- 83
- 16 261
Done
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 29 ก.ย. 2020
Your Channel for Assa Rogue M+ Videos!
Thank you for watching!
I am Done and i do casual M+ how i am able to run and finish the keys in time. Feel free to comment, I would be happy if you´d leave a like or a comment.
Have fun and feel free to ask.
I would be glad if you subscribe to my channel, so you dont miss any videos.:)
Thank you for watching!
I am Done and i do casual M+ how i am able to run and finish the keys in time. Feel free to comment, I would be happy if you´d leave a like or a comment.
Have fun and feel free to ask.
I would be glad if you subscribe to my channel, so you dont miss any videos.:)
Grim Batol M+10Assassination Rogue 1M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Steingewölbe
Thanks guys.
Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Und danke an die Gruppe=)
Dont forget to like and subscribe.
raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done
worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done
Talents:
CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA
Feel free to ask or write a comment.
Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Und danke an die Gruppe=)
Dont forget to like and subscribe.
raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done
worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done
Talents:
CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA
Feel free to ask or write a comment.
Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
มุมมอง: 224
วีดีโอ
The Stonevault M+8 Assa Rogue 1,2M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Steingewölbe
มุมมอง 194วันที่ผ่านมา
Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Und danke an die Gruppe=) Dont forget to like and subscribe. raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Mists of Tirna Scythe M+9 Assa Rogue 1,1M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nebel Tirna Scythe
มุมมอง 9814 วันที่ผ่านมา
Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Und danke an die Gruppe=) Dont forget to like and subscribe. raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Necrotic Wake M+8 Assa Rogue 1,3M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nekrotische Schneise
มุมมอง 10414 วันที่ผ่านมา
Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Mists of Tirna Scythe M+7 Assa Rogue 1,0M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nebel Tirna Scythe
มุมมอง 11221 วันที่ผ่านมา
Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Und danke an die Gruppe=) Dont forget to like and subscribe. raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Ara-Kara City of Threads M+8 Assa Rogue 900K Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1
มุมมอง 8021 วันที่ผ่านมา
Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Mists of Tirna Scythe M+9 Assa Rogue 1,0M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nebel Tirna Scythe
มุมมอง 9021 วันที่ผ่านมา
Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! Und danke an die Gruppe=) Dont forget to like and subscribe. raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
The Dawnbreaker M+7 Assa Rogue 1,0M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Morgenbringer
มุมมอง 132หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Ara-Kara City of Echoes M+7 Assa Rogue 900K Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1
มุมมอง 151หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Siege Of Boralus M+7 Assa Rogue 1,0M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Belagerung
มุมมอง 148หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Done worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Necrotic Wake M+7 Assa Rogue 1,3M Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nekrotische Schneise
มุมมอง 164หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Freakfiech worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Siege Of Boralus M+6 Assa Rogue 800k Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Belagerung
มุมมอง 78หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Freakfiech worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
The Dawnbreaker M+6 Assa Rogue 780 k Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Morgenbringer
มุมมอง 107หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Freakfiech worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Necrotic Wake M+5 Assa Rogue 860 k Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nekrotische Schneise
มุมมอง 148หลายเดือนก่อน
Dont forget to like and subscribe. Thanks guys. New Intro will follow in the next days. Vielen Dank fürs zuschauen! raider.io/characters/eu/antonidas/Freakfiech worldofwarcraft.blizzard.com/de-de/character/eu/antonidas/done Talents: CMQA27SZpS4XnmFfcXRqkppuwPjZmZmxwyMAAAAAAMLD2mBAAAAAg22mZmxDMzgZmZZ2GjBzMzMDmZmNLjZA2MLDMglglhJwwCA Feel free to ask or write a comment. Thx 4 watching #thewarwithin
Delve Spiral Weave 8 Solo Prot Warri GS 570 I Spiral Gewebe 8 Solo World of Warcraft the War Within
มุมมอง 68หลายเดือนก่อน
Try to farm gear for the first M runs. Worked well but i died 2 times because I wanted too much =P. Tiefe auf Stufe 8 hat gut geklappt, bin nur leider 2 mal gestorben weil ich dumm war -.-.
Assa Rogue Mists of Tirna Scythe M+4 730k Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nebel Tirna Scythe
มุมมอง 178หลายเดือนก่อน
Assa Rogue Mists of Tirna Scythe M 4 730k Overall WoW The War Within M Season 1 Nebel Tirna Scythe
Assa Rogue Deathstalker Necrotic Wake M+2 630 k Overall WoW The War Within M+ Season 1 Nekrotische
มุมมอง 1702 หลายเดือนก่อน
Assa Rogue Deathstalker Necrotic Wake M 2 630 k Overall WoW The War Within M Season 1 Nekrotische
Lets Play World of Warcraft War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 6 Dungeon Priorat der heiligen Flamme
มุมมอง 722 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lets Play World of Warcraft War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 6 Dungeon Priorat der heiligen Flamme
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 5 Grußmutters Geschichten und Rätsel
มุมมอง 432 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 5 Grußmutters Geschichten und Rätsel
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 4 Neues Höhlengebiet!
มุมมอง 382 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 4 Neues Höhlengebiet!
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 3 Ab gehts ins erste Dungeon!
มุมมอง 573 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 3 Ab gehts ins erste Dungeon!
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 2
มุมมอง 353 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch # 2
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch #1
มุมมอง 263 หลายเดือนก่อน
Lets Play World of Warcraft The War Within Assa Rogue Deutsch #1
Assassination Rogue Halls of Infusion M+13 Tyrannical Season 4 M+ Hallen der Infusion 13
มุมมอง 733 หลายเดือนก่อน
Assassination Rogue Halls of Infusion M 13 Tyrannical Season 4 M Hallen der Infusion 13
Protection Warrior/Tank Algethar Academy M+10 Season 4 Wow Dragonflight M+
มุมมอง 463 หลายเดือนก่อน
Protection Warrior/Tank Algethar Academy M 10 Season 4 Wow Dragonflight M
Assassination Rogue Halls of Infusion M+14 Fortified Season 4 M+ Hallen der Infusion 14
มุมมอง 1003 หลายเดือนก่อน
Assassination Rogue Halls of Infusion M 14 Fortified Season 4 M Hallen der Infusion 14
Protection Warrior/Tank Neltharus M+8 Fortified Season 4 Wow Dragonflight M+
มุมมอง 743 หลายเดือนก่อน
Protection Warrior/Tank Neltharus M 8 Fortified Season 4 Wow Dragonflight M
Assassination Rogue Neltharus M+13 Fortified 480k Overall Season 4 Wow Dragonflight M+
มุมมอง 1773 หลายเดือนก่อน
Assassination Rogue Neltharus M 13 Fortified 480k Overall Season 4 Wow Dragonflight M
Assassination Rogue Halls of Infusion M+12 Fortified Season 4 M+ Hallen der Infusion 12
มุมมอง 1.3K3 หลายเดือนก่อน
Assassination Rogue Halls of Infusion M 12 Fortified Season 4 M Hallen der Infusion 12
Ruby Life Pools M+13 Season 4 Assassination Rogue Wow Dragonflight M+ Meucheln Schurke
มุมมอง 6543 หลายเดือนก่อน
Ruby Life Pools M 13 Season 4 Assassination Rogue Wow Dragonflight M Meucheln Schurke
1m overall?? man were doing that in +2s
I know its Not so good but key was in time. I have never seen this strategy at third boss. In the future it will be getting better. I also do 1m in +2. Thank you for your comment:)
bro what are you on let the guy have fun shut ur mouth
+8 are Fun.... hey Music is loud...
@@jim9387 i will remember the music and will tune it down. Thank you for your comment:)
Was not a good performance and i dont know tactics in these run on the 3rd boss. I have never seen anyone doing the boss like this 😅
Bro +8 nothing to upload music also way too loud
@@DiscStockiable i will think of it in the future. You dont have to like +8 thats fine :)
Insane bro
@@eissaalqubaisi-lu8pq thank you for your comment i dont like the dungeons this season, not a little-.-
Cover ist wrong, was a envenom crit and not kingsbane. New Cover will follow this evening
The run was not perfect but it was really fun and we do it in time 🎉 thx 4 group and for tanking and healing (only 597 itemlvl😮)
nice.. Unfortunately my pc has been down all week be back soon.
@@roguehavikk thats Bad mate, hopefully you can fix this soon. I still about doing ksh on rogue and play tank in future. I dont like to wait 40 min to deplete a key :( I am happy that in your case everything works well
Insane work ❤️
I will try to Do 10 this evening. Its getting for us puggs 😊
nice, keep grinding its what us puggers can do!
the music is not it
@@foreignerthethird7045 its Not easy to find music which is free to use :) Would you like it more without?
Music is fine.. ignore the clowns
Hey bro, thanks for the run, always happy to see good rogue
Thx for the run. Good groups are rare and i was happy to found a group where everything runs good🎉🎉
kannst du mir mal dein neuen talentbaum reinschicken habe i wie probleme seit dem neuen patch
@@ibolito6412 klar www.wowhead.com/talent-calc/rogue/assassination/deathstalker/DANFVFFRVBUVZiRBCURNVUVVVEYEQFKFUBEEVVVUCEA
@@ibolito6412 Mit was genau hast du denn Probleme?
Gar kein Problem, ich helfe Dir gerne wenn ich kann. 🎉
amazing work brother keep it up
wp bro nice dmg
I Sure need a better dagger. 603 is just too low 😢 But i try what i can to Do damage 😅
Hey dein nameplates gefällt mir kannst du vielleicht teilen? 😅
Klar, schreibe ich dir heute abend🎉
Ich habe die Plater nameplates. Findest du bei Curse 😎
bro is afraid of pressing interrupt lmao
Not afraid 😅 sometimes i just forget and sometimes i use blind . But youre right that i could kick more often:)
Still a lot to learn with the hero talents but lets get into it. I Sure need better gear and rating, but i also need time to play. What Do want so see in the next videos? Maybe i gonna upload a delve 🎉🎉
Gearings been harsh to say the least, in 5's farming nyself. GJ WB
@@roguehavikki was in 10 m+ this week and only 2 items dropped -.- I Sure need crests and valorstones. But i also need better gear. This evening i will try to push and get last 3 dungeons on +4 or 5
Tell me what you think about it which dungeons i should play next? What kind of content Do you want so see? Sagt mir ruhig was ihr über den run denkt oder was ihr noch für Content sehen möchtet 🎉
Grüße von Talak
Vielen Dank, ich sehe gerade meinen Rechtschreibfehler -.- war ein schöner run, hat mir gut gefallen =)
Sudden Demise: Nicht "demies", sondern "demais" Das Talent is krank zum Leveln... In praxis fällt einfach alles unter 35% tot in sich zusammen, braucht natürlich zusätzlich Crimson Tempest, keine Ahnung wie das auf Deutsch heißt... Müsste Roter Sturm oder so ähnlich heißen...
@@mcbrite hab mich vielleicht vertippt:( Vielen Dank für deinen Kommentar und den Tipp
@@mcbrite blutroter sturm heißt es:)
+12!! Lol that key is the most ez in this S4 🤣
@@alanzavala292 but halls are not so popular;)
@@alanzavala292 and i dont know why but halls key most of the time went well
ultra low dmg for 527
@@fhjkghdfsgh hey mate and thank you for your comment, damage is really low youre right. But nokhud is just not my favourite dungeon and it was not a good Performance of me 😞 There is more dmg possible for Sure:)
great video! what weak auras/addons do you run
hey mate, thx for your comment. i use this addons: - elvui - plater nameplates - gtfo - weakaura luxthos - details - dbm you can find them all on curse =) or do you need the links?
Es wird auch deutsches lets play beim addon geben. Ich muss nur mein Headset davor nochmal richtig einstellen 😅
Last key with rogue for the season. I declined to rank 6 but thats ok. Lets see what the addon will bring to assa;)
Thx 4 the key guys, this run was pretty smooth and it was really fun. Next time i will do bigger pulls=)
Great run!
@@Avashil96 thank you for your comment. What did you like most and which is your preferred dungeon?
Thank you very much for tanking and healing, was not a good performance of me, but i dont like halls and it costs me 6 months of lifetime everytime i went in there Vielen Dank fürs Tanken und Heilen, war nicht mein Abend heute aber der Key ist getimed. Es kostet mich jedes Mal gefühlt ein halbes Jahr Lebenszeit wenn ich in den Hallen der Infusion bin Pretty nice group and i hope we will play together soon!
Medium rare at 03:20 so funny😂
You are so HOT😍
it was such a good run and a great party, i hope we will play together soon!🎉I am really sorry for the mistake in the Thumbnail. its fortified and not tyrannical
Dreamcarver doesn't need to be used but once for the permanent buff. risking losing important leech when needed. Nice run!
@@EllisForeman-k3t i know what you mean but i dont know and i have never watched which buff i get. Because the tooltip says it depends on enemy maybe i have a look this evening
@@EllisForeman-k3t thank you for your comment :)
Thx 4 the tip mate
@@Freakfiech There's some info out there but different enemies give a permanent buff until used again or the weapon is unequipped. Beasts grant 10% additional leach below 50% health I believe, taking a lot of pressure off healers during big pulls or high keys. I macro'ed this into DM and a bunch of healers PM'ed me so figured Id share. Solid run tho, was not intending to nit pick or anything.
@@EllisForeman-k3t I found a list of buffs if youre interested www.method.gg/guides/list-of-dragonflight-season-3-special-weapons
The key was not easy but we made it in time :) Pala was a little bit toxic at the end, but im am happy that we finished it. Thanks for tank and heal , you were doing well. You should never let anyone bring you down. 🎉
Warrior was really good and thanks for heal and tanking 🎉
Thx guys for the party and the fun. It´s not my best key but i dont like this dungeon as melee -.- i am happy i dont need to go there more often
nice vid, and i love your interface
Thanks mate, Do you want more information about it? Im trying to get 3k rio. But its Not so easy 😂
Wow
War ein guter Key, danke dafür ;)
Gar kein Problem, hat uns allen ja etwas gebracht 🎉
Bekommt man da nicht Epilepsie? 😂
@@machete7846 sieht das als caster anders aus? Man gewöhnt sich voll dran, es ist nicht so schlimm wie es aussieht:)
Hab ich gerne gemacht
Können auch gerne noch mehr laufen, brauche noch ein paar keys😂😂
This key was really fun and greetings to All of the Party members! Thanks scorp for tanking and of course for healing:) Hope we will play together soon.
Key didnt start perfect but we made it well. I think we had a bug at the 3 Tree boss but finally i was able to record a run where no one left the group and key was in time.
What do you think about them removing shadowdance from the rogue for assassination tree? like, i think this skill is essential for Assassination man, we need to be stealth to play literally...
I think its sad about the dmg and crit boost. But sometimes you can use vanish instead. Just make sure that you need vanish with your 2 min cds. Stealth is essential for us, but i think we will find a way to Do as good dmg as before. Maybe they will boost some other stuff 😅
Thank you for your comment mate🎉
Bigger problem in my opinion is Indiscriminate Carnage in m+. The time was beeing reduced and its more difficult to apply your bleeds to the enemys. Dont forget the global cooldown which also takes time. Not 4 seconds, but time you could apply garrote for example
@@yeaboi9686 otherwise its Not such a big dmg loss as you think. Garrote does roughly 14% of your damage overall in a key. This means from 100% improved garrote uptime to 0% improved garrote uptime, you would be losing 4.6% of your overall damage From rogue discord which is proved with sims
Nice video mr Rogue, i was the warrior in the run!
This key was fun and it worked all well:) I hope that we will play together soon. I see that i missed to cut the end of the bossfight. I will Do add the missing seconds tomorrow evening. Thank you for the key mate :)
@@Freakfiech PEW PEW - Hunter 🤪
Pew pew worked pretty well 😂
I'll try to become rank 10 of assa rogues on my Server. There are only 25 rio missing. Maybe i can reach rank 10 this weekend:) Thx 4 watching
wtf am i looking at? what are all those numbers? how do you understand what is happening?
Dont you know the game?
i m the pal XD
@@Playmographic that was a nice run. But affix was really hard last week
Thank you for the nice run guys, this key was really fun. Hopefully we can play together soon! The WL was just unbelievable =)
Haha thank u :D /Locklisa
Maybe we play together soon, but the World is so big. But it was a nice run and really made fun 🎉
yo mate, why no crimson tempest?
Because i takes too long to apply All bleeds and enemys wont live long enough. In some dungeons or some weeks crimson tempest is usefull. It depends on grp also, if you have 2 other dds which will Do heavy damage crimson tempest wont last long :/. I like to play with crimson, but sometimes its just not useful :(