วีดีโอ

모짜르트를 너무 딱딱하게 치네요 정신없이 음만 따라가는 거 같이. 우아함이 전혀 없음. 어떻게 저렇게 못치냐 속도에 목숨 건 느낌. 아무리 가르쳐도 변화 없는게 더 놀라움

Also das ist das beste,auf,diesem Gebiet, was ich auf TH-cam entdeckt hab. Der Mann ist genial und man muss alles hören.

What a wonderful lecture! Thank you Professor Scheps for creating this immensely useful video which is a tremendous help for us in trying to understand and appreciate the secrets and beauty of these great Chopin etudes. We look forward to many more lectures like this from you. Thanks so much!

Wonderful.

Can’t say enough how much I loved this! I loved the swinging of the giant bell in his motions. Also the Professor’s touch is impeccable. I hear immediately the difference in the sound when he plays versus the student.

Какое наслаждение получаю от Ваших мастер- классов, уважаемый Маэстро! Низкий поклон и глубочайшее почтение!

В восхищении!!! Я абсолютно не знаю английский, но как понятно, чутко...просто потрясающе! А девочка в процессе как заиграла!...Магия.... Спасибо 🙏🏼

A great way to understand what he's talking about with the overtones, or harmonics, is to silently depress the RH E and G then play three measures of the LH without sustaining pedal and see how they sound after you've let go the LH. Try it!

Guy is too old 😂

Greetings, could you hear and subscribe to my TH-cam channel with some of my classical works, I would be happy to get some resonance and support? Hope you like it, Thanks in advance. th-cam.com/video/hjqyrqJh8DA/w-d-xo.html

What a superb masterclass - Professor Scheps has such helpful technical insights about producing the right tone and phrasing for this extraordinarily rich and expressive piece. And he communicates in such an understanding and gentle manner.

the kids don't get deep enough, especially for Rachmaninoff. She tries to but it never comes off.

musically, the kid is constitutionally unable to plumb the depths. It's a cultural conditioning issue. Far-Easterners are relatively understated emotionally, reserved.

the thing about far-Easterners is that their nervous systems are not amenable to the spirit of Western music. They don't have the pathos, the depth. They gloss over the depth of the details, the minute emotionalism. Technically, they're fine. But doesn't technique include what I am talking about.

Great, really great Musician. Awesome

Was ist da bitte virtuos 😆auch Chopin hatte Unterricht und sogar studiert was keine Kunst ist ❕nach Klimpern lernen 🤦🏻

🤦🏻🤦🏻🤦🏻😆😆😆🙄

I learnt a lot thank you❤️

The pianist is the accompanists for much of the opening pages. I felt the “Student” was a bit too aggressive. I type as I’m hearing it. Waiting for commentary. Thanks for posting this.

Иля, now I want to hear you play the whole thing! Can you not make a recording of you playing this MM on this Bösendorfer?

es muy bello

❤❤❤

I really enjoyed the lesson

Einfach wunderbar

What an amazing teacher and pianist! So kind, encouraging, respectful and humble. He really brings out the heart-wrenching expressiveness and gorgeous tone quality of the piece.

If you turn on subtitles and then auto-translate in settings you can read what the professor is saying in English or German. Thank you professor we are glad you are well.

Big of blablabla from another professor

He looks like he could play Joker 😂

I have to say, I dislike this style of teaching. It’s very superficial. It’s just showing how to do something and not why to do it.

My cup of tea!

Melodize it. That’s the winner

Yea, I wouldn’t call this a master class. Just teaching to be a puppet. Give a path why you wanna sound ascertain way. Very superficial way of teaching in m humble opinion

A master piece. We pretty much settled on how it’s played. The composer himself played it and recorded it. Now it’s just a matter how deep you can get into it. And what your performance looks like. And don’t break the chords at the beginning

Aaah, don’t break the chord. Just leave out the bottom note

피아노는 타자기가 아님./ beautiful teaching.

Невероятно красиво ❤

Stunning performance!

Lindo...muy expresivo...adelante! Falta Forma Musical, mayor comprension de la forma. Muy bien. México.

Amazing sound and teaching ❤❤❤ Thank you so much 😍

Bravo !Et félicitations ❤

Grazie per la condivisione

Truly wonderful masterclass extract. Thank you...!

Playing wasn’t as good as the teaching. Speed was all over the place. The pp weren’t as soft as they need to be. Too technical. Much of the special phrasing got lost in the speed.

Frankly speaking, she unfortunately has no feeling for the necessary, so important subtleties in Chopin, delays inappropriately, almost only plays down this so high-quality music, audible mistakes included. Still much to work on.

Wundarbar. Vielen Dank!

Потрясающий профессор! Человек музыки!

She plays a little bit "dry" as if lacking in vitality, while the professor tries to add some vibrat colors. Mr. Ilja feels the sadness behind notes that not everyone can feel. Although her technical proficiency remains admirable, the essence of emotion seems absent from her notes.

Marvelous teacher with such a refined touch, so much to learn from him. She is like so many similar student I have seen who are convinced that once they can keep up with the metronome over the entire piece using whatever inadequate touch and buldozing through that they deserve to perform the piece. As far as i am concerned i think this student cannot play this piece, this is not playing the piece, it's rushing through it - may give what may -. I am sure Chopin would be horrified not by her playing but by her lack of realizing that hers is not a musical approach. And then there are so many of them, and when they get a bit better than her, and are able to add some dynamics they think they're total masters when they don't understand a thing about music. It must be said most of them are from the far east. They think speed is the only thing that matters. I would be ashamed, I don't even think she should be there taking the place of other more musical student who maybe does not play fast yet but has musicality.

I much prefer how he plays it to his daughter’s version. True expression and maturity.

Wundervoll, wirklich! Hab das Stück noch nie schöner gespielt gehört.