วีดีโอ

Guidance from scholars, which has been unanimously accepted over centuries: If you want to know about someone, ask who their friends are. When you associate with some people, you will be considered one of them. Let no one blame anyone but themselves. All these verbal clarifications means nothing.

How do you know this? State your evidence please

@@akram6505 th-cam.com/video/QDqfTQxybJQ/w-d-xo.html

He took back his comments which he made years ago

@@yomanali2093 evidence?

@@akram6505 th-cam.com/video/QDqfTQxybJQ/w-d-xo.html

Does this “fact check” make any sense? Sayed Hossein Nasr is unapologetic Shia then a staunch perennialist. Debate ends here. There is huge logical fallacy here which you don't realise. If they are not looking for salvation in any religion other than Islam then their books on perennialism is of no use. Is it just for misguidance/confusion or just for paltry dunyawi benefit?. A valid logical question. Isn't it? If your “fact check” is true then the world doesn't need any of their books on perennialism. Let them accept their mistake and remove their works from the market and we will happily welcome them to Ahl Sunnah.

⁠@@mujahidkhalfan5246you are conflating two different things. You are just using some temporary geo-political situation to divert the attention from the original subject. You are putting words in my mouth. I just said he is an unapologetic Shia and nothing more. I want the Sunni people to know that fact, that’s it. Didn’t make any claims about Shia being this or that. On the other hand, you have used abusive language. Just read both messages. There is huge logical fallacy here which you don't realise. If they are not looking for salvation in any religion other than Islam then their books on perennialism is of no use. Is it just for misguidance or just for money. A valid logical question. Isn't it? It is highly recommended in Islam to oppose deviancy, especially perennialism, i.e., acceptance of the validity of any religion other than Islam after the coming of the last and final Prophet SAW. Just search for Schuon’s video online where he says it’s valid and sufficient for people from different ethnicities to continue to worship their “tradional” way, sing their hymns as worship, etc. This is called a verifiable FACT. I will send you the link if you want. No one, No one, orthodox Sunni or Shia has accepted perennialism in the history of Islamic scholarship. It's Kufr to believe in it. Now don’t put words in my mouth, I just said believing this is Kufr and have not made Takfeer of any individual. Hossein Nasr is the spiritual successor of Schuon. Com to your own conclusion. I’m presenting real facts for the guidance and you are using your skewed “facts” in support of things which will lead to deviancy and kufr. You have to bear it on your head on the day of judgment. When the soul gets rusted and corrupted the truth sounds disgusting. Imam Busiri said: when the body is sick pure water tastes bitter. We cannot stop saying the truth because of sick people to appease everyone and grossly abuse the concept of inclusiveness and magnanimity as many western scholars now do. Support inclusiveness with your money and efforts not with Deen and purity of Aqida.

Walaikumasalaam I would recommend reaching out to Dr. Shadee directly or the Safina Society directly

this dude is right because he is a sheikh and is warning us from a book that has perennialist ideas that can lead to kufr.

He's not dead wrong. Perennialism is not Islam. How can Jesus be God and Allah be God and Krishna be God as well as Vishnu? That's Perennialism for you. And that's anti-Islamic. It's very simple.

Perenialist are not associating anyone to God, what are you alking about. You are judging pereniliast today, but the only judge will be Allah. And before the day of Judgement, Issa and the Mahdi will judge your accusation of the perennial view.Adhering to the perenialist view is not necessary for salvation though, and that's why perennialist don't seek to "convert" or impose their doctrine and understanding of Islam

@@inprincipioeratverbum1844 One is not considered a Muslim if they do not believe that Islam is the only path to salvation, that Prophet Muhammad is the final messenger, and that his guidance is the sole way forward. Everything else is meaningless. Imam Mahdi and Isa (peace be upon him) will affirm the same message upon their arrival. These perennialists will go in hiding out of fear when they come.

@@AMANAH456 define Islam? Is every muslim really submitting to God ?

This is misinformation. There is no insult to anyone in this. It’s commendable that Shaykh Shadee said the truth. As for Lies, Slander or Talebearing against Shaykh Nuh’s organization is put out by Fasiqs without proof. In contrast, the authors have put their names on The Study Quran and published it, so it’s not hearsay. It’s shameful to even compare these two. This is the matter of Aqida that is between Kufr and Eman.

Copy right is not an Islamic concept lol

What are you talking about???

Where were you able to get it?

Never can any type of translation reach the level of the Quran in Arabic, if you know Arabic you will know what I'm talking about

@@sup7067 yes arabic quran is the word of Allah. There is no human interpretation. But the translations are human work. So no matter who translate the Arabic quran that can never be as the Arabic quran. But among the English translation the translation but nuh Keller is a good one and the bridges translation is also a good one.

It’s from Zaytuna’s book club videos that Shaykh Hamza does 3 times every month live on zoom. I attended this one.

@@hamzaalikhoso6688 are the recordings available anywhere?

@@thesilentobserver6046 all recordings are available on Zaytuna’s website. TH-cam doesn’t allow posting links so you’ll have to google “zaytuna bookclub”. You’ll need to be a member to access the videos, and you can be a member for free according to Shaykh Hamza if you email zaytuna and request membership. Or if you want to pay and support Zaytuna then the membership starts at $5 a month.

@@hamzaalikhoso6688 JazakAllahu khairan brother

Subhanallah - join the club ! Immensely grateful that I've sat with these giants. Saying Alhmadulillah a million times is not enough to express my shukr to Allah swt for the blessing of these 2 amazing souls 💖

Don’t be a Sufi, be a Muslim which is Quran and sunnah

@@farkhkhan9495 To be a sufi is to try to delve into the depth of Quran and Sunnah

@@farkhkhan9495 you seem to be someone who is highly ignorant

Shaykh Hamza is a shadili as well :)