วีดีโอ

The consonant harmony sounds better and the dissonant sounds slightly worse

I can sense the difference in the underlying chords. Like, at first it sounds kind of wrong to me. It's "out of tune" but it isn't? Cool.

Very beautiful! Cubase seems to have this Hermode Tuning too. Still, I can hear at some places the limitations of the Hermode system, based on a database as it is. Still, it is a huge improvement!

Very beautiful! I have always been a favorite of classical music played in Just Intonation. However, the Hermode system is 'database based'. Which means, that there is no mathematical theory underneath it, except for the harmony theory, that says that a harmony of several notes must also be seen as one note with a very rich overtone spectrum, so that notes move 'into and out of' harmonies. An idea that is an extension of Pythagoras' idea that harmony is the result of whole-number frequency ratios of different pitches. The Hermodic system is basically a representation of this idea. But a full theory of harmony must also include Helmholtz' idea of dissonance, which the Hermonde system does not. To make music that complies fully to both Pythagoras and Helmhotz' definition of harmony, you could take 'a look at' some of my own compositions, which you can find on my TH-cam channel. I cannot post links here, because the TH-cam algorithm doesn't allow this. Still, listening to this Romance in Hermodic Just Intonation improves the piece a lot!

This is sort of(*) a preview of what it would be like if this was played on a fluid piano th-cam.com/video/t7Cq3pbcMkI/w-d-xo.html&pp=ygULZmx1aWQgcGlhbm8%3D but with foot pedals to change all the notes in one pitch class instead of having to reach over and move each slider by hand. (*)The fluid piano is a modern tangent piano with sliders, rather than a standard piano with sliders.

Am I crazy or are there mistakes like at 0:32 and 2:28?

Terrible, why listen to this when there are many recorded performances on YT?

Ca ƒerraille ((un tout petit peu)), qui est le ƒacteur de piano…… s'il y en a un ? Pas non plus de pianiste ? Juste un Tuning par "LOGIC" et Just Intonation, "possiblement" ? Peut-être R 2 D 2 a-t-il une réponse toute prête.

JI sounds so good and odd at the same time

Yo, what if you tune the Db Fm Gbm with major chords for Db, minor chords for Fm, and subminor chords for Gbm (6:7:9)? It should have a more harmonic connection, right?

I really love "just intonation" ... ET is nice but we lost so much

that song at the beginning scratched an itch in my mind I didn't know I had. Please please tell me where to find more!

How can I put this? It sounds wrong (not to say that it sounds bad) because of the way I have heard things my entire life. BUT I think equal temperament would sound really wrong if we all only ever heard just intonation.

What's fun to do is listen to this, and then go listen to it in ET and realize just how dissonant ET is 😮

My god that is so much better than normal! My whole life I've wondered why other people like CdL; it's always sounded out of tune to me.

This is something that could only be done with a VSTi

Is it possible that the higher harmonics get lost because of that technique to convert to just intonation?? I sounds pure and smooth but so dark ??

Shouts to podcasterHH!!!1

Equal temperament really ruins so many songs.

how can it be 357 limit, 357 is divisable by 3, 7, and 17

2:14 This part sounds off to my TET-adjusted ears.

What a wonderfull transcription indeed !

ahhh, those 7th harmonics!

As "perfect" as this sounds, I still heard a tiny bit of wavering. I guess it's only natural. Parts such as 1:37 sound so resolved and perfect, that it almost sounds sterile to me. Not that it's bad at all. Maybe it's because everything is in equal temperament for such a pragmatic reason, that I'm used to hearing imperfections, and I like it. Without the sour, the sweet is not as sweet.

Was the harpsichord in Just Intonation tuning as well? Meaning only in tune for the key of D.

One of the first to invent a useable system for just intonation in modern times, was the Norwegian composer Eivind Groven. I wonder if it's his system that's in use here. He invented a pure-tuned organ, and realized that the smallest possible way to make each modulation "just", was by having three possible semitones pr octave, thus making up three times as many possibilities than the usual 12-semitone scale. In later years, his system has been made accessible through modern computing, and through the internet. Having worked with his system for some time now, I can't help but wonder if this is the case here (and also having played the same sonata, tuned the same way).

Both beautiful to listen.

Wonderful

To my ears it sounds out of tune in a lot of places. And I play on string instruments and play in just intonation whenever possible

Just intonation is another name for pythagorean tuning right?

Your pedal-free interpretation of the middle arpeggio part is stunning.

Is this retuning done manually or is there a script to do it automatically? I'm doing research on algorithmic just intonation.

❤

Beautiful! glad to see you make more of these

Man, that E major chord at 0:45 really sounds way off. 2:19 is just abysmal. Don't know how much of it is just weird stuff from the pitch correction (3:46-3:49 clearly is), but it really shows how pieces with a lot of modulation simply don't work in just intonation.

Great music!

Extremely beautiful and touching

empalagoso

Is this real piano or keyboard?

I almost can't tell the difference. Not as unusual as I thought it would be. Very good to listen to. Thanks!

I oddly think this sounds prettier than in equal temperament. Not because I'm some just temperament elitist, I just think the slightly untuned-ness sometimes gives it so much more color. Yes, people describe it as perfect rainbows, but it literally is only that way half of the time. The other half it is very clearly not tuned like we know it in equal temperament, and I think that makes it quite beautiful. Edit: I meant just intonation, I meant it sounds prettier in just intonation. I'm so sorry, guys.

Bruh tune your piano 😂

I like the sound of this, but I think there's too much pedal/reverb perhaps?

My 12 tet biased ears hate this immensely, which is sad, because I want to like it

I don't think this is a just intonation. It sounds like slightly oddly tuned piano.

Delicious 🤤

It sounds strange to me for some reason. Even though it should sound better I feel like it doesn’t. Maybe it’s because it’s not played by a real person? Or Just intonation just sounds like perfect rainbows instead of “raw human”

Oh my, this is an unfound diamond

Very nice, thank you for this. I'd be curious to hear a similar version for: Piano Sonata No. 11 in A major, K. 331 - I. Andante grazioso

Do you choose a note at the beginning of the piece, say "C", to be the fundamenta,l and then take every other note in the piece from the C harmonic series OR do you choose a new fundamental at each chord change, choosing the root note of that chord, and then take every other note played during that chord from the harmonic series of that chord root note?