case analyses, and discussions on current events.
มุมมอง: 2
วีดีโอ
This WWI Poem Will Change How You See The Iliad
มุมมอง 87814 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Discover how Patrick Shaw-Stewart’s haunting WWI poem, ‘I Saw a Man This Morning,’ redefines our understanding of Homer’s Iliad. Through the lens of war, mortality, and classical education, this analysis connects the trenches of WWI to the timeless struggles of Achilles. Watch now to see why this poem still resonates today 0:00 - Introduction 0:42 - The Poem’s Background 2:30 - First Reading of...
Who Are Our Heroes and Why? W/Poet Kassandra Dick
มุมมอง 142หลายเดือนก่อน
Join us on a literary journey through time as we explore the timeless archetype of the hero. From Achilles to Hamlet, and even modern heroes like Elon Musk and Christopher Reeve, discover what it means to be a hero and why these stories continue to inspire us. Dive into the evolution of heroism across eras and cultures in this thought-provoking discussion. You can purchase Kassandra's Book on A...
Teaching William Blake's 'The Little Black Boy' Across All Age Groups
มุมมอง 38หลายเดือนก่อน
Teaching William Blake's 'The Little Black Boy' Across All Age Groups
Translating Shakespeare's Julius Caesar for a Modern Audience
มุมมอง 1.4K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
Translating Shakespeare's Julius Caesar for a Modern Audience
Creating Austin’s ‘Central Perk’: Building Community through Smart Urban Planning
มุมมอง 5352 หลายเดือนก่อน
Creating Austin’s ‘Central Perk’: Building Community through Smart Urban Planning
William Blake’s ‘The Echoing Green’ Explained: A Teacher’s Guide to Reading and Reflection
มุมมอง 663 หลายเดือนก่อน
William Blake’s ‘The Echoing Green’ Explained: A Teacher’s Guide to Reading and Reflection
From AI to AGI: Revolutionizing Intelligence with Peter Voss
มุมมอง 7063 หลายเดือนก่อน
From AI to AGI: Revolutionizing Intelligence with Peter Voss
Shakespeare No Longer Required in Texas: The Crucial Role of Austin Shakespeare
มุมมอง 6053 หลายเดือนก่อน
Shakespeare No Longer Required in Texas: The Crucial Role of Austin Shakespeare
William Blake’s ‘The Shepherd’ Explained: A Guide for Teachers and Parents
มุมมอง 753 หลายเดือนก่อน
William Blake’s ‘The Shepherd’ Explained: A Guide for Teachers and Parents
The Transformative Power of Shakespeare for Young Minds
มุมมอง 1163 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Transformative Power of Shakespeare for Young Minds
William Blake's Songs of Innocence & Experience Introduction.
มุมมอง 1363 หลายเดือนก่อน
William Blake's Songs of Innocence & Experience Introduction.
Reimagining Comic Books as Literary Art W/Michael Morse
มุมมอง 3.4K3 หลายเดือนก่อน
Reimagining Comic Books as Literary Art W/Michael Morse
Modern Dating Advice for Men Leaves THIS Out?
มุมมอง 913 หลายเดือนก่อน
Modern Dating Advice for Men Leaves THIS Out?
Red Pill Poison: Unpacking the Controversy and Misconceptions
มุมมอง 17K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
Red Pill Poison: Unpacking the Controversy and Misconceptions
Catholicism to Objectivism: Exploring Faith, Cults, and Homeschooling
มุมมอง 1.4K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
Catholicism to Objectivism: Exploring Faith, Cults, and Homeschooling
Stalker's Delight: Does Baby Reindeer condone bad behavior?
มุมมอง 3.4K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Stalker's Delight: Does Baby Reindeer condone bad behavior?
Behind ‘Liar Liar’: Screenwriter Paul Guay on Crafting Classic Films
มุมมอง 1286 หลายเดือนก่อน
Behind ‘Liar Liar’: Screenwriter Paul Guay on Crafting Classic Films
Egoism Without Permission: Tara Smith on Ayn Rand’s Ethics
มุมมอง 26K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Egoism Without Permission: Tara Smith on Ayn Rand’s Ethics
The Realism of Love in Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130
มุมมอง 666 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Realism of Love in Shakespeare’s Sonnet 130
Beyond Netflix: Discovering the Thrill of Live Theatre
มุมมอง 486 หลายเดือนก่อน
Beyond Netflix: Discovering the Thrill of Live Theatre
How Reading Romeo And Juliet Improves Your Romantic Life
มุมมอง 15K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
How Reading Romeo And Juliet Improves Your Romantic Life
Fallout Breakdown: Plot, Characters, and the Big Business Debate!
มุมมอง 5K6 หลายเดือนก่อน
Fallout Breakdown: Plot, Characters, and the Big Business Debate!
Shakespeare Sonnet 94: The Power to Hurt
มุมมอง 837 หลายเดือนก่อน
Shakespeare Sonnet 94: The Power to Hurt
Overcoming Envy and Despair in Shakespeare's Sonnet 29
มุมมอง 337 หลายเดือนก่อน
Overcoming Envy and Despair in Shakespeare's Sonnet 29
Can't believe I haven't read this poem before! I was just *certain* you would read Wilfred Owen
Luke Ranieri over at Polymathy memorized the first 100 lines in ancient Greek; methinks you would like it.
Yes I love the Wilfred Owen poem. I need to do a video on that poem soon. Thanks for watching!
I did understand it as I've read such stories of ancient times for many years...and I heard this poem maybe 30 years ago on a TV program and was much taken by it. But never knew the title or the poet so could never find it. And now...here you are. Thank you ever so much!
I fell in love with this poem after taking some courses on ancient greek literature. This is a very under-appreciated poem of WWI. But it was once quite famous. Thanks for watching!
Here is a great song that gives an account on the campaign from an ANZAC perspective. Really enoyed the video. Made me want to reread them. I enjoyed your translation! th-cam.com/video/PKURhqmSLmM/w-d-xo.htmlsi=zqLnIRMafRYqq7A9
I read the Illiad and the Odyssey (had to look that spelling up thanks to that new website) back in High School in Texas in the mid=90s, actually! I didn't catch the reference because it's been too long. Thanks for clearing it up, love the channel.
Thanks for watching! And glad you liked this poem. I’m glad to hear you read these classics in high school. They weren’t required reading only schools. Also, I went to high school in Texas in the 90s! :)
My advice is to stop reading self help books. It’s 99% garbage.
Fair enough :)
Great interpretation of the lyrics. Thank you. I think it's either a one-night stand or possibly a prostitute. I don't know which, and it doesn't matter. It's a beautiful song.
You're right it doesn't matter and it is a beautiful song! One great thing about me starting this channel is being introduced to great art. Thanks for watching!
Uilleann pipes
Greatest rapper of all time
Tupac is the greatest rapper of all time
Kinda late but I love this reaction/review. Dylan has so many phases where he shares a lot of similarities with old poets. Especially 17th and 18th century. You could do hundreds of videos on him. This song is one of his most beautifully written but in my opinion there are far better songs that stand on their one better without the music. In 1965 he said that words are as important as the music to him, which is something we don’t see these days except maybe in hip-hop. I have a lot of recommendations in mind but the best in my opinion are: Visions of Johanna (credited as the best song ever written) and Desolation Row (incredible surrealism).
I need to continue this series :)
Are you still doing Bob Dylan reactions? If so, you should react to Mr Tambourine Man, Desolation Row and A Hard Rain’s a-gonna fall.
I need to get back into doing these! Thanks for the reminder
Comments are rightfully killing this guy 😂 is this man insane
This guy is the exact opposite of 2pac 😂😂😂😂😂
A thinker?
@TroubadourChannel More like someone self-centered who likes the smell of his own farts
So could you please give us a thesis statement about The Foster mother's tale , what Coleridge was trying to prove to us? what are the main themes in this poem? Thank you for this video , it is really interesting
It was played in the police bar a few times in the series - the wire. They are/were an amazing band. Tommy Makem - Broad majestic Shannon is a marvellous tribute, from a man who influenced Dylan, and also loved the pogues. Ta. ❤️👍🏽👍☘️
He's writing this song for the unborn kids all over the world. Who will be born one day and hear his music like we are doing now. He is still raising kids with his messages who weren't even born when he recorded it
Very true, slang and understanding the lingo is key. But i still enjoy it, especially if i figure out or learn what it means.
I love your video❤❤❤
Thanks!
Listen to the studio version.
Sorry, this message was left with me to pass along to whom it may concern, it reads: Went my own way, not coming back. -Men, Circa 2019-2035.
?
This song is actually autobiographical about his life with his own wife and family.
This bought sorrow and regret to the one I loss before me. However it helped cleanse my heart.
Thanks for the inclusion of my poem and the art from our gallery. So very appreciated!
Fun fact: "Ozymandias" is the hellenised version of "Usermaatre Setepenre", the regnal name of Ramesses II, which was one of the greatest Egyptian pharaohs in history.
I’ve read this poem 100s of times and never knew that!
@@TroubadourChannel glad to inform. It does take away from the mystery of the poem but also adds a lot of context to it.
Any plans for Songs From the Mountaintop to be on Kindle/e-book?
Not at the moment, but I will be recording the individual poems and posting them on TH-cam, so feel free to follow for updates 🎉❤
Thoroughly enjoying this dialogue! Kas, you're so talented and brave xoxoxo
What year was this written? It hardly seems possible that eternity would have been pronounced 'eetrni-tay" to make the rhyme. Is it possible there was a category of slant rhyme so oblique as to include this last line? What can you tell us about the other places in the text where our modern ears expect a rhyme?
It may be an audio quirk. I kind of hear what you’re hearing. But I meant it as a standard pronunciation of “eternity.”
This is mid 19th century. Emily Dickinson
I think....l.The song is about a wake for the deceased Big Jim Dwyer. The cadillac/tinker boys verse tells me the location of the wake is a house in a gritty working class neighborhood in America. Dwyer was a young Irish immigrant who moved to America. He was a proud Irishman, but also proud to be a "free born man of the USA." He was also a virtuous and athletic lad who became a boxer, who got drafted and sent to war, where he was killed. My guess is it was WW1. After the wake, and even though he had become an American,his body is being returned to his beloved homeland....Ireland.
Exactly. Probably a Boston Southie
Kadafi didn't get much credit this homey was ❤ touch
My view on real life, living heroes, is that I don’t really have any who are famous, but I have many heroes who I know on a personal level. My roommate, Kassi here, and while I don’t know him, Yaron Brook. I know Yaron enough to view him as a virtuous hero in his pursuit of happiness and spreading objectivism to the globe. Second, if any of these heroes of mine fall from Grace, I can always remember what they used to be without evading who they are. I can always find new heroes, especially in fiction
Wow, to hear I'm a hero in your eyes means a lot! I will stay virtuous because I believe that despite my mistakes, I can learn and gain values!
Great choices!
Ayyy I had this poem in 8th grade literature. Brings back memories.
It's a great one!
Thats pretty good. Would listen to before bed at that.
Thanks for watching :) I’ll do more of them
❤❤❤❤❤
I suggest his “Every Grain of Sand.”
I’ve reacted to that one. Love it!
Listening to audiobook is great as I work... English is my first language so I'm good 👍
Oh did I say not to listen to audiobooks?
This is true: it's about Suze Rotolo, his first true love, who he met and dated on Fourth Street, where the NY folk community centered. He loved her and in this song dredged up the confusion they both felt right before Suze took a long tour in foreign lands. Jump from this song way back to "Boots of Spanish Leather."
I think the line "one who might move the wise man to that scorn which wisdom holds unlawful, ever." means to say that the person "whose eye is ever on himself" could influence the "wise man" to revert back to not thinking beyond themselves. (BTW thank you for this analysis. I read an excerpt of it in the book "Push" by Sapphire and at first I could not get my head around it. After watching your break down of it, I came to fully understand its meaning.)
❤
:D
I'm really not a fan of making things more accessible so that more people will understand what his plays are about. They are of their time. If you modernise or dumb down the language then they become something different. Just read around them and you may learn something in the process.
Do you think the version I created was “dumbed down?” I agree with what you’re saying. But I believe we can have updated language, since there has been 400 years of language change in English.
So much ... Rimbaud? Crikey mate. AEIOU?
Wilson Susan Garcia Matthew Walker Angela
In the first verse he doesn't realize she is a prostitute. That's the twist. In the second verse he is confused, but he figures it out when they get to the neon hotel. The reality of the situation hits him like a freight train. In the third verse she drops a coin into the cup of "another blind man". He was the first blind man. Now he sees clearly who she is, but he still has feelings for her. I think the whole story is an allegory for his first marriage which is breaking up.
Music should be felt not listened to, Dylan does that.
True
I've come a bit late to this party. Beg pardon. -- However, -- This song is about infidelity (understood from the "feel" of the whole song before beginning the analysis). -- One thing I have learned from a lot of Dylan's "story" songs is that the first verse in kinda the last verse put at the beginning. When you find a first person reference somewhere, as in this one, it probably is a real memory of his. This makes that first verse an introduction to his memory of the whole episode. -- I think he felt he actually made a big mistake, brought on by a Simple Twist of Fate.
Oh! That’s a useful interpretive tool
I like the theory that the 'blue' he's tangled up in is the Joni Mitchell album of that name
I mean, personally, "Distracts with Feminine Wiles" is nod-wink enough to be clear she seduced him and bedded him.
love this
Thanks!
You should do a video on Chum by Earl Sweatshirt
I listened to this on 2X speed it was so slow 😂
You are correct in that :) Thanks for watching. In so many of my earlier videos I think I babbled way too much. I am working on redoing many of them.
Unconditional Love by Tupac That right there is a different kind of song, different side to Pac.