วีดีโอ

沒調查清楚就來臺灣

我國的國籍可不是出生屬地主義

雙重國籍會帶來很多逆選擇，跟道德性的問題。 我更傾向完善居留證的權利。

如果你真心了解台灣與中國的處境 如果真的開放雙重國籍 那麼在未來你看到的台灣將不再會是台灣😢

對真心喜愛台灣並有實際貢獻的外國人入籍如此刁鑽，但遇到粉紅中配確百般禮遇，還想方設法要讓入籍條件一再簡化，這是何道理🤔

喔! 中華民國國籍是屬人主義，所以小孩國籍是看出生當時父親的國籍。 等哪天那群呆丸郎推翻中華民國建立台灣共和國時，說不定只要高喊著我愛呆丸就能拿到呆丸國的國籍!哈哈!

都已經入籍台灣公民，女兒當然是台灣人！政府不為移民法做有效的改善。天天想選票

如果同時擁有兩個國籍，當國家有難時，你會為哪一個國籍而戰？

#賴清德政府這是不是超級可笑 #立法院的支那國民黨你們看到了嗎不要一直耍白痴當支那共產黨的白手套弄一些政治鬥爭趕快修國籍法

会解決修正不必 煩惱

這才是台灣應該要改進的地方 憑什麼中國人嫁到台灣來六年就能拿到身分證證？ 而且這些中國配偶的婚前子女或家人還可以來台灣，因為他的中國配偶身分

無聊的政府官員，台灣什麼時代，應該要再修改吧！停留在一百年前的古董

請你尊重台灣的法律,你家小孩還小講啥忠誠度,你們這些說法實在令人可疑～～

要入籍台灣就放棄原有國家的國籍,沒毛病阿 不這樣做看不出來你是否珍惜台灣給的資源

有利益😢有忠誠

幸好留言區明事理的人還滿多的～

中資頻道一直洗，很會洗齁？

就是按照法律，該怎麼樣就怎麼樣，沒什麼好需要同情，更不要濫用通融，都不尊重我國的制度了，還想要當公民？

半導體人才邏輯這麼差喔？？各國入籍本來就有各國的規定規則，跟什麼人才沒什麼關係啦，半導體走到現在這個規模這個程度，不會因為少一個人才就有什麼翻天覆地的變化，人才多的是。所以要討論入籍就一碼歸一碼的討論，不用前面冠個什麼人才不人才～

先入籍後，小孩才出生。 那麼小孩會有台灣籍。 若非，一切按照台灣法律。菲律賓不準讓未成年放棄國籍，那麼就等她長大吧！ 身為父親，干涉女兒原有的菲律賓國籍權利，讓她獲取台灣籍的想法很不好。 私心只是要給她雙國籍的身分，但就依法吧！

拿就業金卡不等於放棄原國籍，台灣不接受雙重國籍的。

So glad and relieved to read these comments. Disinformation does not fool wise minds!

full of red necks opportunists! APRC holders want more than just that! first want their kids to have citizenship then thier parents, later want thier entire kin family all to have it. At the end they want their whole mother fxxking country to have citizenship

支持你

我們在國外也尊重他國的法律制度🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

請你尊重我的國家制度😮😮😮😮😮

大家都說這個協會有問題

不放棄原本國籍根本不會珍惜台灣

放棄外國籍再入台灣籍這沒什麼不對，那當初怎不先入台灣籍要入菲律賓籍呢？

台灣最需要嚴格的是針對中國國籍的審查，中共是台灣唯一敵人

基本上台灣的國籍法是屬人主義不是屬地主義，即必須父或母是本來就是台灣國籍，不是出生在台就是台灣國籍，此與美國不同。 專業人士的就業金卡或長期居留權不等於其子女或配偶必然有台灣的國籍。 任何國家的國籍法有其特別的考慮，沒有個別的例外！

那在中國出生的台灣人怎麼辦？

搞清楚，就業金卡的台灣籍額度只有一個，就是持有就業金卡本人。 是在亂什麼亂～

Dear Sam, I totally understand the challenges you and your daughter Zara are facing regarding her Taiwanese citizenship status. I'd like to provide you with a clear explanation of the relevant laws and potential solutions based on Taiwan's current immigration regulations. Taiwanese Citizenship by Naturalization As you know, Taiwan allows foreigners to apply for naturalization after meeting certain residency, language, and financial requirements. You have successfully gone through this process, demonstrating that you meet these requirements. Complexity for Children of Naturalized Citizens However, for children of naturalized citizens like Zara, the process is way more complex. Under Taiwan's Nationality Act, a foreign national must firstly renounce their original nationality before being granted Taiwanese citizenship. This requirement applies to both adults and minors. Renunciation of Original Nationality Unfortunately, the Philippines does not allow minors to renounce their citizenship until they reach the age of 18, which is the pivotal obstacle preventing Zara's citizenship application from moving forward. Temporary Solution: Alien Resident Certificate (ARC) In the meantime, Zara can continue residing in Taiwan legally under an Alien Resident Certificate (ARC). As the child of a naturalized citizen, she is eligible to apply for this status, which allows her to live, study, and access public services in Taiwan. While this does not grant her full citizenship, it will enable her to maintain a stable life in Taiwan until she reaches the age of 18. Applying for Citizenship at Age 18 Once Zara turns 18, she will be legally eligible to renounce her Filipino citizenship. After this step, she can apply for Taiwanese citizenship, submitting the necessary documents, including proof of residency, and meeting any other naturalization requirements. Dual Citizenship Exception for Minors While Taiwan generally requires the renunciation of prior citizenship, there are limited exceptions under the law. However, these exceptions are primarily for individuals who can prove significant contributions to Taiwan in areas such as national defense, the economy, or science and technology. Unfortunately, this exception is not typically extended to minors or individuals applying on the basis of family ties alone. Potential Future Legal Reforms I understand that this situation can be frustrating, especially for families like yours who are fully integrated into Taiwanese society. Taiwan's Immigration laws have been evolving to address various challenges posed by immigration and citizenship, and there is always the possibility that future legal reforms could address situations like Zara's more directly. Advocacy for reforms related to children born and raised in Taiwan by foreign parents is ongoing, and these changes may eventually make the process easier for children in similar situations. I hope this information helps you better understand the current situation and potential solutions for Zara's citizenship status. Please feel free to reach out if you have any further questions or concerns. Best Wishes

台灣國籍法是屬人主義而非屬地主義，父母非台灣人，小孩當然隨父母，不能因在台灣出生就是台灣人，要取得台灣的國籍當然得依法，不能有特例。台灣的國籍法寬鬆，日韓只有單國籍，而台灣普通百姓還可擁雙國籍，如張韶涵，竟在雙十大陸圍台軍演竟，還發表一中，所以，台灣國籍法很寬鬆了。

雷，😂臺灣又不是公廁，想來就來 再說你如何證明自己不是共匪？

台灣的政策真的很扯

Michael Turton, since you dont live in Taiwan anymore, why do you care about Taiwan's Immigration laws? Arent you in the Philippines?

"All foreigners, especially migrant workers, who work so hard, should have a simple path to citizenship: stay here five years, keep nose clean, take out citizenship. We should not have to exhibit some kind of special record on Taiwan’s behalf, like so many trained, high-status monkeys." - Michael Turton (I hate Black People) Source: Taipei Times - Notes from Central Taiwan: Discrimination tarnishes Taiwan’s image, Jun 12th, 2023 by Michael Turton

要擁有台灣國籍本就該依照台灣的法令，就因為你個人台灣就要承認你雙國籍實在有夠無言，你怎麼不叫菲律賓修法，簡直莫名其妙～

因為台灣旁邊有個隨時會對台灣發動軍事侵略的世界第二大國,並且在平時就利用各種滲透方式,吸收、賄絡、策反等方式,偷竊各種科技機密,並欲併吞台灣,不得不審慎嚴格移民政策,若哪天共產黨垮台,中國民主化了,我想放鬆移民政策是指日可待的~

台灣是屬人主義啦！除非另一半是台灣人啦！否則生下的小孩是無法成為台灣人民啦！因為這是法律規定的！因為台灣不是像美國是屬地主義啦

學台語，找委員

一切必須合乎法律，並非是拿到台灣護照就全家都可以成台灣籍！

如果每人都想雙重國籍，這地球就住了100億人口了！

我們現在已經沒有明文禁止本國人雙重國籍了。張先生竟然把一個聯合國不承認的政治實體的競爭力、國際化，與解除「入籍成為雙重國籍」的「放棄原國籍限制」掛鉤，吐槽點多到不行😢身為你口中的「中華民國籍選民」，我不允許不願放棄原國籍的投機份子架空我的國家。中華民國是一個資源極為有限、有可能進入戰爭狀態的國家，如果你親身在台灣生活好幾年並自稱愛台灣，但仍因為個人原因不願放棄原國籍，那請對自己誠實，比起成為台灣人，你有更在意的東西。我歡迎你來旅遊、探親、開展事業，但你沒有重要到可以成為例外❤

爸爸是台灣籍且在台出生，孩子可以申請身分證，但禁止雙重國籍，這是台灣的基本常識…..似係這影片有不合理之處🧐

又在拿小孩來情緒勒索，和一些中南美和穆斯林的非法移民如出一轍，每個國家都又自己的人口政策，況且台灣也不是移民國家，憑什麼要去迎合你啊?

我國法律就是規定你要入籍，條件合乎後，還是要放棄原有國籍的。這是台灣訂的規則，我覺得沒什麼不通人情的。

Then they should complain to Phillipines government isn't?