Historically Speaking
Historically Speaking
  • 75
  • 42 134
PMO Former Advisor Sanjaya Baru Reveals about How Congress Party ignored P V Narasimha Rao !
PMO Former Advisor Sanjaya Baru Reveals about How Congress Party ignored P V Narasimha Rao !
P. V. Narasimha Rao (or PV as he was popularly known) has been widely praised for enabling the economic reforms that transformed the country in 1991.
#narsimharao #aishwaryapandit #historicallyspeaking
About Channel:
Historically Speaking is a unique TH-cam channel that delves into the fascinating world of politics and art. Our channel is dedicated to exploring the intersection of history, politics, and culture through engaging conversations and insightful interviews. From in-depth discussions on contemporary political issues to thought-provoking analyses of historical events, our channel offers a platform for diverse perspectives and opinions. We also delve into the world of art, exploring the ways in which it reflects and shapes our understanding of history and society. Join us on a journey of discovery and exploration as we uncover the stories and ideas that shape our world.
Follow Us:
TH-cam - shorturl.at/dvBY5
Instagram - shorturl.at/kBHIU
มุมมอง: 55

วีดีโอ

Sanjaya Baru explains 'How PV Narasimha Rao Made History' in 1991 ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 2417 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Sanjaya Baru explains 'How PV Narasimha Rao Made History' in 1991 ? | Historically Speaking P. V. Narasimha Rao (or PV as he was popularly known) has been widely praised for enabling the economic reforms that transformed the country in 1991. #narsimharao #aishwaryapandit #historicallyspeaking About Channel: Historically Speaking is a unique TH-cam channel that delves into the fascinating world ...
Know the Hidden Story behind The Accidental Prime Minister | Sanjaya Baru | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 612 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Know the Hidden Story behind The Accidental Prime Minister | Sanjaya Baru | Historically Speaking In this Podcast with Sanjay Baru he explains the story behind writing The Accidental Prime Minister The Accidental Prime Minister: The Making and Unmaking of Manmohan Singh is a 2014 memoir by Indian policy analyst Sanjaya Baru, who was Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's media advisor from May 2004 to...
How Social And Political Transformations that led to the Decline of Congress explains Sanjay Baru !
มุมมอง 492 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Social And Political Transformations that led to the Decline of Congress explains Sanjay Baru In a vodcast with Sanjay Baru, He explains about how Regional Leadership of the congress that became weaker and weaker vis a vis National Leader then. #sanjaybaru #historicallyspeaking #regionalleadership #congress #aishwaryapandit About Channel: Historically Speaking is a unique TH-cam channel that de...
Know in depth about Sanjay Baru's India’s Power Elite: Historically Speaking | Episode 11
มุมมอง 1.9K7 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Know in depth about Sanjay Baru's India’s Power Elite: Historically Speaking | Episode 11 In India’s Power Elite: Class, Caste and a Cultural Revolution, Sanjaya Baru explores change and continuity in the making and workings of India’s power elite, moving from the colonial period to the decades since independence. The book offers an engaging account of the changing nature of the Indian state an...
How Indian Elite has been the thin layer of the society explains Sanjay Baru ! Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 30212 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
What Is India's power elite? How is it connected to particular caste or class. How far India has evolved since 1947? In India’s Power Elite: Class, Caste and a Cultural Revolution, Sanjaya Baru explores change and continuity in the making and workings of India’s power elite, moving from the colonial period to the decades since independence. The book offers an engaging account of the changing na...
Why Ayodhya Is a Cause For Celebration, Not Complacency, Explains Dr. Meenakshi Jain
มุมมอง 9514 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Why Ayodhya Is a Cause For Celebration, Not Complacency, Explains Dr. Meenakshi Jain Indian Ancestors did not give up the basis of temple and image worship The Long Struggle For Dharma: Ayodhya Is a Cause For Celebration, Not Complacency #contemporaryindia #aishwaryapandit #historicallyspeaking #ayodya #ayodhyamandir In a Podcast of Historically Speaking, Meenakshi Jain will be seen with Dr. Ai...
Know the truth behind Mathura Shahi Eidgah Dispute | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 3914 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Know the truth behind Mathura Shahi Eidgah dispute | Know The slow Reclamation which has been a Great injustice to Hindu says Dr. Meenakshi Jain. In a Podcast of Historically Speaking, Meenakshi Jain will be seen with Dr. Aishwarya Pandit. Meenakshi is an Indian political scientist and historian who served as an associate professor of history at Gargi College, Delhi. In 2014, she was nominated ...
Know the Hidden Truth of Sambhal Violence, Since Unfolding history might result in destructions !
มุมมอง 5416 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Know the Hidden Truth of Sambhal Violence, Since Unfolding history might result in destructions ! | Historically Speaking #aishwaryapandit #historicallyspeaking #sambhal #sambhalviolence In a Podcast of Historically Speaking, Meenakshi Jain will be seen with Dr. Aishwarya Pandit. Meenakshi is an Indian political scientist and historian who served as an associate professor of history at Gargi Co...
Facts about Oldest sculpture of Devi Saraswati, Pedestal Found in Mathura | Dr. Meenakshi Jain
มุมมอง 57216 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Facts about Oldest sculpture of Devi Saraswati, Pedestal Found in Mathura | Dr. Meenakshi Jain Oldest sculpture of Goddess Saraswathi in India. The excavations at the site of Kankali Tila in Mathura revealed a sculpture of the goddess, dated to 132 CE. It was donated by a Jain metal worker. In a Podcast of Historically Speaking, Meenakshi Jain will be seen with Dr. Aishwarya Pandit. Meenakshi i...
Know the interesting fact about 630 inscriptions on Sanchi Stupa, out of which only 3 has royalty !
มุมมอง 4819 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Know the interesting fact about 630 inscriptions on Sanchi Stupa, out of which only 3 has royalty ! Oldest sculpture of Goddess Saraswati in India. The excavations at the site of Kankali Tila in Mathura revealed a sculpture of the goddess, dated to 132 CE. It was donated by a Jain metal worker. #aishwaryapandit #historicallyspeaking #meenakshijain #sanchistupa #sanchi About Channel: Historicall...
What Is India's power elite ? How far India has evolved since 1947 ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 29619 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
What Is India's power elite ? How far India has evolved since 1947 ? | Historically Speaking What Is India's power elite? How is it connected to particular caste or class. How far India has evolved since 1947? In India’s Power Elite: Class, Caste and a Cultural Revolution, Sanjaya Baru explores change and continuity in the making and workings of India’s power elite, moving from the colonial per...
Know the hidden truth of Contemporary India and Medieval Period | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 69921 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา
Know the hidden truth of Contemporary India and Medieval Period | Historically Speaking
Know the Truth behind Ban on Sati Pratha by Bentinck, How did the message spread then ?Historically
มุมมอง 242วันที่ผ่านมา
Know the Truth behind Ban on Sati Pratha by Bentinck, How did the message spread then ?Historically
Why the section that demanded partition did not migrate to Pakistan ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 8Kวันที่ผ่านมา
Why the section that demanded partition did not migrate to Pakistan ? | Historically Speaking
What was the Interplay between politics and history in Contemporary India ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 30914 วันที่ผ่านมา
What was the Interplay between politics and history in Contemporary India ? | Historically Speaking
Know The History Behind Caste Census in India | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 1.1Kหลายเดือนก่อน
Know The History Behind Caste Census in India | Historically Speaking
Why are Youth getting increasingly involved in the debates of caste census ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 844หลายเดือนก่อน
Why are Youth getting increasingly involved in the debates of caste census ? | Historically Speaking
What is the caste census ? And why did the opposition wanted it ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 356หลายเดือนก่อน
What is the caste census ? And why did the opposition wanted it ? | Historically Speaking
Know the history of Psephology in the Indian Election | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 964 หลายเดือนก่อน
Know the history of Psephology in the Indian Election | Historically Speaking
Truth behind how Rajiv Gandhi was brought down by old India ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 224 หลายเดือนก่อน
Truth behind how Rajiv Gandhi was brought down by old India ? | Historically Speaking
Why did then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi go in for election and lose? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 444 หลายเดือนก่อน
Why did then Prime Minister Indira Gandhi go in for election and lose? | Historically Speaking
How Prime Minister went beyond small motives, to serve larger goals ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 1724 หลายเดือนก่อน
How Prime Minister went beyond small motives, to serve larger goals ? | Historically Speaking
Political India is about one person: How Prime Minister Decides ? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 2.1K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
Political India is about one person: How Prime Minister Decides ? | Historically Speaking
How Prime Ministers Decide? An unprecedented Explosive journey at how decisions are taken ?
มุมมอง 2.3K4 หลายเดือนก่อน
How Prime Ministers Decide? An unprecedented Explosive journey at how decisions are taken ?
UP Election Analysis: Is Akhilesh Yadav the Real Winner Over Rahul Gandhi? | Historically Speaking
มุมมอง 1734 หลายเดือนก่อน
UP Election Analysis: Is Akhilesh Yadav the Real Winner Over Rahul Gandhi? | Historically Speaking
A Tale of Two Parliaments: From UK’s Engaging Debates to Suppressed PM Voice in Sansad
มุมมอง 854 หลายเดือนก่อน
A Tale of Two Parliaments: From UK’s Engaging Debates to Suppressed PM Voice in Sansad
From Scandal to Security: Did India's Cyber Revolution Gains Momentum After Nagarwala Scandal?
มุมมอง 254 หลายเดือนก่อน
From Scandal to Security: Did India's Cyber Revolution Gains Momentum After Nagarwala Scandal?
Budget 2024: Was Opposition Aggression the Real Focus of the 2024 Budget Session or a Diversion?
มุมมอง 154 หลายเดือนก่อน
Budget 2024: Was Opposition Aggression the Real Focus of the 2024 Budget Session or a Diversion?
Nagarwala Scandal: Was Indira Gandhi Truly Innocent or Politically Shielded?
มุมมอง 404 หลายเดือนก่อน
Nagarwala Scandal: Was Indira Gandhi Truly Innocent or Politically Shielded?

ความคิดเห็น

  • @Akhyayamaharana
    @Akhyayamaharana 16 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

    बहत खूब.......

  • @Avtard398
    @Avtard398 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Aa . Aaa , aaa , aaa ,aaa , excellent host

  • @Akhyayamaharana
    @Akhyayamaharana วันที่ผ่านมา

    Nice ......

  • @MSKim6563
    @MSKim6563 วันที่ผ่านมา

    🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

  • @kamleshmishra7031
    @kamleshmishra7031 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    We had to practice sati and child marriage only due to islam. Whenever they saw any hindu women, they tried soft terrorism and converted most of them. Kerala is an example of such case

  • @TheJeetChatterjee
    @TheJeetChatterjee 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

    1947 was a historic mistake by the hindu community. When india was divided based on religion, every last muslim should have been told to quit india and go to the country that was created for them by them.

  • @PJ-yp3vb
    @PJ-yp3vb 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Islamists rely on, and exploit the "Secular Keeda" in weak Hindu minds

  • @neerajfw
    @neerajfw 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    well defined ....India's power elite

  • @RamamurthyIravatham
    @RamamurthyIravatham 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Iramamurthy It is really funny that Muslims stayed back in India wanted one more partition and objecting of implementation of CAA,.NRC,.CCC, Thalak law, workship act, wakf board act. Tragedy on Hindus by anti India Congress party and their cohort Communist party who wants partition of India. India should be made Bharat Rashtra. Jai hind bharat Mata ki jai Vande matharam

  • @RamamurthyIravatham
    @RamamurthyIravatham 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Iramamurthy When India partitioned pakisthan for Muslims India should have deported all the Muslims to pakisthan Muslims. Great blunder done by great Ahimsa Preacher M.K.Gandhi and J.L.Nehru to sustain the violence in India. Jinnah and Dr.B.R.Ambedkar were advocated for the redistribution of population of muslims and Hindus to the respective Muslim country and Hindu country India..In west Bengal many Muslims did not move to East Bengal (east bengal) whereas many Hindus were tortured and killed and again in 1950 many Hindus were tortured and were compulsorily dragged out from east bengal and sent to west bengal and usurped the properties of Hindus. Had redistribution of population taken place, Indian economy would have improved drastically as of today. Greatest blunder by India now suffering heavily instead of appeasing Muslims for vote bank politics and pesedo sicklular draconian law might have been avoided. Jai hind bharat Mata ki jai Vande matharam

  • @justanotherhuman1992
    @justanotherhuman1992 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Good conversation!

  • @bhagwanbhagchandani5627
    @bhagwanbhagchandani5627 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

    THE FACTS NO PARTITION JUST BALANCING POWER OF MOSLEMS BY NEHRU DYNASTY WHO ARE ALSO MOSLEMS HIDING AS HINDUS.TODAY HINDUSTANI ARE DOMINATES AND CONTROLS BY CONGRESS AS MOSLEMS EVERY DECISION

  • @InSoloDeo
    @InSoloDeo 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The irony is so rich here!

  • @jitendranathjohari8582
    @jitendranathjohari8582 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Very well said. Nehru was responsible for this mistake against the opinion of Baba saheb and Sardar Patel . This is responsible for the troubles we are facing today,compounded by the selfish Politicians. Very well said

    • @kamleshlulla5303
      @kamleshlulla5303 51 นาทีที่ผ่านมา

      Nehru was thankful to British and Islamist for the power he got he considered Indians as slaves and petty thieves begging for bakshish before Brits

  • @ParthaSarathyIppili
    @ParthaSarathyIppili 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Why this dirty old stories???

    • @cvenkat7766
      @cvenkat7766 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      To save India from dirty politics , the country will face it in future .

    • @SriranganathHosur
      @SriranganathHosur 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      To prevent probable dirty that may again happen on Hindusthan

  • @mohsinraza2931
    @mohsinraza2931 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    It's so IRONIC that HINDUTVA THUGS claimed Partition of the nation was based on "religion" but didn't allow MUSLIM MAJORITY PROVISIONS as per 1941 census (BENGAL , PUNJAB , KASHMIR , LAKSHADWEEP) to Pakistan !!!!

  • @NpsI2050
    @NpsI2050 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Maulana let slip once: "We will accept Pakistan.. FOR NOW." Some stayed because they wanted Pak immediately AND India in future.

    • @Sthithpragnya
      @Sthithpragnya วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@NpsI2050 Which Maulana?

  • @physicsi5974
    @physicsi5974 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

    An eye for an eye makes whole world blind

  • @arsalanmirza3411
    @arsalanmirza3411 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    🤡 HOGWASH 🤮

  • @ganapatinaik7834
    @ganapatinaik7834 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    What is stopping current BJP government in centre from giving the correct version of Indian history?

  • @kamleshlulla5303
    @kamleshlulla5303 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Partition was the biggest land grabbing scam undertaken by Congress and muslims to allow Nehru to be throned because where hindu also had to vote never voted Hindus are trained to blame only, they had options to ignore Gandhi but they didn't

  • @AjcAch
    @AjcAch 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Wait few more years .1947 will repeat.Thanks to hindu seculars.

  • @ShivamKumar-cu4zf
    @ShivamKumar-cu4zf 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Yr nehru ko akal bhi nhi ayi ki agar phirse koi jinnah khda ho gya phirse dekh ke tukde honge uper se kashmir wala msla bhi bich me atka diya un jakar

  • @sramay123
    @sramay123 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    those who stayed back just to demand one more partition is this secret?

  • @balakrishnarao6818
    @balakrishnarao6818 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Ambedkar only reiterated population exchange, but our leaders bastards ignored, only way now to save hindus separate electorates only only this method save hindus.

  • @pundalikmopkar8820
    @pundalikmopkar8820 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    JAICHANDI POLITICIANS OF THAT PERIOD CHEATED HINDUS BECAUSE OF THIS UNJUST PARTITION. MOREOVER LAKHS OF HINDUS WERE SLAUGHTERED.

  • @maverick792
    @maverick792 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Finish the partition. Soon. 40 crores already.

  • @jatinpatel1224
    @jatinpatel1224 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The partition of India is not complete till population exchange is not completed. Jihaadis do not want CAA, NRC, UCC, PCC for this exact reasons and proclaim human rights.

  • @omfficial
    @omfficial 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    👍

  • @VarunStream
    @VarunStream 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    They did not leave because they knew Hindu Kafirs are divided - and sooner or later they can butcher these Hindus and claim all of India as their jaageer.

  • @Streetsmart24
    @Streetsmart24 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Stellar studio, brilliant host and an insightful guest, truly an enriching experience....

  • @aqeelkhurshid4860
    @aqeelkhurshid4860 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The so called partition is a complete myth propogated India. India was always a subcontinet and never a country before 1947. There were many independent kindgoms in this subcontinent that had been fighting and conquering each other for mellenias just like in europe. Punjab was a country. Kashmir was a country. The actual partition happened in Punjab and Bengal. At the end of the British empire, two new large counteries came into existence, the erstwhile kingdoms and states were asked join to form these new counteries. One country called itself Pakistan, the other however conscripted the name of this subcontinent for itself and this is where the confusions lies. Imagine if a large country was created in Asia which then chose to call itself Asia, that would be absurd, but that is exactly what "India" did! Remember the very words India and Hindustan come from Sindh and river Indus, both of which are located in Pakistan. The land of Indus (Pakistan) gave India its name. Indus civilisation flourished along the Indus River in Punjab and Sindh. It doesn't belong to the current state called India. Their civilisation is in Ganga /jamuna. The descendants of Indus civilisation, Sindhis and Punjabis still live in Pakistan along the Indus River

    • @DebadritoDutta
      @DebadritoDutta วันที่ผ่านมา

      Contrary to your opinion, a modern nation State is western concept, and colonial India was created by the British, yeh it's true if there was no modern nation State before consolidation, but there was the concept of Arya varta ( real name) people from West popularize as Hindustan ( the term Hindu came from Indus indeed ) which is broadly geographic term, and the religion the people of subcontinent followed was Sanatan Dharm. From ancient times Samrat Ashoka to Samundra Gupta had successfully got small capitals into larger ones. The problem with many muslims is the civilizational ethos , you follow the Abrahamic religion and we follow the belief of this land, even in Sanatani many beliefs in one God, and some sections don't even follow God just Karma. The most pathetic case is that mutual respect, not annihilation. A mediaeval tyrant in the name of Islam wipes out Iran's Jorastrians, Egypt's old religion...but only in India they can't.But in 1947 this is well established in modern history India was a country because of 200 years of colonization, that's why India have common ethos.

    • @Sthithpragnya
      @Sthithpragnya วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@aqeelkhurshid4860 Partition as myth is as good as a big mouthful of lie mind it the Direct Action Day was initiated by leaders of a certain community, Hindus/Sikhs never started it

    • @aqeelkhurshid4860
      @aqeelkhurshid4860 วันที่ผ่านมา

      You are right, what is India today as a state was created by the Brits. Arya varta only refers to an area in the north of India, not whole of it. Bharat only refers to the western part of Gangetic valley. The real origin of this subcontinent is Sindh. Indus valley civilization predates all religions present in this subcontinent today. The heart of this civilization is Sindh and Punjab. There was no concept of one identity in this subcontinent. Pashtuns which make up around 20 % of Pakistan's population have almost nothing in common with people of Kerala, Tamil Nadu, Assam, Sikkim and many other areas of present day India. Their languages are mutually unintelligible, their attire, music, literature, folklores and legends, their poetry are all different. They even look drastically different. I could say the same thing about Punjabis, Kashmir and other ethnicities in Pakistan as compared to ethnicities in India. Ashoka and Gupta did not "merge' areas. That's a convenient euphemism. Ashoka and Gupta created empires via unimaginable atrocities. All empires are brought about through conquest and violence, be it the Mughals, Brits, Arabs or any other blood thirsty ambitious war monger. It surprises me that people so eagerly appose diversity and seem so determined to foist a mono identity on others. As a pakistani I've no trouble recognising that people from Maharashtra or Andhra Pradesh may have many things in their culture and customs drastically different to mine. It doesn't bother me in the slightest. If anything it makes me curious about their culture and I wish them all the best

    • @DebadritoDutta
      @DebadritoDutta วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@aqeelkhurshid4860 good prospective, actually people that matters, as long as people celebrate their own belief without destroy social ethos. Hinduism has never been a monoisthic thought process and we accept another person's perspective. Just wish the other side will regard the same.

    • @aqeelkhurshid4860
      @aqeelkhurshid4860 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Thank you for your compliment. I think in time, probably a few generations from now or a bit longer, religion will become irrelevant in social life and become purely a personal matter, as it should. Those counteries that are most diverse, respect civil liberties and practice true free speech will become the most prosperous. There is no one version of history, there are some facts but a lot of events can be interpreted in many ways. Noone has the final word on any subject. If Europeans who had fought each other for centuries and commited untold massacres amongst themselves can free themselves of the past and become a successful continent that it is today, then surely India, Pakistan and other home nations can resolve their issues too

  • @aqeelkhurshid4860
    @aqeelkhurshid4860 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The so called partition is a complete myth propogated India. India was always a subcontinet and never a country before 1947. There were many independent kindgoms in this subcontinent that had been fighting and conquering each other for mellenias just like in europe. Punjab was a country. Kashmir was a country. The actual partition happened in Punjab and Bengal. At the end of the British empire, two new large counteries came into existence, the erstwhile kingdoms and states were asked join to form these new counteries. One country called itself Pakistan, the other however conscripted the name of this subcontinent for itself and this is where the confusions lies. Imagine if a large country was created in Asia which then chose to call itself Asia, that would be absurd, but that is exactly what "India" did! Remember the very words India and Hindustan come from Sindh and river Indus, both of which are located in Pakistan. The land of Indus (Pakistan) gave India its name. Indus civilisation flourished along the Indus River in Punjab and Sindh. It doesn't belong to the current state called India. Their civilisation is in Ganga /jamuna. The descendants of Indus civilisation, Sindhis and Punjabis still live in Pakistan along the Indus River

    • @Anonymous_7866
      @Anonymous_7866 3 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Go and read the correct history not what has been taught in your schools by your Punjabi military dictators who twisted history to glorify themselves and dominate over different ethnicities in your country. Punjab and Kashmir were never ever countries. They were just geographical areas which were ruled at different times by different rulers. As far as Indus civilisation is concerned,it was not just confined to Punjab and Sindh, a large part of it is there in Indian States of Gujarat, Rajasthan and Haryana. Pakistani Punjabis have a tendency to dominate over other people by glorifying themselves.

    • @Sthithpragnya
      @Sthithpragnya 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Read correct history, Indica term was described by Megasthanes, and yes Bharatvarsh existed centuries before that Kashmir and Punjab as a country???? Have a reality check Population exchange during partition in Bengal was largely one sided wherein most Hindus were thrown out, the other community hardly moved Circumcision happens in Jews , they too are Abrahamics however they aren't brainwashed to the point of indulgence in T@qqia!!!

    • @aqeelkhurshid4860
      @aqeelkhurshid4860 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      You mean the history they teach you in Nazi inspired RSS Shakhas! I never made any refrence to any religion in my previous message, yet your entire message is about religion. Perhaps you need to introspect your bigotry. Bharatvasrsa only refers to the western part of Gangetic valley. The very words India and Hindustan come from Sindh. Sindh predates India. 90 % of all sindhis are Pakistani citizens. Sindh and Punjab are the lands of Indus valley civilization. People of Pakistan are the descendants of that glorious civilization. Punjab was a kindgon which was dissolved by the British on the middle of the 19th century. Kashmir was a kingdom until 1947. That's the reason why all these independent kingdoms were asked to join up with either of the two new large counteries that emerged at the end of British Raaj. If India was always a country, why would there be any need to ask anyone to join it! India is unable to define it's identity without a direct reference to Sindh and Sindh has no such need. It has its own identity. I am a half Sindhi and half Punjabi. I look at India as my child ;)

    • @faisalrehman8298
      @faisalrehman8298 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@aqeelkhurshid4860spot on..the Indian subcontinent had so many different countries for centuries. Mughals and then the British consolidated it for their own end. Its many diverse cultures with hundreds of different languages cultures and genetically different peoples and their different beliefs is living proof of it. Indian subcontinent is not one nation but many.

    • @aqeelkhurshid4860
      @aqeelkhurshid4860 2 วันที่ผ่านมา

      That's correct! What does a pashtun has in common with a keralan, what does a Punjabi has in common with a tamilian and what does a Kashmir has in common with an Assamese! Never forget this subcontinent is named after Sindh and river Indus. The current state called India is not the origin of the word india. Indians are living with an identity borrowed to them by Sindh. Sindh is a the father of this subcontinent. 90 % of all sindhis are Pakistani citizens 70 % of all Punjabis are Pakistani citizens. In conclusion the people of Pakistan are the daddy of this subcontinent

  • @tianaslade71
    @tianaslade71 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

    "Mullah-Marxist-Missionary" combine has successfully brainwashed generations of Indians

  • @biswaruppaul8841
    @biswaruppaul8841 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The Complete Works of Swami Vivekananda published by The Ramakrishna Mission in English Hindi and other languages is a must for understanding the real history,culture and ethos of India. Without going through it you cannot write the true history of India. This should be included in the syllabus of school, college and university syllabus. Dr. Jain is right.

  • @KrishnamurthyAiyer
    @KrishnamurthyAiyer 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    whose mistake was that?

  • @girishmalviya7719
    @girishmalviya7719 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    96% Muslims voted for partition of India but only 50% went across. The 46% who stayed back don't feel ashamed for being responsible for partition of India but think they did a favour to Hindus by staying back. Leaders like Gandhi and Nehru made the Hindus of India feel guilty about the sins of muslims who stayed back in India.

    • @toolsierammahase8884
      @toolsierammahase8884 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I totally agree with you

    • @ravitezaganta5497
      @ravitezaganta5497 6 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I always think that when partition happened why so many muslims are staying in india. Leaders would have agree that partition only happened if all muslims step out of court...see in pakisthan and bangladesh hindus population dropdown...and in india their population is increasing and they need reservations and scheems and waqf board and specail laws...what a gandu and nehru...khangress

    • @haalee007
      @haalee007 5 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Liaqat ali thru parliament banned muslim migration to pakistan from Dec 31 1951 This still in pakistan citizenship n nationality act 1951 Than in 1980. Zia canceled citizenship of bangldesh bihariz and granted citizenship to afghan By martial law regulations

    • @bhagwanbhagchandani5627
      @bhagwanbhagchandani5627 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

      A SHAME ?? THATS THE STRATEGY OF MOSLEMS FACTS SEE TODAYS MOSLEMS DOMINATES

    • @kamleshlulla5303
      @kamleshlulla5303 ชั่วโมงที่ผ่านมา

      Their commitment is towards their Allah to finish all the religions and they work accordingly only Hindus show their loyalty towards them and get cheated themselves or their community.

  • @dineshmohanlal5697
    @dineshmohanlal5697 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    TAKE BACK AND RETAIN BHARAT/INDIAS NATURAL IDENTITY A factual analigy of Bharat/Indias partition when many Muslims remained behind and many that reached the Kashmir boarder had mixed feelings about venturing into Pakistan for fear of the worst future from their own compared to the calm nature of HINDUS throughout Bharat/India & Pakistan while finding Kashmir a relatively nice place to settle in with its appealing geographical location it would have been easier and closer to enter into Pakistan should a need arise. However, after settling comfortably in Kashmir, it dawned on their minds that by increasing their numbers they would have had a fair chance of claiming Kashmir to be their own territory. That belief was supported by Pakistan typically in their Invader forefathers fashion to invade, wreck all sorts of havok, and make it their own as was since their medieval times. Bharat/India owes nobody anything and should take back whatever belongs to her and her HINDU PEOPLE. TAKE BACK AND RETAIN HER NATURAL IDENTITY .. Jai Hind🇮🇳

  • @practiceday-to-dayhindi6083
    @practiceday-to-dayhindi6083 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    So, whose fault is this that they didn’t leave this land ? Theirs or ours?

    • @bmniac
      @bmniac 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

      They were risk averse.

  • @VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhu
    @VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhu 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    So, the partition happened on religious grounds, but even this is denied by colonised historians, as displayed by opposition to giving shelter to oppressed Sanatanis from neighbouring Islamic countries, and even worse, they champion the right of Muslims to come to BHARAT. We must answer: what right do Muslims (apart from asylum) have to come to BHARAT after this violent religious partition in1947? Even more importantly, for the future of BHARAT, does a secular Muslim exist, even if they state that "There is no God but Allah"? And if a secular Muslim exists, then where EXACTLY is the secular Muslim country, especially after the fall of Assad's Syria? Name ONE secular Muslim country from the 55 around the world. JAI BHARAT JAI BIHAR.

  • @MuhammadKhan-hk5qz
    @MuhammadKhan-hk5qz 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    It is Hindu religion to make life miserable if non Hindus and even of Hindus i.e.Dalits.My parents migrated from UP to Pakistan and cried whole life remembering UP.Thry said after RSS started anti Muslim riots in India( and Indian history in starting riots and mayhem on minorities like Muslims,Dalits,Christians ,Sikh they decided to move to Pakistan for the future of their generations and they were so right.

    • @VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhu
      @VivekwhuVivekwhuVivekwhu 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

      So, why EXACTLY have the % of Muslims increased in BHARAT after 1947 and the % of Sanatanis decreased in Pakistan and Bangladesh? Is it something in the water or is it the Islamic "There is no God but Allah" business? Good luck to you and your family in Islamic (Sunni, Shia or Ahmedhiya?) Pakistan while BHARAT goes to the Moon and beyond. Keep out of BHARAT forever. JAI BHARAT JAI BIHAR!

  • @nipponjain5899
    @nipponjain5899 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    वास्तविकता यह है कि आज हम महात्मा गांधी की अदूरदर्शिता और जवाहर लाल नेहरू की सत्ता की भूख का खामियाजा भुगत रहे हैं! गांधी जी के अत्यधिक मुस्लिम प्रेम एवं जवाहर लाल नेहरू की हिंदू विरोधी मानसिकता की वजह से भारत छोड़कर पाकिस्तान जाने वाले मुस्लिम लोगों को जबरन जाने से रोका गया था! यदि कांग्रेस मजबूत हो कर जिन्ना को पूरी आबादी की अदला बदली करने का कहती तो जिन्ना कभी भी बंटवारे के लिए तैयार नहीं होता

  • @Chuckruu
    @Chuckruu 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    British had nothing to do with it?! Skewed approach to further agenda of the good ole British trick to divide and rule plus alienating segments of Indian society to justify agendas of superiority politricks !

  • @mikesheth5370
    @mikesheth5370 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Some 85% of Indian Muslims voted for Jinnah’s Muslim League! They stayed put in india ! And Khaiber Pakhtoon people who voted in favour of India forced to stayed put! Thrown to wolves in word of Khan Abdul Gafrakhan!

  • @althea_is_smokin_hot
    @althea_is_smokin_hot 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Yes Madam,you are right. This displayed the rogue character of indian muslims which is no less even now.

  • @annievarkey3071
    @annievarkey3071 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

    So,now send them back! Why did they create the Hell and killed many.

  • @AutomateTon
    @AutomateTon 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

    But that still don't answer why they didn't leave.

    • @sailakshmivarsha6419
      @sailakshmivarsha6419 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

      Bharati is a better place than their wasted deserted homeland

    • @peachNplum
      @peachNplum 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

      For creation of Ghazwa-E-Hind.

    • @mikesheth5370
      @mikesheth5370 7 วันที่ผ่านมา

      @@AutomateTon Answer is clear cut! 1.Once they saw what kind of Pakistan it’s going to be many dropped idea of going to Islamic ELDORADO! Others were part of conspiracy , especially Aligarh crowd and clergy to stay put, make india Dareslam Muslim majority state. Rank and file stayed because state protected them from Hindu attacks or there were few Hindu attacks, didn’t match in scale. India country side Muslims were untouched! Where as Pakistan country side including Punjab and Loonghistan broke back of Hindus and Sikhs! Or it was not in nature of Hindus to reply in kind! These are the reasons! Even Jinnah thought he can peacefully retire in Bombay heaven in a big bungalow not far from sea!

    • @bhagwanbhagchandani5627
      @bhagwanbhagchandani5627 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

      THEY ARE SMART BRAVES AND UNITED TO FOOLS THE HINDUS WHO ARE FOOLISH IDIOTS

  • @NewsWire24X7
    @NewsWire24X7 8 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Good answer

  • @sambhavsharma4428
    @sambhavsharma4428 9 วันที่ผ่านมา

    The British Census of India categorized communities based on caste, this solidified caste identities in India

    • @rakhimukerji7937
      @rakhimukerji7937 4 วันที่ผ่านมา

      I AM SORRY THAT SATI HAPPENED EVEN IF THE NO WERE SMALL. OFTEN PROPEFTY WAS INVOLVED

  • @rameshkulkarni830
    @rameshkulkarni830 10 วันที่ผ่านมา

    Smt Meenakshi Jain is real historian and gem in history field.