วีดีโอ

A nice critical perspective. There are characters who practiced 'normal Islam.' The likes of Laila's and Tariks family. On the other hand, There is Rashid who practices the 'Fundamental Islam' So it's up to the reader to identify how the characters practiced their belief. I don't think that if the writer tries to draw the line between 'normal Islam', and 'Fundamental Islam". He did his best to show how faith can be abused among politicians. (As a remark @ 2:48 you mentioned that Mariam forced to Marry Jalil. Jalil is her father. It is rather Rashid.) By the way the story has many resemblance with my country (Ethiopia) civil war period. For that reason I have translated "A Thousand Splendid Suns" in to Amharich (our official language)

I have seen hijabi girls do not so modest things Lets not pretend here this is just a man problem but women are better at keeping it hidden

The author is merely pointing out how some people misrepresent Islam. The title of the book is itself from Maulana Rumi’s poetry.. spirituality and humanity transcend organised religion itself.

I agree that the narrator always depicts men as cruel creatures and women as victims

Non muslim here. Thank you, just finished the book, found this video and, yes, at times I felt that it kind of had a set political view instead of just keeping neutral and focusing on the story. Thanks for sharing your knowledge and demystifying the issues around orientalism and fundamental Islam. Blessings.

I will never understand people defending any person we as Muslims imams, humans, sheikhs etc, do have lots of flows, example here my beloved NAK(oh I love him a lot in regards with the quran he teaches). Why would u defend anybody, we all have flows. We are not prophets. A question to u sis, CAN I CALL U A CELEBRATY SHEIKHA OR MUSLIMAH? (I loved your concern, it is something to talk about. But isn't it 0.000001% of all the imams) here is a food of thought for u "Allah asked women to clap their hands when a mistake is done in the recitation in SALAH, whereas we as men can raise our voice saying subahanallah. (I know u will get it. May Allah bless you sis)

My only complaint, why are you holding a keyboard :D, and the word facade (fuh-sawd) Otherwise, eye opening and nothing but the truth in this video

Relax Mohammedans, your prophet was the most indecent man ever walked on this earth, high on ganja.

You’re right on point!

Fake news

Yeah all of them they are pervert like Muhammad, going after 6 years old girl, and then his son wife going inside her house flirting with her according to Muslim stories but God knows what he did, and he claimed that a lot told him to do that😂😂😂

At last someone said it! From a certain point on in the novel I felt something is very wrong but wasn't sure. In the second half everything became clear and I totally agree with the points made in this video. I read it recently and seeing it was published in 2003 during the invasion and the massive propaganda following it, it made a lot of sense that this book was pushed to glory and sold so many copies. Thank you for this brave video that stands against the current. Even if you are just pointing out the obvious.

Sister Sara, we have proper Islamic method of criticising others. It is clearly laid down in the Shariah. I would request you follow the guidelines and protect your Akhirah. This is not about rights and wrongs, it is the constructiveness of this very sensetive issue. May Allah guide us all.

Salaam dear sister. There's already so much of chaos created by shaitan between the ummah, please dont add to it.. A true believer will never generalize all the sheikhs like this, you could have put a better thumbnail, that to be aware from some of the online sheikhs, but you made all of them shady, and those brothers and sisters who are distanced from deen, who are considering getting closer to their lord again, they will get confused by your videos and it will be on your head god forbid.. please sister, don't let shaitan play tricks through you..

The problem is that the sheeple cannot recognise ultimate truth from Noman saying the Prophet Mohammad had to proclaim his shahaadah very ignorant Noman they travel the world with your money in five star and you pay them sheeple to learn Quran or Arabic search history and see if Imam Malik charged a fee or ima shaafi or any companion sahabah for teaching Arabic, tajweed. Hajj and umrah classes and don’t say they must make living what did sahabah do as earning a living not charge the taabi -een did imam albukhari travel the world for conferences and charge students all these people mufti men and the like Omar Sulaiman super feet osman bin farook proven he cannot even read Quran properly but his the man وعن بريده رضي الله تعالى عنه قال: قال رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: (من قرأ القرآن يتأكل به الناس، جاء يوم القيامة ووجهه عظم ليس عليه لحم).- رواه البيهقي. 28. It is reported by Buraydah (RA) that the Messenger (SAW) said: ‘whoever recites the Qur’an for gaining something to eat from the people will come on the Day of Qiyamah with a skeletal face without any flesh on it. Transmitted by al-Baihaqi وعن عبد الرحمن بن شبل الأنصاري رضي الله تعالى عنه، أن النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم، قال: (اقرأوا القرآن، واعملوا به، ولا تجفوا عنه، ولا تغلوا فيه، ولا تأكلوا به، ولا تستكثروا به). - رواه أحمد، وأبو يعلى، والطبراني، والبيهقي. 25. It is reported by ‘Abdul-Rahman ibn Shabal al-Ansari (RA) that the Messenger (SAW) said: ‘recite the Qur’an and act on it, do not shun it, do not excessive in it, and do not earn a livelihood through it. Transmitted by Ahmad, Abu Ya‘la, al-Tabarani and al-Baihaqi.

Omg, thank you!!!!!! Let truth be known lol… they have unchecked egos/ and always talking about other people and drama… their aggression etc etc etc 😊 PLEASE KEEP GOING

Islamic organizations and celebrity scholars have access to spyware. They can bug women's system remotely n have access to women's phone calls, WhatsApp calls n WhatsApp messages! I was writing on the facebook n TH-cam pages of islamic organizations in 2017 using fake profiles. They managed to figure my identity out. When i changed my number as well as phone in 2018/19, they managed to figure out my new number as well. Spyware allows for all of that, like stealing numbers updated on gmail or facebook. They have hacked me since 2017 n used my WhatsApp data for their content/videos and i only figured out this year. They try to talk to me through their videos but when i send them emails, they don't reply. Most don't even have email ids mentioned on their websites. Do u know any female scholar who would hear me out??? I wrote to FACE and Hurma 1.5 weeks back n they don't reply. FACE is on an investigative moratorium since 2021 n Hurma website says they don't investigate cases of abuse. I am not from the US. I need your help!

Assalamu alaikum! Please get rid of the photo of NAK... I am not trying to take away from what you are saying, sister, just the photo is unnecessary :)

Why are you visting graves?

Please take down the Nouman Ali Khan picture because it’s literally slanderous and nothing was proven. I get it you want clicks and views but take it down

Very true re Red Pill pipeline I have noted this with many celebrity "Sheikhs", and I think it serves their personal agenda just like having an online platform can for financal gain. This isn't backbiting its a very serious concern that we are facing as a community. PS. Facade not pronounced "Fakade" but "Fasade" the c is an s not k sound

A lot of these celebrity sheiks are ikhwanis, a deviant group after political power. They justify Harām suicide bombing (with conditions), respect and work with 12er shia Iran, and takfīr muslim rulers, (except Iran's transgender supporting rulers ofc 😉). Beware of any celebrity daa`3ī relying on public speaking skills over knowledge and qualifications.

Salaam sister, I think you are brave for talking about this topic. I started watching Nouman Ali Khan but something seemed very "off" to me about the way he speaks, this was before I even knew about the allegations! Thank you for sharing this information.

Dude, are you recording your audio on your iPad? That's pretty sick!

You repeated the same sentence over and over again in the video: see who these Sheikhs are and see their credentials.

There is no such thing celebrity sheikh! in Islam unlike other religioun we dont have a class of priests or imams etc! Islam recognizes that any one is vulnarable for sinful acts! we do listen to them as long as their teachings aligns with Quran and Sunnah,however I wouldnt take their life as an example as they are not profits or angel and they are pretty much vulnarable commit sins just like anyone.

9:31 They have taken their rabbis and monks as well as the Messiah, son of Mary, as lords besides Allah,1 even though they were commanded to worship none but One God. There is no god ˹worthy of worship˺ except Him. Glorified is He above what they associate ˹with Him˺! 45:6 These are Allah’s revelations which We recite to you ˹O Prophet˺ in truth. So what message will they believe in after ˹denying˺ Allah and His revelations?

Wanted to share some authentic and true shaykhs from madinah; Shaykh Abdur Razzaq al-Badr Shaykh Sulayman Ruhaylee Shaykh usaymi Shaykh saleh As sindi and many more حفظهم الله Hope this will be beneficial In shaa Allah

واخيرا وحده حجتها finally someone said it

Please dear sister, do you really think that Allah is Please with you, making this video.? Is this helping is any way our ummah? There is lot of important things that people need. What this individual have done Allah almighty already show them... We are all human being, and we all make mistakes in our life we all sin. Would you like for this to happen to you? If you make any mistakes and them every one post your photos on social media? Is very wrong what they have done, and they have to pay for that... But everyone talking about it over and over again most of them for views is just destroying even more our ummah and making the disbelieves happy with our division... Post beneficial video to help us be better not to divide us... Show the beautiful of islam...

Innocent until proven guilty. If theres no proof that nouman ali kha did anything stop putting hiis pictures up there. Hes a great sheikh and does alot of help in our community of ummah. Take care sister.

Great video ❤

Waalaikumussalaam wr. I don't like "celebrity sheikhs". But seems like you're no different, maybe I'm wrong but from what I can tell an unmarried man hating angry woke feminist hijabi Muslima.

Sister, the allegations against Nouman Ali Khan were never proven so it's not quite correct that you believe that he has committed something wrong and discourage people from benefiting from the tremendous work that he has done over the last decade.

MashAllah sister great content .jazakallahukhair for standing up. MuizzyGo subscribed🫡

I got a question sister. You mentioned dr Zakir Naik as an example of being extreme. Do you think dr Zakir Nike is a wrong person to watch? Because i watch him a lot and i dont know what to do anymore

Also be careful. Why take the word of the kaafir over the muslim? If they are found guilty then great, otherwise we must be careful not to backbite

This is what happens when you accept Islam and democracy in the same heart.

I'm so glad someone is talking about this. The number of pop and celebrity sheiks who will spread misinformation but because they take the aesthetic of sheiks they aren't held accountable is growing and its really important to address

Asalam u Alaikum sister, what you are doing is actually backbiting. Unless you yourself say that they are not "accused" but GUILTY. Can you say that? Off course you can not. That's why taking names is Wrong. What you generally said is correct but referring to specific persons especially Noman Ali is like giving air to the fire of Shaitan. If you are thinking that he is to blame, then off course you are free to think that for yourself but you shouldn't say that to other people unless you have proof or unless you can't use the word "accused".

Salaam Sister, you should take down Noman Ali Khan's picture. He didn't do anything illegal, or a grievous violation of Shariah Law that is a violation of Hudood laws.

wait who was the fake muslim couple

This is already being talked about in communities. Please don’t take names but speak about it generally. We NEVER know, even with any evidence, if they are wrong. We always keep good assumptions and forbid the evil not the person who does the evil. The reason is that we speak about the topic and not the person specifically is because of fitnah. How many ppl must have thought bad about Islam and good righteous imams and shuyūkh because of your title? Lastly, please don’t generalize this to celebrity imams. When a person does wrong we speak about the wrong. But using celebrity culture reference of imams in your title shows that you are now assuming every Imam does this. There are many normal imams and more so who do this. But you don’t have the name. So instead you should call out the sin, not the sinner.

Asalamalakum sister 💞I think it’s important to talk about this celebrity cultures with religious figures and the effects. Thank you for this, however I don’t think you should use that pic of Nouman, he could’ve made repentance, it was a long time ago and none of us are perfect, if we were, we wouldn’t be here, we should try and protect people’s honor. Thank you so much for making this vid

We can give advice about them clarifying their credentials but does not mean they don’t have it. You’re talking about allegations. Where is your proof? I didn’t like your analysis. It’s not based on facts. And based off this: what are YOUR credentials to judge other people?

Salaam sister. I think its really amazing to warn people of falling for the "holiness" of anyone let alone a "celebrity sheikh". I would refrain from using anyone's picture however. If we are right about them, then I don't personally know anything wrong with that. But if we are wrong about them, wont Allah punish us for defiling our brothers and sisters honour? I think speaking about this topic without using a specific person as an example keeps us in a safe place religiously.

Salaam Sister, u may not agree with certain things of Shekhs and that’s okay. But coming in public platform and addressing them “cockroaches” Astagfirullah . I have had few not so good experience with some Muslims includes sheikhs but just because few bad experience i m not gonna label all sheiks. There are black sheep in each community . All u gonna get from making videos like this attention from western/non Muslims. Is that ur goal just like MALALA

Her video might be a propaganda against Muslim celebrities.

Assalam O Alikum Sis, about Nouman Ali Khan, I had the same experience as you. I used to enjoy his videos but after learning about his allegations I also became disinterested and talked about this to my sister. She said to me, that you should not believe until it's proven, it could have been done to assassinate his reputation. While I do agree that one shouldn't multiply anyone by 0, but also make a conscious decision about who you listen to.

Wait, did I see a picture of Nouman Ali Khan? Has there been a scandal regarding this cheikh? By the way, I found your content really interesting. Thank you for assessing misogyny and how it's not part of Islam.