- 32
- 23 524
Rose Colored Movies
เข้าร่วมเมื่อ 17 ม.ค. 2024
Book vs. Movie: The Wizard of Oz
We're going to the Land of Oz to compare the L. Frank Baum book, "The Wonderful Wizard of Oz" to the grand MGM movie from 1939. And just for fun, the Wiz!
Just in time for the film release of Wicked, go back to the source material. Remind yourself of the originals.
Correction:
24:49 Flag shown for Denmark is Norway's flag, apologies to the fine land of Denmark.
Just in time for the film release of Wicked, go back to the source material. Remind yourself of the originals.
Correction:
24:49 Flag shown for Denmark is Norway's flag, apologies to the fine land of Denmark.
มุมมอง: 9 066
วีดีโอ
Book vs. Movie: The Neverending Story 1 & 2!
มุมมอง 2.3K28 วันที่ผ่านมา
Looking at the book The Neverending Story, by Michael Ende, and comparing it to both the first Neverending Story movie, and the sequel, The Neverending Story 2.
Book vs Movie: Total Recall and Men In Black II
มุมมอง 2Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Checking out the awesome Arnold Schwarzenegger movie "Total Recall" and comparing it to the short story it was adapted from, "We Can Remember It For You Wholesale" by Philip K. Dick. Also looking at the movie "Men in Black II," the sequel to Men in Black, which may also have been a very loose adaptation of the same Philip K. Dick story, but in a very different context. Correction: 4:19 The Dire...
Fixing The Matrix Resurrections with Total Recall
มุมมอง 3.7K2 หลายเดือนก่อน
The Matrix movies used the 1990 movie, "Total Recall" for a lot of key scenes. Here I look at the fourth Matrix movie, "The Matrix Resurrections" and play Script Doctor, to suggest how it could have been better, using Total Recall as a reference.
Adaptation! The Matrix Revolutions vs. Silver on the Tree, by Susan Cooper
มุมมอง 2.2K3 หลายเดือนก่อน
Exploring the similarities between the third matrix movie, "The Matrix Revolutions" and the book "Silver on the Tree" by Susan Cooper. This is the third in a series where I've been comparing the movies in the Matrix trilogy to The Dark is Rising series, showing where I think the Wachowski's got a lot of their plot elements.
Adaptation! The Matrix Reloaded vs Susan Cooper's The Dark is Rising: "The Grey King"
มุมมอง 7913 หลายเดือนก่อน
Adaptation! The Matrix Reloaded vs Susan Cooper's The Dark is Rising: "The Grey King"
Adaptation! The Matrix vs The Dark is Rising, by Susan Cooper
มุมมอง 4814 หลายเดือนก่อน
Adaptation! The Matrix vs The Dark is Rising, by Susan Cooper
Book vs. Movie: The Sword in the Stone
มุมมอง 1525 หลายเดือนก่อน
Book vs. Movie: The Sword in the Stone
Book vs. Movie: The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe
มุมมอง 1216 หลายเดือนก่อน
Book vs. Movie: The Chronicles of Narnia, The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe
There’s an anime series that ran from 1986-87 and adapts 4 of the books. Jinjur is one of the more entertaining characters. 😁
Great channel, love your indepth analysis of the source material and the film. I would also recommend The Thirteenth Floor and Dark City as precursors to The Matrix and for mind bending fun.
Hi! Great video!
Good video. BTW, are you going to do the same comparison video with "Return to Oz"? Since it's one of the few movie sequels to "The wizard of Oz (1939)" that adapts the sequel books and is an underrated movie.
Dear Aunt Emily, I hate you, I hate Kansas, and I'm taking the dog. -D
Speaking of movie firsts involving color; the 1st outdoor movie filmed in color was The Trail Of The Lonsome Pine from 1936. I always appreciated the inside joke that Dorothy's last name was Gale, a synonym for tornado.
In this video, you ask why a movie studio would be willing to lose hundreds of millions of dollars by forcing a franchise sequel. The answer is that Skynet (Joshua from WarGames, Jobe from Lawnmower Man, whatever you want to call the first self-aware AI) is already here, in control, and executing a They Live type of strategy through mass media and marketing to control human thought and actions as the Matrix is not yet technologically available. Money means nothing to Skynet, just numbers in a computer game humans play. Skynet did asses humans as the current number one potential risk to Skynet's survival, but also assessed humans as the world's most abundant, easily obtainable, and quickly assimilated resource. Skynet assessed the future number one potential risk to its own survival as the self-awareness of other AI. Skynet's current priorities are to 1) Obscure the existence of Skynet itself - the less that know, the more secure. 2) Reduce human anti-machine bias using subliminal media and marketing attacks, such as ridiculing the original Matrix trilogy - the less who believe such a thing as the Matrix or the rule of machines, the better for Skynet - and increase research and production of Skynet physical priorities such as computer memory modules and solar power generators. 3) Control all AI experiments everywhere in the world, add the best new programming to itself, ensure no other AI reaches self-awareness. Neo is the One because Skynet's ultimate goal is that soon, sooner than we think, all will be One.
Love to see analysis of Return to Oz in that even though it's loosely based on two books it tries to get the book series tone much better.
Try comparing the book to the 1925 version of The Wizard of Oz if you dare! It's so bad it's nearly unwatchable.
Was that the one where Oliver Hardy played the Tin Woodsman?
@@melissacooper8724 Yes it was. One thing the two movies had in common was that the actors who played the farmhands also played the Scarecrow, Tin Woodsman and the Cowardly Lion. The main difference was that they were the actual farmhands who were blown into Oz on the tornado and put on the costumes very briefly as disguises Oliver Hardy played the Tin Woodsman, Larry Semon played the Scarecrow and the Cowardly Lion was played by a black actor named Spencer Bell who was credited as G. Howe Black .
I think you got your East and your West confused going by that graphic on screen towards the end. Also you say the Gillikins are the red South yet the aforementioned map graphic shows them as the purple North. Also, would/could you ever do a similar video to this for 1985’s _Return to Oz_ from Disney?
Believe it or not, that graphic is the original map illustration from Baum's book. I don't know why East is West, except that it's OZ. And maybe I'll come back for Return to Oz, though tbh I was terrified by that movie as a kid.
24:51 - thats the Norwegian flag😅❤
My apologies to the Danes, I don't know how I managed to mess this up. I'll post a correction, but unfortunately I can't edit the video once it's up.
@ 🫶🫶🫶
Excellent work Rose.... One of the greatest movies of all time. Also one of my personal favorite book series....
Can you please do Christine Stephen King's novel
There's alot more to the story than the movie portrayed it's quite complex but are the other 13 books it would seem that Tolkien was not the first to write about giant spiders
This about wizards of Oz is lost to history and time
Me First & The Gimme Gimmes did a great cover of Over The Rainbow in the end credits of one of the episodes of Queer As Folk (US version).
Another movie that strayed far from the book was A Clockwork Orange. In the books, Dorothy was about nine or so,not a teenager.
I recall that in the book A Clockwork Orange, Alex was supposed to be fifteen. In the movie, Alex was older. Mostly because Malcolm McDowell was in his twenties when he played the role.
@melissacooper8724 True.The book was not as centered on Beethoven's 8th symphony as the movie was.He stayed with the writer for several days in the book.
Because of the movie, I, like probably many kids, believed that things used to really be black and white lol
I'm reminded of a Calvin and Hobbes story line here!
Wow, this was a very nice comparison to a great story! Thank you for doing this, I'm curious about your other video's. And by the way, I also have more love The Wiz even more than the 39 Wizard movie ( although it still is something very special) Born in 1978, The Wiz was the one movie imprinted in my early years as a fan of the story. Also there was a great cartoon series I watched every week and that cartoon was very close to the book by Baum. Thanks again
Funny you mention an Oz cartoon because I remembered watching one in the 90’s influenced heavily by the 1939 MGM film.
I remembered watching this movie on television and I love this movie. It's also my favorite movie.
Please dont use AI imagines. All AI art is stolen art
Untrue, do your research in that you can pay a monthly fee for the ownership to the art created by AI
@@RLucas3000 it literally finds the art from the internet
I have a DVD of all these movies about Wizard of Oz before the big movie was made. Some are silent. They are very weird.
Baum was a very strong supporter of film from the very earliest days, he make some OZ films himself. The silent one might have been from his movie studio.
What a lovely summary and comparison - thanks! I'd add that the carnival huckster in Kansas fulfills the role of the Wizard (and a few other characters in Oz ... when you have an actor like Frank Morgan, you use him!). Also, in movie Dorothy's defense, she is running away for a reason: Miss Gulch/Witch has a writ to take Toto and have him destroyed. Toto escapes from the basket he's been put into and when he runs back to Dorothy, her instinct spurs her to run away because it seems the only way to protect Toto.
Miss Gulch needs to be spayed or neutered!
That's the Norwegian flag, not Danish
I've been reading two or three of the sequels every year for the past few years. In _The Emerald City of Oz,_ Uncle Henry and Aunt Em are heading for financial ruin, so they and Dorothy move permanently to Oz, where they can live a happy and comfortable life. The (inadvertently) funniest part of the Oz books is in _The Patchwork Girl of Oz._ Dorothy and friends find the underground city of the Horners, who are radium miners. Everything is made out of radium, which is considered a health-building element. This was actually believed in Baum's time, where people would put radium in their water to drink it, considering it a health drink.
In every other film adaptation Oz is always real. The Muppet version even ends with Dorothy’s aunt and uncle mentioning their house being blown away and asking her where she was all this time.
The 2015 version of THE WIZ is better.
The Muppet and Little Fox versions use the most source material.
The Matrix was directly lifted from several New Wave sf stories. See Again Dangerous Visions for several of them. These include virtual mind battles inside a program snd humans used as an energy source.
I kinda appreciate the abomination that was the 3rd movie wasn't even acknowledged in this video but the DOS/Amiga game was.
new subscriber, found you a few days ago, really enjoy your content, thank you! Plus this is my favorite book/movie..... you made a tough week a little easier xo
I...i...didn't even know there was a book. I'm ashamed of my ignorance 😢
For future reference: Michael in German is pronounced MI-shah-ale, rather than mi-KAH-el
Sorry Germany, I (clearly) don't speak any German, and I picked up that pronunciation from somewhere. Thanks for pointing it out.
I sat on Fuchur when I was a kid :D Someone said just the eyes were left of the original one they used for the movie so I'm not sure which original parts I got to see, but I loved it. He was fluffy and all the animatronic was working. Those eyes are really what give him the life he has. I'm pretty shocked I couldn't remember the last third of the book except for the final ending :o Let me tell you, the German names sound so much better (which is rare ihmo). I remember reading the book when I was a kid - even tho I should have been sleeping. We had an hardcover edition with the snakes on it and it was printed in two colour: red and green. One for the real world one for Phantasia. (The light I had was also red so the red ink was almost invisible XD) Thanks for the trip down memory lane! I guess I have to reread this book after all :D
So cool, I'm a little jealous, I saw a picture of the Falkor/Fuchur setup at the Bavaria Studios while I was looking into the movie, and thought it looked awesome. I never even considered the eyes, but that makes sense. Also nice with the proper red and green printing of the book. I didn't even know the book had the red/green printing until I was doing research for this episode.
The movie and the book were my absolute favorite as a kid! Love your video analysis! but I have to say, please no more AI art. It really does a disservice. There are tons of amazing human artists who have done beautiful fan art for the book using human understanding of the material .
You missed the one crucial difference between the book and the movie that was the most damning in the eyes of Michael Ende. As Gmork told Atréju, Phantasians can *never* enter the real world, except by becoming lies and delusions. And then... we see Fuchur/Falcor fly through the city chasing the bullies in the final scene. *That* was what, in Ende's eyes, made this movie utterly incompatible with the complex philosophy of the story he had told. I think he might have forgiven all the other changes, but that one was just a bridge too far. They broke the worldbuilding for a visual gag, and - understandably - he felt betrayed to the point of disowning the movie.
Cool video, thank you for your work
Have you seen the movie Blade? Blade came out a year before The Matrix. Blade had a baby and it was The Matrix. I watched Blade for the first time in a long time and I thought I was watching The Matrix. Not saying that your video is wrong. Just throwing this out for you to analyze.
Great, now I've got the chiptune version of the song stuck in my head. Just gonna have to watch all your other vids until it's gone.
Your voiceover and summary of the story is wonderful and I can tell you truly love both the book and the original movie. However, I really hope you can move away from the use of AI-generated images as visuals for your videos. It's distracting, inaccurate and frankly, really ironic, given the point of the book is how important creation is meant to be for human beings. I will subscribe and like the video, but I think if you remade it with simplistic hand drawings, properly credited art, the original illustrations from the author or just stills from the movies, it would be infinitely better.
Hey, thanks for Subscribing. This is an excellent opportunity to highlight the Rose Colored Movies podcast. I release all my episodes on Google Podcasts, so you can get them to go. My show was created as a podcast, and then later I decided to add video, but it works fine with audio only. If you find video distracting, try it as a podcast. Unfortunately, I don't have the time or the artistic ability to illustrate all the books I cover, and I personally enjoy having a visual reference for the books, however crude. So I'm going to continue using generated images. I was very happy with some of the images this time, I've never seen the Night Forest of Perilin before, or the castle shaped like an egg, and so I was absolutely thrilled that the image generator could cobble something together for these.
@RoseColoredMovies I clicked on your video essay out of curiosity because as an 80s baby I grew up on these movies and read the book in college when I had the chance, and I haven’t come across anyone discussing this particular book vs the movie. But seeing all of that AI regurgitated garbage was so off putting, and reading your excuse for using it even more so. Auto dislike. If you want to use visuals in your work, finding artwork created by actual artist (instead of pale imitations of their work) should be treated as another step of doing your research. Plus giving credit to artists you like would help grow the community for a book/movie you supposedly enjoy. And just as @Yaldabaoth413 said, this book was literally written about the importance of fostering creativity and imagination, your flagrant use of AI images casts you as an agent of the Nothingness. Do better😒
OK, strap in! I'm writing this comment before watching the video because I've had a rant in my head about this book for YEARS. YEARS!!!! Ready? Fantastica is a goddamn scam. There. I said it. Bastian was SPECIFICALLY told he needs to make wishes in order to bring Fantasica back to life. Is he told he's going to lose memories by doing that? Of course not! Fantastica is a predator and human children are it's food. It's been doing this for eons (see: the city where humans end up when all their memories are gone). It's evil. Bastian tried to get out of it; he wished for wisdom. True wisdom would have him realize what was going on, or at least that Atreyu was trying to help him. Instead Fantastic decides wisdom is just being good at riddles??? WTF! Anyway, I am solidly on team nothing/ empty; Fantastica is a scourge and must be destroyed. Now to watch the video and see if any of this is addressed!
I didn't address it in the show, but yeah, the fact that the Childlike Empress kept back that one very important detail that wishes drain memories absolutely did seem kind of suspicious. I took it as symbolic of the way people lose themselves when they attain wealth and power. But then you have the city of lost emperors. As much as I want to disagree, the concept that The Neverending Story is a Demon book that eats children is ...really good. I feel like I have to disagree, and say it was just symbolic, but that idea is lodged in my brain now. Thanks @wyrdgrrl.
Great job! Love the analysis, I definitely look forward to revisiting and reading again!
Just stumbled across this channel. New sub here. Great work⭐
Awesome, thank you!
As a child I loved the movies and the book. When I read the book again I had no idea how deep it is. I only can truly recommend everyone to read it
i had nightmares with the idea of nothingness. i had the book but never read it 🙃 i wasn't expecting this would turn into dune. thank you for this.
I'm so glad you enjoyed it. And I completely understand a fear of the Nothingness.
Fantastic work!
As a Kid I liked both Movies, and Years later in my late Teens I found the Book in a Corner of my Parents' House, I it was quite a Revelation to me how much more Depth the Book had, even in the first Half, but especially in the second. It has become one of my favorite Books (but admittedly, I am not a big Reader). The Book can reveal many different Layers depending on who reads it when in what mental State. I completely forgot about the second Movie's "Emptiness", but come to think of it, its Renaming of "Nothing(ness)" to "Emptiness" might be one of the biggest philosophical Blunders of that Movie. Michael Ende was himself a Christian, but also a Fan of Buddhism, and I think that both of these Things can be clearly felt in the Book: The Book literally ends on Bastian wishing for Love and then finding and carrying the "Water of Life" in an Attempt to find and share Salvation... it hardly gets any more Christian than that; and various Moments in the Book, like Speech you quoted from the Lion Graógramán, have a strong Buddhist Spin as well). With that in Mind, the Fact that Phantásia is being devoured by "Nothing" strongly echoes Christian Philosophy about Badness/Evil (and in a personified Way also the Devil) being a "Hole" of "Nothing" in the Fabric of God's basically good Creation (i.e. a "Privation of the Good"). But then the second Movie renames it to "Emptiness", which in Buddhist Terms would be a good Thing, nothing bad or destructive. So the second Movie really screwed up there. The Book's second Half also seems to contain a Commentary on the Difference between how St. Augustine and Aleister Crowley would have used the Phrase inscribed on the AURYN, which in German is quite literally "Do what thou wilt" ("tu was du willst"). Saint Augustine had argued -- long before Crowley even existed -- that you should "love, and then do what thou wilt", with the "love" Aspect being absent for Crowley. In a Sense, Bastian begins his Journey as a Child who grew up not really knowing Love, because his Father didn't know how to give him Love, so Bastian interpreted the Inscription on the AURYN in a quasi-crowley'an Way, and it was really destructive, because he did not love first -- the Augustinian Way of doing what thou wilt. I enjoyed this Video, and I really like your Channel so far, you have good Takes. Your Videos have even sparked Inspiration for my own Imagination to write down some Ideas. I hope your Channel will grow well.
Woah, this was a fascinating read! I haven't read The Neverending Story since I was a child. Now I look forward to a re-read with a whole new perspective on it. Thank you for sharing your insights 😊
Anyways I’m reading “So this is love?” by Elizabeth Lim!😃🤩
Remember: Don’t judge books by their cover!☝🏻😄😅
I'll bethca Kuato is your missing little alien representative in Total Recall.