วีดีโอ

i love brian

Correct

I don't know if he's the best he controlled everybody and dominated the game but I don't know if I would consider him the best

U should've done a video on Sarah lacina

Chris Daugherty would like a word

I think you should do one on Richard hatch as well

Tony’s style of play is from Russell Hantz!!! Russell was the OG to play aggressively and the most influential player even to Tony. The only reason Russell didn’t win his two first seasons is because he was hated so much by the players.

Winning back to back is much more impressive than winning, flopping and being 2nd boot, then winning again sorry Tony. Also I don’t think it can be understated how much certain players like Nick, Wendell and Adam were creaming their pants at the thought of handing a 2nd win to a guy they all idolized.

We never saw the ice man in advantageland, he could be a savage

I hope you start doing top 20 rankings or analysis videos, your content is amazing.

I think Brian was the first player you could guess was going to win by the time the merge rolled around. Once Ken went home, it was over.

Thailand is not a good season, but Brian is a great player.

She clealry isnt because she has a fatal flaw. She stinks at physical challenges and a total diva

There’s also the luck based element to the game. With the cast, the challenges thrown at you at the right time. The fact that he could come off as condescending and could seem very untrustworthy.

My Favorite Survivor of all time!!!

This is such an amazing analysis

Tops the psychopath rankings for sure

I dont care what anyone says - Heidik is the GOAT. put him in 100 seasons with random people and where nobody knows anything about the other people playing and Heidik will have the highest winning %...... and he's probably going to make top 6 every time

Dude, you can't talk about Survivor Thailand without at least a mention of "The attack zone" lmao

You forgot to mention the most important skills needed to win Survivor. "Skating skills! because usually on skater you have to be ice-cold, can't lose your cool. You gotta be like ice.."

YES ! 100 % BRIAN HEIDIK

Hit the nail on the head when talkiny about his social game at the end. Subscribed

1:30 disagree, Ghost Island is the worst in the shows history

love these videos? are going to do one for boston rob?

Goddess. Legend. And she is the moment

I think winners at war proved this is nowhere close to being true.

the only thing i would critique about tony is his game in game changers where he literally announced his intention to find an idol which is bad but hes still the best player of all time imo

Incredible video, your channel deserves more recognition

I knew the final entry would be either Tony or Bob Crowley. (Just kidding ) Love it. Thank you. Tom and Tony make great bookends. I think they're really the two best. Tony played a third time getting a little more gold. I really look forward to what you make after this series. Despite what the previous comment says the views are actually incredible, considering how new your channel is and how few videos there are and you don't do any promotion outside just uploading good content.

I know you haven't gotten a ton of views on these, but I want to say that your scripts for these videos are very sharp and that your editing is really fun. I really do enjoy these videos as an interesting way of arguing on behalf of certain players, and it's definitely a fun thought exercise. It's a shame that you do not have plans to continue with this series, as I do think you could also make legitimate claims for Jeremy Collins (the optimizer of Survivor's most effective strategy: meat shielding), Parvati Shallow (master of position play across three different seasons), Earl Cole (a practical savant who never watched the game yet who won the first unanimous jury), Denise Stapley (played a textbook Survivor winning season that would succeed across multiple different seasons), Todd Herzog (a top-level thinker who built one of the strongest alliances in Survivor), or even Cirie Fields (who is statistically the most likely to have won the most seasons, but for poorly planned twists). These were very fun to watch, and I think you put some great effort into these. Of course, the question of who is actually best at the game is incredibly difficult to discern, given the often highly misleading nature of the Survivor edit. My personal belief is that Tony and Sandra both have equally good claims to the title, by virtue of them each being optimized to win certain categories of seasons. Sandra's skillset is optimized for juries that favor social bonds (roughly half of all Survivor seasons) and Tony's is optimized for juries that favor theatrical gameplay (roughly half of all Survivor seasons). Under no circumstances could Sandra win Cagayan. Under no circumstances could Tony win Pearl Islands or Heroes vs Villains. Sandra has been given editorial credit for besting Tony once. Tony won a season that Sandra lost. Tony is the best "offensive" Survivor player the game as ever seen, Sandra the best "defensive." Both equal Parvati, Kim, and Tom as masters of position play: rarely if ever is it anyone else's best move to cut them as both are incredibly good at making it seem as if they are reasonable bets to take to the end. Thanks for making these--they were very fun.

Do Parvati next

This video was more entertaining than One World.

Why only 2 videos ?

Loved seeing Tom gaslight Ian worse than I ever seen anyone gaslit on national TV and then tried to vote him out final 4.... twice

My favorite player, and the best player. You did Brian justice with this video.

To me he is the best ever. When I watch Survivor I am not expecting someone I could like as a friend. I like to watch somebody like him. He is so good at hiding his true colors. He is the perfect example of a true survivor. The producer and Jeff hated him so much because like u said he broke their code. That is why he was never invited.

please make more videos

Yes, the most powerful winner, Mr Freeze

Love that you give Clay credit! He’s really not the best, but his social game is 100% underrated.

He was Mr Freeze for a reason because he put feelings away and just did business

Agree... Tom and Tony were the greatest ever imo.

Love this. Could you do what if videos

Not the best, but my favourite and an actual unique winner. It was thought impossible to hide who you really were for weeks on end, but Brian managed it. He was a different person to everyone on his tribe and all of them couldn't believe he wasn't the lovable soccer dad he had come across as. The first truly dominant player. People love to say he almost lost to Clay.. I think they should get over him winning already, because the 4-3 vote shit always come across really salty lol.

How am I subscribed?