- 14
- 52 818
Julia Judges RG
Germany
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 31 พ.ค. 2020
Hey! I’m Julia! And I’m enthusiastic about RG judging :)
2024 update: Thank you everyone for being here since 2020! I’m not interested in the judging procedure anymore for a year already, and I’m not long going to run this channel. However, all my love still goes to Rhythmic Gymnastics. This channel was a small part of what I loved to do, but now I don’t, so I want to finish that project. x
2024 update: Thank you everyone for being here since 2020! I’m not interested in the judging procedure anymore for a year already, and I’m not long going to run this channel. However, all my love still goes to Rhythmic Gymnastics. This channel was a small part of what I loved to do, but now I don’t, so I want to finish that project. x
วีดีโอ
Scoring Darja Varfolomeev’s Clubs Routine at the @ ECh 2022 in Tel Aviv!
มุมมอง 1.9K2 ปีที่แล้ว
Darja Varfolomeev officially scored 33.150 with her clubs routine at the ECh 2022 in Tel Aviv, and took the bronze medal in the clubs individual final! And in this video I’m scoring and analysing her routine. Like, comment and subscribe if you find my content interesting and educational! (I would really appreciate it! Thank you :D) ~ Why some difficulties aren’t valid and I haven’t scored them?...
Russian Codes of Points 2022-2024. Analysing Lala Kramarenko’s Clubs routine.
มุมมอง 4.3K2 ปีที่แล้ว
sorry, i’ll add the description later :’(
Anastasiia Salos - 4 Routines 2022 - Maximum Difficulty Scores
มุมมอง 4.2K2 ปีที่แล้ว
Anastasiia Salos - 4 Routines 2022 - Maximum Difficulty Scores
Sofia Raffaeli - Clubs 2022 Analysis - WC, Faliro 2022
มุมมอง 6K2 ปีที่แล้ว
Sofia Raffaeli - Clubs 2022 Analysis - WC, Faliro 2022
Sofia Raffaeli - Ball 2022 - Analysis with new Codes of Points
มุมมอง 15K2 ปีที่แล้ว
instagram: @iulaxrg 1:38 sorry for a wrong text. the editing app bugged :/
Arina Averina - New Ribbon 2021 - Maximum Difficulty Score
มุมมอง 4.2K3 ปีที่แล้ว
video credits for @RGYMRUSSIA instagram: @iulaxrg
Yana Kudryavtseva - Clubs 2015 - The 2013-2016 cycle with the CoPs 2017-2021
มุมมอง 1.1K3 ปีที่แล้ว
instagram: @iulaxrg
Rut Castillo Galindo - All-Around 4 Routines Analysis - Pan-American Games, Rio 2021
มุมมอง 1.2K3 ปีที่แล้ว
instagram @iularg8
Alice Taglietti - 4 Routines Difficulty Analysis - Qualifications - IT, Sofia 2021
มุมมอง 8K3 ปีที่แล้ว
1:04 i’m sorry, the text was accidentally duplicated. leave ur opinion, corrections, questions, whether in the comments section :) instagram: @rhythmicjuliagymnastics
i edited grand-prix in moscow (some parts of serie a).
มุมมอง 2.3K3 ปีที่แล้ว
Instagram: @juliargjudging Videos credits go to @Telesport.
0:28 throw during bd, hoop on a horizental axis 0.2+4 rotations 0.4+catch inroation without hands and visual control and with change of axis 0.4 Eleni Kelaiditi : 19.7 The risk is worth 1 and with tge value of the jump added its 1.4 not 1.2 so +0.2 2:23 this balance is only worth 0.4 when dpne on flat foot 2:25 execution deduction bent leg Nikol zelikman : 21.3 3:39 AD 0.2 ( slide of the hoop : in rotation without visual control ) 3:44 AD 0.4 ( catch from high throw/rotation of the hoop around a body part: without hands ) 3:45 idk about you but for me the hoop clearly does a full rotation while she holds the balance so i would say +0.5 BD and +0.2 AD 5:00 this is clearly not a loss 💀💀 you can see she passes intentionally throught the hoop so +0.4 DA and +0.5 from the execution deduction Laura zeng : 22 5:20 throw without hands, without visual control, change of axis and with rotation of the hoop around its axis 0.4 + 3 rotations 0.3 + catch without visual control and in rotation 0.2 The risk is worth 0.9 not 0.7 so +0.2 5:34 DA 0.4 ( catch from high throw/rotation of the hoop around a body part : without hands ) 5:39 DA 0.3 ( large throw of the hoop : under leg/during bd ) 6:07 DA 0.2 ( rotation of the hoop around a body part : without hands/without visual control/ during bd ) 6:10 throw after roll on the floor, without hands, without visual control, change of axis 0.4+ 4 rotations 0.4+ catch without visual control, passing throught and in rotation 0.3 The risk is worth 1.1 not 0.9 so +0.2 6:14 the catch from the small throw is done while the shape of the balance is still fixed so the balance is valid even if the AD isnt wich means +0.5 6:37 DA 0.2 ( small throw of the hoop/ rotation of the hoop around its axis : without hands ) Alina Harnasko : 25.2 7:09 it's a roll so 0.3 not 0.2 7:10 DA 0.3 ( throw of the hoop/rethrow after rotation of the hoop on a body part : during bd ) 7:34 throw during horizental axis 0.2+ 3 rotation 0.3+ catch in rotation without hands without visual control passing throught change of axis 0.5 The risk is worth 1 and with the value of the jump its 1.5 And for the deduction, I wouldn't say it was an adjustment of body position, she just went into the rotation so for me +0.5 7:50 she does a teneau in combination with the penche pivot so +0.3 8:11 it's not an adjustment of body position since it's part of the choreography so +0.1 8:14 AD 0.4 ( catch of the hoop/rotation of the hoop around a body part : without hands ) 8:29 AD 0.3 ( throw of the hoop : under leg, during bd ) Anastasia salos : 26.3 ( wich is exactly the official score ) 8:51 AD 0.2 ( rotation of the hoop around a body part: without hands and in rotation ) 8:57 AD 0.3 ( throw of the hoop/rotation of the hoop around its axis : during bd ) 8:58 even is the bd is not valid the catch still is so +0.4 9:15 she passes throught the hoop so the risk is worth 0.8 not 0.7 wich means +0.1 9:17 AD 0.2 ( small throw/rotation of the hoop around its axis : during rotation ) 9:35 just because the shape hasn't been held long enough doesn't mean the whole thing doesn't count, both the ad and the bd still count so +0.7 Arina Averina : 22.1 10:37 the jump is worth 0.5 not 0.4 +0.1 11:36 AD 0.4 ( catch from large throw/rotation of the hoop around a body part : without hands ) Linoy Ashram : 25 12:12 the dance steps are 8 seconds long so +0.3 12:33 just because the shape isnt held for long enough doesn't mean the ad and bd aren't valid so +0.8 12:40 after tge transmition theres a small throw in ritation without visual control so +0.2 12:56 the teneau was correctly executed you can't fix a shape during thus roation since it's a body wave, it's supposed to move so +0.3 and there's no deduction +0.3 13:16 Just because the shape isn't held for long enough doesn't mean the ad and the bd aren't valid so +0.9 13:25 AD 0.2 ( small throw/rotation of the hoop around its axis : without visual control *I'm not entirely sure about this one since she seems to throw without looking then turn her body ) 13:26 to me this was a 180⁰ rotation I even watched it in slow motion and looked frame by frame and it still was 180⁰ so +0.5 and +0.2 for ad 13:31 AD 0.4 ( catch from high throw : under leg, during bd *just because the shape wasn't held for long enough doesn't mean that the ad doesn't count ) Dina Averina : 22 RANKING : 🥇anastasia salos : 26.3 ( wich was the judges' score ) 🥈alina harnasko : 25.2 🥉linoy ashram : 25 4-Arina averina : 22.1 5-laura zeng ( same score as dina but higher execution ) 22 6-Dina averina : 22 7-nikol zelikman : 21.3 8-Eleni kelaiditi : 19.7
This is great! I'm newly into rythmic gymnastics so this has helped a lot. Can I ask what the codes mean? As in the AD etc
“Codes” means “The Code of Points” (well, just a pdf file with official rules written by the international rhythmic gymnastics Federation, aka FIG). “AD” in 2021 meant “apparatus difficulty”. Now it’s “DA” which is “difficulty of apparatus”. “BD” in 2021 meant “body difficulty”. Now it’s “DB” - “difficulty of body”. DB includes jumps, balances and rotation/pivots. A risk is a throw of apparatus, and under it the gymnasts does at least 2 rotations. Risks are a part of DB.
hi!! I love your vids because they help me so much with knowing what deductions to avoid in my own routines now but I would like to ask where you got that artistry faults sheet for this routine?
hi! thank you! www.gymnastics.sport/site/rules/#5 here's the link to all codes of points and sheets/forms which judges use during the competitions. the artistic form is placed in the last ZIP file from jan. 20 2022.
Эту гимнастику отличает от всех лёгкость и слитность сложных элементов и движений....просто музыкальный ручеёк или ветерок
Preciosa! Arte en movimiento!
Sjajnooooo!!!!
Алисия Таглиетти - это настоящее явление в художественной гимнастики!!! Очень жаль, что она так рано закончила свою спортивную карьеру!
аличе её не заканчивала :)
@@juliajudgesrg в прессе сообщалось, что случился конфликт с тренером и она решила оставить занятия.. А сегодня к своей радости прочла, что Алисиа поменяла тренера и возвращается.. 👏👏👏
Pure art
You forget count many throw without hand in the risk
?
Я не верю, это что ещё один канал, в котором честно судят и показывают настоящие оценки Я так устала от ужасного судейства, что уже просто нет сил смотреть художественную гимнастику и фигурное катание Году ещё в 2019 я могла предположить, какие оценки будут, но когда пошли нереалистичные 26+ оценки, я поняла, что в судействе творится полный бред, и чтобы не делала Дина - она всегда первая, а чтобы не делала Салос - она постоянно ниже, чем должна была бы быть на самом деле Надеюсь, хотя бы вы сделаете разбор олимпиады Спасибо за адекватность и объективность
спасибо большое! разбор олимпиады я не планировала делать ещё до начала олимпиады, так как это может вызвать огромный хейт и резонанс. возможно, это не так и плохо, но я к этому не готова. а так я в целом согласна с судейством на олимпиаде.
thanks for the corrections to my dear fellow friend @Samuel RG! there’s no more criteria in the Risk for “the axis of the club” (basically when the club flies like a helicopter). i’m so sorry for being mistaken! but thanks so much for correcting me :) new codes are complicated with many different exceptions and keys, so i’m trying to be as precise as i can!
Здравствуйте!:) благодарю за видео😊 Я немного поздно, но есть вопрос, какие критерии будут здесь? 11:26 во вращении и без рук? Запутал это момент, т.к. вроде без зрительного контроля не подходят, или тут будет две базы плюс критерий? Ловля с высокого броска плюс вращение вокруг части тела? Перекаты обруча у сестёр - какой-то особый элемент, ни разу не видела, чтобы они делали большой перекат обруча нормально, как такое засчитывают😆, а теперь большой перекат - ещё и самая дорогая база, can't wait🙃
добрый вечер! на 11:26 я бы засчитала ловлю с высокого броска + 2 критерия: вращение телом 180° и вращение обруча вокруг своей оси после вращения. вообще очень старое видео. ошибки могут присутствовать, поэтому спасибо, что спрашиваете.
@@juliajudgesrg Спасибо) я ещё порасспрашивала, мне ответили, что там две базы ловля плюс вращение обруча вокруг руки и критерий во вращении, в любом случае ловлю можно засчитать) 2:08 я думаю, здесь Николь делает большой перекат, 11:21 ещё думала насчёт этой ловли, можно ли применить критерий во вращении? Мне кажется, Линой слишком поздно уходит в него, хотя, я слышала, что в судейской практике достаточно, чтобы какая-либо часть тела ушла во вращение, не знаю, насколько это правда)) 11:49 похожая ловля есть чуть ли не у всех топов в разных предметах, но ведь "без зрительного контроля" нельзя применить, т.к. рука прямо над головой?
@@juliajudgesrg 13:30 я видела, у Клематис была засчитана эта ловля, но, мне кажется, там просто как бы прибив руками обруча к ноге, каждый раз исполнение такое, не совсем понимаю, что Дина пытается сделать, под ногой и в BD? 12:27 здесь, мне кажется, она ловит в локоть, а потом только проходит ногой.
@@evgeniiawr.5289 12:27 да, я согласна, но засчитала с критериями «без зрительного»/«без рук». сейчас такое уже бы не прокатило. тогда ещё даже не было информации про то, когда можно считать «без зрительного», а когда нельзя, поэтому смотрела на глаз. 13:30 я не засчитала скорее всего из-за того, что форма равновесия была задержана только после ловли. сейчас бы ещё сделала сбавку -0.3 за как раз тот прибив к телу.
Her ball routine 😍😍😍
I love her ball exer wow
She has some of the best musicality I have seen.
You deserve way more recognition!
From which country are you??
at the moment, from russia ;)
are 11 good?
it’s low now even for the juniors but we should remember that was 5 months ago. and the junior level was different too. i guess, i would get a bit higher the D score now because then i was hesitating about giving her some ADs (because a) there was the lack of criteria, b) it was executed incorrect). so i hope to watch the upcoming events to understand this thing.
@@juliajudgesrg sorry for the dumb question but what AD and BD stand for?
@@heyletsdoitcrazyAD = Apparatus difficulty BD = Body difficulty
I'm so surprised abt the Dina SCORE
ah yes, with unlimited time i can find anything to deduct haha but a lot of things can be seen in the real life by the judges.
@@juliajudgesrg I hope in OG every gymnasts can get the scores they deserve...
@@juliajudgesrg do you say that when you evaluate a routine during the competition the judges do not have enough time to assess the performance and they just give whatever points? I seriously cannot understand how Dina and Arina always have more than 9 for execution and based on your assessment Dina has barely a bit over 6 (which in my opinion corresponds to her execution) I just wish at some point in RG gymnasts will be evaluated according to their performance and not the country of origin
@@venini6120 i meant, i was analysing those 8 routines for 3-4 days. every day i was reviewing each of them to find any mistakes by me. of course, some of routines weren’t reviewed straight for 4 days but i had enough of time to see all the deduction, to talk with my judging friends, maybe to have a conversation with a FIG qualified judge for some points i was hesitating. the judges have at least 2 minutes to give the points for the gymnasts, so that’s okay that the scores aren’t that fair, but, of course, some things could be seen by the judges for these 2 minutes. they just count everything they saw, even the apparatus difficulties in incorrect body shapes, with any other deduction. that’s sad for sure, but when i see clear Linoy, i’m literally shocked how her moves are accurate and don’t need a lot of timing and hesitations to give her points for that. yeah, she has 2 points difference in the score, but the routines are judged in the real life, i won’t see some things, too.
@@venini6120 maybe there’re some political things. we will never know. rhythmic gymnastics was never a subjective kind of sport, so most probably there’s the thing in russians taking the whole podium. judges have the preferences too, one judge won’t deduct for the small thing, another will, for example. so, everyone literally judges a bit different.
Hello can You make Analysis for other gymnasts which was at top?
hi! yes, i can, what gymnasts do u want to see? or maybe from the actual competition? i usually do top 3 from the finals. just text me what you want to see :]
she's gifted with her flowing movements, i guess it just seems like indescribable ballet beauty my wife is a dancer and she's amazing to watch - many do these rhythmic gymnastics really well but alice's flowing motions do stand out as just phenomenal and natural . You can try to teach that, but you can't teach that type of movement. She is gifted
Why judges don't check a workplan during performance? They just sit and watch a routine. I just wondering.
they do 😄
Still rendered speechless by that thumbnail 😍😍😍
thank you ☺️
😍🥰❤️❤️
❤️🔥💫✨🌸
2,19 ahhhhhhhhh. how not to put the mask
I loved this 😂😂😂😂😂 made my day
thank you so much 😁😂
I have really enjoyed this video! Thank you! :) Can you please review and score the podium gymnasts at a ball final and may be the hoop final?
hi! thank you! i’m glad you enjoyed it :D of course, i’ll analyse it. from grand-prix, yeah?
@@juliajudgesrg yes, from the gran prix, thank you :)
love this 😂😍
thank youu!! 🙈
2:12 " stravinsky will help us to fight against corona" AHAHAHA I can't XD. you are savage XD
HAHAHHAH thank you! 🙈😂
Omg I loved every second of this 😂
thank you so much! 💓😫🙈
I LOVED EVERY PART OF THIS 😍😂
THANK YOU 🥰
I love this video❤Рlease do this after every tournament😁
hi, thank youu 💓 i think, this will happen really rare because i should watch the competitions all day long which never happens (only today and yesterday i’ve done that). i usually watch routines of some gymnasts after. but i’ll try if i’ll find some fun moments to upload videos like this more often.
Thank you SO MUCH!!!❤️❤️❤️
You are welcome! <3
Wow! Amazing channel 😍💙
hi, thank you so much! 😄