วีดีโอ

Duffer.

No competition in the tiger era!!!

Great Golfer but……..

Love Jack. Clearly the most dominant player ever across an entire career. But... there is NO sport with firm measures where athletes from forty years ago are as good as now. People are provably stronger and faster now. In golf, they don't just hit it farther now, they hit more fairways. They hit more greens. They hit it closer to the pin. They hit fewer putts. They play much longer courses and still score lower.

GOAT = Tiger. Nobody..I mean Nobody has played the kind of golf Tiger did between 2000 and 2010. Winning percentage which will remain unfathomable...more wins than anybody in the history of the game...Nicklaus was a majors specialist

all he had to do

It is John Daniels... Wall to Wall.

What is the UK Open?

Most wins against what is now an abbreviated field since the split...ugh so frustrating. Least most are there for most majors.

Addendum: Old as I am, I never say Bobby Jones play...but Bobby won 13 out of 31 majors he entered, a 41.9% winning average. THAT is the GOAT! I know, it was almost a century ago, but it should not be forgotten.

Tiger in 2000 was the finest golfer I've ever seen, and I'm 86...so I saw (in their prime) Snead, Hogan, Littler ( WAY underrated), Palmer, Boros (also underrated), Casper, Lema, Watson, Trevino, Weiskopf, Norman and a HOST of others. But one year, no matter how great, does not make you the GOAT. I side with brucewayne3602: the 19 second places and 9 third places put Jack head and shoulders above ALL the rest. Jack had 56 top-5s in majors; Tiger has 33. With just a bit of luck, Jack could have won 25 majors... Game over!

Obviously Jack is the goat. He wasn't a drug addict or sex pervert. He also knew when to retire, unlike the spoiled rotten Woods!!

we had an athlete like that in Australia, his name was Shane Warne lol

I played my best pool when I had a buzz going 😅

Knew the 20..🤦

opened golf up to the working class

Time out. No question Jack is on Mount Rushmore, but stats do open up more questions. 69-76 general average # of players exempt was 75. 2000-2010 tour card holders 125+. # of players within 2 strokes of Jack’s average was 25-28. # within 2 of tiger was 40-45. Different tourney winners per year for Jack it’s around 25, for Tiger it’s near 35. My point is that the competition in Tigers decade was much much deeper, than it was for Jack. In Tigers decade any 1 of 100 golfers could win week to week. In Jack’s maybe 1 of 50-60. This is a broad look that does not take away from Jack’s greatness. In my eyes it dilutes the 19 second place finishes based on the overall competition they both played against.

Don't forget his short game! I miss watching him play.

Did any courses "Jack Proof" themselves? They sure did "Tiger Proof" them. hmm.

just think if jack would of had the club's and golf ball's tiger played with

No question Jack was the GOAT.

John Daly was great but to say he was more gifted than Tiger..............total BULLSHIT !

Just and FYI, Jack had a bad hip through most of his career. He would get injections so he could play. Later he had it replaced. He never complained about it because he didn't want to give his competition an advantage. Tiger of course was raised during the age of 'victims,' 'betas,' and 'don't keep score in soccer.' So as tough as he was mentally the culture was different and probably explains why Nicklaus hid his injuries and Tiger had no problem wearing them as a badge of courage.

How can Tiger be a GOAT when he was always a JACKASS?

Why doesn’t the author share his name?

Jack is the Greatest of All Time! The equipment was nothing compared to what is available today. I had the great pleasure of briefly speaking with Jack at the 1974 US Open at Winged Foot!

Equipment and course quality is not part of the argument. All the players had the latest equipment and played on the same course, at a given time.

Title should read "Better than Jack?" Jack was the best.

What are my favorites behind Payne Stewart? I wonder if he’s the only one that ever won that with a mullet😂😂

Nicklaus

I don’t disparage John’s lifestyle but I feel if he had have taken himself more seriously he’d have been the most successful golfer in history!

Every category of life needs a John Daly in the mix 🇺🇸🇺🇸

I can do a 3 stroke 69 but it looks a bit different

With Bryson, he played the SHORTEST tees possible (ladies tees). He can’t carry his driver longer than 180 on a good shot. He frequently chunks wedges and hits his irons extremely thin. He’s teeing off, with Bryson, on a 100yd par 3 and has a 7 iron in his hand. The guy probably can’t play a normal 6500-7000yd course and break 100. Any legit par 5 would take him 4 or 5 shots just to reach the green. The “par 5s” he played with Bryson were less than 400yds. The “solo eagle” with Bryson was on a 208yd par 4…that is a par 3…not a par 4

Tiger became his true self and broke Johnny Holmes record.

2.8 what a lot of bullshit...anyone got video of a full round??? Of course not .....

The disrespect in that title.

And they didn’t even touch upon his acting career, beast mode .

2nd best golfer ever. Tiger reigns Supreme

Ironic that Phil's sponsor was the accounting firm KPMG when he committed tax fraud and insider trading.

ata boy john keep on truckin.

No questions its Jack. Statistics are statistics. If you take in account each contender for the GOAT and the personal life to complete the man, Jack wins hands down

we now got golfs version of sunnyv2, keep up the work

Jack is the goat. And tiger is the tiger. Anybody that can hit a 341 yard drive with a wood club with a steel shaft and a rubber band ball. When adjusted for current club/ball tech that's 450 yards.

The GOAT? John Daly. I’d like to see Nicklaus play a drunk barefoot round and still shoot under par

This video actually confirms Jack is the GOAT. Aside from the most important measurement. 18 Majors (vs Tiger’s 15), its this 19 second places in Majors that confirms his status.

The debate is not even close. Jack is the clearly the best of all time. The fact that he won more outright and then finished second so many more times that Tiger proves it beyond a doubt.

Bryson just worked the PR machine and popped up on every TH-cam channel possible, as well as launching his own, but there’s no smoke without fire, guys is still a jackass.

No chance

Very good analysis, sir. Well done. You may have mentioned this, but perhaps the most impressive stat about Jack is that while he did indeed win 18 majors, he finished SECOND in 18 more!! Consider that for a moment. A few strokes here and there and Jack may have won 25 or more! Also, Jack did all this while having an amazing family life, raising successful kids and enjoying a rock solid marriage. Golf was never #1 in Jack's life. Another factor worth considering is golf course conditioning. Tiger's prime was played on manicured courses with the best that science and agronomy and course maintenance had to offer. Jack played at a time when your putt may bounce 3 times and fairways had dead spots. And the difference in club and ball technology was night and day. At his absolute best, Tiger probably played the best golf that's ever been played. Winning majors by 12 and 15 strokes is mind boggling. But Jack was better longer, thus making him the GOAT.